Tue Jul 25

Employers will resist, but the changes for casual workers are about accepting reality

Written by John Buchanan, Professor, Discipline of Business Information Systems, University of Sydney Business School, University of Sydney

The Albanese government’s plan to improve the pathway to permanency for casual workers has employers worried, fearful their ability to employ casual workers will be restricted.

Even before the details had been released, there was certainty, in the words ^[1] of Australian Industry Group chief executive Innes Willox, that there “is simply no justification for further changes to the regulation of casual work”.

In support of this argument are statistics suggesting the casualisation trend has peaked. But that’s by no means certain: the most recent data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics shows casualisation climbing again, with an overall rate of 23.5%.

The counterargument is that entrenched casualisation doesn’t make the status quo right, and that the government’s proposed reforms will give greater recognition to reality. That is, if a worker is effectively working as a permanent employee, they have the right to be treated as such. Read more: Albanese government to make it easier for casuals to become permanent employees ^[2] Rise of the ‘permanent casual’ While casual employment can often suit both employer and employee, the evidence does suggest some employers have exploited the legal ambiguities around definitions and obligations. Australia’s National Employment Standards – the minimum safety net for all workers – say a casual employee who has worked for their employer for 12 months must be offered the option ^[3] to convert to full-time or part-time (permanent) employment. But there are significant exemptions, particularly for small business. Close to 60% of Australia’s casual workers have been with their employer for more than a year ^[4], and 45% to 60% report regular hours and pay ^[5]. This has resulted in the great Australian oxymoron of “the permanent casual”. There is effectively a class of workers who don’t get holiday and sick pay, no matter how long or regularly they work, simply because their employer deemed them “casual” when they began. Read more: The truth about much 'casual' work: it's really about permanent insecurity ^[6] The legal landscape Since the 1990s, workers and their union representatives have challenged these contrivances in industrial tribunals. Several of these decisions have been tested on appeal in the Federal Court. In two cases in 2018 and 2020 ^[7], the Federal Court agreed a worker’s employment status should based on the reality of their long-term employment relationship. That is, if there was continuity, based on extended, regular patterns of employment, a worker was a permanent employee. Similar principles applied to those deemed contractors. However, appeals to the High Court in 2021 ^[8] and in 2022 ^[9] overturned these rulings. For the High Court, a formal stipulation of relations written in a contract were all that counted. The reality of life on the job was irrelevant. Read more: What defines casual work? Federal Court ruling highlights a fundamental flaw in Australian labour law ^[10] Common law versus parliament The High Court’s decisions – that formal freedom of contract has to be respected irrespective of the realities of bargaining power – reflect a long struggle between the common law and parliament in matters concerning working life. In the 1700s and 1800s, workers were jailed for meeting to discuss wage campaigns. To this day, commercial common law considers the principle of “freedom of contract” as the foundation for all commercial relations – including those involving employment. Union activity is an illegal restraint of trade. These principles have never been changed in the courts. It is only by statute (legislation passed by parliament) that trade unions and collective action by workers has been allowed. The federal Employment and Workplace Relations Minister, Tony Burke, says ^[11] the government “will legislate a fair, objective definition to determine when an employee can be classified as casual”, and no one will lose their casual status if that is their preference. There will, no doubt, be opposition, with warnings about threats to productivity and suggestions economic conditions are too fragile. But there’s a lot to be said in favour of giving greater recognition to reality.

References

^{^} the words (www.theaustralian.com.au)
^{^} Albanese government to make it easier for casuals to become permanent employees (theconversation.com)
^{^} must be offered the option (www.fairwork.gov.au)
^{^} for more than a year (www.aph.gov.au)
^{^} regular hours and pay (www.aph.gov.au)
^{^} The truth about much 'casual' work: it's really about permanent insecurity (theconversation.com)
^{^} 2018 and 2020 (www.lexisnexis.com.au)
^{^} in 2021 (www.corrs.com.au)
^{^} in 2022 (www.minterellison.com)
^{^} What defines casual work? Federal Court ruling highlights a fundamental flaw in Australian labour law (theconversation.com)
^{^} says (ministers.dewr.gov.au)

Employers will resist, but the changes for casual workers are about accepting reality

References

The Evolution of Retail: From Bricks and Mortar to Online — What’s Next?

FOLLOW.ART Launches the Nexus Card as the Ultimate Creative-World Holiday Gift

Big batteries are now outcompeting gas in the grid – and gas-rich Western Australia is at the forefront

The social media ban is just the start of Australia’s forthcoming restrictions – and teens have legitimate concerns

Politicians bank on people not caring about democracy – but research shows we do

REINSW: The Real Week Ahead

Times Magazine

Freak Weather Spikes ‘Allergic Disease’ and Eczema As Temperatures Dip

IPECS Phone System in 2026: The Future of Smart Business Communication

With Nvidia’s second-best AI chips headed for China, the US shifts priorities from security to trade

Navman MiVue™ True 4K PRO Surround honest review

Australia’s supercomputers are falling behind – and it’s hurting our ability to adapt to climate change

Australia’s electric vehicle surge — EVs and hybrids hit record levels

The Times Features

What We Know About Zenless Zone Zero 2.6 So Far

For Young People, Life Is an All-New Adventure. For Older People, Memories of Good Times and Lost Friends Come to Mind

Single and Ready to Mingle – the Coffee Trend Australians Can Expect in 2026

The Evolution of Retail: From Bricks and Mortar to Online — What’s Next?

How hot is too hot? Here’s what to consider when exercising in the heat

Vendor Advocacy Fees

MYA Cosmetics launches in Australia with bold new collection designed for creative tweens

How smart home materials can shield us from extreme heat and cut energy bills all year

What is autistic burnout? And what can you do about it?