The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

How the fast-track law could expose future NZ governments to expensive trade disputes

  • Written by Jane Kelsey, Emeritus Professor of Law, University of Auckland, Waipapa Taumata Rau
How the fast-track law could expose future NZ governments to expensive trade disputes

Resources Minister Shane Jones has reportedly asked officials[1] for advice on whether oil and gas companies could be offered “bonds” as compensation if drilling rights offered by the present government were extinguished by any future administration.

Such a move would have real implications under the government’s proposed Fast-track Approvals Bill[2], which is designed to “enable faster approval of infrastructure and other projects that have significant regional or national benefits”.

NZ First’s Jones is one of three ministers who could have sign-off powers under the new law. Offering investors protection against future liability may be seen as one way to attract such projects.

But some of those investors may already have the means of securing compensation and deterring government interference under existing “investor-state dispute settlement” (ISDS[3]) mechanisms.

This is despite efforts by recent governments – including coalition partner NZ First – to close that door. The potential fiscal and political risk adds one more reason not to proceed with the fast-track bill.

Shane Jones in parliament
NZ First’s Shane Jones: seeking advice on compensation for investors. Getty Images

A chilling effect on governments

Investor-state dispute settlement provisions have been included in bilateral investment treaties, and some investment chapters in free trade agreements (FTAs), for several decades.

These agreements confer special protections on foreign investors against laws, policies, decisions and other actions and omissions that – contrary to their “legitimate expectations” at the time of investing – adversely affect the value or profitability of their investments.

The foreign investor can directly enforce those guarantees against the host state in ad hoc international tribunals. These have been widely criticised[4] as favouring investors, lacking precedents and appeals, and for conflicts of interests when the arbitrators may be advocates for investors in other disputes.

Most agreements do not permit considerations of fault, even for environmental damage or human rights violations. Nor do they protect a democratically elected government’s mandate to amend the law.

The tribunal can award billions of dollars in compensation for lost future profits, with compound interest, even where the investor made a minimal outlay.

‘Treaty shopping’

The goal is to “chill” governments from pursuing the actions investors want to stop. Cases are increasingly bankrolled by third party funders[5] willing to speculate on the outcome, so the investor has no risk in bringing a dispute.

Fighting a dispute can cost many millions, even if the state eventually wins. Yet the very existence of an ISDS dispute can be kept secret.

In theory, only investors from states which are party to these trade or investment agreements can sue. But “treaty-shopping” has seen investors use ISDS against their own governments.

In 2019, for example, Australian mining magnate Clive Palmer announced he had moved ownership[6] of his flagship company to Singapore, having briefly shifted[7] it to New Zealand first. The purpose was to take advantage of ISDS in the ASEAN-Australia-New Zealand FTA, and the Singapore-Australia FTA.

Palmer now has three claims[8] totalling around US$300 billion against his own government, including for matters he has litigated on and lost in the Australian courts.

European Commission building in Belgium
The European Commission headquarters in Brussels: worried about energy companies using ISDS against climate policies. Getty Images

Investor disputes and climate change

The bulk of ISDS cases involve natural resources[9] and, increasingly, climate change measures. As of 2022, investors in the fossil fuel sector had brought at least 192 known ISDS cases against governments. The past decade has seen more than 80 known cases brought by investors in the renewable energy sector.

Last year, the UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights and the Environment warned[10] that governments could be liable to oil and gas corporations for US$340 billion in future disputes over fulfilling their commitments under the Paris Agreement on climate change.

This is a major disincentive to ambitious climate action. States that once championed agreements containing ISDS are now withdrawing from them. This year, the European Commission proposed a coordinated EU withdrawal[11] from the multilateral Energy Charter Treaty because energy companies are using ISDS to challenge new climate change laws and policies.

The New Zealand parliament began to step back from ISDS in 2015, when NZ First MP Fletcher Tabuteau sponsored a private member’s bill “to protect New Zealand laws by prohibiting New Zealand from entering international agreements that include provision for investor-state dispute settlement”.

The Fighting Foreign Corporate Control Bill was defeated by a single vote[12] (Labour, the Greens and NZ First for; National, ACT and United Future against). But in 2017, the Labour-NZ First coalition adopted a policy of no ISDS in future trade agreements.

One National MP predicted[13] the earlier NZ First bill “would make it very difficult to enter into new trade deals and negate current trade deals which would be disastrous for the economy”. But subsequent FTAs, including with the UK and EU, have been concluded without ISDS.

Fiscal and democratic risk

However, a number of New Zealand’s other FTAs still allow ISDS claims to be initiated by investors legally located in partner countries: China, Japan, Canada, Singapore, Indonesia, Philippines, Malaysia, Mexico, South Korea and Brunei, among others.

This raises the stakes of the Fast-track Approvals Bill, including for Māori. The Waitangi Tribunal[14] inquiry into the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement[15] expressed concern that the potential for ISDS disputes might deter the Crown from meeting its te Tiriti/Treaty obligations if doing so affected investors.

The Tribunal was also uncertain if the Treaty of Waitangi exception[16] included in free trade agreements would provide protection against such claims.

The existence of ISDS might suit the proponents and beneficiaries of the fast-track legislation. But the government must also be aware it carries fiscal risks that could run into the billions.

Foreign investors wanting to protect their gains under the controversial new law could hold the country to ransom by threatening a dispute. As a result, they would constrain New Zealand’s democratic ability to exercise its sovereignty, and to protect te Tiriti rights.

References

  1. ^ reportedly asked officials (www.thepost.co.nz)
  2. ^ Fast-track Approvals Bill (environment.govt.nz)
  3. ^ ISDS (www.mfat.govt.nz)
  4. ^ widely criticised (www.transnationalmatters.com)
  5. ^ bankrolled by third party funders (ccsi.columbia.edu)
  6. ^ moved ownership (thewest.com.au)
  7. ^ briefly shifted (www.stuff.co.nz)
  8. ^ three claims (www.iisd.org)
  9. ^ natural resources (investmentpolicy.unctad.org)
  10. ^ warned (www.ohchr.org)
  11. ^ coordinated EU withdrawal (www.europarl.europa.eu)
  12. ^ defeated by a single vote (www.parliament.nz)
  13. ^ predicted (www.parliament.nz)
  14. ^ Waitangi Tribunal (forms.justice.govt.nz)
  15. ^ Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (www.mfat.govt.nz)
  16. ^ Treaty of Waitangi exception (law.unimelb.edu.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/how-the-fast-track-law-could-expose-future-nz-governments-to-expensive-trade-disputes-229363

The Times Features

The Importance of Regular Roof and Gutter Maintenance for Adelaide Home

The Importance of Regular Roof and Gutter Maintenance for Adelaide Homes Your roof and gutters can be integral to maintaining the structural integrity and aesthetic appeal of yo...

Designer Wardrobe reports surge in pre-loved wedding gowns

As Australia’s wedding season approaches, and amidst a challenging cost of living backdrop, new insights from Designer Wardrobe reveal that Australia and New Zealand (ANZ) brid...

DIY Bathroom Remodel: Essential Tips for a Fresh Look

As the home improvement craze continues to grow, more folks are diving into the world of DIY projects to transform their living spaces. Among these, bathroom remodels have gain...

STI rates are increasing among midlife and older adults. We need to talk about it

Globally, the rates of common sexually transmissible infections[1] (STIs) are increasing among people aged over 50. In some cases, rates are rising faster than among younger pe...

The Gift That Keeps Growing: Why Tinybeans+ Gift Cards are a game-changer for new parents

As new parents navigate the joys and challenges of raising a child in the digital age, one question looms large: how do you preserve and share your baby's milestones without co...

Group Adventures Made Easy: How to Coordinate Shuttle Services from DCA to IAD

Traveling as a large group can be both exciting and challenging, especially when navigating busy airports like DCA (Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport) and IAD (Washington...

Times Magazine

The Benefits of School Excursions to Underwater Worlds

Exploring the mystical depths of underwater worlds holds an unparalleled charm, especially for young minds eager to learn and discover. School excursions to places like aquariums offer more than just a day away from the classroom; they present a un...

Credit Card Compare Australia on Major Rebuild and Relaunch

David Boyd's entrepreneurial journey is a compelling narrative of innovation, relentless pursuit of goals, and a firm belief in the transformative power of technology. He immigrated from Northern Ireland to Australia in 2003. Boyd became known as a...

Things you need to know about certificate iii in mobile plant technology

g Certification is very important for all types of work in the industry. To succeed in the field, you need to complete the certification in the required field that you opt for. You can keep industrial technology working at peak capacity with certi...

Best Brisbane Personal Injury Lawyers: Finding No-Win, No-Fee Lawyers to Represent You

Navigating a personal injury claim can be an overwhelming experience, particularly when compounded by the financial stress that often accompanies trauma. Fortunately, Brisbane boasts a number of personal injury lawyers who offer no win, no fee arra...

Reasons Why You Should Hire A Marketing Agency If You Want Your Company To Rank Better On Google

A solid online presence is essential for every company's success in the modern digital era. Ranking high on search engine results pages (SERPs) has become a primary goal since the great majority of consumers use search engines like Google to loca...

How DevOps Course Is Revolutionizing Modern Software Development

In order to provide products and services more quickly and effectively, DevOps is a software engineering technique that integrates software development (Dev) with IT operations (Ops). It places a strong emphasis on automating software deployment, inf...