The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

The Greens aren't grandstanding on a new coal and gas ban – they're negotiating well

  • Written by Rebecca Pearse, Lecturer, Australian National University
pilbara gas export

This fortnight, Australia’s parliament is considering an amendment to the safeguard mechanism[1], which is the main way we’ve tried to cut emissions over the last nine years. As you may already know, it hasn’t done[2] what it was meant to do.

The mechanism was meant to force our largest greenhouse gas polluters to buy carbon credits if they emitted over a baseline. But almost no one ever paid, as the baselines were set very high. That’s why Labor wants to tighten up Australia’s overly flexible carbon trading scheme[3] as part of this bill.

But to pass it, the government needs support from most of the crossbench, which is unlikely, or from the Greens, given the Coalition has refused to support it. Australia’s third largest party has offered to “support the bill tomorrow[4]” – if the Albanese government agrees to stop all new coal and gas[5] projects.

Labor won’t agree to this. But it will need[6] to negotiate to have any chance of success.

Are the Greens grandstanding, as some commentators have suggested? Hardly: they’re negotiating hard to try to get the best outcome for the climate.

Read more: Grattan on Friday: Adam Bandt is wedged by Greens' overreach on emissions legislation[7]

The trouble with negotiating strong carbon market rules

If the Greens were in power, they might choose a different approach. But they are limited by what Labor is offering: the ability to improve the rules of Australia’s carbon market[8].

In 2023, our methods of driving down emissions are still limited. Labor has decided to focus on improving the safeguard mechanism, which is a baseline-and-credit[9] carbon offset scheme first legislated [10] by the Abbott Coalition government in 2014.

Because of very loose[11] baselines given to the 215 major emitters covered by the scheme, emissions actually grew. The previous government also bought carbon credits through the flawed Emissions Reduction Fund[12].

What Labor proposes[13] is to make the mechanism function more like the carbon market set up by the Rudd/Gillard Labor governments over a decade ago.

How? By adding rules to allow new flexibility options for crediting and trading of carbon rights. The current safeguard bill also adds a “reserve” carbon budget for new fossil fuel projects, which would allow them to be built.

At the same time, the Chubb review[14] into our carbon offset laws is recommending more oversight[15] into the scheme following integrity questions[16].

In sum, though, climate change minister Chris Bowen’s proposed amendments are still too flexible[17].

If Labor gets its amendments through unchanged, big industrial emitters will likely[18] be able to avoid actually having to reduce how much carbon dioxide and methane they can pump into the skies through loose baselines and unlimited offsets.

gladstone coal export
Will Australia keep approving new fossil fuel projects, as in this 2014 photo of a coal export terminal being built in Gladstone in Queensland? Dave Hunt/AAP

Is ‘no new coal and gas’ viable?

Since the early 2000s, the environment movement have campaigned for “no new coal[19]”. As the gas industry surged in the 2010s, environmentalists called for limits on fracking and exports.

It’s entirely reasonable for the Greens to push the government to come clean about plans for emissions-intensive industries. Mining workers want to know[20] what the future will hold. Labor voters are also wondering[21].

The Greens want a managed transition plan[22] out of thermal coal by 2030 and coking coal (used for steelmaking) by 2040, with packages to help workers change jobs. They want Australia to be the first major fossil fuel exporter to limit production.

That’s what they want. But what can they get, given carbon-pricing mechanisms like the safeguard mechanism leave these decisions to the market[23]?

This week, the Greens and the Coalition are forcing the government to release its modelling[24] of the future of emissions-intensive industries.

How big does the government expect fossil fuel production facilities to be in the future? How much will big emitters rely on offsetting rather than reductions at the source?

pilbara gas export In the last 15 years, Australia’s gas exports have skyrocketed. Shutterstock

Trading offset reform for no new coal and gas?

Crossbencher David Pocock is pushing for reforms on carbon offsets[25]. But the Greens have offered to “put aside[26]” their concerns about offsets if Labor moves to ban new fossil fuel projects.

If the Greens were successful in strengthening safeguard rules to introduce a zero-carbon limit on all new coal and gas mines, new fossil fuel projects would have to find carbon offsets for 100% of their emissions each year. But if Labor keeps refusing this approach, compromise may have to come elsewhere.

Greens leader Adam Bandt says they are making “an offer, not an ultimatum[27]”. They want to bargain.

What could this look like?

Labor might seek to group Pocock and the 12 Green senators together to negotiate limits on permissible carbon offsets. If so, the Greens would end up where they were in 2009–11, trying to ensure carbon market rules minimise use of offsets.

What are the most likely deals we could see?

We could see four other compromises. In order of likelihood, they are:

Pausing new coal and gas mine approvals until environmental laws are stronger

Our biodiversity and environment laws are not up to the task[28]. Labor has pledged[29] to fix them.

Making federal environmental laws stronger is arguably a clearer way to reducing fossil fuel expansion. Why? These laws overlay state planning laws which keep churning out new mining licences. The Greens will want influence here.

The ‘climate trigger’

The Greens want to create a climate trigger modelled on the “water trigger[30]” negotiated by former independent MP Tony Windsor.

A climate trigger, if it got up, would mean future projects would be assessed on greenhouse impact. But it wouldn’t be the same as a direct ban[31] on new coal and gas. The Greens have a climate trigger bill before parliament[32], which would permit the climate change minister to reject large mines.

Bianca De Marchi/AAP Climate change minister Chris Bowen and Prime Minister Anthony Albanese want to amend the safeguard mechanism. The Greens want faster action on fossil fuels.

Replacing offsets

Offsets are often rubbery. But there are other ways to finance carbon cuts[33]. A decarbonisation fund could permit democratic decision-making about carbon and biodiversity improvements.

Given carbon offset credits have political risks[34] for the government and corporations[35], there’s merit to returning to fixed carbon pricing.

Negotiate with the states about fossil fuel industry transition

Labor could offer to negotiate with the states about managing the path away from coal and gas. Talking about what we have to do to stay in our carbon budget[36] could foster parliamentary good faith and end finger pointing.

Climate wars – or real progress?

The Greens have a long history of pushing back against weak climate policy. Labor, in turn, has a history of criticising what they see as doctrinaire refusal. But when the cameras are off, these two parties have managed to achieve compromise and progress. It’s happened before, and it will most likely happen again.

References

  1. ^ safeguard mechanism (www.aph.gov.au)
  2. ^ hasn’t done (theconversation.com)
  3. ^ carbon trading scheme (www.cleanenergyregulator.gov.au)
  4. ^ support the bill tomorrow (youtu.be)
  5. ^ all new coal and gas (greens.org.au)
  6. ^ will need (www.afr.com)
  7. ^ Grattan on Friday: Adam Bandt is wedged by Greens' overreach on emissions legislation (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ carbon market (www.youtube.com)
  9. ^ baseline-and-credit (www.oecd.org)
  10. ^ first legislated (www.legislation.gov.au)
  11. ^ very loose (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ Emissions Reduction Fund (theconversation.com)
  13. ^ Labor proposes (www.aph.gov.au)
  14. ^ Chubb review (www.dcceew.gov.au)
  15. ^ more oversight (www.theguardian.com)
  16. ^ integrity questions (www.theguardian.com)
  17. ^ still too flexible (theconversation.com)
  18. ^ will likely (www.themonthly.com.au)
  19. ^ no new coal (www.routledge.com)
  20. ^ want to know (www.afr.com)
  21. ^ also wondering (www.smh.com.au)
  22. ^ managed transition plan (greens.org.au)
  23. ^ to the market (www.abc.net.au)
  24. ^ release its modelling (www.theguardian.com)
  25. ^ reforms on carbon offsets (www.thesaturdaypaper.com.au)
  26. ^ put aside (www.abc.net.au)
  27. ^ an offer, not an ultimatum (www.abc.net.au)
  28. ^ not up to the task (www.canberratimes.com.au)
  29. ^ has pledged (www.theguardian.com)
  30. ^ water trigger (www.dcceew.gov.au)
  31. ^ direct ban (theconversation.com)
  32. ^ before parliament (www.aph.gov.au)
  33. ^ finance carbon cuts (theconversation.com)
  34. ^ political risks (www.theguardian.com)
  35. ^ corporations (www.afr.com)
  36. ^ our carbon budget (www.smh.com.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/the-greens-arent-grandstanding-on-a-new-coal-and-gas-ban-theyre-negotiating-well-201287

The Times Features

Air is an overlooked source of nutrients – evidence shows we can inhale some vitamins

You know that feeling you get when you take a breath of fresh air in nature? There may be more to it than a simple lack of pollution. When we think of nutrients, we think of t...

FedEx Australia Announces Christmas Shipping Cut-Off Dates To Help Beat the Holiday Rush

With Christmas just around the corner, FedEx is advising Australian shoppers to get their presents sorted early to ensure they arrive on time for the big day. FedEx has reveale...

Will the Wage Price Index growth ease financial pressure for households?

The Wage Price Index’s quarterly increase of 0.8% has been met with mixed reactions. While Australian wages continue to increase, it was the smallest increase in two and a half...

Back-to-School Worries? 70% of Parents Fear Their Kids Aren’t Ready for Day On

Australian parents find themselves confronting a key decision: should they hold back their child on the age border for another year before starting school? Recent research from...

Democratising Property Investment: How MezFi is Opening Doors for Everyday Retail Investors

The launch of MezFi today [Friday 15th November] marks a watershed moment in Australian investment history – not just because we're introducing something entirely new, but becaus...

Game of Influence: How Cricket is Losing Its Global Credibility

be losing its credibility on the global stage. As other sports continue to capture global audiences and inspire unity, cricket finds itself increasingly embroiled in political ...

Times Magazine

Interview with author Christian White. His latest book The Ledge is out now

What inspired you to write the book? I’d always wanted to write a coming-of-age thriller. The book started as a love letter to all the coming-of-age books and movies that shaped me as a teenager: Lord of The Flies, It, The Body / Stand By Me, The ...

Consider This Before Selling Your Motorhome on Consignment

It goes without saying that selling your motorhome is one of the greatest decisions to make when it is not being used or you want to buy a new vehicle and do not want to keep your old one. Although renting the motorhome for passive income or tradin...

How to Optimize Your Dust Collector’s Performance with the Right Filter Cartridge

The filter cartridge is one of the critical components of your dust collector system, and the efficiency of your system depends largely on it. The type of cartridge used in the dust collection system can significantly influence its performance, cos...

Rental Car Accidents: Key Steps to Take Right After a Crash

Rental Car Accidents: Key Steps to Take Right After a Crash The Immediate Aftermath of a Rental Car Accident When the unexpected happens, and you're involved in a rental car accident, the moments immediately following the crash are crucial. S...

Make the Most of Your Printing with the Right Printer Price in Singapore

Printers Available in Singapore Singapore is home to a wide variety of printers available at various price points. Whether you need a printer for home or office use, there's something for everyone. With the latest technology and features on offer...

Unveiling The Future: Dive Into The Latest Canon Models Online

Canon has remained at the forefront in the rapidly changing world of photography, continually setting new standards and transforming the sector. Canon constantly introduces innovative camera models that enthrall both professionals and enthusiasts...