No, your aches and pains don’t get worse in the cold. So why do we think they do?
- Written by: Manuela Ferreira, Professor of Musculoskeletal Health, Head of Musculoskeletal Program, George Institute for Global Health
It’s cold and wet outside. As you get out of bed, you can feel it in your bones. Your right knee is flaring up again. That’ll make it harder for you to walk the dog or go to the gym. You think it must be because of the weather.
It’s a common idea, but a myth.
When we looked at the evidence, we found[1] no direct link between most common aches and pains and the weather. In the first study of its kind, we found no direct link between the temperature or humidity with most joint or muscle aches and pains.
So why are so many of us convinced the weather’s to blame? Here’s what we think is really going on.
Weather can be linked to your health
The weather is often associated with the risk of new and ongoing health conditions. For example, cold temperatures may worsen[2] asthma symptoms. Hot temperatures increase the risk[3] of heart problems, such as arrhythmia (irregular heartbeat), cardiac arrest and coronary heart disease.
Many people are also convinced the weather is linked to their aches and pains. For example, two in every three[4] people with knee, hip or hand osteoarthritis say[5] cold temperatures trigger their symptoms.
Musculoskeletal conditions affect more than seven million Australians[6]. So we set out to find out whether weather is really the culprit behind winter flare-ups.
What we did
Very few studies have been specifically and appropriately designed to look for any direct link between weather changes and joint or muscle pain. And ours is the first to evaluate data from these particular studies.
We looked at data from more than 15,000 people from around the world. Together, these people reported more than 28,000 episodes of pain, mostly back pain, knee or hip osteoarthritis. People with rheumatoid arthritis and gout were also included.
We then compared the frequency of those pain reports between different types of weather: hot or cold, humid or dry, rainy, windy, as well as some combinations (for example, hot and humid versus cold and dry).
What we found
We found changes in air temperature, humidity, air pressure and rainfall do not increase the risk of knee, hip or lower back pain symptoms and are not associated with people seeking care for a new episode of arthritis.
The results of this study suggest we do not experience joint or muscle pain flare-ups as a result of changes in the weather, and a cold day will not increase our risk of having knee or back pain.
In order words, there is no direct link between the weather and back, knee or hip pain, nor will it give you arthritis.
It is important to note, though, that very cold air temperatures (under 10°C) were rarely studied so we cannot make conclusions about worsening symptoms in more extreme changes in the weather.
The only exception to our findings was for gout, an inflammatory type of arthritis that can come and go. Here, pain increased in warmer, dry conditions.
Gout has a very different underlying biological mechanism to back pain or knee and hip osteoarthritis, which may explain our results. The combination of warm and dry weather may lead to increased dehydration and consequently increased concentration of uric acid in the blood, and deposition of uric acid crystals in the joint in people with gout, resulting in a flare-up.
Why do people blame the weather?
The weather can influence other factors and behaviours that consequently shape how we perceive and manage pain.
For example, some people may change their physical activity routine during winter, choosing the couch over the gym. And we know prolonged sitting[8], for instance, is directly linked to worse back pain. Others may change their sleep routine or sleep less well when it is either too cold or too warm. Once again, a bad night’s sleep can trigger your back[9] and knee[10] pain.
Likewise, changes in mood, often experienced in cold weather, trigger increases in both back[11] and knee[12] pain.
So these changes in behaviour over winter may contribute to more aches and pains, and not the weather itself.
Believing our pain will feel worse in winter (even if this is not the case) may also make us feel worse in winter. This is known as the nocebo effect[13].
When it’s cold outside, we may be less active.
Anna Nass/Shutterstock[14]
What to do about winter aches and pains?
It’s best to focus on risk factors for pain you can control and modify, rather than ones you can’t (such as the weather).
You can:
become more physically active. This winter, and throughout the year, aim to walk more, or talk to your health-care provider about gentle exercises you can safely do at home, with a physiotherapist, personal trainer or at the pool
lose weight if obese or overweight, as this is linked to lower levels[15] of joint pain and better physical function
keep your body warm in winter if you feel some muscle tension in uncomfortably cold conditions. Also ensure your bedroom is nice and warm as we tend to sleep less well[16] in cold rooms
maintain a healthy diet and avoid smoking[17] or drinking high levels of alcohol. These are among key lifestyle recommendations[18] to better manage many types of arthritis and musculoskeletal conditions. For people with back pain, for example, a healthy lifestyle is linked with higher levels[19] of physical function.
References
- ^ we found (www.sciencedirect.com)
- ^ may worsen (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
- ^ increase the risk (www.thelancet.com)
- ^ two in every three (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
- ^ say (bmcmusculoskeletdisord.biomedcentral.com)
- ^ seven million Australians (www.aihw.gov.au)
- ^ Pearl PhotoPix/Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
- ^ prolonged sitting (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
- ^ back (link.springer.com)
- ^ knee (www.sciencedirect.com)
- ^ back (link.springer.com)
- ^ knee (www.sciencedirect.com)
- ^ nocebo effect (link.springer.com)
- ^ Anna Nass/Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
- ^ lower levels (jamanetwork.com)
- ^ less well (www.sciencedirect.com)
- ^ avoid smoking (www.thelancet.com)
- ^ key lifestyle recommendations (ard.bmj.com)
- ^ higher levels (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
