50 years ago when the Middle East was at war, oil prices skyrocketed. But it probably won't happen this time.
Written by: Jamie Cross, Assistant Professor of Econometrics & Statistics, Melbourne Business School
Global oil prices jumped after Israel declared war on Hamas in response to its unexpected attack on Israel on Saturday, the eve of the 50th anniversary of the 1973 Arab-Israeli War.
Back then, between late 1973 and early 1974, the world oil price almost quadrupled[1] after the United States offered financial support to Israel in the Arab–Israeli War. The Organisation of Arab Petroleum Exporting Countries cut off oil exports to nations including the US, the United Kingdom, Canada and Japan.
While there are uncanny similarities between the events of 1973 and today, there are more important differences.
This time it’s different
The 1973 war pitted Israel against two oil-producing nations: Egypt and Syria.
When the US offered support to Israel, the Organisation of Arab Petroleum Exporting Countries instituted an oil embargo, followed by a series of production cuts that pushed up world price of oil.
This 2023 war pits Israel against Hamas, the Islamist group that controls the tiny Gaza Strip[3], hemmed in by Israel, Egypt and the Mediterranean Sea.
Shutterstock
Neither Gaza nor Israel produces much oil[4].
The price increase has been short-lived
It is possible that the oil-rich nation of Iran could become involved in the conflict. It is rumoured to have helped plan the Hamas attack, although its Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei has denied Iran’s involvement[5].
It is also possible that petroleum-exporting nations might cut supplies in a show of support for Hamas.
But there is no current reason to believe this will happen, and there has been relatively little movement in the petroleum price.
When Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, the price of Brent crude[6] jumped 15% from around US$95 per barrel to US$110.
Russia had been the world’s third-biggest[7] oil producer, pumping out about 10% of the world’s supply.
In contrast, the Brent crude price closed on Friday (before the Hamas attack) at around US$84. It climbed to US$88 on Monday, then fell back to US$86 – well below even last month’s peak of US$94.
Why was there an increase at all?
Not every spike in oil prices is due to a shortage of supply.
My research shows how jumps in demand[8] can also play a role. These can be further categorised as “precautionary demand” and “speculative demand”.
Precautionary demand is the demand for extra oil to hold in reserve, in case supply tightens. Speculative demand comes from investors expecting to profit from further price rises. Both push up the oil price.
The good news is that both effects should be relatively short-lived, unless the unexpected happens. In this case, the effects so far have been small.
Read more:
No hike yet, but what happens on Melbourne Cup Day depends on petrol[9]
What would happen if prices did take off?
As a relatively small and open economy, Australia would suffer from higher import prices if the price of oil surged.
But research[10] suggests the type of price hikes we’ve seen so far would have only a small impact, even if the price rises were sustained.
The Hamas-Israel war pushed up oil prices by less than 5%, for about a day.
If the 5% increase had been sustained, the research suggests Australia’s inflation rate would have been (at most) 0.3 percentage points higher, Australia’s GDP would have been about 1% lower and Australia’s real exchange rate would have been 2% lower.
This means Australia’s Reserve Bank will be watching oil prices closely, but if the price remains stable (or at least no more unstable than it has been) the war is unlikely to prompt the bank to move interest rates.
References^almost quadrupled (www.federalreservehistory.org)^history doesn’t repeat, but it rhymes (quoteinvestigator.com)^Gaza Strip (www.abc.net.au)^produces much oil (www.cnbc.com)^denied Iran’s involvement (www.nytimes.com)^Brent crude (www.investopedia.com)^third-biggest (markets.businessinsider.com)^jumps in demand (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)^No hike yet, but what happens on Melbourne Cup Day depends on petrol (theconversation.com)^research (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
