The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

Child abductions can be hard to identify, and people may not know they are witnessing a serious crime

  • Written by Hayley Cullen, Lecturer, Macquarie University
Child abductions can be hard to identify, and people may not know they are witnessing a serious crime

On a summer’s day in January 1970, three-year-old Cheryl Grimmer was kidnapped from Fairy Meadow Beach in Wollongong, New South Wales. This is the last time Cheryl was seen. Cheryl remains missing[1], 53 years later. She is one of the 2,500 people considered to be a long-term missing person in Australia.

In 2020, the New South Wales government offered[2] a $1,000,000 reward to anyone who could provide information to help locate and arrest the person who abducted Cheryl. Yet, even with this large reward, witnesses were not forthcoming. The only information witnesses at the beach on that day could provide about the girl’s kidnapper was that they were an unknown male.

In 2022, the BBC released a podcast[3] about Cheryl’s case, “Fairy Meadow”. After listening to the podcast, an anonymous witness has recently come forward with a more detailed description[4] of the unknown male, such as his age, hair and build. This new information may help police to finally find Cheryl’s kidnapper after half a century of searching.

Some might question why the anonymous witness did not come forward sooner with information about Cheryl’s abduction. The witness claimed[5] he clearly remembered seeing a teenage male holding a young child on their hip on that day at Fairy Meadow Beach and moving towards the car park. Even though he reported the child was screaming, he did not think the child was being abducted. It was only when hearing the podcast that the witness became aware of the gravity of what he had seen 50 years before.

The Fairy Meadows shower block where three-year-old Cheryl Grimmer went missing in January 1970. Dan Himbrechts/AAP

Kidnapping is a prime example of an ambiguous crime. Imagine you are shopping at your local mall. You see a young child interacting with an adult. The child and the adult leave together, and the child is calm. You would probably think the child and the adult know each other; perhaps the adult is the child’s parent or carer. Even if the child was distressed, you may still think the child was just having a tantrum with an adult known to them. While these interpretations might be normal or common, they may not always be correct.

Children may leave with strangers who are trying to kidnap them without resisting or struggling. This was true of a Brisbane case in 2019[6], when Sterling Mervyn Free was able to convince a young child to follow him out of a busy department store. Many people would have been unconcerned when they saw the two leave the store together. Free sexually assaulted the young child before returning her to the store.

Read more: Cleo Smith case: how 'cognitive interviewing' can help police compile the most reliable evidence[7]

Some of Australia’s most terrifying crimes involve children who have been abducted by strangers, such as the tragic case of Daniel Morcombe[8]. Yet, even though kidnappings are often ambiguous and can occur in very public spaces, there has been limited research dedicated to understanding how such crimes are interpreted by witnesses.

Our research team conducted two experiments to explore whether interpreting a kidnapping as a crime would depend upon the level of ambiguity of the kidnap itself. In our experiments[9], university psychology students watched a video of a bus stop scene. In the video, several people waited for their bus to arrive, including a young female child. The child was sitting at the bus stop by herself. She was approached by a female adult, who started a conversation with her that was not audible to participants.

The two versions of the bus stop video where a child was abducted. In the version on the left, the woman and the child leave together and the child does not resist or struggle. In the version on the right, the child physically resists and can be heard calling for help. Hayley Cullen

Participants saw slightly different endings of the bus stop video. In one version, the child and the adult did not leave the bus stop. In a second version, the child and the adult left together without the child resisting. In the third version, the child and the adult left, but the child physically resisted and audibly called out for help.

Later in the experiment, we asked participants whether they believed that what they saw in the video was a crime. Importantly, these students did not know that they would see a crime in the video; we used a cover story to mask our research aims.

In our first experiment, we found that only 34.8% of participants who saw the child leave with the woman without resistance interpreted this as a crime. However, less than half (46.7%) of participants who saw the video where the child struggled and called out for help interpreted this as a crime. Participants in this first experiment were given realistic tasks to complete while they watched the video, such as counting how many buses stopped at the bus stop.

In our second experiment, when we minimised these distracting tasks, closer to three-quarters of participants interpreted both versions of the kidnapping as a crime.

These results tell us a key reason why witnesses do not provide information about child abductions is that they may fail to interpret these events as crimes in the first place. This could be the case even when children show clear signs of distress, just as the anonymous witness claimed Cheryl Grimmer did on that fateful day.

References

  1. ^ remains missing (www.missingpersons.gov.au)
  2. ^ offered (www.police.nsw.gov.au)
  3. ^ podcast (www.bbc.co.uk)
  4. ^ more detailed description (www.abc.net.au)
  5. ^ claimed (www.bbc.com)
  6. ^ Brisbane case in 2019 (www.theguardian.com)
  7. ^ Cleo Smith case: how 'cognitive interviewing' can help police compile the most reliable evidence (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ Daniel Morcombe (www.abc.net.au)
  9. ^ our experiments (ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)

Read more https://theconversation.com/child-abductions-can-be-hard-to-identify-and-people-may-not-know-they-are-witnessing-a-serious-crime-219221

The Times Features

HOYTS Gift Cards are coming in hot this festive season

With a hot selection of blockbuster movies coming to the big screen this summer, avoid the crowds and enjoy some movie magic at HOYTS with discounted gift cards—perfect for stuff...

Top 10 holiday houses across Brisbane

As Brisbane gears up to become an Olympic city, the Sunshine State capital is seeing a surge in new residents, luxury hotels, and major developments including The Star Brisbane...

Australian small businesses set to win big as many brace for a bumper holiday season

With the holiday sales season in full swing, new data from the Commonwealth Bank reveals small businesses could be set to receive a much-needed end-of-year financial reward...

BeerFest Sydney at Darling Harbour Tumbalong Park

Sydneysiders’ ultimate summer party is here! BeerFest Sydney is making its triumphant debut at Darling Harbour’s Tumbalong Park on 6–7 December, bringing together NSW’s best bo...

The Importance of Regular Roof and Gutter Maintenance for Adelaide Home

The Importance of Regular Roof and Gutter Maintenance for Adelaide Homes Your roof and gutters can be integral to maintaining the structural integrity and aesthetic appeal of yo...

Designer Wardrobe reports surge in pre-loved wedding gowns

As Australia’s wedding season approaches, and amidst a challenging cost of living backdrop, new insights from Designer Wardrobe reveal that Australia and New Zealand (ANZ) brid...

Times Magazine

The perfect place: how to properly use a jewellery box

There is nothing worse than going to wear one of our favourite pieces only to realise it has depreciated with time. It’s a sad disappointment to see special pieces suffer with time, and for this reason many people invest in high quality jewellery...

Skullcandy's New Skull-iQ Earbuds have one big advantage over key competition

Easy-to-Use, Voice-Driven Technology Platform Debuts With The All-New Push Active True Wireless And Grind True Wireless Earbuds, Unlocking A Range of Hands-Free Audio Experiences   Skullcandy®, the original lifestyle audio brand, announced to...

Consider This Before Selling Your Motorhome on Consignment

It goes without saying that selling your motorhome is one of the greatest decisions to make when it is not being used or you want to buy a new vehicle and do not want to keep your old one. Although renting the motorhome for passive income or tradin...

Waave launches ‘Wallet’ for Pay by Bank with Australian-first biometric security

Payments technology and Open Banking leader Waave today announces the introduction of the Waave Wallet to house its upgraded Pay by Bank product, a real-time account-to-account payment method which now features industry-leading biometric security...

Meet the artist combating the mental impacts of advanced tech with art

In a world where advanced technology threatens to diminish our creative minds and impact our mental well-being, one extraordinary artist is taking a stand. Ange Miller, a visionary artist and advocate for the transformative power of creativity, is ...

Innovative Strategies for Using the Wheel Spinner

For ages, the wheel spinner has been used to manufacture high-quality yarn and fabrics. It is a versatile tool that may be used to create simple yarns as well as sophisticated multi-coloured mixtures. The wheel spinner has changed as technology has...