The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

NZ’s government is relying on executive power to govern – that’s not how MMP was meant to work

  • Written by Richard Shaw, Professor of Politics, Massey University
NZ’s government is relying on executive power to govern – that’s not how MMP was meant to work

Thirty years ago, frustrated with wild swings of the policy pendulum and the arrogance of successive Labour and National governments, New Zealanders changed the electoral rules[1].

The old first-past-the-post (FPP) electoral system was replaced with the mixed member proportional system (MMP[2]). At the time, it was thought this would bring the curtain down on an era of executive overreach.

It was hoped multiparty and minority governments would not be able to throw their weight around in the way single-party majority governments can – and often did.

In a nation lacking the constitutional guardrails found elsewhere – including a formally codified constitution, a second parliamentary chamber with powers of legislative oversight, or a top court able to rule on the probity of executive action – electoral law reform looked like a recipe for policy moderation.

Supporters of the new system also anticipated it would encourage a more cooperative style of politics, one that eschewed the combative, winner-takes-all approach practised by successive FPP governments.

Right now, that optimism can look naive. Following three years under a Labour administration that behaved like a minority government despite commanding an outright parliamentary majority, New Zealanders find themselves governed by a three-party coalition more than willing to use its numerical advantage.

David Seymour, Christopher Luxon and Winston Peters walking toward camera in parliament corridor
Using their numbers: Prime Minister Christopher Luxon flanked by his coalition partners David Seymour and Winston Peters. AAP

Urgency and executive power

The National-led coalition has passed more legislation[3] under parliamentary urgency during its first 100 days in office than any other MMP government.

Some will see the parliamentary process being truncated in this way as an indication of efficiency. But it’s equally fair to say there can be a price to pay for avoiding public scrutiny.

Legislation that is not fully stress-tested in select committees can be flawed. And questions can reasonably be raised about the legitimacy of a process that denies public input in this way.

Read more: The government’s first 100 days have gone largely to plan – now comes the hard part[4]

Other initiatives, too, are tipping the balance of power towards the political executive. The government’s fast-track consenting legislation[5] places significant powers in the hands of just three ministers who will have the discretion to overrule judicial decisions.

In effect, they can personally consent to big developments, potentially including roading, mining or tunnelling projects which critics fear might be fast-tracked regardless of their environmental impact[6].

Also telling was the response to outrage[7] over inadequately communicated changes to disability funding. Future decisions on operational matters affecting Whaikaha-Ministry of Disabled People will now be signed off directly by cabinet.

Aside from what it says about the political future of disability issues minister Penny Simmonds, this represents an unusual degree of direct ministerial involvement in the activities of a government department.

Read more: NZ is in recession – so far there are few signs the government has a plan to stimulate and grow the economy[8]

A diminished public service

There are other signs all is not well between ministers and officials. Most obviously, significant numbers of public service jobs are being lost[9].

The fast-track consenting legislation was prepared without a comprehensive analysis[10] of the possible impact on fisheries and the conservation estate. And ministers are making selective use[11] of regulatory impact statements.

In short, the capacity of the public service to speak truth to executive power is being diminished.

Beyond these and other instances of executive muscle flexing, the government’s perceived lack of compassion[12] and rhetorical style have also drawn attention.

Examples include the possible cancellation[13] of the school lunch programme, a seemingly cavalier approach to transparency requirements[14] around ministers and the tobacco industry, the apparent celebration of job losses[15] in the public sector, and the suggestion the state might decide[16] whether school pupils are unwell enough to stay home.

Some of this will pass. But there are reasons to be wary of the return of combative executive politics.

Balancing government and the governed

Left to their own devices, ministers do not always make good decisions. Parliamentary democracy is essentially government by amateurs. Ministers are professional politicians but are rarely experts in their portfolios. They learn on the job[17] and need help doing so.

Much of this assistance comes from officials. The point of a professional public service is to provide expert advice to those with the democratic mandate to take decisions.

Ministers are free not to act on official advice. But deciding on a course of action without at least listening to and considering that advice undermines well-informed decision-making.

Read more: Return of the ‘consultocracy’ – how cutting public service jobs to save costs usually backfires[18]

There is a reason to keep some distance between politics and administration, too. When politicians make decisions about the operations of government departments and ministries, there is the danger that partisanship wins out over considerations of fairness and justice. Removing that gap risks politicising public administration.

Finally, perhaps the biggest threat of the centralisation of executive power is to the integrity of democratic norms and institutions.

In politics there is always a trade-off between decision-making efficiency and democratic effectiveness. New Zealand’s democratic institutions are not the preserve of ministers – they belong to everyone. And they need to endure long after an administration has left the executive stage.

MMP was designed to strike a better equilibrium between government and the governed. Losing that balance would contribute to the kinds of democratic erosion[19] being seen elsewhere in the world.

References

  1. ^ changed the electoral rules (nzhistory.govt.nz)
  2. ^ MMP (elections.nz)
  3. ^ passed more legislation (newsroom.co.nz)
  4. ^ The government’s first 100 days have gone largely to plan – now comes the hard part (theconversation.com)
  5. ^ fast-track consenting legislation (www.beehive.govt.nz)
  6. ^ regardless of their environmental impact (thespinoff.co.nz)
  7. ^ response to outrage (www.rnz.co.nz)
  8. ^ NZ is in recession – so far there are few signs the government has a plan to stimulate and grow the economy (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ public service jobs are being lost (www.nzherald.co.nz)
  10. ^ without a comprehensive analysis (newsroom.co.nz)
  11. ^ making selective use (thespinoff.co.nz)
  12. ^ perceived lack of compassion (newsroom.co.nz)
  13. ^ possible cancellation (www.newshub.co.nz)
  14. ^ transparency requirements (www.nzherald.co.nz)
  15. ^ celebration of job losses (www.newshub.co.nz)
  16. ^ state might decide (www.1news.co.nz)
  17. ^ learn on the job (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  18. ^ Return of the ‘consultocracy’ – how cutting public service jobs to save costs usually backfires (theconversation.com)
  19. ^ democratic erosion (www.idea.int)

Read more https://theconversation.com/nzs-government-is-relying-on-executive-power-to-govern-thats-not-how-mmp-was-meant-to-work-227352

The Times Features

Joykids Australia Presents the Joykids Family Rave: A Weekend Adventure Like No Other

Get ready to kick off the first day of summer and the festive season with an unforgettable family adventure! Joykids Australia is excited to announce the Joykids Family Rave—an...

New study suggests weight loss drugs like Ozempic could help with knee pain. Here’s why there may be a link

The drug semaglutide, commonly known by the brand names Ozempic or Wegovy, was originally developed[1] to help people with type 2 diabetes manage their blood sugar levels. How...

Maintaining Your Pool After a Marble Interior Upgrade

After upgrading your pool with a marble interior, it’s crucial to understand that maintenance is key to preserving its elegance and longevity. You’ll want to regularly skim for d...

Labor using explanatory document to hide true powers of Misinformation Bill

The opinions and commentary of individuals could be deemed misinformation under Labor’s proposed legislation changes, according to James McComish of Victorian Bar. Appearing in...

Hotel Indigo launches limited-edition candle collection inspired by local neighbourhoods across ANZ

Hotel Indigo, part of IHG Hotels & Resorts' luxury and lifestyle portfolio, is releasing a limited-edition candle collection inspired by the unique neighbourhoods its hotel...

Kyndryl ANZ appoints new Head of Strategic Partnerships and Alliances

Former Head of Marketing to lead and grow Kyndryl’s local channel ecosystem and bolster technological capabilities Kyndryl has strengthened its local leadership team with the ...

Times Magazine

Samsung brings Neo QLED 8K Display to Australia

Samsung Australia has announced the expansion of its QLED display business range with the introduction of the Neo QLED 8K Display.     As businesses increasingly need larger displays to create unique brand moments, promote collaborations or req...

Harnessing the Power of ERP for Efficient Business Operations

Definition of ERP System ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) is a type of business management software that enables businesses to manage their core operations, such as accounting, inventory control, human resources and customer relationship manag...

6 Reasons Why West Aussies Love Crossovers

We went from loving the Holden commodore wagon (bless its heart) to a fierce obsession with sedans, but now all anyone can talk about is crossovers. Yep, you can’t shuffle through a car park without gawking at these cars trying to nuzzle their w...

How to Get More Traffic from Google

SEO, or search engine optimisation, is one of the most important aspects of any business website. Without it, your website will likely not appear in Google search results, which means you will miss a lot of potential traffic. This blog post will d...

Holiday Home Hacks: 5 Tips for Beautifying Your Outdoor Living Spaces

Aussie summers are all about time spent outdoors, especially if you're lucky enough to have a holiday home in the family. With the right design choices and professional assistance for the bigger tasks, you can turn your outdoor living space into an...

The Entrepreneur's Legal Toolkit

Essential Resources and When to Call in the Lawyers When it comes to entrepreneurship, laying a strong legal foundation is just as crucial as the business idea itself, if not more. As you embark on the exhilarating journey of building your enterpr...