The Times Australia
Google AI
The Times World News

.

Australia and Norway were once tied in global anti-corruption rankings. Now, we're heading in opposite directions

  • Written by A J Brown, Professor of Public Policy & Law, Centre for Governance & Public Policy, Griffith University
Australia and Norway were once tied in global anti-corruption rankings. Now, we're heading in opposite directions

In a worrying sign, Australia has plummeted in Transparency International’s latest Corruption Perceptions Index[1] – the world’s most widely cited ranking of how clean or corrupt every country’s public sector is believed to be.

In the 2021 index released today[2], Australia has repeated its largest-ever annual drop – falling four points on the 100-point scale, from 77 to 73. Zero is considered highly corrupt, while a score of 100 is very clean.

Overall, Australia has dropped 12 points on the index since 2012, more than any OECD country apart from Hungary, which also fell 12 points. Australia’s rate of decline is also similar or steeper than other countries with far worse issues, including Cyprus, Lebanon, Syria and Venezuela.

Australia was ranked seventh in the world in 2012, level with Norway. This year, Australia has fallen to 18th out of 180 countries. In contrast, Norway’s global standing has improved, climbing from seventh to fourth on the index.

It’s a clear sign Australia has missed a huge chance to correct our failing anti-corruption reputation. And this will likely continue to fall unless integrity policies are turned around at this year’s federal election.

Author provided What the index shows The Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) is compiled annually by Transparency International using the most credible, independent, long-running corruption measures in the world. Sources[3] include the Economist Intelligence Unit, Freedom House, the World Justice Project and the World Bank. These surveys focus on levels of public sector corruption, as well as the strength of mechanisms for preventing and controlling corruption. This makes the index not simply a list of which countries are more or less corrupt, but also an evaluation of their current anti-corruption efforts. The CPI is recognised as a key indicator of Australia’s integrity performance – not only by reform advocates, but by the federal government itself. Read more: As a NSW premier falls and SA guts its anti-corruption commission, what are the lessons for integrity bodies in Australia?[4] In September 2018, then-Attorney-General Christian Porter famously tried to defend the nation’s anti-corruption record by telling parliament[5] the CPI had placed Australia “consistently in the top 20 countries on Earth for low corruption”. It took Centre Alliance MP Rebekha Sharkie to point out[6] Australia used to be not only in the top 20, but the top ten. Instead of maintaining its high score, like Norway, Australia has gone in the other direction – and it now risks falling out of the top 20 altogether.
Author provided Australia had the chance to stem the fall Before this year, Australia’s score on the index had levelled off as the federal government finally made pledges to address integrity issues and other efforts to root out corruption took place. In that period, there was hope things might turn around: corrupt politicians and officials were successfully convicted in several states (including NSW’s prosecution[7] of former ministers Eddie Obeid and Ian Macdonald, while action was taken against local government corruption[8] in Queensland) Former Labor minister Eddie Obeid. Former Labor minister Eddie Obeid was sentenced last year to seven years over a rigged mining tender. Bianca de Marchi/AAP after many years, the major parties finally pledged to establish a federal integrity commission (Labor in February 2018[9] and the Coalition in December 2018[10]) long-overdue legislation was introduced to parliament to enhance laws against bribery of foreign officials[11] bipartisan recommendations were made to strengthen whistleblower protections[12], with new laws on private sector whistleblowing and promises of reform for the federal public sector high-profile federal enforcement action was taken against money laundering through Australian banks[13], while growing evidence of money laundering in casinos and real estate raised hopes of further reform. But the last year has seen progress stalled The latest drop in the CPI shows business and expert confidence in Australia’s official responses to corruption has collapsed again. Since 2020, when the data for this year’s index were mostly collected, the expected progress has not happened. Instead, Australia has seen: Bridget McKenzie during 'sports rorts' inquiry Bridget McKenzie quit the front bench and resigned as deputy Nationals leader after the so-called ‘sports rorts’ affair. Mick Tsikas/AAP NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian announcing her resignation NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian announcing her resignation last October. Bianca de Marchi/AAP Why leadership is key It doesn’t have to be this way. Transparency International has used this year’s global index[14] to highlight the need for countries to improve checks and balances through strong integrity institutions and to uphold people’s rights to hold those in power to account. When countries show serious leadership in anti-corruption reform – such as the United Kingdom during David Cameron’s Conservative government from 2012–17 - their scores on the index can climb. Clearly, the world now fears this type of leadership is lacking in Australia. The priorities and potential solutions are increasingly understood by experts, observers and the community. For example, Griffith University and Transparency International Australia recently assessed Australia’s national integrity system and developed a reform blueprint[15] to follow. With the 2022 federal election now just months away, the quality of the parties’ anti-corruption commitments – and leaders’ willingness to implement them – will matter as never before. Key issues still hang in the balance. As recently as November, the prime minister and attorney-general revealed[16] they were shelving any improvements to their Commonwealth integrity commission plan. This announcement came despite the government having spent yet another year consulting over the plan’s obvious problems[17]. Read more: Explainer: what is the proposed Commonwealth Integrity Commission and how would it work?[18] Anti-corruption reform is no longer the “fringe issue[19]” Prime Minister Scott Morrison claimed it was several years ago. For confidence in Australia’s public integrity to improve, the winner of the election is going to need to promise – and deliver – more convincing solutions than we’ve seen in the last two years. References^ Corruption Perceptions Index (transparency.org.au)^ 2021 index released today (www.transparency.org)^ Sources (www.transparency.org)^ As a NSW premier falls and SA guts its anti-corruption commission, what are the lessons for integrity bodies in Australia? (theconversation.com)^ telling parliament (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)^ point out (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)^ prosecution (www.abc.net.au)^ local government corruption (www.brisbanetimes.com.au)^ February 2018 (www.theguardian.com)^ December 2018 (www.abc.net.au)^ bribery of foreign officials (www.corrs.com.au)^ strengthen whistleblower protections (theconversation.com)^ Australian banks (www.abc.net.au)^ this year’s global index (www.transparency.org)^ reform blueprint (transparency.org.au)^ revealed (ministers.ag.gov.au)^ the plan’s obvious problems (transparency.org.au)^ Explainer: what is the proposed Commonwealth Integrity Commission and how would it work? (theconversation.com)^ fringe issue (www.theguardian.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/australia-and-norway-were-once-tied-in-global-anti-corruption-rankings-now-were-heading-in-opposite-directions-174966

Times Magazine

Navman MiVue™ True 4K PRO Surround honest review

If you drive a car, you should have a dashcam. Need convincing? All I ask that you do is search fo...

Australia’s supercomputers are falling behind – and it’s hurting our ability to adapt to climate change

As Earth continues to warm, Australia faces some important decisions. For example, where shou...

Australia’s electric vehicle surge — EVs and hybrids hit record levels

Australians are increasingly embracing electric and hybrid cars, with 2025 shaping up as the str...

Tim Ayres on the AI rollout’s looming ‘bumps and glitches’

The federal government released its National AI Strategy[1] this week, confirming it has dropped...

Seven in Ten Australian Workers Say Employers Are Failing to Prepare Them for AI Future

As artificial intelligence (AI) accelerates across industries, a growing number of Australian work...

Mapping for Trucks: More Than Directions, It’s Optimisation

Daniel Antonello, General Manager Oceania, HERE Technologies At the end of June this year, Hampden ...

The Times Features

Human Rights Day: The Right to Shelter Isn’t Optional

It is World Human Rights Day this week. Across Australia, politicians read declarations and clai...

In awkward timing, government ends energy rebate as it defends Wells’ spendathon

There are two glaring lessons for politicians from the Anika Wells’ entitlements affair. First...

Australia’s Coffee Culture Faces an Afternoon Rethink as New Research Reveals a Surprising Blind Spot

Australia’s celebrated coffee culture may be world‑class in the morning, but new research* sugge...

Reflections invests almost $1 million in Tumut River park to boost regional tourism

Reflections Holidays, the largest adventure holiday park group in New South Wales, has launched ...

Groundbreaking Trial: Fish Oil Slashes Heart Complications in Dialysis Patients

A significant development for patients undergoing dialysis for kidney failure—a group with an except...

Worried after sunscreen recalls? Here’s how to choose a safe one

Most of us know sunscreen is a key way[1] to protect areas of our skin not easily covered by c...

Buying a property soon? What predictions are out there for mortgage interest rates?

As Australians eye the property market, one of the biggest questions is where mortgage interest ...

Last-Minute Christmas Holiday Ideas for Sydney Families

Perfect escapes you can still book — without blowing the budget or travelling too far Christmas...

98 Lygon St Melbourne’s New Mediterranean Hideaway

Brunswick East has just picked up a serious summer upgrade. Neighbourhood favourite 98 Lygon St B...