The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

why Australian women have so little trust in religious institutions

  • Written by Kate Gleeson, Associate Professor of Law, Macquarie University
why Australian women have so little trust in religious institutions

The Albanese government is weighing up the costs of delivering an election promise to protect religious people from discrimination in Commonwealth law. Such protections were relatively uncontroversial when included in state anti-discrimination laws. However, the religious discrimination debate became toxic under former prime minister Scott Morrison when it became tied to[1] the rights of religious schools to discriminate against LGBTIQ+ staff and students.

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has said[2] the government has draft legislation ready to go. However, it won’t introduce it without bipartisan support because, “now is not the time to have a divisive debate, especially with the rise in antisemitism and Islamophobia”.

Religious discrimination might not be addressed by the Australian parliament any time soon. Albanese must first persuade Opposition Leader Peter Dutton to support legislation to protect both religious people and LGBTIQ+ staff and students at religious schools.

Second, he will need to contend with an electorate that appears, at best, ambivalent about the problem of religious discrimination[3], while maintaining strong concerns about discrimination against LGBTIQ+ groups.

Trust in organised religion is low

Our new research report, Trust in Religion among Women in Australia[4], highlights some electoral realities relevant to legislating to protect religion in Australia today. The report analyses data from the nationally representative Australian Cooperative Election Survey[5], taken from May 2–18 2022. We surveyed 1,044 voters, of whom 531 were women. While we analysed the data for both men and women, we found that women are significantly more likely than men to express distrust in religion, and so our report focussed on them.

Our findings present a bleak picture for religious organisations hoping to gain political traction based on trust in their ability to act ethically and responsibly.

Jeremy Bannister/AAP
Child abuse scandals have played a big part in eroding the trust of women in particular.

When compared internationally, Australians – particularly women – have very low trust in organised religion. This gendered outcome makes Australia an outlier in the Western world and is likely related to women’s concerns for children in the care of religious organisations. Key findings include:

  • about one-third of Australian women have no trust in organised religion and religious leaders

  • distrust is highest among younger women: almost half of all women aged 18-29 have no trust in religious leaders

  • among religious women, around 10% have no trust in organised religion and religious leaders, while around half have “not very much trust” in either

  • LGBTIQ+ women have some of the lowest levels of trust in Australia. Almost two-thirds have no trust in religious leaders

  • Women living in outer regional and remote Australia are significantly more likely to distrust religion than women living in cities and inner regional areas.

Child abuse scandals have eroded trust

Consistent with international studies[6], our research indicates religious child abuse scandals have greatly affected trust. Australian women are highly sceptical about the capacity of religious leaders to protect the children in their care. In fact, almost half report low, or no, trust.

They also doubt the ability of religious leaders to respond to the findings[7] of the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse. Over half report low, or no, trust in this. Concern for children is highest among LGBTIQ+ women, likely reflecting concerns about discrimination against LGBTIQ+ school children, as well as child abuse.

Trust affects how women view the role of religion in the public sphere. We found that about four in five women who have no trust in religion believe religious organisations should no longer be granted tax-exempt status by the government. Around two-thirds of this group also believe the government should stop funding religious schools.

Similarly, two-thirds of women with no trust in religion think religious organisations should play a smaller role, or no role at all, in counselling in schools. Around 60% of this group also think religious organisations should play a smaller role, or no role at all, in primary and high school education.

Anthony Albanese will need to get the balance right in any religious discrimination legislation. Mick Tsikas/AAP

Can trust be regained?

The report concludes that organised religion is facing a profound crisis of trust, particularly among women. Concerns for children are paramount in shaping women’s opinions about religious organisations and the services they offer. The high level of distrust among younger women suggests the crisis is generational and cannot be corrected without dedicated interventions on the part of religious organisations and governments.

If left unchecked, this crisis has the potential to undermine the social and economic fabric of Australia, given the prominence of religious organisations in the provision of education, healthcare, and social services.

Religious organisations must work to establish or regain the trust of the electorate, especially among regional and remote communities. The current national emergency[8] of violence against women perhaps provides one opportunity for religious organisations to build this trust. This is especially so given the pivotal role they now play in the outsourced domestic violence services sector, which was once community-run[9].

Politically, this crisis of trust does not bode well for governments seeking support for any legislation that might appear to offer greater protections to organised religion.

In particular, any protections that are perceived to encroach on children’s rights will almost certainly be rejected by those large sections of the Australian electorate reporting low or no trust in religion. Albanese will need to get the balance right.

References

  1. ^ it became tied to (theconversation.com)
  2. ^ said (theconversation.com)
  3. ^ ambivalent about the problem of religious discrimination (theconversation.com)
  4. ^ Trust in Religion among Women in Australia (apo.org.au)
  5. ^ Australian Cooperative Election Survey (apo.org.au)
  6. ^ international studies (openpresstiu.pubpub.org)
  7. ^ findings (www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au)
  8. ^ national emergency (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ community-run (www.smh.com.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/crisis-of-faith-why-australian-women-have-so-little-trust-in-religious-institutions-228291

The Times Features

Australian small businesses set to win big as many brace for a bumper holiday season

With the holiday sales season in full swing, new data from the Commonwealth Bank reveals small businesses could be set to receive a much-needed end-of-year financial reward...

BeerFest Sydney at Darling Harbour Tumbalong Park

Sydneysiders’ ultimate summer party is here! BeerFest Sydney is making its triumphant debut at Darling Harbour’s Tumbalong Park on 6–7 December, bringing together NSW’s best bo...

The Importance of Regular Roof and Gutter Maintenance for Adelaide Home

The Importance of Regular Roof and Gutter Maintenance for Adelaide Homes Your roof and gutters can be integral to maintaining the structural integrity and aesthetic appeal of yo...

Designer Wardrobe reports surge in pre-loved wedding gowns

As Australia’s wedding season approaches, and amidst a challenging cost of living backdrop, new insights from Designer Wardrobe reveal that Australia and New Zealand (ANZ) brid...

DIY Bathroom Remodel: Essential Tips for a Fresh Look

As the home improvement craze continues to grow, more folks are diving into the world of DIY projects to transform their living spaces. Among these, bathroom remodels have gain...

STI rates are increasing among midlife and older adults. We need to talk about it

Globally, the rates of common sexually transmissible infections[1] (STIs) are increasing among people aged over 50. In some cases, rates are rising faster than among younger pe...

Times Magazine

Racer Holly Espray hits the track with Uniden for V8 SuperUte Series in Bathurst

Leading SuperUte racer Holly Espray is geared up for her next big challenge at Bathurst, and she's relying on support from her new sponsor Uniden, known for its cutting-edge technology, to keep her connected and secure, both on and off the track. ...

What You Need to Know About the Best Viber Promotional Messages

One of the most popular communication apps in the world, Viber's promotional messages are a powerful tool for connecting with potential clients. To maximize the effectiveness of your campaigns, it's critical to understand the fundamentals of Viber ...

WITHINGS, the pioneer of the connected health movement announces Body Scan

The connected health station helps users get a handle on health with the ability to measure health vitals and access to personal health plans based on behavioural science WITHINGS, the pioneer of the connected health movement, brings the smart s...

JOLT, Australia’s first free electric vehicle charging network

Seedooh charges up with JOLT   JOLT, Australia’s first free electric vehicle charging network, has partnered with purpose-built technology platform Seedooh to verify all advertising campaigns running across its new 100% Digital Out of Home netw...

Types of Hot Water Systems: Different types of systems and the advantages

1. Electric: Electric hot-water systems are the simplest and most common type of hot water system. They work by circulating heated water through a tank filled with cold water using electricity as the heat source. The electric current heats the wa...

A Fantastic Look Into The Top Fitness Trackers And Swimming Apps For 2022

People want swimming pools for several reasons and the best fibreglass pools today offer myriad advantages in your backyard. Anyone who gets a pool these days wants to swim in it for fun and fitness. Once you get a pool installed, you will likely u...