The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Men's Weekly

.

The brumby debate will never be settled until we face the role horses played in colonisation

  • Written by Isa Menzies, Visiting Fellow, Research School of Humanities and the Arts , Australian National University
The brumby debate will never be settled until we face the role horses played in colonisation

The brumby debate refuses to go away. Nothing seems able to settle this matter.

Neither a heritage listing[1] in 2018 nor the 2021 Management Plan[2] brought the issue to a close. Last week, the report of the Senate Inquiry into the impacts of feral horses on the Australian Alps[3] recommended state and territory cooperation to urgently manage the numbers of feral horses in the Australian Alps.

The horse-human partnership has existed for around 4,000 years[4], and humans and horses share a co-evolutionary history[5]. Given this, it’s unsurprising the horse has a high emotional impact.

Tensions around wild horse management also exist in other countries[6], particularly around mustangs[7] in the United States, which are a federally protected species. However, the Australian context retains a unique flavour: the brumby has become a focus for concerns around what it means to belong in Australia[8] for settler-colonial Australians.

Horses, we are often told, have a special connection[9] with the Australian character and are part of our national psyche[10].

But too often our discussions of brumbies and Australia’s “special” relationship with the horse don’t consider the darker aspects of the horse’s role in Australian history.

Read more: Why do brumbies evoke such passion? It's all down to the high country's cultural myth-makers[11]

Horses and colonisation

Sociologist Catriona Elder has argued[12] ideas about being Australian are fundamentally tied to

a desire for the land, a fear of others who may claim the land and, as a result of this, a deep ambivalence about belonging to this space.

Horses were crucial[13] to the colonisation of this land.

They increased settler mobility in both speed and range. Being mounted offered improved field of vision when deploying a firearm. Even the body of the horse could act as a weapon, particularly when attacking camps. Taken together, the horse represented a devastating tactical advantage[14] to settlers. They proved integral to the frontier violence[15] that created modern-day Australia.

W. A. Cawthorne, 1844, A Fight at the Murray. Mitchell Library, State Library of NSW

Historian Nanette Mantle argues[16] the figure of the stockman is a celebratory story that evolved to mask the dark truth of Aboriginal dispossession.

Richard Swain (Wiradjuri) is an ambassador for the Invasive Species Council and a founding member of Reclaim Kosci[17], an organisation that seeks to raise awareness about the impacts of feral horses and create support for their humane reduction.

He has been targeted in racist attacks from the pro-horse lobby, including being threatened with the “colonial experience[18]”.

This reference, wielded as a threat, is fitting.

Tom Roberts, Dorchester, England 1856–Kallista, Victoria, Australia 1931. In a corner on the Macintyre (The bushranger), 1895. oil on canvas canvas. National Gallery of Australia, Canberra Purchased 1971.

As Tim Flannery writes[19], The Man from Snowy River is “an archetypal Australian hero – one of the brave Aussies who tamed the rugged land”.

It was these stockmen mounted on horseback, Flannery writes, who were “the shock-troops in our Aboriginal wars”.

Read more: Feral horses will rule one third of the fragile Kosciuszko National Park under a proposed NSW government plan[20]

A symbol of belonging

Horses also represent a particular identity associated with Britain and Europe.

Compare horses with camels. Camels were integral[21] to the exploration and opening up of inland Australia and, like horses, were used in the battle of Beersheba[22] in the Sinai and Palestine campaign of the first world war. Like brumbies, Australia also has the largest feral camel population in the world[23].

Camels are culturally and historically significant for Arab peoples, yet here they are routinely culled[24] without a second thought.

Camels Australia has the largest feral camel population in the world. Shutterstock

Despite their long history in Australia, camels are associated with Asia and the Middle East and seen as exotic and foreign. Horses, on the other hand, have Anglo-European connotations that fit comfortably within Australia’s white identity[25].

As horses that have successfully adapted to Australia’s extreme conditions, brumbies are used to justify the coloniser’s presence on the land: if horses belong, surely we do too.

An evolving conversation

Our thinking about brumbies has evolved in recent years. The debate has moved from uncritically accepting stories of wild horses as part of Australian culture, through debates focused primarily on management, to the current recognition of the role these animals play as cultural markers.

If we can look beyond the celebratory stories and accept the role the horse has played as a highly effective tool of dispossession, we can more readily accept the truth of Australia’s colonisation. From there, we will be better positioned to resolve the brumby debate, able to move forward as a society on a mutually-agreed rather than deeply contested pathway.

Beyond the wild horses, an understanding and acceptance of this element of our dark colonial history may also better enable us to embrace reconciliation.

Read more: If The Man from Snowy River is Indigenous, what does that mean for our national myth-making?[26]

References

  1. ^ heritage listing (www.parliament.nsw.gov.au)
  2. ^ 2021 Management Plan (www.environment.nsw.gov.au)
  3. ^ impacts of feral horses on the Australian Alps (www.aph.gov.au)
  4. ^ 4,000 years (www.nature.com)
  5. ^ co-evolutionary history (www-sciencedirect-com.virtual.anu.edu.au)
  6. ^ other countries (www.publish.csiro.au)
  7. ^ around mustangs (www.nationalgeographic.com)
  8. ^ what it means to belong in Australia (search.informit.org)
  9. ^ special connection (www.newsouthbooks.com.au)
  10. ^ our national psyche (www.australiangeographic.com.au)
  11. ^ Why do brumbies evoke such passion? It's all down to the high country's cultural myth-makers (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ has argued (www.routledge.com)
  13. ^ crucial (unsw.press)
  14. ^ tactical advantage (unsw.press)
  15. ^ frontier violence (www.panmacmillan.com.au)
  16. ^ argues (catalogue.nla.gov.au)
  17. ^ Reclaim Kosci (reclaimkosci.org.au)
  18. ^ colonial experience (www.abc.net.au)
  19. ^ writes (www.quarterlyessay.com.au)
  20. ^ Feral horses will rule one third of the fragile Kosciuszko National Park under a proposed NSW government plan (theconversation.com)
  21. ^ integral (www.abc.net.au)
  22. ^ battle of Beersheba (www.awm.gov.au)
  23. ^ in the world (pestsmart.org.au)
  24. ^ routinely culled (www.aljazeera.com)
  25. ^ within Australia’s white identity (openresearch-repository.anu.edu.au)
  26. ^ If The Man from Snowy River is Indigenous, what does that mean for our national myth-making? (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/the-brumby-debate-will-never-be-settled-until-we-face-the-role-horses-played-in-colonisation-212961

Times Magazine

Effective Commercial Pest Control Solutions for a Safer Workplace

Keeping a workplace clean, safe, and free from pests is essential for maintaining productivity, protecting employee health, and upholding a company's reputation. Pests pose health risks, can cause structural damage, and can lead to serious legal an...

The Science Behind Reverse Osmosis and Why It Matters

What is reverse osmosis? Reverse osmosis (RO) is a water purification process that removes contaminants by forcing water through a semi-permeable membrane. This membrane allows only water molecules to pass through while blocking impurities such as...

Foodbank Queensland celebrates local hero for National Volunteer Week

Stephen Carey is a bit bananas.   He splits his time between his insurance broker business, caring for his young family, and volunteering for Foodbank Queensland one day a week. He’s even run the Bridge to Brisbane in a banana suit to raise mon...

Senior of the Year Nominations Open

The Allan Labor Government is encouraging all Victorians to recognise the valuable contributions of older members of our community by nominating them for the 2025 Victorian Senior of the Year Awards.  Minister for Ageing Ingrid Stitt today annou...

CNC Machining Meets Stage Design - Black Swan State Theatre Company & Tommotek

When artistry meets precision engineering, incredible things happen. That’s exactly what unfolded when Tommotek worked alongside the Black Swan State Theatre Company on several of their innovative stage productions. With tight deadlines and intrica...

Uniden Baby Video Monitor Review

Uniden has released another award-winning product as part of their ‘Baby Watch’ series. The BW4501 Baby Monitor is an easy to use camera for keeping eyes and ears on your little one. The camera is easy to set up and can be mounted to the wall or a...

The Times Features

Running Across Australia: What Really Holds the Body Together?

How William Goodge’s 3,800km run reveals the connection between movement, mindset, and mental resilience As a business owner, I’ve come to realise that the biggest wins rarely com...

Telehealth is Transforming Healthcare Services in Australia

It has traditionally not been easy to access timely healthcare in Australia, particularly for people who live in remote areas. Many of them spend hours on the road just to see a...

Launchd Acquires Huume, Strengthening Creative Firepower Across Talent-Led Marketing

Launchd, a leader in talent, technology and brand partnerships, has announced its acquisition of influencer talent management agency Huume from IZEA. The move comes as the medi...

Vietnam's "Gold Coast" Emerges as Extraordinary Investment Frontier and Australian Inspired Way of Life

$2 Billion super-city in Vung Tau set to replicate Australia's Gold Coast success story A culturally metamorphic development aptly named "Gold Coast" is set to reshape Vietna...

Choosing the Wrong Agent Is the #1 Regret Among Aussie Property Sellers

Selling your home is often one of the largest financial transactions you’ll make, and for many Australians, it’s also one of the most emotional. A new survey of Australian home se...

Travel Insurance for Families: What Does it Cover and Why it’s Essential

Planning a family trip is exciting, but unexpected mishaps can turn your dream vacation into a stressful ordeal. That’s where travel insurance comes in—it’s your safety net when ...