Flu may be back, but COVID is far from over. How do they compare?

Since Australia’s first Omicron wave after borders opened late last year, the pandemic has largely faded from the news and public perception. Gone are the daily briefings with updates on the numbers of cases, hospitalisations and deaths.

But this perception doesn’t match reality. While hospitalisation and death rates have been relatively lower than earlier waves – thanks to the vaccination rollout and naturally acquired immunity – 95%^[1] of all Australia’s COVID cases have occurred since the New Year. The daily rate of infections continues in the tens of thousands.

Almost 3,000 Australians died of COVID^[2] in the first quarter of 2022, placing it between coronary heart disease and stroke as a major cause of death.

This year we’ve seen both the Omicron wave and the re-emergence of influenza. After almost disappearing for two years of the pandemic, the lifting of most restrictions (such as social distancing and working from home), the decline in mask use and opening of international borders has allowed influenza to re-emerge.

So, how do COVID and seasonal influenza compare?

How deadly are COVID and influenza?

The case fatality rate^[3] – the proportion of COVID cases who die – has improved dramatically over the pandemic. In the 2020 Victorian June-October wave, around 3% of cases died.

In the 2021 Delta waves in New South Wales and Victoria, the death rate was under 1%.

For the Omicron wave this year – by which time most of the population were vaccinated – the case fatality rate has approached 0.1%. This is comparable to the seasonal influenza case fatality rate^[4] seen in “normal” flu years.

This drop in COVID case fatality rate has several causes: our high vaccination uptake, immunity from previous infection, better treatments, and Omicron being less deadly. The relative contributions are hard to tease out, but vaccination is likely to have played the most significant role.

The importance of COVID vaccination was underscored by a recent report estimating that internationally, vaccines have prevented between 14.4 and 19.8 million deaths^[5]. The impact would have been much greater with more equitable global distribution of vaccines.

Read more: Respiratory infections like whooping cough and flu have plummeted amid COVID. But 'bounce back' is a worry^[6]

Which is worse for unvaccinated people?

As of January, Omicron caused^[7] around one-third the rates of hospitalisation and death as the Delta variant. And for well-vaccinated people, this was comparable to influenza.

For unvaccinated people, Omicron was still worse than influenza.

But any comparison of COVID variants and influenza is complicated by new sub-variants, waning immunity, and the effects of vaccine booster doses.

How well do vaccines protect against COVID variants?

Although Omicron is less lethal than Delta, vaccination is also less effective, especially without a third or fourth dose.

The table below is compiled from weekly reports from the United Kingdom^[8] of vaccine effectiveness, mostly among those over 50 years of age. It shows vaccine effectiveness in preventing cases has declined with the Omicron variant.

But the effectiveness in preventing hospitalisations and deaths has remained high, particularly with boosters.

It’s important to interpret the apparently lower protective effect of vaccination against hospitalisation and death during the Omicron wave with caution. Some patients in hospital were found incidentally to have a positive test for COVID, which did not contribute to their subsequent death. Vaccination could not have prevented that.

Read more: Herd immunity was sold as the path out of the pandemic. Here's why we're not talking about it any more^[9]

Which is more transmissible – COVID or the flu?

COVID has been far more infectious and spreads more rapidly than influenza.

The first Omicron variant was estimated to be 100% more transmissible than the original SARS-CoV-2 virus, and 37% more transmissible^[10] than Delta. Successive Omicron sub-variants have ever higher infectiousness^[11] – all far beyond that of influenza.

Seasonal influenza has a reproduction number of about 1.3^[12] , compared with 4.2 for Omicron^[13]. That means one person with the flu spreads it to 1.3 other people, on average, while one person with Omicron passes it to 4.2 others. That sounds modest but these multiply, so three cycles of flu is 1.3 x 1.3 x 1.3 = 2.2 cases, whereas three cycles of Omicron is 4.2 x 4.2 x 4.2 = 74.

As a result, we have had nearly 100-fold more COVID than influenza cases this year, and COVID will likely remain the major cause of hospitalisations and deaths over winter.

One illustration of this is data from the United States^[14]: in January 2022, more US children died of COVID in a single month than in any of the ten previous years from influenza.

What are we likely to see in future?

Compared with many countries, Australia has done well in controlling COVID. It has minimised both the impact of illness and the economic burden, through international and state border closures, intermittent lockdowns in some states, and a very successful initial vaccine rollout.

But the COVID pandemic is not over, and we will experience further waves of infection with new sub-variants such as Omicron BA.4/5 (now 35% of cases in NSW^[15]), which will continue to cause illness, hospitalisation and death.

Unfortunately, Australia’s booster uptake has been much slower than the initial vaccination campaign and has almost stalled. This complacency is dangerous.

In the past three years we have experienced the pandemic and a series of natural disasters in Australia. Fatigue and a desire to move past COVID is completely understandable but carries substantial risk.

During winter, we must redouble our efforts to maintain population immunity through vaccine boosters combined with reasonable protective measures. Make sure your COVID and influenza vaccines are up-to-date, avoid crowded places (or wear a mask if you can’t), and avoid others if you have any respiratory symptoms.

Read more: COVID mask mandates might be largely gone but here are 5 reasons to keep wearing yours^[16]

References

1. ^{^} 95% (www.covid19data.com.au)
2. ^{^} 3,000 Australians died of COVID (www.abs.gov.au)
3. ^{^} case fatality rate (www1.health.gov.au)
4. ^{^} seasonal influenza case fatality rate (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
5. ^{^} between 14.4 and 19.8 million deaths (www.thelancet.com)
6. ^{^} Respiratory infections like whooping cough and flu have plummeted amid COVID. But 'bounce back' is a worry (theconversation.com)
7. ^{^} Omicron caused (twitter.com)
8. ^{^} weekly reports from the United Kingdom (www.gov.uk)
9. ^{^} Herd immunity was sold as the path out of the pandemic. Here's why we're not talking about it any more (theconversation.com)
10. ^{^} 37% more transmissible (www.medrxiv.org)
11. ^{^} ever higher infectiousness (aci.health.nsw.gov.au)
12. ^{^} reproduction number of about 1.3 (bmcinfectdis.biomedcentral.com)
13. ^{^} 4.2 for Omicron (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
14. ^{^} data from the United States (insidemedicine.bulletin.com)
15. ^{^} now 35% of cases in NSW (www.health.nsw.gov.au)
16. ^{^} COVID mask mandates might be largely gone but here are 5 reasons to keep wearing yours (theconversation.com)