The Times Australia
The Times News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

With their mother’s Australian citizenship cancelled over alleged ISIS-links, how will NZ deal with her children?

  • Written by Claire Breen, Professor of Law, University of Waikato
With their mother’s Australian citizenship cancelled over alleged ISIS-links, how will NZ deal with her children?

By unilaterally revoking the citizenship[1] of the 26-year-old woman detained in Turkey this week, Australia has potentially left her two children in diplomatic limbo.

Known only as “S.A.” (but named by the ABC[2] as Suhayra Aden from Melbourne), she was the subject of an Interpol blue notice, according to the Turkish Ministry of National Defence, which alleges she was a terrorist with Islamic State.

New Zealand Prime Minister Jacdina Ardern responded sternly[3] to Australia’s actions, saying it amounted to their dumping the problem on New Zealand’s doorstep.

The mother had dual New Zealand and Australian citizenship, but left New Zealand for Australia at the age of six, and travelled to Syria from Australia.

It would now appear Australia is also seeking to shut the door on the two children. To paraphrase the old saying, the sins of the mother are being visited upon the children.

The ‘privileges’ of citizenship

The stripping of citizenship as a counter-terrorism measure seeks to address the threat posed by individuals suspected of, or engaged in, terrorist activity.

It’s a tactic used by many countries to prevent citizens from returning when they’re perceived as a risk to national security.

Read more: New Zealand is violating the rights of its children. Is it time to change the legal definition of age discrimination?[4]

These types of legal balancing acts between an individual’s human rights and national security are not uncommon. As Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison has stated[5] more prosaically, his job is to protect Australians from terrorists “enjoying privileges” of citizenship.

But that view overlooks the situation of two other individuals. Aged five and under, they are presumably not suspected of terrorist activity. Legally, this raises questions about the justification for limiting their citizenship rights.

Where do the children stand?

In spite of the seeming intractability of the row between the two countries, the situation facing these children needs resolving.

Key to that will be the recognition that children enjoy the same human rights protections as adults under the general framework of international human rights law. They also have particular and specific protection under the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child 1989[6].

Both Australia and New Zealand have accepted these international legal obligations, meaning a number of the provisions of this convention must inform both countries’ decisions in this case.

The convention opens by stating[7] that the family is “the fundamental group of society” and the child should grow up in a family environment[8].

Similarly, involuntary separation[9] is to be avoided, unless it is in the child’s best interests.

The right to a nationality

Children have a right to a nationality[10]. As far as possible, they also have the right to know and be cared for by their parents.

This right is particularly important in the current situation. Children born overseas to Australian citizens can claim Australian citizenship upon application. So too can the children of New Zealanders born overseas.

However, the children of Australian citizens who have had their citizenship revoked can themselves lose[11] their citizenship rights.

The UN Committee on the Rights of the Child[12] highlighted the potential impact on the citizenship of Australian children. It called for Australia to ensure no child is deprived of citizenship on any ground regardless of the status of his or her parents.

Human rights versus national security

The case also raises questions around the balancing of national security and human rights. For the children involved, a number of the convention’s guiding principles[13] underpin these rights.

As part of the prohibition of discrimination[14], states are required to ensure the child is protected against all forms of discrimination or punishment on the basis of the status or activities of the child’s parents.

Read more: 'The Australian government is not listening': how our country is failing to protect its children[15]

The best interests[16] of the child should govern all decisions relating to them, and the child has a right to be heard[17] in all proceedings affecting them.

The child also has the right to life[18], survival and development. Given reports that a third sibling has died[19] of pneumonia, this right and guiding principle[20] takes on real significance.

In essence, then, the rights of the child must inform any decisions about the future of these children. As part of that process, the maintenance of relationships with the wider family unit — if not their mother — is still key and the child’s best interests must be taken into account.

These are rights, not privileges.

References

  1. ^ revoking the citizenship (www.theguardian.com)
  2. ^ named by the ABC (www.abc.net.au)
  3. ^ responded sternly (www.stuff.co.nz)
  4. ^ New Zealand is violating the rights of its children. Is it time to change the legal definition of age discrimination? (theconversation.com)
  5. ^ stated (www.newshub.co.nz)
  6. ^ UN Convention on the Rights of the Child 1989 (www.ohchr.org)
  7. ^ stating (www.ohchr.org)
  8. ^ grow up in a family environment (www.ohchr.org)
  9. ^ involuntary separation (www.ohchr.org)
  10. ^ nationality (www.ohchr.org)
  11. ^ lose (www.legislation.gov.au)
  12. ^ UN Committee on the Rights of the Child (www2.ohchr.org)
  13. ^ guiding principles (docstore.ohchr.org)
  14. ^ prohibition of discrimination (www.ohchr.org)
  15. ^ 'The Australian government is not listening': how our country is failing to protect its children (theconversation.com)
  16. ^ best interests (www.ohchr.org)
  17. ^ right to be heard (www.ohchr.org)
  18. ^ right to life (www.ohchr.org)
  19. ^ third sibling has died (www.abc.net.au)
  20. ^ guiding principle (docstore.ohchr.org)

Read more https://theconversation.com/with-their-mothers-australian-citizenship-cancelled-over-alleged-isis-links-how-will-nz-deal-with-her-children-155385

The Times Features

Brisbane Water Bill Savings: Practical Tips to Reduce Costs

Brisbane residents have been feeling the pinch as water costs continue to climb. With increasing prices, it's no wonder many households are searching for ways to ease the burde...

Exploring Hybrid Heating Systems for Modern Homes

Consequently, energy efficiency as well as sustainability are two major considerations prevalent in the current market for homeowners and businesses alike. Hence, integrated heat...

Are Dental Implants Right for You? Here’s What to Think About

Dental implants are now among the top solutions for those seeking to replace and improve their teeth. But are dental implants suitable for you? Here you will find out more about ...

Sunglasses don’t just look good – they’re good for you too. Here’s how to choose the right pair

Australians are exposed to some of the highest levels[1] of solar ultraviolet (UV) radiation in the world. While we tend to focus on avoiding UV damage to our skin, it’s impor...

How to Style the Pantone Color of the Year 2025 - Mocha Mousse

The Pantone Color of the Year never fails to set the tone for the coming year's design, fashion, and lifestyle trends. For 2025, Pantone has unveiled “Mocha Mousse,” a rich a...

How the Aussie summer has a profound effect on 'Climate Cravings’

Weather whiplash describes the rollercoaster-like shifts in weather we’ve experienced this summer —a blazing hot day one moment, followed by an unexpectedly chilly or rainy tur...

Times Magazine

Sheridan Invites You to Live Life in Colour with Their New Summer Collection

It’s time to colour your summer with Sheridan’s new range of beach-ready designs. Dive into the season’s brightest hues with their selection of vibrant beach towels, beach wear, and table linen – where relaxation and fun come to play. Crafted wit...

Explore the Hidden Treasures of the Disney100 Celebration Collection

Disney is a magical place that has captivated the hearts of millions for over a century. To commemorate this momentous milestone, Disney is presenting an unprecedented celebration of its 100th anniversary. As part of this celebration, Disney is unv...

Take Extra Care Through the Help of iPhone Camera Repairs

As technology continues to advance at a breakneck pace, it's becoming increasingly important to know how to repair your Apple iPhone camera. With the rise of social media and the importance of capturing life's moments, having a functioning camera on ...

Make Mom Smile on Her Special Day by Showing Your Love with Mother's Day Flowers

Mother's Day is the perfect time to show your mum just how much she means to you, and what better way to do that than with a beautiful bouquet! Whether you choose a stunning arrangement of roses, lilies, and sunflowers, or a cheerful mix of daisies...

How to Օvercome Լaziness

Everyone has moments of laziness from time to time, when all you need to do is sit or lie down and do nothing. How to overcome this laziness or stop procrastinating. Let's share some useful tips. From time to time, you can afford to be a little...

New household battery incentives now available for NSW

Residents across the state can take advantage of the NSW Government's new incentive to make battery storage more affordable. Installing more batteries across NSW will enable homes and businesses to maximise their use of generated solar energy, lo...

LayBy Shopping