The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

Yes, Australia’s big supermarkets have been price gouging. But fixing the problem won’t be easy

  • Written by Bree Hurst, Associate Professor, Faculty of Business and Law, QUT, Queensland University of Technology
Yes, Australia’s big supermarkets have been price gouging. But fixing the problem won’t be easy

A much-awaited report into Coles and Woolworths has found what many customers have long believed – Australia’s big supermarkets engage in price gouging.

What started[1] as a simple Senate inquiry into grocery prices and supermarket power has delivered a lengthy 195-page-long report[2] spanning supermarket pricing’s impact on customers, food waste, relationships with suppliers, employee wages and conditions, excessive profitability, company mergers and land banking.

The report makes some major recommendations, including giving courts the power to break up anti-competitive businesses, and strengthening the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC).

It also recommends making the Food and Grocery Code of Conduct mandatory for supermarket chains. This code governs how they should deal with suppliers. The government’s recent Independent Review of the Food and Grocery Code[3] also recommended making it mandatory for the supermarket giants.

But at this point it’s hard to say what, if anything, the recommendations will mean for everyday Australians and the prices they actually pay.

Price gouging isn’t illegal

At the heart of the Senate inquiry was the question of whether Australian supermarkets were price gouging. According to the committee, the answer is a “resounding yes”, despite the evidence presented by supermarkets to the contrary.

Price gouging is when businesses exploit a lack of competition by setting prices well above cost price. But the practice is not explicitly illegal[4].

Man in supermarket viewing receipts
It’s not illegal to set prices higher than they need to be. Denys Kurbatov/Shutterstock[5]

The committee put forward a number of recommendations that could help reduce price gouging. These include making it an offence to charge excess prices and establishing a new “Commission on Prices and Competition” to examine price setting practices in different sectors.

The committee also wants the ACCC to be given enhanced powers to investigate and prosecute unfair trading practices, and to be better funded and resourced.

The committee says supermarket claims that price gouging does not exist should mean the giants have nothing to fear under tougher legislation. However, it says:

the evidence brought forward by people willing to speak out about the business practices of Coles and Woolworths suggests that maintaining margins and increasing margin growth is occurring at the expense of suppliers, consumers, and best business practices, and without proper justification.

Storefront signs saying 'Coles' and 'Woolworths'
Coles and Woolworths have repeatedly rejected claims they engage in price gouging. Joel Carrettt/AAP[6]

It’s unlikely we’ll see relief anytime soon

Will these recommendations actually deliver any relief on prices? It’s hard to say at this point. The recommendations put forward are comprehensive, but they’re unlikely to result in any short-term change for consumers.

At any rate, the Albanese government does not support many of them. In the report’s additional commentary, Labor senators argue that Australian competition law already addresses excessive pricing by prohibiting misleading and deceptive conduct. They also don’t support establishing a new commission to examine prices.

Rather, the report calls for a dramatic overhaul of current regulatory settings, which it says are “not appropriate or fit for purpose”. This is not going to be an easy or fast process.

What does the report mean for the Greens’ divestiture bill?

While the inquiry was underway, the Greens introduced a bill[7] which would give courts “divestiture powers”. This means a corporation could be ordered to sell some of its assets to reduce its market power.

While the bill lacks support from the major parties, the committee suggested that such divestiture powers should be introduced specifically for the supermarket sector. Where abuse of market power was able to be proven, supermarkets could be forced to sell certain stores.

While Australia does not have divestiture powers in this context, some other countries do. In New Zealand, the UK and the US, courts can force corporations that are abusing their market power to sell components of their business. Such powers are very rarely used, but the deterrent they impose can be highly influential[8] on corporate behaviour.

Labor rejects creating any forms of divestiture power in the report’s additional commentary. But the Coalition isn’t entirely against the idea, noting that it “does not believe the committee has persuasively found that divestiture powers should not be pursued at all” and that “divestiture powers should be targeted to sectors of concern”.

Read more: It's time to give Australian courts the power to break up big firms that behave badly[9]

What’s next?

At this stage, the report suggests there’s only one action all political parties agree on at this stage: making the Food and Grocery Code of Conduct mandatory and ensuring its full enforcement. We’re unlikely to see much unity on the other recommendations.

Farm workers pick mandarins and load them onto a truck
There remains a stubborn power imbalance between major supermarkets and their suppliers. Kevin Wells Photography/Shutterstock[10]

In a scathing commentary, the Coalition argues the report represents “a missed opportunity to address some of the structural imbalances in our supermarket sector that are impacting Australia’s growers, farmers, small businesses, and ultimately consumers”.

While this is a harsh assessment, the reality is that unless these structural imbalances in our food system are addressed, we’re unlikely to see meaningful change.

The report draws on substantial evidence to paint a troubling picture of the food system in Australia – in particular, how growers and consumers are struggling. The task for regulators is working out what mechanisms can be used to address the imbalance of power in the market, in a way that doesn’t force growers or Australian consumers to bear the cost.

References

  1. ^ started (www.aph.gov.au)
  2. ^ report (www.aph.gov.au)
  3. ^ Independent Review of the Food and Grocery Code (treasury.gov.au)
  4. ^ not explicitly illegal (www.accc.gov.au)
  5. ^ Denys Kurbatov/Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
  6. ^ Joel Carrettt/AAP (photos.aap.com.au)
  7. ^ introduced a bill (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)
  8. ^ highly influential (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ It's time to give Australian courts the power to break up big firms that behave badly (theconversation.com)
  10. ^ Kevin Wells Photography/Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/yes-australias-big-supermarkets-have-been-price-gouging-but-fixing-the-problem-wont-be-easy-229602

The Times Features

Designer Wardrobe reports surge in pre-loved wedding gowns

As Australia’s wedding season approaches, and amidst a challenging cost of living backdrop, new insights from Designer Wardrobe reveal that Australia and New Zealand (ANZ) brid...

DIY Bathroom Remodel: Essential Tips for a Fresh Look

As the home improvement craze continues to grow, more folks are diving into the world of DIY projects to transform their living spaces. Among these, bathroom remodels have gain...

STI rates are increasing among midlife and older adults. We need to talk about it

Globally, the rates of common sexually transmissible infections[1] (STIs) are increasing among people aged over 50. In some cases, rates are rising faster than among younger pe...

The Gift That Keeps Growing: Why Tinybeans+ Gift Cards are a game-changer for new parents

As new parents navigate the joys and challenges of raising a child in the digital age, one question looms large: how do you preserve and share your baby's milestones without co...

Group Adventures Made Easy: How to Coordinate Shuttle Services from DCA to IAD

Traveling as a large group can be both exciting and challenging, especially when navigating busy airports like DCA (Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport) and IAD (Washington...

From Anxiety to Assurance: Proven Strategies to Support Your Child's Emotional Health

Navigating the intricate landscape of childhood emotions can be a daunting task for any parent, especially when faced with common fears and anxieties. However, transforming anxie...

Times Magazine

The gold standard: why acrow props are still imperative to modern construction

Acrow props, or “scaffolding poles”, have long been one of the most imperative pieces of construction equipment. They are designed to provide extra structural support for the various levels found in new builds as the construction workers move upwar...

How to Create an Engaging and Functional Web Design

A website is an essential tool that many businesses use to reach out to their target audience and promote the goods and services they offer. It also helps businesses in developing and maintaining a pool of loyal customers. However, these goals ca...

The Best Venues for Hire in Melbourne that Suit Your Needs

Definition of Venue Hire When planning an event, one of the most important decisions is choosing the right venue. Venue hire refers to the process of renting a space for a specific period of time to host an event. This can include conference cen...

Australian workers to embrace ‘machine-mates’ in artificial intelligence fuelled future

A new report by AI expert Dr Catriona Wallace and ServiceNow reveals Australia’s post-pandemic future, with AI-powered digital colleagues or ‘machine-mates’, new-look employee and customer experiences, and significant cultural shifts Australia, ...

Australians can now recycle unwanted sports balls

It’s predicted that 330 million sports balls are made worldwide each year – but where do they end up? TreadLightly launches new SPORTS BALL recycling program.[1] TreadLightly today launches its new SPORTS BALL recycling program, aimed at reduci...

How To Pack Shoes And Hats For Moving

Packing your shoes and hats for a move can seem like a daunting task. But with a little planning and organisation, it can be done quickly and easily. Here are some tips from removalists Brisbane specialists to help you get started.  Start As Ear...