The Times Australia
The Times World News

.

Students think the ATAR is 'unfair' but we need to be careful about replacing it

  • Written by Ilana Finefter-Rosenbluh, Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Education, Monash University
Students think the ATAR is 'unfair' but we need to be careful about replacing it

Many students spend their final years of school working toward the highest Australian Tertiary Admission Rank (ATAR) they can get. But after many years of concerns[1], there is a renewed debate[2] about whether we should scrap this university entrance ranking altogether.

Last month, a high-profile group of Victorian educational leaders called[3] for education authorities to replace the ATAR with a “learner profile”. Such an approach – also called “narrative evaluation” by researchers – provides information about a student’s interests, values and skills not necessarily captured in the ATAR. This might include things such as communication, caring and creativity.

Indeed, a common criticism[4] of the ATAR is that it does not tell universities enough about potential students and does not do enough to ensure diversity. Our research suggests students also see it as unfair.

But despite these concerns, we need to be careful about what we replace the ATAR with, or whether we should replace it at all.

What is the ATAR?

Young person holding a pile of books over their face.
The ATAR is used by all states and territories in Australia. Siora Photography/Unsplash

The ATAR[5] gives students a rank between zero and 99.95. It is a “percentile rank” – an estimate of the percentage of the population a student outperformed.

The method of calculating the ATAR varies across states and territories. Generally speaking, it involves complex scaling and moderation[6] processes that consider how competitive a subject is, with each student being academically compared to the other students in the same year level doing the same subject.

Both school evaluation marks and final external exam marks are considered in the calculation process. The higher your school’s average, the more favourable the process will be to your school.

This is why students are “dragged up” by high achievers in their school – they are pushing up the mean, thereby pushing up everyone’s marks in that school. In other words, your school peers’ achievement can greatly affect your school evaluation mark, which will be considered in your ATAR.

Read more: What actually is an ATAR? First of all it's a rank, not a score[7]

ATAR is still the most common way to go to uni

Introduced in 2009, the ATAR was designed to unify the university entrance system in Australia. Before this, each state and territory had its own system.

One criticism of the ATAR is that it is too “blunt” and too stressful for students, with all their school efforts hanging on a number. Critics have also called for “non-ATAR-based pathways[8]” to make access to university more equitable.

Some universities and degree programs don’t just rely on ATARs. They also use[9] entry tests, interviews, or other requirements such as portfolios. Figures also suggest more students are rejecting[10] the ATAR. For example, in 2021, about 10% of Victorian students completed the Victorian Certificate of Education without getting an ATAR.

Nevertheless, the ATAR remains the dominant form[11] of Australian university admissions.

Read more: We can predict final school marks in year 11 – it's time to replace stressful exams with more meaningful education[12]

Our study

As part of a wider 2021 study into how Australian private schools provide fair and inclusive education, we conducted focus groups with 24 students from both private and government schools.

One issue we identified was students believe the ATAR is “unfair”. This is not necessarily because they think the evaluation process must be more holistic in nature, but because they believe private schools have an advantage. They note how these schools tend to do better in state league tables, naturally pulling up the marks of students who attend them.

As one government school student observed:

One of the biggest influences on your ATAR is your school average […] and private schools have higher grades because they’re more selective, so we need to really upbeat our game because they have a huge advantage on us.

Similarly, a private school student explained:

Paying so much money to attend such a good school, it’s kind of a waste of money and resources if you’re not utilising that, like, if you’re not taking advantage of your advantage and do the best you can to succeed. It’s reassuring that your peers are strong students.

Certainly, research shows[13] socioeconomic background has a big impact on students’ academic performance. A 2015 Australian study[14] also suggests private schooling can add up to eight points to a student’s ATAR.

What about narrative evaluation?

So-called “narrative evaluation[15]” approaches seek to move the focus from a score to what a student has learned and engaged with.

It may come in the form of written text (or “mini essay”) about completed coursework and a student’s performance, supplementing or replacing other measures such as grades or pass/fail designations.

Internationally, different forms of narrative evaluation are used by some universities[16] and schools[17]. For example, Hampshire College in Massachusetts uses narrative evaluations instead of grades[18], to eliminate competition and enhance a “collaborative learning community”.

Other US universities such as MIT, Johns Hopkins and Brown University have been considering overhauling traditional grading[19] to reduce stress in the first year of college and make evaluation fairer for students who didn’t come from prestigious high schools.

View of a book being held open.
Narrative evaluations emphasise information about the individual student over a grade or mark. Valentin Salja/Unsplash

Narrative evaluations can be a problem, too

But narrative evaluation has also been criticised for making it difficult for students to get into graduate schools or secure scholarships. This is because grades are the “common currency” in most universities, and not having them could project an image of low standards to other institutions.

The University of California Santa Cruz, for example, abandoned[20] the narrative evaluation system in 2001 because it “created a bad image”, among other reasons.

Research[21] also shows US secondary students find narrative evaluations more stressful than letter grades. This is due to the intensity of the provided feedback (which could be seen as nitpicky), teacher subjectivity and need for revisions. Teachers also report this type of evaluation takes up a lot of resources and time.

Read more: Students are more than a number: why a learner profile makes more sense than the ATAR[22]

What happens next?

Like any other evaluation system[23] the ATAR has its flaws, which should be acknowledged and discussed. The fact that some students do not see it as fair is a significant issue, but a straight narrative evaluation system in its place may not be the answer.

This is not to say more personal evaluation components can’t be added. Medical schools, for example, have found interviews[24] an effective and important way to evaluate students’ personal and social capacities for the profession.

As the ATAR debate no doubt continues, we might be critical of this “blunt” number, but need to be careful any changes are genuine improvements – for students, schools, universities and employers.

References

  1. ^ years of concerns (theconversation.com)
  2. ^ renewed debate (www.theguardian.com)
  3. ^ called (www.theage.com.au)
  4. ^ common criticism (www.theage.com.au)
  5. ^ ATAR (www.vtac.edu.au)
  6. ^ scaling and moderation (www.vcaa.vic.edu.au)
  7. ^ What actually is an ATAR? First of all it's a rank, not a score (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ non-ATAR-based pathways (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ use (apo.org.au)
  10. ^ rejecting (www.theage.com.au)
  11. ^ dominant form (www.cis.org.au)
  12. ^ We can predict final school marks in year 11 – it's time to replace stressful exams with more meaningful education (theconversation.com)
  13. ^ shows (theconversation.com)
  14. ^ 2015 Australian study (theconversation.com)
  15. ^ narrative evaluation (www.k12academics.com)
  16. ^ universities (www.k12academics.com)
  17. ^ schools (www.k12academics.com)
  18. ^ narrative evaluations instead of grades (www.hampshire.edu)
  19. ^ overhauling traditional grading (www.mercurynews.com)
  20. ^ abandoned (www.sfgate.com)
  21. ^ Research (www.jstor.org)
  22. ^ Students are more than a number: why a learner profile makes more sense than the ATAR (theconversation.com)
  23. ^ evaluation system (www.oecd.org)
  24. ^ interviews (www.ama-assn.org)

Read more https://theconversation.com/students-think-the-atar-is-unfair-but-we-need-to-be-careful-about-replacing-it-200173

Times Magazine

Headless CMS in Digital Twins and 3D Product Experiences

Image by freepik As the metaverse becomes more advanced and accessible, it's clear that multiple sectors will use digital twins and 3D product experiences to visualize, connect, and streamline efforts better. A digital twin is a virtual replica of ...

The Decline of Hyper-Casual: How Mid-Core Mobile Games Took Over in 2025

In recent years, the mobile gaming landscape has undergone a significant transformation, with mid-core mobile games emerging as the dominant force in app stores by 2025. This shift is underpinned by changing user habits and evolving monetization tr...

Understanding ITIL 4 and PRINCE2 Project Management Synergy

Key Highlights ITIL 4 focuses on IT service management, emphasising continual improvement and value creation through modern digital transformation approaches. PRINCE2 project management supports systematic planning and execution of projects wit...

What AI Adoption Means for the Future of Workplace Risk Management

Image by freepik As industrial operations become more complex and fast-paced, the risks faced by workers and employers alike continue to grow. Traditional safety models—reliant on manual oversight, reactive investigations, and standardised checklist...

From Beach Bops to Alpine Anthems: Your Sonos Survival Guide for a Long Weekend Escape

Alright, fellow adventurers and relaxation enthusiasts! So, you've packed your bags, charged your devices, and mentally prepared for that glorious King's Birthday long weekend. But hold on, are you really ready? Because a true long weekend warrior kn...

Effective Commercial Pest Control Solutions for a Safer Workplace

Keeping a workplace clean, safe, and free from pests is essential for maintaining productivity, protecting employee health, and upholding a company's reputation. Pests pose health risks, can cause structural damage, and can lead to serious legal an...

The Times Features

The Role of Your GP in Creating a Chronic Disease Management Plan That Works

Living with a long-term condition, whether that is diabetes, asthma, arthritis or heart disease, means making hundreds of small decisions every day. You plan your diet against m...

Troubleshooting Flickering Lights: A Comprehensive Guide for Homeowners

Image by rawpixel.com on Freepik Effectively addressing flickering lights in your home is more than just a matter of convenience; it's a pivotal aspect of both home safety and en...

My shins hurt after running. Could it be shin splints?

If you’ve started running for the first time, started again after a break, or your workout is more intense, you might have felt it. A dull, nagging ache down your shins after...

Metal Roof Replacement Cost Per Square Metre in 2025: A Comprehensive Guide for Australian Homeowners

In recent years, the trend of installing metal roofs has surged across Australia. With their reputation for being both robust and visually appealing, it's easy to understand thei...

Why You’re Always Adjusting Your Bra — and What to Do Instead

Image by freepik It starts with a gentle tug, then a subtle shift, and before you know it, you're adjusting your bra again — in the middle of work, at dinner, even on the couch. I...

How to Tell If Your Eyes Are Working Harder Than They Should Be

Image by freepik Most of us take our vision for granted—until it starts to let us down. Whether it's squinting at your phone, rubbing your eyes at the end of the day, or feeling ...