Google AI
The Times Australia

Times Media

China is taking Russia’s oil from India — and Australia could pay at the fuel pump

  • Written by: The Times

The World is short of oil not due to its existence but the Iran and Ukraine wars

The Iran war has produced another unexpected consequence.

China needs oil.

India needs oil.

Russia has oil.

And Australia needs the petrol, diesel and aviation fuel that Asian refineries manufacture from it.

Those apparently separate facts are becoming part of the same story.

China has sharply increased its purchases of Russian crude as it attempts to replace Middle Eastern and particularly Iranian supplies disrupted by the Iran war.

The problem is that much of the Russian crude China is now pursuing has traditionally gone somewhere else.

India.

India's purchases of Russian crude have consequently fallen sharply.

That matters far beyond India because the country is one of Asia's major refiners and exporters of diesel, petrol and other petroleum products.

If Indian refineries cannot obtain enough crude, their output may eventually fall.

And Australia buys finished fuel in the same increasingly constrained Asian market.

The Iran war is therefore creating an extraordinary chain reaction.

Iran loses exports. China looks to Russia. China competes with India. Indian crude supplies tighten. Asian refined-fuel supplies become more vulnerable. Australia competes for what remains.

The battlefield may be thousands of kilometres away.

The eventual consequence could appear on an Australian service-station price board.

China has an enormous hole to fill

Before the war, China was the dominant customer for Iranian crude.

More than 80 per cent of Iran's shipped oil has historically been destined for China.

Commodity analysts Kpler estimate China imported about 1.14 million barrels a day of Iranian crude in March, reflecting cargoes loaded before the US and Israeli attacks on Iran began on February 28.

By August, estimated Iranian arrivals had collapsed to around 340,000 barrels a day.

China therefore needs replacement oil.

Its refineries still need crude.

Its economy still consumes enormous quantities of petroleum.

So Chinese buyers have done exactly what markets encourage them to do.

They have gone somewhere else.

Russia provides part of the answer

China already buys enormous quantities of Russian oil.

But its buying pattern is changing.

Kpler estimates Chinese imports of seaborne Russian crude at about 1.25 million barrels a day during August.

July and August are China's two strongest months for seaborne Russian crude imports since April.

More importantly, China is increasingly purchasing Russian crude from European ports.

Historically, China obtained most of its seaborne Russian supply from Russia's eastern ports.

India was the major customer for Russian crude leaving European terminals.

That division is breaking down.

Kpler estimates approximately 31 per cent of China's Russian seaborne crude will come from European ports during August.

China has entered India's supply chain.

India suddenly has a problem

India became an enormous buyer of Russian oil after Western sanctions reshaped petroleum trade following Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

The arrangement suited both countries.

Russia obtained a major customer.

India obtained substantial quantities of discounted crude.

Indian refineries could process that crude and sell petroleum products into domestic and international markets.

The Iran war initially made that relationship even more important.

India imported about 2.73 million barrels a day of Russian crude in June and 2.79 million barrels a day in July, according to Kpler estimates cited by Reuters.

For August, that is expected to fall to approximately 1.87 million barrels a day.

That is a very large change in one month.

The competition is particularly intense in Europe

The numbers become even more revealing when Russian export locations are examined.

India's purchases from Russia's European ports are estimated to have fallen by about 770,000 barrels a day in August, or almost 30 per cent.

China, meanwhile, is taking more crude from those same western Russian ports.

This is what a genuine global supply disruption looks like.

Oil does not simply disappear.

Trade routes change.

Buyers compete.

Cargoes change direction.

Discounts change.

Tankers travel different routes.

One country's solution can become another country's problem.

India's total crude imports are falling

The consequences are already becoming visible.

Kpler estimates India's overall crude imports at approximately 4.17 million barrels a day during August, down from about 5.06 million in July.

That would be India's lowest monthly import level since the Iran conflict began. The August estimate may still be revised as additional cargoes are identified before the end of the month.

For the moment, India's refineries continue exporting substantial quantities of fuel.

August exports of light and middle distillates are estimated at around 1.29 million barrels a day, roughly matching July.

So the problem has not yet become a collapse in Indian fuel exports.

The concern is what happens next.

September could reveal the real effect

There is normally a delay between a change in crude supply and its effect on refinery output.

The oil already inside the system can continue being processed.

Inventories provide a buffer.

Cargoes already at sea arrive.

Contracts continue being fulfilled.

That means August's lower crude imports may not materially affect India's finished-fuel exports until September or later.

Reuters' analysis identifies precisely that risk: if India's crude shortage persists and refinery production falls, the resulting reduction in fuel exports would intensify an already tight Asian refined-products market.

For Australia, that is the point worth watching.

Australia buys the product India makes

Australia's petroleum vulnerability is sometimes misunderstood.

We frequently discuss whether the world has enough crude oil.

That is important.

But Australia needs something more specific.

Finished fuel.

Petrol.

Diesel.

Aviation fuel.

Crude oil has to pass through a refinery before it becomes those products.

Australia has only limited domestic refining capacity and depends heavily on imported refined petroleum.

That makes the health of Asian refining enormously important to us.

If Indian refineries produce less fuel for export, the consequences do not have to involve a direct India-to-Australia cargo.

Supply is fungible.

Remove fuel from the regional market and everybody competes for a smaller pool.

This is already an exceptionally tight market

Unfortunately, the potential Indian problem is arriving at precisely the wrong time.

The Iran war has damaged the global refining system far more severely than many initially expected.

More than 20 per cent of the Middle East's 9.6 million barrels-a-day refining capacity remains offline, according to International Energy Agency figures cited by Reuters.

Global refinery runs during the second quarter were approximately 5.1 million barrels a day below the corresponding period last year.

The world has done an extraordinary job replacing disrupted crude.

Replacing refinery capacity has proved much harder.

You can redirect oil more easily than rebuild a refinery

That distinction explains much of what Australians are seeing in fuel markets.

When Middle Eastern crude became difficult to obtain, buyers found alternatives.

American crude went to Asia.

West African crude went east.

Russian trade changed direction.

Saudi Arabia used alternative export infrastructure.

The UAE used Fujairah.

Ship-to-ship transfers expanded.

Tankers travelled further.

The market adapted.

But a damaged refinery cannot simply be moved somewhere else.

Industrial refining complexes cost billions of dollars and take years to construct.

Replacement parts can be highly specialised.

Repairs take time.

And refineries cannot indefinitely operate above their designed capacity.

The world can find another barrel of crude considerably faster than it can find another refinery.

Russia creates another complication

Russia might appear to provide the solution.

It is one of the world's largest petroleum producers.

But Russian refining itself has been severely disrupted by Ukrainian attacks on energy infrastructure.

Reuters reports Russian refining throughput has fallen sharply in recent months, contributing to reduced international fuel availability.

So Russia can export crude to China and India.

But disruption to Russian refineries reduces the amount of finished Russian fuel reaching international markets.

The world gains crude supply while simultaneously losing some refining output.

Again, the problem has moved downstream.

Global fuel inventories have been providing the cushion

The reason this has not produced an even larger crisis is inventory.

Before the war, the world had substantial quantities of petroleum products in storage.

Those inventories allowed consumption to exceed current refinery production for a period.

But inventories are finite.

Reuters, citing US Energy Information Administration estimates, says global oil stocks fell at a rate of around 3.5 million barrels a day between March and July.

US diesel inventories are at their lowest level for this time of year in three decades.

The buffer that protected consumers during the first months of the crisis is being depleted.

That makes every additional refinery disruption more consequential.

India therefore matters much more than it might appear

A reduction in Indian refining would not occur in isolation.

It would arrive on top of:

lost Middle Eastern refinery production;

reduced Russian refining;

depleted international inventories;

extraordinary diesel refining margins;

expensive tanker freight;

continued Hormuz disruption;

and elevated crude prices.

The system has less spare capacity available to absorb another problem.

That is why China's competition for Russian crude matters to Australia.

It potentially weakens another part of the supply chain we rely upon.

Oil itself is rising again

The crude market is also becoming more expensive.

Brent crude settled 2.4 per cent higher at US$93.78 a barrel on Thursday, its highest settlement since July 24, after the United States threatened substantially stronger economic measures against Iran and countries helping sustain its economy.

That means Australia faces pressure at both ends of the petroleum chain.

The raw material is becoming more expensive again.

And the capacity to transform that raw material into finished fuel remains constrained.

That is an uncomfortable combination.

Diesel is particularly important to Australia

Petrol receives enormous public attention because households buy it directly.

Diesel is arguably more important to the functioning of the economy.

Trucks.

Farms.

Mining.

Construction.

Heavy machinery.

Regional transport.

Generators.

Commercial fleets.

Much of Australia's physical economy depends upon diesel.

When diesel becomes expensive, the cost does not remain at the service station.

It travels.

The truck passes the cost onwards

Consider a supermarket product.

Its ingredients may have travelled to a factory.

Packaging arrives separately.

The finished product moves to a distribution centre.

Then another truck takes it to a supermarket.

Every journey requires energy.

If diesel becomes more expensive, transport operators eventually have to recover some of that cost.

The supermarket receives a higher freight bill.

The supplier faces higher distribution costs.

Eventually some portion can reach the consumer.

That is how an international oil-market rearrangement can become Australian inflation.

Regional Australia has greater exposure

Distance magnifies the problem.

Products arriving at an Australian port may still have hundreds or thousands of kilometres to travel.

Regional supermarkets require deliveries.

Farm inputs need transportation.

Machinery needs moving.

Produce has to reach processors and markets.

Remote communities have fewer alternatives.

Higher diesel prices therefore have a disproportionately important effect outside the major metropolitan centres.

Australia's geography makes transport energy economically significant.

Aviation belongs in the same discussion

The refined-fuel shortage is not confined to diesel.

Aviation fuel remains under pressure as well.

Australia depends heavily upon aviation because of its geography.

International tourism.

Regional connectivity.

Business travel.

Air freight.

All require reliable jet-fuel supply.

A crude shortage affecting Asian refineries can therefore eventually affect aviation as well as road transport.

Again, the important commodity is not simply crude oil.

It is the particular refined product Australia needs.

The market is performing an extraordinary balancing act

None of this means Australia is about to run out of fuel.

That distinction is important.

Markets are adapting.

High prices encourage additional refinery output where capacity exists.

They suppress some demand.

They attract cargoes from distant suppliers.

They encourage governments to release inventories.

China has increased some refined-product exports.

American refineries have been operating at very high utilisation.

Australia is strengthening its own strategic fuel arrangements.

The system continues functioning.

But it is functioning with progressively less margin for error.

China is solving China's problem

There is nothing unusual about China's behaviour.

China needs crude.

Iranian supply has collapsed.

Russian crude is available.

Chinese refiners buy it.

That is rational.

India does exactly the same thing when it can.

The important point is not to assign blame.

It is to understand the consequence.

In a constrained global market, one buyer's replacement supply can be another buyer's lost supply.

The barrel China buys from western Russia is a barrel India may have expected to purchase.

India then has to find another barrel somewhere else.

That replacement barrel may otherwise have gone to another refinery.

The competition spreads.

Sanctions could make the equation even more complicated

There is another geopolitical layer.

The United States is preparing what Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has described as extraordinarily severe new sanctions against Iran, while President Donald Trump has threatened consequences for countries providing Tehran with economic support.

China remains Iran's principal oil customer.

At the same time, India faces its own uncertainty over purchases of Russian crude.

This means the two largest Asian oil importers are attempting to restructure their supply while sanctions policy around both Iran and Russia remains fluid.

Oil traders dislike uncertainty.

Refiners dislike uncertainty.

Shipping companies dislike uncertainty.

Eventually, risk itself acquires a price.

The Australian dollar matters as well

Australians purchase internationally traded petroleum largely priced in US dollars.

That means the exchange rate can either cushion or magnify international movements.

A stronger Australian dollar can absorb some of an increase in US-dollar fuel prices.

A weaker dollar makes the international increase more expensive locally.

That is why Australian motorists should never expect an exact relationship between Brent and the number appearing on the service-station sign.

Crude is only one component.

Refining margins, freight, currency, taxation and retail economics all matter.

This could keep inflation alive

The broader economic implication is becoming increasingly important.

Australia has already experienced an energy shock from the Iran conflict.

If refined-fuel scarcity persists, the inflationary effect can last much longer than the initial crude-price spike.

Freight becomes more expensive.

Agriculture becomes more expensive.

Construction becomes more expensive.

Air transport becomes more expensive.

Imported goods can become more expensive.

Businesses attempt to recover their costs.

That is how an external energy shock becomes embedded in domestic prices.

And the Reserve Bank cannot fix the underlying problem

Interest rates cannot create Russian crude.

They cannot repair a Gulf refinery.

They cannot increase Indian refinery feedstock.

They cannot reopen Hormuz.

They cannot manufacture diesel.

But the Reserve Bank of Australia is responsible for domestic inflation.

If international energy costs begin influencing broader Australian prices and inflation expectations, monetary policy eventually has to respond to the consequences of a problem it cannot itself solve.

That is one of the most difficult characteristics of supply-driven inflation.

Reopening Hormuz would help — but it would no longer solve everything

This is perhaps the most important development of all.

Earlier in the conflict, reopening the Strait of Hormuz appeared to offer the obvious solution.

Today it would still provide enormous relief.

More crude could move.

More refined products could move.

Shipping costs could fall.

Insurance risk could decline.

But the energy system has suffered damage beyond the Strait itself.

Refineries have been damaged.

Inventories have been consumed.

Russian refining is disrupted.

Trade patterns have been rearranged.

Tankers have been repositioned.

Reuters analysis argues that even a diplomatic resolution would not immediately restore the lost refining capacity or replenish depleted inventories.

The recovery could therefore take much longer than the reopening of a shipping lane.

What Australia should watch next

The next important indicator may not be Brent.

It may be Indian refinery output and fuel exports during September.

If India's crude imports recover, the problem may ease.

If India secures replacement barrels elsewhere, refinery operations can continue.

If Chinese demand for Russian crude moderates, competition may diminish.

But if India's crude availability remains constrained and its exports of diesel and petrol begin falling, Asia's refined-fuel shortage enters another stage.

That would have direct relevance to Australia.

The Times View

The Iran war began by disrupting Middle Eastern oil.

The consequences are now travelling around the world.

China lost much of its Iranian supply.

It went looking for replacement crude.

Russia had barrels available.

China increased its purchases.

But many of those barrels were part of the supply system feeding India.

Indian Russian crude imports have consequently fallen sharply, from around 2.79 million barrels a day in July to an estimated 1.87 million barrels a day in August.

India's overall crude imports are estimated at their lowest level since the Iran war began.

For the moment, Indian fuel exports remain strong.

The danger comes next.

If less crude enters Indian refineries, eventually less petrol and diesel can come out.

And India is a major supplier to an Asian refined-fuel market already struggling with lost Middle Eastern refinery capacity, disrupted Russian production and depleted inventories.

Australia participates in that market.

That is why a contest between China and India for Russian crude matters here.

China is solving its Iranian oil problem by buying more Russian oil. In doing so, it may be creating a crude problem for India. If that becomes a refinery problem for India, it becomes a fuel-supply problem for Asia.

And when Asia has a fuel problem, Australia cannot stand outside it.

We import the consequences.

The next chapter of the Iran war may therefore appear far removed from Hormuz.

It could emerge in an Indian refinery that does not have enough crude to process.

But follow the supply chain far enough and it eventually leads to an Australian truck, aircraft or service station.

That is how a global energy crisis travels.

Times Magazine

China copied the Falcon 9 formula. Now it has made it work

China has spent years watching SpaceX transform the economics of spaceflight. Now it is beginning...

Tax Deductions Australians Are Missing – and the Claims That Could Land You in Hot Water

Every tax season, Australians tend to fall into one of two camps. There are those who are so nervou...

Camden Valley Inn Opens Its Doors for Couples Planning Their Dream Wedding

Couples are invited to discover one of South-West Sydney’s most picturesque wedding destinations and...

Technology

China copied the Falcon 9 formula. …

China has spent years watching SpaceX transform the economics of spaceflight. Now it is beginning...

Local News

Psychology clinic in Tasmania opens…

In response to Tasmania’s growing mental health crisis, a new purpose-built, multi-disciplinary me...

Culture

World’s Largest Outback Choir rocks the Mundi…

Thousands of Bashers came together in the world’s biggest outback choir - raising vital funds for ...

Travel

Cairns Esplanade Lagoon — the stage where Cai…

“All the world's a stage.” Shakespeare wasn't writing about Cairns when he penned that famous lin...

The Times Features

World’s Largest Outback Choir rocks the Mundi Mundi Pla…

Thousands of Bashers came together in the world’s biggest outback choir - raising vital funds for ...

Zambrero Rolls Out Australian-First Air-Fried Hot Chips

The country's biggest Mexican food franchise becomes the first to air-fry its hot chips - crisp, gol...

Broken Hill Mundi Mundi Bash pop up concerts

In support of patrons unable to access the event site due to unprecedented rainfall, the Broken H...