Google AI
The Times Australia

Times Media

When the Numbers Matter: Albanese, the Greens and the New Politics of Parliament

  • Written by: The Times

Budget measures to pass through The Senate

The Albanese Government begins this parliamentary term from a position of considerable strength. With a majority in the House of Representatives and a willingness to negotiate with the Greens in the Senate, the Government is well placed to see much of its legislative agenda become law.

That does not mean every proposal will pass unchanged.

Australia's Parliament was designed with checks and balances. The Senate remains a chamber of review, and while the Government can often secure enough votes through negotiations with the Greens, agreements usually involve amendments, compromises and lengthy discussions rather than automatic approval.

Recent tax reforms provide a clear example. Labor and the Greens reached agreement after negotiations over housing, capital gains tax and self-managed superannuation rules. The result was legislation that differed from the Government's original proposal, demonstrating that influence in Parliament is often exercised through negotiation rather than outright opposition.

For Australians, this raises an important question.

Should governments that have won an election be able to implement their agenda with minimal obstruction? Or is it healthy that legislation is refined by crossbench parties before becoming law?

Supporters of the current arrangements argue the Greens provide additional scrutiny, forcing governments to justify their proposals and improve legislation where necessary. They contend that compromise is a normal feature of a mature parliamentary democracy.

Critics see the situation differently. They argue that a relatively small party can exert influence beyond its electoral support by becoming the deciding vote in the Senate. From this perspective, governments may find themselves implementing policies that were never clearly presented to voters during an election campaign.

Neither view is entirely right or entirely wrong.

Australia's parliamentary system has always required negotiation whenever governments lack a Senate majority. In previous decades governments have relied on Democrats, independents, or other minor parties. Today's negotiations with the Greens are simply the latest version of that longstanding constitutional reality.

The more significant question is likely to emerge over the next three years.

If Labor continues to rely on Greens support for key legislation, voters will increasingly judge not only Labor's policies but also the compromises required to secure their passage. Every negotiated amendment becomes part of the Government's record.

The Albanese Government and Chalmers have the opportunity to enact substantial reforms. Whether those reforms are viewed as balanced compromises or excessive concessions will ultimately be decided not in Parliament, but by Australian voters at the next federal election.

Times Magazine

Still Want to Change Gears? The New Cars Keeping the Manual Alive in Australia

For decades, learning to drive meant mastering the clutch pedal, selecting the right gear and find...

SpaceX changed spaceflight. Now China is proving reusable rockets are the new battleground.

When SpaceX first landed a Falcon 9 booster vertically on a floating drone ship, many experts desc...

Hybrid, Plug-in Hybrid or Electric? Understanding the Differences

Buying a new car has become more complicated than choosing between petrol and diesel. Today's buye...

Technology

SpaceX changed spaceflight. Now Chi…

When SpaceX first landed a Falcon 9 booster vertically on a floating drone ship, many experts desc...

Local News

Fremantle Ports to trial project to…

Fremantle Ports has partnered with Byssal and DevelopmentWA to trial an innovative nature-based pilo...

Culture

Healthy Eating: What Does a Science-Based Die…

After years of changing food trends—from low-fat to low-carbohydrate, detoxes and "superfoods"—it ...

Travel

Santorini: Is Greece's Most Famous Islan…

Whitewashed villages perched on volcanic cliffs. Blue-domed churches overlooking the Aegean Sea. S...

The Times Features

IKEA: More Than Furniture—A Complete Design System for …

For many Australians, IKEA is simply a place to buy affordable furniture. Look more closely, howe...

Healthy Eating: What Does a Science-Based Diet Actually…

After years of changing food trends—from low-fat to low-carbohydrate, detoxes and "superfoods"—it ...

Healthy Living: Can Exercise and Good Nutrition Help Yo…

Most people begin exercising or improving their diet with a specific goal in mind. It may be to lo...