Olympic Games are great for propagandists – how the lessons of Hitler's Olympics loom over Beijing 2022
- Written by Michael J. Socolow, Associate Professor, Communication and Journalism, University of Maine
On the morning of Aug. 14, 1936, two NBC employees met for breakfast at a café in Berlin. Max Jordan and Bill Slater were discussing the Olympic Games they were broadcasting back to the United States – and the Nazi propaganda machine that had made their work, and their visit to Germany, somewhat unpleasant.
Slater complained about all the staged regimentation and the obviously forced smiles everywhere.
“Why don’t they revolt? We wouldn’t stand for all this browbeating and bullying in America. I know that. Why do they stand for it here?” Slater asked Jordan.
As they were talking, three armed Nazi guards sat down at the next table. The whole café quieted. “It was as though a chill had come over those present,” Jordan later recalled. “In a nutshell, there was the answer to Bill’s question.”
I included the story Max Jordan recounted in his memoir in my book on the Nazi origins of Olympic broadcasting[1] because it perfectly encapsulated the quandary facing American sports journalists whenever the International Olympic Committee pushes them to broadcast happy images provided by repressive regimes.
It’s now less than 100 days from the opening ceremony of the 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics[2], and therefore it’s time for an honest discussion about the ethics of sport journalism and the morality of American media’s complicity with authoritarian regimes that hide the active repression of their citizens.
Abundant evidence
The world knows what China is doing right now. Courageous reporting has publicized the series of repressive domestic[4] and international actions taken by the Chinese government[5] over the past five years.
The persecution of the Uyghurs[6] and other human rights abuses, the abrogation of the Hong Kong treaty[7] along with the imposition of the Chinese government’s repression[8] in that port city, and the prevention of a comprehensive and transparent investigation[9] into the origins of COVID-19 are all well documented.
Thus, the Chinese government now wants good press in the West. And its efforts to ensure favorable coverage have prompted new concerns about media control and censorship during the Games, with a U.S. government spokesman recently[10] urging Chinese government officials “not to limit freedom of movement and access for journalists and to ensure that they remain safe and able to report freely, including at the Olympic and the Paralympic Games.”
But, as was clear from the experience during the 1936 Olympics, if U.S. journalists go to Beijing and emphasize the beauty of its landscape, the happiness of its citizenry and its futuristic infrastructure, and fail to cover the more controversial realities in China, that would signal compliance with – and promotion of – Chinese propaganda.
This is American sports journalism’s Red Smith moment.
Politics, meet sports
On Jan. 4, 1980, Walter “Red” Smith, the veteran New York Times sports columnist, surprised his readership[11] with his endorsement of the boycott movement against that summer’s Moscow Olympic Games. Boycott advocates were protesting the Soviet Union’s invasion of Afghanistan.
Smith’s stance was unexpected, as he had carefully sidestepped – or even ignored – many other moments he considered unhealthy political intrusion into international athletic competition. But Smith wrote that history had proved that America’s participation in the Nazi Games was a mistake – even if the great Black American runner Jesse Owens[12] redeemed the event in public memory.
“When Americans look back to the 1936 Olympics,” Smith wrote in his famous column[13], “they take pleasure only in the memory of Jesse Owens’ four gold medals.” Outside of that, he admitted, “we are ashamed at having been guests at Adolf Hitler’s big party.”
Smith was an old-school sports reporter[14], already an old-timer in 1980 – he died in 1982. His reporting and columns reflected the influence of Grantland Rice[15] and Paul Gallico[16], the giants who invented modern American sports writing in the 1920s. But there had always existed another group of sports reporters less afraid to point out obvious political unpleasantness.
For example, the great Jimmy Cannon[17] had no problem freely peppering political references and acerbic commentary throughout his columns. Westbrook Pegler detested the Nazis and criticized them relentlessly[18] throughout the 1936 Games. And Howard Cosell’s sharp commentaries[19], on such issues as Muhammad Ali’s boxing suspension in the 1960s and the political activism that erupted in 1968 in Mexico City, remain a credit to his legacy.
‘The U.S. Olympic Committee … is in the main a group of pompous, arrogant and medieval-minded men who regard the games as a private social preserve,’ said Howard Cosell.That Red Smith had spent decades remaining largely apolitical in public made his support for the boycott surprising. That he was only the second sports columnist to be awarded a Pulitzer Prize[20], and that his opinions were widely respected, gave his endorsement significant clout.
‘The one lever we have’
Smith opened the gates for others to point out the incongruity and obvious hypocrisy of celebrating the Soviet Union’s peaceful intentions while the Soviet army was invading and occupying Afghanistan. In his column, Smith quoted British Member of Parliament Neville Trotter, who led the boycott movement in Great Britain.
“This is the one lever we have to show our outrage at this naked aggression by Russia,” Trotter told Smith[21]. “We should do all we can to reduce the Moscow Olympics to a shambles.”
One well-known and nationally respected sports journalist has explicitly and unambiguously called for boycotting the 2022 Beijing Games: Sally Jenkins. The Washington Post’s veteran columnist – who last year was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize for commentary[22] – published a scorching column plainly stating that “ignorance is no longer an excuse.”
“It was a forgivable mistake to award an Olympics to Beijing in 2008,” she wrote[23]. “It’s unforgivable to hold one there now.”
Red Smith’s boycott column remains one of his most important and lasting examples of public service. As a media historian, I believe that those who emulate his courage today, like Sally Jenkins, will likely be remembered in the same way tomorrow.
[Like what you’ve read? Want more? Sign up for The Conversation’s daily newsletter[24].]
References
- ^ in my book on the Nazi origins of Olympic broadcasting (www.press.uillinois.edu)
- ^ 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics (olympics.com)
- ^ Photo FPG/Archive Photos/Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
- ^ repressive domestic (www.icij.org)
- ^ international actions taken by the Chinese government (www.propublica.org)
- ^ persecution of the Uyghurs (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ abrogation of the Hong Kong treaty (www.cnbc.com)
- ^ Chinese government’s repression (apnews.com)
- ^ a comprehensive and transparent investigation (www.npr.org)
- ^ a U.S. government spokesman recently (www.reuters.com)
- ^ surprised his readership (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ great Black American runner Jesse Owens (www.cbc.ca)
- ^ Smith wrote in his famous column (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ Smith was an old-school sports reporter (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ Grantland Rice (theathletic.com)
- ^ Paul Gallico (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ Jimmy Cannon (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ criticized them relentlessly (olympic-century.blogspot.com)
- ^ sharp commentaries (www.youtube.com)
- ^ awarded a Pulitzer Prize (www.pulitzer.org)
- ^ Trotter told Smith (www.nytimes.com)
- ^ the Pulitzer Prize for commentary (www.pulitzer.org)
- ^ she wrote (www.washingtonpost.com)
- ^ Sign up for The Conversation’s daily newsletter (theconversation.com)
