The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

Is Dune an example of a white saviour narrative – or a critique of it?

  • Written by Cherine Fahd, Associate Professor Visual Communication, University of Technology Sydney
Is Dune an example of a white saviour narrative – or a critique of it?

Science-fiction film as a genre allows us to encounter hypothetical worlds in which to understand our own[1].

These films often present utopian and dystopian worlds, exploring themes of nationalism and heroism. They often include a strong, white, male lead who heroically rescues the poor and the good from the stranglehold of authoritarianism. Therefore, historically, science fiction has had mass appeal for political zealots from the far left to the alt-right[2].

In Denis Villeneuve’s Dune: Part Two (2024), however, science fiction becomes a genre to subvert colonial and patriarchal narratives of the white, masculine saviour.

Read more: Bagpipes in space: how Hans Zimmer created the dramatic sound world of the new Dune film[3]

What is a ‘white saviour’?

Elements of a white saviour narrative are pervasive in Villeneuve’s first Dune film (2021), which hints at – but doesn’t commit to – subverting this narrative. But before we get into the details, it helps to understand what the “white saviour complex” is.

This is, to put it simply[4], the idea that a white person or people are needed to help or “save” people of colour from their circumstances.

White saviourism, also called the white “messiah complex”, is born of a legacy of colonialism[5], and often performed in a paternalistic or self-serving way. For decades, we’ve seen this narrative play out in science-fiction films, from the Star Wars franchise to Avatar[6] (2009).

The setup

Signs of white saviourism in the first Dune film are recognisable in the male protagonist, Paul Atreides, played by Timothée Chalamet. Paul is destined for messianic status in both films, which have so far stayed close to the plot line of Frank Herbert’s book series of the same name.

However, Chalamet’s casting as a white saviour is complicated by his physicality. In both demeanour and appearance, Paul Atreides contradicts the traditional masculinity[7] of science-fiction heroes, with his fine features, elfin stature and mummy’s boy status.

The casting of Chalamet as Paul Atreides is a departure from more conventional depictions of the white, male saviour. Courtesy Warner Bros

The first film follows the House of Atreides as it travels to the distant planet, Arrakas, to take charge of the scarce and precious spice production which their future wealth, power and survival depend on.

The Indigenous inhabitants of Arrakas, the Fremen, are portrayed as being deeply connected to the desert environment.

They find innovative ways to survive in the extreme weather conditions, yet are considered savage by the aristocratic characters in the film. They’re even referred to as “rats” by the film’s villainous, luminously white, oil-bathing leader, Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.

This reflects a common criticism[8] of the white saviour complex: it perpetuates stereotypes about the Indigenous people being “helped”, while ignoring their strengths and agency.

Dune as a colonial critique

It’s tempting to consider Dune’s narrative, settings and costume design as an appropriation of Islamic and Arab culture. For example, there are scenes where the Fremen are dressed in Bedouin[9] clothing, worshipping behind an Islamic architectural screen in ways that are reminiscent of Muslim prayers at a mosque.

The cinematography and light also appear to refer to 19th-century paintings by Jean-Léon Gérôme, much of which are of Islamic subjects. Such appropriations aren’t unique to Dune; the landscape of Arrakas itself is reminiscent of Tatooine, the desert planet where much of the action takes place in the original Star Wars[10] trilogy.

While the intention may be to create otherworldly settings, the portrayal of a desert land often relies on stereotypical tropes of “exoticness”[11] associated with the Middle East, as well as the use of Arabic-sounding names for characters and locations.

The Fremen are portrayed with clear parallels to real Arab-Bedouin peoples. Courtesy Warner Bros

Nonetheless, there is a surprising critique of colonialist fantasy in Dune: Part Two, which primarily takes place through changes between the script and the book[12]. These changes enable us to see the white saviour from the perspective of Chani (played by Zendaya), Paul’s Fremen love interest.

In the book, Chani is a supporting character who is merely there to encourage and promote Paul’s ascendancy. She is also a white person who is bound to Paul through having his children. In the film, Chani’s character has been adapted to provide a critical counterpoint.

This reveals Villeneuve’s directorial intention in reframing the book to account for the postcolonial and feminist perspectives of the 21st century. In many ways, Dune: Part Two can be read through the post-colonial perspective of late Palestinian-American writer Edward Said[13].

In his 1978 book Orientalism[14], a founding text of post-colonialism, Said argued against the West’s distorted image of the East or the Orient as exotic, backward, uncivilised and sometimes dangerous.

He expressed that Western scholars, artists and politicians use Orientalism as a pervasive framework to depict the East as the “Other”. This reinforces a binary opposition between the West as rational, developed and superior and the East as irrational, undeveloped and inferior.

While we see this play out in both Dune films’ visual tropes, a more nuanced message is delivered through the character of Chani.

Paul through Chani’s eyes

Chani is a woman of colour who is sceptical of Paul’s mother’s intentions for him as leader. She also refuses to believe in the prophecy of a saviour, as is held by some Fremen.

Ultimately, the film’s postcolonial and feminist leanings are made explicit in the final scenes. Through careful cinematography and editing, the audience is encouraged to see, from Chani’s perspective, the ways in which Paul is being manipulated.

Chani (Zendaya) is sceptical of the intentions of Paul’s mother, Jessica Atreides (Rebecca Ferguson). Courtesy Warner Bros

When Paul avenges the death of his father and takes control of the empire, promising to marry the empress – despite having declared his enduring love for Chani – we encounter this betrayal from Chani’s standpoint.

The scenes tend to switch back to her disappointment as the witness. As viewers, we are not encouraged to celebrate Paul’s rise to messiah. Rather, we mourn the loss of his moral conscience with Chani. And this point is affirmed when we see Chani surfing the worm alone[15] in the final scenes.

As a woman of colour who is both independent, powerful and resistant to the white saviour narrative, Chani activates the idea of looking at cinema from a non-white vantage point[16]. She leads us to be critical of both colonial and patriarchal narratives.

Where will this lead? We will have to find out in the next film.

In a press tour for Dune: Part Two, director Denis Villeneuve said ‘Dune Messiah’ would be his last Dune film. Courtesy Warner Bros

Read more: Diplomacy and resistance: how Dune shows us the power of language – including sign language[17]

References

  1. ^ to understand our own (www.google.com.au)
  2. ^ alt-right (lareviewofbooks.org)
  3. ^ Bagpipes in space: how Hans Zimmer created the dramatic sound world of the new Dune film (theconversation.com)
  4. ^ it simply (www.e-ir.info)
  5. ^ legacy of colonialism (www.google.com.au)
  6. ^ Avatar (www.nytimes.com)
  7. ^ traditional masculinity (www.bloomsbury.com)
  8. ^ common criticism (www.theguardian.com)
  9. ^ Bedouin (www.britannica.com)
  10. ^ Star Wars (www.theguardian.com)
  11. ^ stereotypical tropes of “exoticness” (www.thoughtco.com)
  12. ^ script and the book (www.esquire.com)
  13. ^ Edward Said (www.newworldencyclopedia.org)
  14. ^ Orientalism (theconversation.com)
  15. ^ surfing the worm alone (variety.com)
  16. ^ non-white vantage point (warwick.ac.uk)
  17. ^ Diplomacy and resistance: how Dune shows us the power of language – including sign language (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/is-dune-an-example-of-a-white-saviour-narrative-or-a-critique-of-it-225656

The Times Features

The Budget-Friendly Traveler: How Off-Airport Car Hire Can Save You Money

When planning a trip, transportation is one of the most crucial considerations. For many, the go-to option is renting a car at the airport for convenience. But what if we told ...

Air is an overlooked source of nutrients – evidence shows we can inhale some vitamins

You know that feeling you get when you take a breath of fresh air in nature? There may be more to it than a simple lack of pollution. When we think of nutrients, we think of t...

FedEx Australia Announces Christmas Shipping Cut-Off Dates To Help Beat the Holiday Rush

With Christmas just around the corner, FedEx is advising Australian shoppers to get their presents sorted early to ensure they arrive on time for the big day. FedEx has reveale...

Will the Wage Price Index growth ease financial pressure for households?

The Wage Price Index’s quarterly increase of 0.8% has been met with mixed reactions. While Australian wages continue to increase, it was the smallest increase in two and a half...

Back-to-School Worries? 70% of Parents Fear Their Kids Aren’t Ready for Day On

Australian parents find themselves confronting a key decision: should they hold back their child on the age border for another year before starting school? Recent research from...

Democratising Property Investment: How MezFi is Opening Doors for Everyday Retail Investors

The launch of MezFi today [Friday 15th November] marks a watershed moment in Australian investment history – not just because we're introducing something entirely new, but becaus...

Times Magazine

Skullcandy's New Skull-iQ Earbuds have one big advantage over key competition

Easy-to-Use, Voice-Driven Technology Platform Debuts With The All-New Push Active True Wireless And Grind True Wireless Earbuds, Unlocking A Range of Hands-Free Audio Experiences   Skullcandy®, the original lifestyle audio brand, announced to...

CRM Implementation Challenges and How to Overcome Them

Modern business moves quickly and demands satisfaction from customers. One of the best ways to achieve this is through Customer Relationship Management, or CRM for short. Implementing a CRM system can greatly benefit businesses, especially in the ret...

Transformation of imagination into reality

Captivating Visual arts In relation to the visual arts which are ever evolving, there has been one entity that has been highly successful with respect to stealing the spotlight. This theft has occurred through the utilization of the medium's mes...

AURA BUY INVEST DONATE

Aura Buy Invest Donate, one of Australia’s newest cash back reward programs, is thrilled to announce Shell Coles Express as its Exclusive Fuel Partner, in a new deal that will see Aura Members receive money back into their Aura Investment Account...

Making Memories Around Your Pool- Here Are Some Fantastic Tips to Help You Capture Those Perfect Moments

Now you have your dream pool in your yard; it is time to make some wonderful memories. Your pool space offers a fantastic scope to take delightful pictures, and it would be a great idea to capture those special moments in the pool. It doesn't matt...

How to improve sleep and comfort with a high-quality double bed quilt cover

Every loving couple looks forward to spending quality time together. It is often likely after being apart in different workplaces before spending the evening either relaxing at home or maybe occasionally heading out for dinner or entertainment. Cat...