The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

how to avoid a repeat of this circular economy scandal

  • Written by Salman Shooshtarian, Senior Lecturer, School of Property, Construction and Project Management, RMIT University
how to avoid a repeat of this circular economy scandal

Asbestos has been found in mulch used for playgrounds, schools, parks and gardens across Sydney[1] and Melbourne[2]. Local communities naturally fear for the health[3] of their loved ones. Exposure to asbestos is a serious health risk – depending on its intensity, frequency and duration[4] – as it may lead to chronic lung diseases[5].

The source of contamination is believed to be timber waste[6] from construction and demolition sites that was turned into mulch. So far, 60 locations in Sydney[7] and 12 in Melbourne[8] have been identified as contaminated with asbestos to various degrees. The numbers could increase as investigations continue.

Following the initial detection in New South Wales and Victoria, an investigation in Queensland[9] detected asbestos in one compost and one mulch product.

The severity, spread and impact of the issue convince us to call it the largest scandal in the history of Australia’s circular economy[10]. A circular economy recycles and reuses materials or products with the goal of being more sustainable.

Our research[11] highlights the importance of making it mandatory to certify recycled products such as mulch to ensure their safety. We found none of the local, state or national policies on sustainable procurement practices recommend recycled product certification as a preventive strategy. We also found significant levels of ignorance and resistance to certification schemes in the recycling sector.

These obstacles must be overcome so we have certification of recycled products that ensures their quality[12], performance, environmental friendliness and safety.

Read more: Building activity produces 18% of emissions and a shocking 40% of our landfill waste. We must move to a circular economy – here’s how[13]

Scandal is damaging for the circular economy

The discovery in January of asbestos in mulch in NSW triggered a series of actions. These have involved the NSW and Victorian Environment Protection Authorities, local councils[14], Fire and Rescue NSW[15] and a NSW taskforce[16], drawing from agencies such as SafeWork, Public Works and the Natural Resources Access Regulator. The actions include testing in identified areas, cordoning off and signposting affected garden beds, engaging licensed asbestos removalists, and sampling to determine disposal options.

Unfortunately, this contaminated mulch raises concerns about the reckless implementation of circular economy principles in Australia. This scandal could make users of recycled materials, particularly local councils, hesitate about procuring these resources, if not dissuade them altogether.

Understandably, the waste management and resource recovery sector is in a state of shock. More broadly, this scandal could undermine efforts[17] to advance the circular economy in Australia.

It’s a reminder that the circular economy concept is based on a system-thinking approach, where all elements must work in harmony. A failure in one can result in the entire system collapsing.

Regulations don’t go far enough

Under NSW legislation, mulch must not contain asbestos, engineered wood products, preservative-treated or coated wood residues, or physical contaminants such as glass or plastics.

However, it isn’t mandatory[18] for suppliers to test for contaminants in mulch. There are no specified procedures they must follow to ensure mulch doesn’t contain asbestos.

The fact is existing policies and regulations, such as the NSW Environment Protection Authority’s Mulch Order 2016[19], failed to prevent mulch contamination. It’s a reminder of the need for effective strategies to ensure a circular economy will not go wrong.

These strategies must integrate encouragement, education and enforcement. Otherwise, we risk facing unintended economic, environmental and social consequences.

‘Soft fall’ mulch in a playground in Melbourne. Salman Shooshtarian.

Read more: Buildings used iron from sunken ships centuries ago. The use of recycled materials should be business as usual by now[20]

Why isn’t certification standard practice?

At RMIT University’s Construction Waste Lab (CWL[21]), we have been researching and sharing key strategies with policymakers and industry. In 2022 and 2023, working with researchers from Griffith and Curtin universities and our industry partners, we explored[22] the use of recycled product certification schemes.

In our research[23], supported by the Sustainable Built Environment National Research Centre[24], we gathered insights from 16 industry professionals engaged in projects involving large quantities of recycled materials. We specifically asked for their views on certification schemes for these materials.

We found only nine of them were aware of such schemes in Australia. A similar number supported their use for construction projects. The main reasons for not supporting them are shown below.

Data: S. Shooshtarian et al 2023 David Baggs is chief executive and cofounder of Global GreenTag International[25], a recycled product certifier that operates nationally and internationally. He told us a major barrier to the uptake of these schemes is that they’re simply not a priority for many organisations. He added: The cost of certification is a fraction of whatever their marketing budget might be in any single month, let alone a year. So, particularly for the bigger companies, it’s not about cost, it’s about priorities. If they can see that their certification becomes part of their marketing budget, then the cost of certification is a single-digit percentage of most marketing budgets. Read more: Turning the housing crisis around: how a circular economy can give us affordable, sustainable homes[26] What more can be done? To encourage builders to use these schemes, the Green Building Council of Australia[27] provides a list of endorsed certifiers. Our research identified seven major drivers for adopting certification schemes when procuring recycled materials, as shown below. Read more: Trash TV: streaming giants are failing to educate the young about waste recycling. Here's why it matters[28] The CEO of the Waste Management and Resource Recovery Association of Australia, Gayle Sloan, has highlighted[29] the need for effective reforms of waste regulations. In addition, we stress the importance of directories of approved recyclers to ensure end users have access to quality, uncontaminated recycled materials. An example is Sustainability Victoria’s Buy Recycled Directory[30]. These directories should require listed suppliers to provide certification for their recycled products. It will help distinguish reputable suppliers from rogue suppliers. References^ Sydney (www.epa.nsw.gov.au)^ Melbourne (www.theage.com.au)^ fear for the health (www.smh.com.au)^ frequency and duration (theconversation.com)^ chronic lung diseases (theconversation.com)^ timber waste (www.theguardian.com)^ 60 locations in Sydney (www.epa.nsw.gov.au)^ 12 in Melbourne (www.epa.vic.gov.au)^ investigation in Queensland (www.qld.gov.au)^ circular economy (ellenmacarthurfoundation.org)^ Our research (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)^ ensures their quality (thefifthestate.com.au)^ Building activity produces 18% of emissions and a shocking 40% of our landfill waste. We must move to a circular economy – here’s how (theconversation.com)^ local councils (www.cityofsydney.nsw.gov.au)^ Fire and Rescue NSW (www.news.com.au)^ NSW taskforce (www.epa.nsw.gov.au)^ undermine efforts (www.linkedin.com)^ it isn’t mandatory (www.theguardian.com)^ Mulch Order 2016 (www.epa.nsw.gov.au)^ Buildings used iron from sunken ships centuries ago. The use of recycled materials should be business as usual by now (theconversation.com)^ CWL (www.rmit.edu.au)^ we explored (thefifthestate.com.au)^ our research (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)^ Sustainable Built Environment National Research Centre (sbenrc.com.au)^ Global GreenTag International (www.globalgreentag.com)^ Turning the housing crisis around: how a circular economy can give us affordable, sustainable homes (theconversation.com)^ Green Building Council of Australia (new.gbca.org.au)^ Trash TV: streaming giants are failing to educate the young about waste recycling. Here's why it matters (theconversation.com)^ highlighted (www.linkedin.com)^ Buy Recycled Directory (directories.sustainability.vic.gov.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/asbestos-in-playground-mulch-how-to-avoid-a-repeat-of-this-circular-economy-scandal-227766

The Times Features

Getting the Best Value for Money on Your Next Luxury Car Hire in Sydney

Are you wondering why you need to hire a luxury car when you are in Sydney? Can it be worth the buck when compared with standard car rentals? If you want to know why a lot of peopl...

5 Fun Ways to Use Light-Up Letters at Your Party

Planning a party or special event always involves deciding how to decorate the venue. Whether you're just decorating a small area or the entire space, ample thought is given to t...

The Art of Stone Selection: A Guide to Choosing the Right Type of Stone for Different Furniture Pieces

Stone furniture has become a hallmark of elegance and durability in modern and traditional homes alike. From sleek marble coffee tables to sturdy granite benches, the right stone...

Important things to consider before buying a new TV

The way that people live their everyday lives continues to evolve as new technology becomes available. Those who purchase a home are making what is likely to be one of their larg...

Cast vs. Minted Gold Bars: Key Differences Every Investor Should Know

Investing in gold bars is one of the most dependable ways of preserving one's wealth and diversifying one's portfolio. However, not all gold bars are minted equally. Understanding...

Understanding the Common Challenges Addressed by Child Psychologists

Parenting is challenging, especially when children have emotional, behavioural, or developmental problems. Child psychologists are experts who focus on dealing with such issues...

Times Magazine

Top Tips for Finding a Great Florist for Your Sydney Wedding

While the choice of wedding venue does much of the heavy lifting when it comes to wowing guests, decorations are certainly not far behind. They can add a bit of personality and flair to the traditional proceedings, as well as enhancing the venue’s ...

Avant Stone's 2025 Nature's Palette Collection

Avant Stone, a longstanding supplier of quality natural stone in Sydney, introduces the 2025 Nature’s Palette Collection. Curated for architects, designers, and homeowners with discerning tastes, this selection highlights classic and contemporary a...

Professional-Grade Tactical Gear: Why 5.11 Tactical Leads the Field

When you're out in the field, your gear has to perform at the same level as you. In the world of high-quality equipment, 5.11 Tactical has established itself as a standard for professionals who demand dependability. Regardless of whether you’re inv...

Lessons from the Past: Historical Maritime Disasters and Their Influence on Modern Safety Regulations

Maritime history is filled with tales of bravery, innovation, and, unfortunately, tragedy. These historical disasters serve as stark reminders of the challenges posed by the seas and have driven significant advancements in maritime safety regulat...

What workers really think about workplace AI assistants

Imagine starting your workday with an AI assistant that not only helps you write emails[1] but also tracks your productivity[2], suggests breathing exercises[3], monitors your mood and stress levels[4] and summarises meetings[5]. This is not a f...

Aussies, Clear Out Old Phones –Turn Them into Cash Now!

Still, holding onto that old phone in your drawer? You’re not alone. Upgrading to the latest iPhone is exciting, but figuring out what to do with the old one can be a hassle. The good news? Your old iPhone isn’t just sitting there it’s potential ca...

LayBy Shopping