The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

Sweeping reform of the electoral laws puts democracy at risk. They shouldn’t be changed on a whim

  • Written by Joshua Black, Visitor, School of History, Australian National University



The Albanese government is trying once more to legislate wide-ranging changes to the way federal elections are administered.

The 200-page Electoral Reform Bill[1], if passed, would transform the electoral donation rules by imposing donation and spending caps, increasing public funding, and improving transparency.

As noble as it sounds, the bill in its current form would undermine Australian democracy by favouring established parties over independent candidates and other new players.

Competitive disadvantage

The proposed donation caps[2] are a case in point.

Donors could give A$20,000 per year, per recipient, to a branch of a party or candidate for electioneering purposes. In practice, that means donors could give no more than $20,000 per year to an independent but could contribute $180,000 to the Labor Party via each of its state and federal branches, or $160,000 to the Liberal Party (which has one less branch than the ALP).

The donation cap would reset annually and after each federal election, allowing a single donor to give $720,000 to the Labor Party in one election cycle or $640,000 to the Liberals, but no more than $20,000 to an independent who declares their candidacy in the year of an election.

Five Teal MPs speaking with the media in Parliament House
Independent candidates, like the Teal MPs, could be disadvantaged by the proposed new laws. Mick Tsikas/AAP[3]

Avoiding the American road

There are welcome components in the bill. Faster disclosure and lower donation thresholds would make the system more transparent. Given the large amount of undisclosed funding – “dark money [4]” – currently propping up political parties, this would be a significant improvement.

But democracy is not cheap.

Last year, the Financial Times reported[5] Donald Trump and Kamala Harris spent a combined US$3.5 billion (A$5.6 billion) on their presidential races. This kind of money helps to sustain an American two-party system largely immune to challengers.

Australian campaigns look nothing like this, but there has been increased interest in the money spent in particular seats in recent years.

Former Labor minister Kim Carr revealed in his recent book[6] Labor spent $1 million to defeat the Greens in the Melbourne electorate of Batman in 2018, while the LNP reportedly[7] spent $600,000 campaigning to retain the affluent electorate of Fadden in 2023.

The bill before Parliament would cap election spending at $800,000 in each lower house seat. But the major parties could promote their generic party brand or a frontbench MP (in a seat other than their own) without affecting their capped spending.

These unfair discrepancies[8] would reward the major parties while kneecapping independents whose first hurdle is to get their name “out there”.

Haunted by billionaires

The government argues its bill limits the influence of “big money” in politics, namely mining boss Clive Palmer, who spent $117 million[9] at the last election.

For the Coalition, it is the community independents and their Climate 200 supporters who represent a kind of money “without precedent in the Australian political system” according to[10] departing MP Paul Fletcher.

Rather than getting big money out of politics, this bill would make the major parties’ own funding pipelines the only money that matters.

The bill recognises “nominated entities” whose payments to associated political parties would not be limited by donation caps. Independents would not have this privilege.

Meanwhile, the long delay before the commencement of the bill in 2026 would give wealthy donors time to get their ducks in order. They could amass their own war chests before the new laws are due to come in to force and then register them as nominated entities at a later date.

Businessman and United Australia Party founder Clive Palmer standing in front of a yellow and black political banner.
The likes of wealthy businessman and founder of the United Australia Party Clive Palmer would still be able to spend big on Australian elections. Joel Carrett/AAP[11]

Who pays? The taxpayer, of course!

Parties and candidates with more than 4% of the primary vote currently receive public election funding. The Hawke government introduced this measure[12] as a “small insurance” against corruption.

The bill would raise the return to $5 per vote, which would mean an extra $41 million in funding, on top of the $71 million handed over after the 2022 election[13]. Most of this money would go to the major parties.

The windfall would come with no extra guardrails or guidelines about how those funds could be spent. There are no laws to guarantee truth in political advertising[14] at the federal level. Voters may well be paying for more political advertising that lies to them.

Closed consultations

Labor’s current strategy is to seek Coalition support for these changes to the rules of democracy.

Special Minister of State Don Farrell claims to have consulted widely on the design of the bill, but that came as news[15] to independents David Pocock and Kate Chaney when asked about it last week.

The government’s haste and secrecy suggest it wants neither the bill nor its motives closely scrutinised.

Australians care about the quality of their democracy. Polling[16] research by the Australia Institute last November showed four in five Australians expect electoral changes to be reviewed by a multi-party committee.

That’s what is needed for this bill. To do otherwise would threaten the integrity of Australian elections – or invite a High Court challenge[17] that may overturn the entire system if the court rules freedom of political expression is at stake.

Democracy matters. The rules must not be changed on a whim.

References

  1. ^ Electoral Reform Bill (ministers.pmc.gov.au)
  2. ^ proposed donation caps (australiainstitute.org.au)
  3. ^ Mick Tsikas/AAP (photos.aap.com.au)
  4. ^ dark money (www.theguardian.com)
  5. ^ reported (www.ft.com)
  6. ^ recent book (publishing.monash.edu)
  7. ^ reportedly (www.theguardian.com)
  8. ^ unfair discrepancies (australiainstitute.org.au)
  9. ^ spent $117 million (www.thenewdaily.com.au)
  10. ^ according to (www.paulfletcher.com.au)
  11. ^ Joel Carrett/AAP (photos.aap.com.au)
  12. ^ this measure (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)
  13. ^ 2022 election (www.aec.gov.au)
  14. ^ truth in political advertising (australiainstitute.org.au)
  15. ^ came as news (www.thesaturdaypaper.com.au)
  16. ^ Polling (australiainstitute.org.au)
  17. ^ High Court challenge (www.smh.com.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/sweeping-reform-of-the-electoral-laws-puts-democracy-at-risk-they-shouldnt-be-changed-on-a-whim-249144

The Times Features

How to Choose the Perfect Outdoor Lift for Your Home

Choosing the right outdoor lift for your home is a decision that blends functionality, aesthetics, and safety. Outdoor lifts not only enhance mobility but also increase the value...

The Importance of Pre-Purchase Building Inspections

Purchasing a property is quite possibly one of the most significant financial decisions you'll ever make. The allure of a new home or investment can often overshadow the necessit...

The Legal Battle Against IP Theft: What Businesses Need to Know

So you've formulated that million-dollar idea and you're ready to take your business to the next level. You were so excited to publicize your supposedly next big thing that you...

Why Roof Replacement Is the Best Solution for Roofs with Major Leaks

When your roof is leaking extensively, the situation can be both frustrating and worrying. The constant drip-drip-drip of water, the potential for structural damage, and the risi...

Some vegetables are pretty low in fibre. So which veggies are high-fibre heroes?

Many people looking to improve their health try to boost fibre intake by eating more vegetables. But while all veggies offer health benefits, not all are particularly high i...

Why Your Tennis Game Isn’t Improving (And How to Fix It)

Tennis is a sport that demands precision, endurance, strategy, and mental toughness. Whether you play casually or competitively, you may reach a frustrating point where your prog...

Times Magazine

Why You Should Choose Digital Printing for Your Next Project

In the rapidly evolving world of print media, digital printing has emerged as a cornerstone technology that revolutionises how businesses and creative professionals produce printed materials. Offering unparalleled flexibility, speed, and quality, d...

What to Look for When Booking an Event Space in Melbourne

Define your event needs early to streamline venue selection and ensure a good fit. Choose a well-located, accessible venue with good transport links and parking. Check for key amenities such as catering, AV equipment, and flexible seating. Pla...

How BIM Software is Transforming Architecture and Engineering

Building Information Modeling (BIM) software has become a cornerstone of modern architecture and engineering practices, revolutionizing how professionals design, collaborate, and execute projects. By enabling more efficient workflows and fostering ...

How 32-Inch Computer Monitors Can Increase Your Workflow

With the near-constant usage of technology around the world today, ergonomics have become crucial in business. Moving to 32 inch computer monitors is perhaps one of the best and most valuable improvements you can possibly implement. This-sized moni...

Top Tips for Finding a Great Florist for Your Sydney Wedding

While the choice of wedding venue does much of the heavy lifting when it comes to wowing guests, decorations are certainly not far behind. They can add a bit of personality and flair to the traditional proceedings, as well as enhancing the venue’s ...

Avant Stone's 2025 Nature's Palette Collection

Avant Stone, a longstanding supplier of quality natural stone in Sydney, introduces the 2025 Nature’s Palette Collection. Curated for architects, designers, and homeowners with discerning tastes, this selection highlights classic and contemporary a...

LayBy Shopping