The Times Australia
Fisher and Paykel Appliances
The Times World News

.

How risky is turbulence on a plane? How worried should I be?

  • Written by Hassan Vally, Associate Professor, Epidemiology, Deakin University
How risky is turbulence on a plane? How worried should I be?

The Singapore Airlines turbulence incident[1] that has sadly left one person dead and others hospitalised has made many of us think about the risks of air travel.

We’ll hear more in coming days about how the aircraft came to drop so suddenly on its route from London to Singapore earlier this week, injuring passengers and crew, before making an emergency landing in Thailand.

But thankfully, these types of incidents are rare[2], and much less-common[3] than injuries from other types of transport.

So why do we sometimes think the risk of getting injured while travelling by plane is higher than it really is?

How common are turbulence injuries?

Turbulence[4] is caused by[5] the irregular movement of air, leading to passengers and crew experiencing abrupt sideways and vertical jolts.

In the case of the Singapore Airlines flight, this type of turbulence is thought to be a severe example of “clear-air turbulence[6]”, which can occur without warning. There are several other types.

About 25 in-flight turbulence injuries are reported[7] to the Australian Transport Safety Bureau each year, although it is thought many more are un-reported. Some of these reported injuries are serious, including broken bones and head injuries. Passengers being thrown up and out of their seat during turbulence is one of the most common type of head injury on a plane.

Other injuries from turbulence are caused by contact with flying laptops, or other unsecured items.

In one example[8] of clear-air turbulence that came without warning, cabin crew, passengers and meal trolleys hit the ceiling, and landed heavily back on the floor. Serious injuries included bone fractures, lacerations, neck and back strains, a dislocated shoulder and shattered teeth. Almost all of those seriously injured did not have their seat belts fastened.

But we need to put this into perspective. In the year to January 2024, there were more than 36 million[9] passengers on international flights to Australia. In the year to February 2024, there were more than 58 million[10] passengers on domestic flights.

So while such incidents grab the headlines, they are exceedingly rare.

Why do we think flying is riskier than it is?

When we hear about this recent Singapore Airlines incident, it’s entirely natural to have a strong emotional reaction. We might have imagined the terror we might feel if we were on the aircraft at the time.

But our emotional response alters our perception[11] of the risk and leads us to think these rare incidents are more common than they really are.

Thinking, Fast and Slow
Penguin Press[12] There is a vast body of literature addressing the numerous factors[13] that influence how individuals perceive risk and the cognitive biases we are all subject to that mislead us. Nobel Prize-winning economist Daniel Kahneman[14] covers them in his bestselling book Thinking, Fast and Slow[15]. He describes the way we respond to risks is not rational, but driven by emotion. Kahneman also highlights the fact that our brains are not wired to make sense of extremely small risks. So these types of risks – such as the chance of serious injury or death from in-flight turbulence – are hard for us to make sense of. The more unusual an event is, and this was a very unusual event, Kahneman says the more impact it makes on our psyche and the more likely we are to overestimate the risk. Of course, the more unusual the event, the more likely[16] it is for it to be in the media, amplifying this effect. Similarly, the easier it is to imagine an event[17], the more it affects our perception and the more likely we are to respond to an event as if it were much more likely to occur. How can we make sense of the risk? One way to make sense of activities with small, hard-to-understand risks is by comparing their risks to the risks of more familiar activities. If we do this, the data shows very clearly that it is much more risky[18] to drive a car or ride a motorbike than to travel by plane. While events such as the Singapore Airlines incident are devastating and stir up lots of emotions, it’s important to recognise how our emotions can mislead us to over-estimate the risk of this happening again, or to us. Apart from the stress and anxiety this provokes, overestimating the risks of particular activities may lead us to make bad decisions that actually put us at greater risk of harm. References^ turbulence incident (www.abc.net.au)^ are rare (www.atsb.gov.au)^ less-common (www.aihw.gov.au)^ Turbulence (theconversation.com)^ is caused by (www.atsb.gov.au)^ clear-air turbulence (www.theguardian.com)^ are reported (www.atsb.gov.au)^ one example (www.atsb.gov.au)^ more than 36 million (www.bitre.gov.au)^ more than 58 million (www.bitre.gov.au)^ alters our perception (psycnet.apa.org)^ Penguin Press (www.penguin.com.au)^ numerous factors (theconversation.com)^ Daniel Kahneman (www.nobelprize.org)^ Thinking, Fast and Slow (www.penguin.com.au)^ more likely (psycnet.apa.org)^ imagine an event (www.sciencedirect.com)^ more risky (www.aihw.gov.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/how-risky-is-turbulence-on-a-plane-how-worried-should-i-be-230665

Times Magazine

This Christmas, Give the Navman Gift That Never Stops Giving – Safety

Protect your loved one’s drives with a Navman Dash Cam.  This Christmas don’t just give – prote...

Yoto now available in Kmart and The Memo, bringing screen-free storytelling to Australian families

Yoto, the kids’ audio platform inspiring creativity and imagination around the world, has launched i...

Kool Car Hire

Turn Your Four-Wheeled Showstopper into Profit (and Stardom) Have you ever found yourself stand...

EV ‘charging deserts’ in regional Australia are slowing the shift to clean transport

If you live in a big city, finding a charger for your electric vehicle (EV) isn’t hard. But driv...

How to Reduce Eye Strain When Using an Extra Screen

Many professionals say two screens are better than one. And they're not wrong! A second screen mak...

Is AI really coming for our jobs and wages? Past predictions of a ‘robot apocalypse’ offer some clues

The robots were taking our jobs – or so we were told over a decade ago. The same warnings are ...

The Times Features

Indo-Pacific Strength Through Economic Ties

The defence treaty between Australia and Indonesia faces its most difficult test because of econ...

Understanding Kerbside Valuation: A Practical Guide for Property Owners

When it comes to property transactions, not every situation requires a full, detailed valuation. I...

What’s been happening on the Australian stock market today

What moved, why it moved and what to watch going forward. 📉 Market overview The benchmark S&am...

The NDIS shifts almost $27m a year in mental health costs alone, our new study suggests

The National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) was set up in 2013[1] to help Australians with...

Why Australia Is Ditching “Gym Hop Culture” — And Choosing Fitstop Instead

As Australians rethink what fitness actually means going into the new year, a clear shift is emergin...

Everyday Radiance: Bevilles’ Timeless Take on Versatile Jewellery

There’s an undeniable magic in contrast — the way gold catches the light while silver cools it down...

From The Stage to Spotify, Stanhope singer Alyssa Delpopolo Reveals Her Meteoric Rise

When local singer Alyssa Delpopolo was crowned winner of The Voice last week, the cheers were louder...

How healthy are the hundreds of confectionery options and soft drinks

Walk into any big Australian supermarket and the first thing that hits you isn’t the smell of fr...

The Top Six Issues Australians Are Thinking About Today

Australia in 2025 is navigating one of the most unsettled periods in recent memory. Economic pre...