The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

How about this time we try, just try, to report on budgets and tax differently?

  • Written by Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University

There are just five weeks until the budget[1], and the usual lists of winners and losers[2].

Among last year’s winners[3] were said to be single parents, renters and first home buyers. Among the losers were said to be vapers, truckies and consultants.

Winners and Losers. The Courier Mail on budget morning. Guardian Australia[4]

It’s also how we talk about tax: winners and losers.

On budget night when the changes[5] to the Stage 3 tax cuts are re-announced, we will be told they will make Australians earning less than A$146,000[6] better off than they would have been, and Australians earning more than that worse off.

It’s terribly predictable, but it’s also worse than that.

It’s part of a way of thinking and reporting that makes changes that could actually help us all but impossible.

Making that point passionately in Canberra last week (and apologising for his own role in it) was Ken Henry[7], the government’s chief economic advisor as head of the treasury between 2001 and 2011, and the head of the 2009 Henry Tax Review.

Confessions of a gun for hire

Here’s Henry’s confession. Shortly after he joined the treasury as a tax expert in the lead up to the 1985 tax summit[8] convened by Treasurer Paul Keating and Prime Minister Bob Hawke, he was taken aside by his treasury bosses and told that arguments about making Australia better weren’t going to fly[9].

His bosses told him:

all anybody would want to know is what was in it for them, how many dollars they were going to get – and that’s also all the newspapers would want to know, that’s what they would be printing on their front pages.

What would matter would be the immediate “overnight” estimates of who would win and who would lose. Beyond not costing the government money, nothing else would matter – not how the changes would affect society by funnelling people into doing some things and not others, and not what they would do over time to the people who won or lost on the night.

So, presumably with a heavy heart, Henry developed a computer model that spat out nothing more than immediate winners and losers and ignored what the changes would do to Australia over the longer term.

Winners and losers are (almost) beside the point

Henry says looking back it is easy to understand “why we did what we did”.

“But I can’t escape the sense that, in developing the tools that facilitated squabbles over the distribution of gains and losses among the households of Australia in 1985, we were participating in a conspiracy against future Australian households.”

Henry did it again in 1991, helping build a much more precise version of the model whose exaggerated precision was used by Keating as prime minister to kill off Opposition Leader John Hewson’s plan for a raft of tax changes[10] including a 15% goods and services tax and to end Hewson’s political career.

But it worried Henry. He says Hewson’s package was a genuine attempt to break out of the winners and losers mindset and argue for changes on the basis they would benefit society.

Then in the late 1990s Henry dusted off the model again and used it in the opposite way – to help the Howard government get its 10% GST over the line.

‘A conspiracy against future Australians’

Henry’s confessions tell us about more than the flexibility needed to serve the government of the day. They tell us the thing that matters most, making Australia work better, can’t really be spoken about.

Confessions on tax reform. Ken Henry. Lukas Coch/AAP[11]

And the more it is not spoken about – the more people are merely told what’s in it for them – the harder that is to change.

Here’s what Henry says really matters, and what he says he tried to address in his 2009 tax review.

The things we ought not to celebrate, and ought to tax heavily, are plunder, dumb luck, and a “finders keepers” approach to resources, including mineral resources.

The things we ought to avoid taxing are income from work, the normal rates of return for businesses, and transactions. They are the things we need more of to build our living standards.

We need less tax on wages and ordinary profits, and more on unreasonably large profits, windfall capital gains, wealth and the use of land and natural resources.

By lightly taxing the things that take from the rest of us (such as the superprofits[12] earned by companies with some sort of monopoly) and heavily taxing the things that give to the rest of us (such as the effort put in by workers and businesses) we are bequeathing to our children a weaker Australia.

What’s winning matters as much as who’s winning

As Henry puts it, Australia’s young people are being screwed – not necessarily by what the tax system is doing to them today (although what negative gearing and capital gains tax breaks are doing to home prices can’t be helping) but by the way we are choking attempts to build the economy they’ll inherit.

He says we’ve got to level with them and level with ourselves, which is also the argument of Mixed Fortunes[13], the book detailing the history of tax reform in Australia by former treasury official Paul Tilley that Henry launched.

It’s an argument the journalists in the audience (I am one) and the lone politician in the audience (Assistant Treasury Minister Andrew Leigh) should take to heart. I’ll still report on winners and losers next month, but I’ll also aim to go deeper – to report on what’s winning as well as who.

Read more: Former treasury head Ken Henry says we need 'big bang' tax reform rather than incremental change[14]

References

  1. ^ the budget (ministers.treasury.gov.au)
  2. ^ winners and losers (www.abc.net.au)
  3. ^ last year’s winners (www.afr.com)
  4. ^ Guardian Australia (www.theguardian.com)
  5. ^ changes (theconversation.com)
  6. ^ A$146,000 (theconversation.com)
  7. ^ Ken Henry (cdn.theconversation.com)
  8. ^ 1985 tax summit (taxpolicy.crawford.anu.edu.au)
  9. ^ weren’t going to fly (cdn.theconversation.com)
  10. ^ raft of tax changes (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)
  11. ^ Lukas Coch/AAP (photos.aap.com.au)
  12. ^ superprofits (www.theguardian.com)
  13. ^ Mixed Fortunes (www.mup.com.au)
  14. ^ Former treasury head Ken Henry says we need 'big bang' tax reform rather than incremental change (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/how-about-this-time-we-try-just-try-to-report-on-budgets-and-tax-differently-227353

The Times Features

Sunshine Coast Personal Injury Lawyers: Expert Guidance for Work Accident Claims

When accidents occur in the workplace, they can have profound and lasting effects on a worker's life, both physically and financially. In Queensland's Sunshine Coast, personal in...

iS Clinical's Skincare Secrets for Radiant Party Season Skin

As the festive season approaches, having runway-ready skin is easier than ever with iS Clinical's  top skincare prep tips. Whether you're walking the red carpet or simply stepp...

How to Camp Sustainably in Byron Bay: Eco-Friendly Tips

Camping in Byron Bay is a fantastic way to soak up nature, from beautiful beaches to lush rainforests. It’s no wonder Byron Bay camping is on so many bucket lists! But with more ...

Book a room in Broome as the northwest is best

Looking for a different kind of seaside escape? Done the east coast? Then book a room in Broome to discover why those in the know say the northwest is best, with Broome one of ...

Primary care involves more than GPs. A new review shows how patients can better access care

Australians today are more likely[1] than previous generations to live with complex and chronic diseases, such as diabetes, heart disease and depression. This means they’re mo...

Why Your Credit Score Matters More Than You Think in Australia

Your credit score isn't just a number, it's a reflection of your financial reputation. In Australia, a good credit score can unlock doors to better financial opportunities, while...

Enhance Your Home’s Comfort and Style with Blackout Curtains from 3Hlinen

Creating a comfortable and peaceful home environment often involves choosing the right window treatments. Among the various options available, blackout curtains stand out as a ve...

Is thirst a good predictor of dehydration?

Water is essential for daily functioning and health, and we can only survive a few days[1] without it. Yet we constantly lose water through sweat, urination and even evaporatio...

How doctors use light to diagnose disease

You’re not feeling well. You’ve had a pounding headache all week, dizzy spells and have vomited up your past few meals. You visit your GP to get some answers and sit while they ...

Times Magazine

Managing Your Online Reputation: Strategies for Removing Negative Content

Maintaining a positive online reputation is crucial for individuals and businesses in today's digital age. However, negative content such as negative reviews, defamatory posts, or outdated information can tarnish your reputation and harm your credi...

PIXMA and MAXIFY Inkjet printer ranges offering new features for home and business

Canon Australia today announces new models in the PIXMA and MAXIFY inkjet ranges, the PIXMA TS3660, PIXMA TS3665, PIXMA TR7860, PIXMA TS7760, MAXIFY GX1060 MegaTank, MAXIFY GX2060 MegaTank and MAXIFY GX5560 MegaTank. Canon continues to expand its...

The Ultimate Pet Handbook

An essential guide for young people with a passion for pets  “As you read this book it will soon be obvious that Ben Dessen is no ordinary individual. From a very young age Ben has had a fascination with animals of all kinds. He has the greatest e...

The Entrepreneur's Legal Toolkit

Essential Resources and When to Call in the Lawyers When it comes to entrepreneurship, laying a strong legal foundation is just as crucial as the business idea itself, if not more. As you embark on the exhilarating journey of building your enterpr...

Providing comprehensive water management solutions for rural areas at its finest.

Are you looking for the ultimate water management solutions to help rural areas? Water is increasingly becoming a precious resource, and the stranglehold of drought and scarcity is impacting communities on a global scale. For remote or rural areas...

Types of Hot Water Systems: Different types of systems and the advantages

1. Electric: Electric hot-water systems are the simplest and most common type of hot water system. They work by circulating heated water through a tank filled with cold water using electricity as the heat source. The electric current heats the wa...