The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

Zomi Frankcom is a tragic victim in the stalemated Israel-Hamas war, but don’t expect Australia’s approach to change much

  • Written by Ian Parmeter, Research Scholar, Centre for Arab and Islamic Studies, Australian National University

Napoleon’s foreign minister, Charles Maurice de Talleyrand, is said to have[1] remarked concerning the effectiveness of targeting civilians in war: “it’s worse than a crime, it’s a mistake”.

Talleyrand was an archetypal exponent of realpolitik, and history provides numerous examples of the validity of his remark. One is the prolonged US bombing of North Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos during the Vietnam war in the late 1960s and early 1970s. These attacks, which included use of the now banned defoliant “Agent Orange”, laid waste vast tracts of territory in all three countries, killing around two million[2] civilians. But they failed to prevent the North winning.

The Gaza war will reach the six-month mark this Sunday. It’s starting to look like a stalemate, raising the question of whether Israel’s military campaign there is proving to be another validation of Talleyrand’s principle.

The headline figure of mainly civilian deaths in Gaza is horrifying enough – now well over 33,000[3] according to the Gaza Ministry of Health. Though the ministry is managed by Hamas, the World Health Organization describes[4] its data collection as “credible and well developed”. Israel claims 13,000 of those killed[5] were Hamas fighters, though it has not said how it calculated that figure.

However, the headline figure also misses the number of aid workers killed in Gaza since the war started – an aspect of the Gaza horror now brought directly to international attention by Israel’s killing of seven volunteers with the food aid agency World Central Kitchen – including Australian Zomi Frankcom.

With the deaths of the World Central Kitchen volunteers, the number of aid workers killed is now 196[6].

Read more: The UN Security Council has finally called for a ceasefire in Gaza. But will it have any effect?[7]

Claims of poor coordination refuted

The basic facts seem to be an Israeli drone fired three missiles at a convoy of three cars carrying the World Central Kitchen volunteers – despite the fact the vehicles were clearly marked on the roof and sides with the charity’s logo. The route had been preapproved and coordinated with the Israel Defense Forces (IDF).

The IDF and defence ministry claimed the strikes on the World Central Kitchen vehicles followed misidentification and poor coordination at night in complex war conditions because of suspicion an armed militant[8] was travelling with them.

A woman wearing a combat helmet smiles at the camera.
Australian aid worker Zomi Frankcom was killed in Gaza. Supplied/AAP

The Israeli newspaper Haaretz, citing defence sources, has refuted these claims[9]. Haaretz quotes its sources as saying the incident had “no connection to coordination” and was caused by the fact “every commander sets the rules for himself”. The army’s killing of seven aid workers in the Gaza Strip on Monday night “stemmed from poor discipline among field commanders, not a lack of coordination between the army and aid organisations”.

These are explosive allegations. A spokesman for Israel’s military, Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari, said the incident has been referred[10] to the Fact Finding and Assessment Mechanism, a military body tasked with investigating accusations and looking into the circumstances behind battlefield episodes. The Israeli military says the mechanism is an “independent, professional and expert body”. However, human rights groups have generally been critical[11] of the Israeli military’s ability to transparently investigate itself.

Unsurprisingly, in the aftermath of the fatal attack, humanitarian groups announced they are suspending operations in the territory. World Central Kitchen, along with other aid organisations such as Anera, which helps refugees around the Middle East, and the US-based Project Hope, which focuses on healthcare, announced they would pause operations[12] in Gaza to protect their staff.

Read more: Gaza conflict: snapshot of a population being starved into submission[13]

How will this affect Australia’s position?

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese spoke with his Israeli counterpart Benjamin Netanyahu on April 2. Albanese said he expressed Australia’s outrage at Frankcom’s death and said he wanted “full accountability[14]”.

Albanese said he had reiterated Australia’s longstanding concern with Israel’s plans for a ground invasion of the southern Gaza area of Rafah, where more than a million Palestinian civilians are sheltering.

He added that he made clear Australia believes humanitarian assistance must reach people in Gaza unimpeded and in large quantities.

A bomb hole through the roof of a white car bearing a logo reading 'World Central Kitchen'. The World Central Kitchen car had the charity’s logo on it. MOHAMMED SABER/EPA

However, Albanese did not give a direct answer when asked whether he had spelled out any potential consequences for the bilateral relationship if Israel does not conduct a satisfactory investigation into Frankcom’s death or change its method of waging war against Hamas.

Netanyahu promised a full investigation. But his initial public comment[15] on the killings that “these things happen in war” seemed like a philosophical shrug of the shoulders, suggesting no major outcome is likely from the investigation. It also suggested Netanyahu has a closer eye on his political standing in Israel than the international reaction to the deaths.

Don’t expect much change

The reality is not much is likely to change in terms of Australia’s dealings with Israel.

Foreign Minister Penny Wong has already made clear no Australian military equipment has been sold to Israel since the start of the Gaza war. Australia’s defence exports to Israel are in any case miniscule[16] – A$13 million over the past five years.

Wong has said many times[17] Israel has the right to defend itself but the way it does so matters. She also told the ABC[18] on April 3:

Wartime does not obviate responsibility for observing international humanitarian law, including the protection of aid workers.

Australia can be expected to reiterate calls for a ceasefire in Gaza and a two-state solution to the conflict. Neither are in prospect because Netanyahu has rejected both[19]. Moreover, a two-state solution is simply not possible given the fact half a million Israeli settlers now live in the West Bank – meaning it can no longer form the basis for any Palestinian state.

With ceasefire negotiations stalled[20], the outlook for Gaza depends on Israeli domestic politics. Netanyahu faces pressure on several fronts. This includes from families and supporters of more than 100 Israeli hostages still held by Hamas, but also from his own hard-right coalition, which insists he continue the war regardless of the high Palestinian casualty rate. Pressure is also coming from the Biden administration, which disapproves of the way Israel is waging the war and the impact on Palestinian civilians.

The only potential circuit breaker would be the capture or killing of the two Hamas leaders in Gaza – Yahya Sinwar and Mohamed Deif – but they are hidden deep inside the tunnel network beneath Gaza.

Read more: Israel-Gaza war: why did the ceasefire negotiations collapse – and can they be revived?[21]

References

  1. ^ said to have (papers.ssrn.com)
  2. ^ two million (www.britannica.com)
  3. ^ well over 33,000 (www.aljazeera.com)
  4. ^ describes (www.bbc.com)
  5. ^ 13,000 of those killed (www.aljazeera.com)
  6. ^ 196 (www.bbc.com)
  7. ^ The UN Security Council has finally called for a ceasefire in Gaza. But will it have any effect? (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ armed militant (www.timesofisrael.com)
  9. ^ refuted these claims (www.haaretz.com)
  10. ^ referred (www.nytimes.com)
  11. ^ been critical (www.nytimes.com)
  12. ^ pause operations (www.theguardian.com)
  13. ^ Gaza conflict: snapshot of a population being starved into submission (theconversation.com)
  14. ^ full accountability (www.theguardian.com)
  15. ^ initial public comment (www.theguardian.com)
  16. ^ miniscule (www.theguardian.com)
  17. ^ said many times (thejewishindependent.com.au)
  18. ^ told the ABC (www.foreignminister.gov.au)
  19. ^ rejected both (www.reuters.com)
  20. ^ stalled (www.reuters.com)
  21. ^ Israel-Gaza war: why did the ceasefire negotiations collapse – and can they be revived? (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/zomi-frankcom-is-a-tragic-victim-in-the-stalemated-israel-hamas-war-but-dont-expect-australias-approach-to-change-much-227045

The Times Features

$15m upgrades to critical Western NSW rural airstrips

The Minns Labor Government is boosting connectivity and resilience in Western NSW with up to $15 million funding for runway upgrades and safety improvements to accommodate larger...

Yeehaw! The Tennessee BBQ range arrives at Macca’s

Reign in the hunger with our new range packed full of Aussie ingredients 30 April 2025: Howdy partners! Hope you brought your hunger because McDonald’s is satisfying cravings...

How weight stigma in maternity care harms larger-bodied women and their babies

According to a study from the United States[1], women experience weight stigma in maternity care at almost every visit. We expect this experience to be similar in Australia, ...

10 Ways to Make Money Online and Provide Financial Stability

The possibility of earning money online has reached unprecedented heights. The proper strategy enables anyone to begin earning money. You don't need fancy degrees or special skil...

The Power of Exterior Design: How Facades Influence Property Value

First impressions count when it comes to real estate, and nothing quite sets the tone for a property like its exterior design. A building's facade is more than just an aesthetic ...

The Best Adjustable Bed and Mattress Packages for Comfort

The appropriate bed and mattress are essential for establishing the perfect sleep environment. If you seek a way to upgrade your sleep experience, adjustable bed and mattress pac...

Times Magazine

Uniden Baby Video Monitor Review

Uniden has released another award-winning product as part of their ‘Baby Watch’ series. The BW4501 Baby Monitor is an easy to use camera for keeping eyes and ears on your little one. The camera is easy to set up and can be mounted to the wall or a...

Top Benefits of Hiring Commercial Electricians for Your Business

When it comes to business success, there are no two ways about it: qualified professionals are critical. While many specialists are needed, commercial electricians are among the most important to have on hand. They are directly involved in upholdin...

The Essential Guide to Transforming Office Spaces for Maximum Efficiency

Why Office Fitouts MatterA well-designed office can make all the difference in productivity, employee satisfaction, and client impressions. Businesses of all sizes are investing in updated office spaces to create environments that foster collaborat...

The A/B Testing Revolution: How AI Optimized Landing Pages Without Human Input

A/B testing was always integral to the web-based marketing world. Was there a button that converted better? Marketing could pit one against the other and see which option worked better. This was always through human observation, and over time, as d...

Using Countdown Timers in Email: Do They Really Increase Conversions?

In a world that's always on, where marketers are attempting to entice a subscriber and get them to convert on the same screen with one email, the power of urgency is sometimes the essential element needed. One of the most popular ways to create urg...

Types of Software Consultants

In today's technology-driven world, businesses often seek the expertise of software consultants to navigate complex software needs. There are several types of software consultants, including solution architects, project managers, and user experienc...

LayBy Shopping