The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

Peter Dutton’s nuclear energy policy will do nothing to ease Australians’ hip-pocket pain, now or in the future

  • Written by Tony Wood, Program Director, Energy, Grattan Institute

Of all the debates unleashed by the Coalition’s nuclear energy announcement[1] this week, energy prices is among the hottest. As Australians struggle with the skyrocketing cost of living, Opposition Leader Peter Dutton’s plan gives little assurance he can bring power bills down – neither soon nor into the future.

Dutton’s plan, for seven Commonwealth-owned nuclear plants across Australia, came with no costings or modelling attached. We don’t know the price tag to build and operate the reactors. More importantly, we don’t what the total system, with nuclear included, will look like or cost.

But we do know the first nuclear plant, if it ever gets built, would not be operational for at least a decade – and even that is a very optimistic timeframe. There are not many Australians worrying about their energy bills in 2035 – but even if they were, nuclear energy is unlikely to bring costs down then.

And what of the hip-pocket pain facing consumers right now? The Coalition’s nuclear plan, if it replaces coal with gas in the medium-term, is only likely to mean higher energy bills – not to mention higher greenhouse gas emissions.

Gas is not the answer

Making his announcement on Wednesday, Dutton said the seven sites chosen for nuclear reactors “will be part of an energy mix – obviously with renewables and significant amounts of gas into the system, particularly in the interim period”. He went on:

Our plan is to deliver cheaper, cleaner and consistent 24/7 electricity as part of a balanced energy mix.

Dutton concedes coal plants are reaching the end of their lives. Almost all will be gone by 2035[2], so new generation sources are needed. But his plan does nothing to explain how the Coalition would do this, and bring down energy prices, in the next five to ten years.

In fact, there is every indication the Coalition’s policy will have the opposite effect. Gas is expensive compared to coal. Its real value is in balancing a high-renewables system – that is, to meet weather-related shortfalls until other solutions are commercially viable.

If a Coalition government slows the renewables’ roll-out, and uses gas to fill the supply gap until nuclear plants are operational, energy prices will only go up.

However, Dutton also needs to explain how he intends to slow down renewables and speed up gas, when such decisions are driven as much by state[3] as federal policies, through measures such as renewable energy targets and state policy roadmaps.

Dutton defends lack of detail in nuclear plan (ABC News, June 20)

What about future energy prices?

Moving on from energy prices over the next decade, what happens in the mid 2030s when the Coalition’s nuclear energy capability is purportedly up and running?

Let’s say the Coalition builds seven small and large nuclear reactors which together add about ten gigawatts of capacity to the grid. This is a feasible figure, taking into account the current capacity of nuclear reactors around the world. However, it is a very small proportion of the generation capacity that will be needed in the later 2030s.

Would electricity from this grid be cheaper than if that ten gigawatts was supplied by renewable energy? So far, the Coalition has provided no evidence to support this argument.

CSIRO research recently found[4] that electricity produced by a large-scale nuclear plant in Australia would be at least 50% more expensive than firmed renewable energy.

There’s another point to consider. Australia’s total electricity generation must increase enormously to meet the electrification needs of other parts of the economy. Homes and much of industry will move away from gas to electricity, light vehicles will be electric, and our “energy superpower” ambitions, such as exporting green hydrogen, will need many gigawatts of new, zero-emissions electricity.

According to the Australian Energy Market Operator, annual electricity consumption from Australia’s grid will need to double by 2050, to about 300 gigawatts[5].

It’s the total system costs that matter when it comes to electricity prices, and ten gigawatts of nuclear would be a very small part of the mix.

Show us the numbers

The Coalition has made much of the need to have a “balanced” energy system to bring energy prices down. This is a strange argument. When coal was seen as the cheapest and best source of energy, we had an electricity system which ran on coal. No-one was talking about “balance” back then.

New technologies were only introduced once we realised coal was no longer fit for the job. The idea that we should have a mix of technologies in the system, simply as a matter of principle, doesn’t make sense. The Coalition has not explained what the balanced system would look like and what roles each technology would play in that system.

Opposition energy spokesman Ted O’Brien says the Coalition will provide costings for its nuclear energy policy before the federal election. This detail will be welcomed, and heavily scrutinised.

Based on what we have seen so far, it’s hard to see how Coalition’s policy will do anything to address cost-of-living challenges now, or in the 2030s and beyond.

References

  1. ^ nuclear energy announcement (theconversation.com)
  2. ^ gone by 2035 (www.unsw.edu.au)
  3. ^ driven as much by state (theconversation.com)
  4. ^ recently found (www.abc.net.au)
  5. ^ double by 2050, to about 300 gigawatts (aemo.com.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/peter-duttons-nuclear-energy-policy-will-do-nothing-to-ease-australians-hip-pocket-pain-now-or-in-the-future-232915

The Times Features

Sunshine Coast Personal Injury Lawyers: Expert Guidance for Work Accident Claims

When accidents occur in the workplace, they can have profound and lasting effects on a worker's life, both physically and financially. In Queensland's Sunshine Coast, personal in...

iS Clinical's Skincare Secrets for Radiant Party Season Skin

As the festive season approaches, having runway-ready skin is easier than ever with iS Clinical's  top skincare prep tips. Whether you're walking the red carpet or simply stepp...

How to Camp Sustainably in Byron Bay: Eco-Friendly Tips

Camping in Byron Bay is a fantastic way to soak up nature, from beautiful beaches to lush rainforests. It’s no wonder Byron Bay camping is on so many bucket lists! But with more ...

Book a room in Broome as the northwest is best

Looking for a different kind of seaside escape? Done the east coast? Then book a room in Broome to discover why those in the know say the northwest is best, with Broome one of ...

Primary care involves more than GPs. A new review shows how patients can better access care

Australians today are more likely[1] than previous generations to live with complex and chronic diseases, such as diabetes, heart disease and depression. This means they’re mo...

Why Your Credit Score Matters More Than You Think in Australia

Your credit score isn't just a number, it's a reflection of your financial reputation. In Australia, a good credit score can unlock doors to better financial opportunities, while...

Enhance Your Home’s Comfort and Style with Blackout Curtains from 3Hlinen

Creating a comfortable and peaceful home environment often involves choosing the right window treatments. Among the various options available, blackout curtains stand out as a ve...

Is thirst a good predictor of dehydration?

Water is essential for daily functioning and health, and we can only survive a few days[1] without it. Yet we constantly lose water through sweat, urination and even evaporatio...

How doctors use light to diagnose disease

You’re not feeling well. You’ve had a pounding headache all week, dizzy spells and have vomited up your past few meals. You visit your GP to get some answers and sit while they ...

Times Magazine

A Guide to the Best Experience at the Monaco Grand Prix

The Monaco Grand Prix is among the jewels that Formula One or F1 owns. The high-speed chase is held in the narrow streets of Monte Carlo. And because little has changed on the race track’s exciting design since the first race was held here, the M...

How To Customise Your Website with HubSpot CMS: A Step-by-Step Guide

In the fast-paced digital landscape, owning a mere business website is not just enough. Your website is the first impression for your potential customer. It must be user friendly and well-designed, the content on the website needs to be appealing, ...

CRM Implementation Challenges and How to Overcome Them

Modern business moves quickly and demands satisfaction from customers. One of the best ways to achieve this is through Customer Relationship Management, or CRM for short. Implementing a CRM system can greatly benefit businesses, especially in the ret...

Craft the Comfort of Childhood With Puppet Toys

Puppet toys have been a beloved form of entertainment for children for centuries. Not only are they incredibly fun for kids, but they also offer valuable developmental benefits. From fostering imaginative play to exploring emotions, puppets can be ...

Segway-Ninebot Launches e-Motorbike Series

Segway-Ninebot, one of the world's leading manufacturers of micro-mobility solutions, is announcing its new e-Motorbike range with three models coming to Australia. Segway-Ninebot is leading the electric evolution in transportation and innovation...

The gold standard: why acrow props are still imperative to modern construction

Acrow props, or “scaffolding poles”, have long been one of the most imperative pieces of construction equipment. They are designed to provide extra structural support for the various levels found in new builds as the construction workers move upwar...