The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

Diverting children away from the criminal justice system gives them a chance to 'grow out' of crime

  • Written by Faith Gordon, Associate Professor in Law, Australian National University
Diverting children away from the criminal justice system gives them a chance to 'grow out' of crime

Prison is no place for a child. Putting children in youth justice facilities can have long-lasting consequences[1] for their physical, psychological and emotional health, wellbeing and development.

Prison can aggravate[2] existing health conditions and result in new ones, such as depression, suicidal thoughts, and post-traumatic stress disorder.

We heard this firsthand from children interviewed by ABC’s Four Corners[3] this week.

The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child[4], to which Australia became a signatory in 1990, states detention should only be used as a “last resort” and, if required, should only be for the least possible time (Article 37). Yet this is not what we see in Australia.

Rather than imprisoning children who come into conflict with the law, the evidence[5] suggests diverting them away from the criminal justice system and providing appropriate supports gives children the best chance to “grow out” of the behaviours that are being criminalised.

A time of rapid brain development

Neuroscience shows children and young people undergo rapid brain development[6]. This can affect risk-taking, particular kinds of decision-making, and the ability to control impulses.

As previous research has shown, many children and young people desist or stop involvement in crime and in effect “grow out[7]” or “age out[8]” of it as they get older.

Reports[9] demonstrate there is typically a peak in involvement in crime in the mid-teens and a decline at the beginning of adulthood.

Read more: One year on from Royal Commission findings on Northern Territory child detention: what has changed?[10]

How do other countries compare with Australia?

Australia has a very low minimum age of criminal responsibility[11] compared to other parts of the world. Children as young as ten can be searched, arrested, detained and held criminally responsible.

Other countries[12] have a much higher age of criminal responsibility. In Luxembourg and South America, it’s 18, Poland is 17 (with some exceptions from 15), Portugal is 16, and Denmark is 15.

In contrast to Australia’s heavy reliance on the police, courts and prisons, other countries prioritise diversion for children who come into conflict with the law and promote alternative, community-based and social care-focused responses, which have much better outcomes for children and for communities.

One example is the public health model approach[13] to address violence in communities, which has been successful in Scotland.

This is where diverse sectors such as health, social services, education, justice and policy work together to solve problems that contribute to violence and criminality including homelessness, addiction and family violence.

Scotland’s homicide rate halved[14] between 2008 and 2018 after the approach was implemented and the number of hospital admissions due to assault with a sharp object fell by 62% in Glasgow (knife crime[15] has been a significant issue in the United Kingdom).

In other countries that have a much higher age of criminal responsibility, such as Norway[16] (where it’s 15), children under 15 do not interact with courts[17], are not punished but rather supported by child protection services[18], and their identities are not released in the media.

For those over 15, suspended sentences and probation[19], as well as support from child protection services, are prioritised.

Norway’s approach appears to be effective with an overall rate of recidivism (the number of people who return to prison after release) of 20%[20]. This is in stark contrast with Australia’s overall recidivism rate of 45.2%[21], with states and territories as high as 58.9%[22] (Northern Territory).

Teen talks with social worker
Other countries focus on support services for the young person. Shutterstock[23]

No benefits, only losses

There is no credible evidence[24] imprisoning children decreases levels of crime or improves community safety.

Yet there is a wealth of established evidence[25] demonstrating interactions with formal criminal justice institutions negatively impact children and are counterproductive. As the data[26] demonstrates, children who are first sentenced between the ages of ten and 12 are more likely to re-offend than those first sentenced when they are older.

Read more: Don Dale royal commission demands sweeping change – is there political will to make it happen?[27]

So what needs to happen?

We need to change our mindset about children who come into conflict with the law. We need a complete overhaul in our systems, with decarceration not incarceration.

Decarceration[28] is a process of reducing the number of people in prison by diverting people away from the criminal justice system and reducing the focus on prison as a solution to crime.

In Australia this would mean detaining children as a last resort and prioritising other methods of diversion, such as fixing the social determinants of criminality, as described above.

Read more: Locking up kids damages their mental health and sets them up for more disadvantage. Is this what we want?[29]

We need to see youth justice facilities closing, not plans and financial resources[30] being allocated to building more.

A major UN human rights review[31] and longstanding national campaigns[32] have called for the minimum age of criminal responsibility to urgently change nationally. The UN recommends 14 as the minimum age. Raising the age will prevent the criminalisation of younger children.

Children with neurodevelopmental disorders, disabilities or developmental delays[33] should not be in the youth justice system, no matter their age.

The harsh bail laws[34] in a number of states and territories also need to be amended, as they are resulting in large numbers of children spending periods in prison on remand.

Due to the bail laws, in Victoria in the decade to 2020 the number of children on remand doubled[35]. Two-thirds spent time in detention but did not go on to receive a custodial sentence.

Justice reinvestment[36] redirects resources from traditional criminal justice and related systems to communities, to instead invest those resources into programs that prioritise early intervention and prevention. Its core aim is to give communities[37] back decision-making powers, allowing them to self-determine their own futures.

Community-designed and community-based diversion programs are much more effective than formal criminal justice system responses and evaluations show positive outcomes and reductions in reoffending[38].

National Children’s Commissioner, Anne Hollonds[39] has called for a national taskforce[40] to urgently address the crisis in youth justice in Australia. However, this needs to be coupled with action from the federal government, in full cooperation with the states and territories.

If there are further delays or a lack of political will to bring about such change, it’s the most vulnerable children and young people who will continue to pay the price. Their wellbeing and futures are at stake.

References

  1. ^ long-lasting consequences (childrendeprivedofliberty.info)
  2. ^ aggravate (www.tandfonline.com)
  3. ^ ABC’s Four Corners (iview.abc.net.au)
  4. ^ United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (www.ohchr.org)
  5. ^ evidence (www.aic.gov.au)
  6. ^ rapid brain development (docstore.ohchr.org)
  7. ^ grow out (www.aic.gov.au)
  8. ^ age out (www.childrenscommissioner.gov.uk)
  9. ^ Reports (justiceinnovation.org)
  10. ^ One year on from Royal Commission findings on Northern Territory child detention: what has changed? (theconversation.com)
  11. ^ minimum age of criminal responsibility (www.aph.gov.au)
  12. ^ Other countries (www.sbs.com.au)
  13. ^ public health model approach (www.tandfonline.com)
  14. ^ Scotland’s homicide rate halved (commonslibrary.parliament.uk)
  15. ^ knife crime (theconversation.com)
  16. ^ Norway (www.ojp.gov)
  17. ^ do not interact with courts (www.ojp.gov)
  18. ^ supported by child protection services (www.theguardian.com)
  19. ^ suspended sentences and probation (www.ojp.gov)
  20. ^ 20% (www.bbc.com)
  21. ^ 45.2% (www.sentencingcouncil.vic.gov.au)
  22. ^ 58.9% (www.sentencingcouncil.vic.gov.au)
  23. ^ Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
  24. ^ no credible evidence (www.unicef.org)
  25. ^ evidence (journals.sagepub.com)
  26. ^ the data (www.sentencingcouncil.vic.gov.au)
  27. ^ Don Dale royal commission demands sweeping change – is there political will to make it happen? (theconversation.com)
  28. ^ Decarceration (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
  29. ^ Locking up kids damages their mental health and sets them up for more disadvantage. Is this what we want? (theconversation.com)
  30. ^ not plans and financial resources (www.abc.net.au)
  31. ^ UN human rights review (www.hrlc.org.au)
  32. ^ longstanding national campaigns (www.changetherecord.org.au)
  33. ^ neurodevelopmental disorders, disabilities or developmental delays (docstore.ohchr.org)
  34. ^ harsh bail laws (www.theage.com.au)
  35. ^ doubled (www.sentencingcouncil.vic.gov.au)
  36. ^ Justice reinvestment (justicereinvestment.net.au)
  37. ^ communities (jrna228913579.files.wordpress.com)
  38. ^ reductions in reoffending (www.aic.gov.au)
  39. ^ Anne Hollonds (humanrights.gov.au)
  40. ^ national taskforce (humanrights.gov.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/diverting-children-away-from-the-criminal-justice-system-gives-them-a-chance-to-grow-out-of-crime-194645

The Times Features

Designer Wardrobe reports surge in pre-loved wedding gowns

As Australia’s wedding season approaches, and amidst a challenging cost of living backdrop, new insights from Designer Wardrobe reveal that Australia and New Zealand (ANZ) brid...

DIY Bathroom Remodel: Essential Tips for a Fresh Look

As the home improvement craze continues to grow, more folks are diving into the world of DIY projects to transform their living spaces. Among these, bathroom remodels have gain...

STI rates are increasing among midlife and older adults. We need to talk about it

Globally, the rates of common sexually transmissible infections[1] (STIs) are increasing among people aged over 50. In some cases, rates are rising faster than among younger pe...

The Gift That Keeps Growing: Why Tinybeans+ Gift Cards are a game-changer for new parents

As new parents navigate the joys and challenges of raising a child in the digital age, one question looms large: how do you preserve and share your baby's milestones without co...

Group Adventures Made Easy: How to Coordinate Shuttle Services from DCA to IAD

Traveling as a large group can be both exciting and challenging, especially when navigating busy airports like DCA (Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport) and IAD (Washington...

From Anxiety to Assurance: Proven Strategies to Support Your Child's Emotional Health

Navigating the intricate landscape of childhood emotions can be a daunting task for any parent, especially when faced with common fears and anxieties. However, transforming anxie...

Times Magazine

The gold standard: why acrow props are still imperative to modern construction

Acrow props, or “scaffolding poles”, have long been one of the most imperative pieces of construction equipment. They are designed to provide extra structural support for the various levels found in new builds as the construction workers move upwar...

How to Create an Engaging and Functional Web Design

A website is an essential tool that many businesses use to reach out to their target audience and promote the goods and services they offer. It also helps businesses in developing and maintaining a pool of loyal customers. However, these goals ca...

The Best Venues for Hire in Melbourne that Suit Your Needs

Definition of Venue Hire When planning an event, one of the most important decisions is choosing the right venue. Venue hire refers to the process of renting a space for a specific period of time to host an event. This can include conference cen...

Australian workers to embrace ‘machine-mates’ in artificial intelligence fuelled future

A new report by AI expert Dr Catriona Wallace and ServiceNow reveals Australia’s post-pandemic future, with AI-powered digital colleagues or ‘machine-mates’, new-look employee and customer experiences, and significant cultural shifts Australia, ...

Australians can now recycle unwanted sports balls

It’s predicted that 330 million sports balls are made worldwide each year – but where do they end up? TreadLightly launches new SPORTS BALL recycling program.[1] TreadLightly today launches its new SPORTS BALL recycling program, aimed at reduci...

How To Pack Shoes And Hats For Moving

Packing your shoes and hats for a move can seem like a daunting task. But with a little planning and organisation, it can be done quickly and easily. Here are some tips from removalists Brisbane specialists to help you get started.  Start As Ear...