The Times Australia
The Times World News

.

Will drivers who paid Victoria's electric vehicle tax be able to get their money back?

  • Written by Eu-Jin Teo, Senior Lecturer, The University of Melbourne

Electric vehicle owners in Victoria couldn’t be blamed for wondering if they might get their money back after the High Court[1] found the state’s zero and low-emission vehicle road-user charge to be unconstitutional.

The government, facing massive budgetary pressures - don’t mention the Commonwealth Games[2] - might also have its own questions to ask about the court putting an end to the tax.

Better known as the “EV tax” (and dubbed by its critics as the worst electric vehicle policy[3] in the world), the charge meant that a registered owner of an electric or hydrogen vehicle had to pay the state government 2.8 cents for each kilometre that the vehicle travelled on public roads. Plug-in hybrid vehicle owners were charged at a lower rate of 2.3 cents.

What the court found

A majority of the justices held that this state “charge” was, in reality, an excise tax. Under the Constitution, only the federal parliament may impose excise taxes.

Blue car hooked up to a charging station to get its battery topped up.
Electric vehicle owners are keen to know if they will get a refund. AAP[4]

Victoria has, as a result, had to stop collecting this tax. Other states that were thinking of imposing such taxes have also put their plans on ice.

The state reportedly had hoped to raise $30 million [5]through this tax over a four-year period. Since its introduction in 2021, about $5 million has been collected.

So, what happens with this money now?

Is there a legal obligation for the state to pay a refund?

One might think that, if tax may be exacted only under valid laws, and a law is shown to have been invalid from its inception, surely it would be axiomatic, if not common sense, that it would be necessary to return the money?

You could be forgiven for thinking so.

However, as has been observed: the law is an ass[6] (at least sometimes).

To get technical, the availability of restitution from public authorities (for instance, in relation to invalid demands for money) is an intractable issue which has been the subject of much debate.

Specifically, the legal position in Australia on the recovery of unconstitutional taxes remains unsettled.

The law can get tricky

Exterior of Australai's High Court. The High Court ruled the tax was an excise and could only be imposed by the Commonwealth. Shutterstock

There currently appears to be no general right to a refund based solely on the invalid nature of a tax.

Oh, if only things were that straightforward.

Instead, a claimant is required to establish that, for example, the tax was paid due to a mistake of law (for instance, as to the validity or applicability of the purported tax).

Or that the tax was paid because of legally unfounded threats made to the taxpayer by the authorities.

However, with $378 being about the average amount of the tax paid by each vehicle operator per year, litigation to recover the tax might prove to be uneconomical.

The case-by-case nature of the enquiry required into whether a particular claimant actually made a mistake or was in fact baselessly threatened, might also make a class action difficult.

But wait, there’s more! Victoria’s statute of limitations states:

despite anything to the contrary in any other Act, if money paid by way of tax or purported tax is recoverable because of the invalidity of an Act or provision of an Act, a proceeding for the recovery of that money must (whether the payment was made voluntarily or under compulsion) be commenced within 12 months after the date of payment.

Put simply, this means that, even if a vehicle operator has satisfactory evidence to establish a legal entitlement to restitution of the invalid tax paid, recovery of the full amount of the tax that has been paid over the years may not be possible.

I say “may”, if only because the validity of this provision of the statute is itself not beyond constitutional doubt.

Read more: It's good the High Court overturned Victoria's questionable EV tax. But there's a sting in the tail[7]

All is not lost

Fortunately for those who’ve paid the tax, Victoria’s road transport regulator, VicRoads, has reportedly said that, although specifics regarding the timeline and amount are still to be determined, a refund process will definitely be put in place.

Otherwise, Victoria may not be able to have its excise but might, effectively, still get to keep it.

References

  1. ^ High Court (www.hcourt.gov.au)
  2. ^ Commonwealth Games (www.9news.com.au)
  3. ^ worst electric vehicle policy (australiainstitute.org.au)
  4. ^ AAP (photos.aap.com.au)
  5. ^ $30 million (www.carexpert.com.au)
  6. ^ the law is an ass (www.enotes.com)
  7. ^ It's good the High Court overturned Victoria's questionable EV tax. But there's a sting in the tail (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/will-drivers-who-paid-victorias-electric-vehicle-tax-be-able-to-get-their-money-back-216021

Times Magazine

Building a Strong Online Presence with Katoomba Web Design

Katoomba web design is more than just creating a website that looks good—it’s about building an online presence that reflects your brand, engages your audience, and drives results. For local businesses in the Blue Mountains, a well-designed website a...

September Sunset Polo

International Polo Tour To Bridge Historic Sport, Life-Changing Philanthropy, and Breath-Taking Beauty On Saturday, September 6th, history will be made as the International Polo Tour (IPT), a sports leader headquartered here in South Florida...

5 Ways Microsoft Fabric Simplifies Your Data Analytics Workflow

In today's data-driven world, businesses are constantly seeking ways to streamline their data analytics processes. The sheer volume and complexity of data can be overwhelming, often leading to bottlenecks and inefficiencies. Enter the innovative da...

7 Questions to Ask Before You Sign IT Support Companies in Sydney

Choosing an IT partner can feel like buying an insurance policy you hope you never need. The right choice keeps your team productive, your data safe, and your budget predictable. The wrong choice shows up as slow tickets, surprise bills, and risky sh...

Choosing the Right Legal Aid Lawyer in Sutherland Shire: Key Considerations

Legal aid services play an essential role in ensuring access to justice for all. For people in the Sutherland Shire who may not have the financial means to pay for private legal assistance, legal aid ensures that everyone has access to representa...

Watercolor vs. Oil vs. Digital: Which Medium Fits Your Pet's Personality?

When it comes to immortalizing your pet’s unique personality in art, choosing the right medium is essential. Each artistic medium, whether watercolor, oil, or digital, has distinct qualities that can bring out the spirit of your furry friend in dif...

The Times Features

How much money do you need to be happy? Here’s what the research says

Over the next decade, Elon Musk could become the world’s first trillionaire[1]. The Tesla board recently proposed a US$1 trillion (A$1.5 trillion) compensation plan, if Musk ca...

NSW has a new fashion sector strategy – but a sustainable industry needs a federally legislated response

The New South Wales government recently announced the launch of the NSW Fashion Sector Strategy, 2025–28[1]. The strategy, developed in partnership with the Australian Fashion ...

From Garden to Gift: Why Roses Make the Perfect Present

Think back to the last time you gave or received flowers. Chances are, roses were part of the bunch, or maybe they were the whole bunch.   Roses tend to leave an impression. Even ...

Do I have insomnia? 5 reasons why you might not

Even a single night of sleep trouble can feel distressing and lonely. You toss and turn, stare at the ceiling, and wonder how you’ll cope tomorrow. No wonder many people star...

Wedding Photography Trends You Need to Know (Before You Regret Your Album)

Your wedding album should be a timeless keepsake, not something you cringe at years later. Trends may come and go, but choosing the right wedding photography approach ensures your ...

Can you say no to your doctor using an AI scribe?

Doctors’ offices were once private. But increasingly, artificial intelligence (AI) scribes (also known as digital scribes) are listening in. These tools can record and trans...