The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

Moving closer to Australia is in New Zealand’s strategic interest – joining AUKUS is not

  • Written by Robert G. Patman, Professor of International Relations, University of Otago

Despite inheriting positive bilateral ties with Australia and the US, New Zealand’s coalition government has indicated it wants an even closer alignment with traditional allies.

In what has been described as “the most challenging strategic environment for decades”, Foreign Minister Winston Peters and Defence Minister Judith Collins held discussions[1] with their Australian counterparts in Melbourne this month.

This was the first time in trans-Tasman relations that ministers in these portfolios have met in such a “two-on-two” format.

A statement[2] issued after the talks said “the two countries share close bonds of history and geography, liberal democratic values, regional and global interests and strategic outlook”.

The statement also agreed the AUKUS security partnership “made a positive contribution toward maintaining peace, security and prosperity in the Indo-Pacific”.

These words may have signalled a potentially momentous break with New Zealand’s previous foreign policy.

New Zealand Defence Minister Judith Collins, Australia Defence Minister Richard Marles, New Zealand Foreign Minister Winston Peters and Australia Foreign Minister Penny Wong at Treasury Gardens, Melbourne.
Closer relations: Judith Collins, Australian Defence Minister Richard Marles, Winston Peters and Australia Foreign Minister Penny Wong in Melbourne, February 1. AAP

A distinctive worldview

There has long been bipartisan acknowledgement that Australia is New Zealand’s closest and most important ally. But there appeared to be little recognition at the meeting that New Zealand’s evolving sense of national identity – anchored in the Pacific – has generated a distinctive worldview.

For much of the post-war era, the New Zealand-Australian alliance has been one of unity rather than uniformity. It has accommodated relatively independent New Zealand stances on non-nuclear security, opposition to the illegal US invasion of Iraq in 2003, and relations with China.

It may be a stretch to say the alliance promoted a principled, independent New Zealand foreign policy, but it has certainly not proved to be an impediment.

However, those days may now be coming to an end. A tighter alignment with Australia – given Canberra’s own very close relationship with Washington – could make New Zealand itself more reliant on US strategic input.

Read more: The defence dilemma facing NZ's next government: stay independent or join 'pillar 2' of AUKUS?[3]

China not the only threat

Close ties with Australia do not mean it is necessarily in New Zealand’s strategic interests to join AUKUS.

Established in 2021, the trilateral security pact[4] between Australia, the US and UK purports to defend “a shared commitment to the international rules-based order” in the Indo-Pacific region.

But it is clearly intended to counter the challenge of China’s assertiveness, and consists of two “pillars”.

Read more: NZ’s first national security strategy signals a 'turning point' and the end of old certainties[5]

Pillar one involves Australia receiving eight to ten nuclear-powered submarines from the US and UK over the next three decades. New Zealand is now actively exploring whether to join pillar two, envisaging the sharing of cutting-edge defence technologies.

According to Collins[6], New Zealand’s “defence has been absolutely gutted in the last three years and we’ve got to build that back”.

While last year’s national security strategy[7] acknowledged New Zealand’s “stability, security and prosperity” depends critically on an international rules-based order, it is also evident China is not the sole threat to this order.

Smoke from an explosion in Gaza
An Israeli military operation in the northern Gaza, February 18. AAP

Gaza and Ukraine

Firstly, there is the unconditional support of the US and UK for the Israeli government’s disproportionate and relentless military response in Gaza to the October 7 terrorist attacks.

An estimated 28,000 Palestinians have been killed, prompting the International Court of Justice to order Israel to prevent acts of genocide there.

New Zealand has voted twice in the UN General Assembly for an immediate humanitarian truce or ceasefire. It also recently joined Australia and Canada in calling for a ceasefire[8] before any ground assault on Rafah.

Read more: From the Middle East to the South China Sea: NZ's new government inherits a defence dilemma[9]

But the government has nevertheless overlooked US complicity (through military aid and use of its Security Council veto) in the Gaza catastrophe. That complicity has allowed Iran and China to strategically capitalise on global anger over the plight of the Palestinians.

As well, Wellington has accepted a US request to send a Defence Force team[10] to the Red Sea to help repel Houthi attacks on civilian shipping.

New Zealand and Australia have a huge stake in reversing the illegal and brutal Russian attempt to annex parts of Ukraine. The Biden administration, however, has struggled since late 2023 to sustain vital military aid to Kyiv.

Serious opposition within the US Congress from some members of the Republican party[11] raises questions for its allies – including its AUKUS partners – about US commitment to the international rules order.

Read more: The 'number 8 wire' days for NZ's defence force are over – new priorities will demand bigger budgets[12]

Would AUKUS help or hinder NZ interests?

There is also a concern among Pacific Island[13] and ASEAN[14] states that New Zealand’s possible participation in AUKUS pillar two could heighten great power rivalry.

Elevating a view that only the US and its Anglosphere partners can counter Chinese influence in the vast region carries several risks.

It may undercut regional leadership, and de-emphasise local national security concerns such as climate change. It might also hurt New Zealand’s diplomatic standing as a Pacific nation projecting an independent, rules-based, non-nuclear foreign policy that is distinguishable from its traditional allies.

Read more: Ukraine war: what the US public thinks about giving military and other aid[15]

The current security situation faces multiple challenges – including US exceptionalism, China’s assertiveness, Russian expansionism and UN Security Council dysfunction.

The key question is whether access to the start-of-the-art defence technologies of AUKUS pillar two will help address or aggravate these challenges for a relatively small actor like New Zealand.

On balance, and mindful that AUKUS does not have a monopoly over new defence technologies, there is little evidence that participation in pillar two will significantly advance New Zealand’s distinctive interests and values in the Indo-Pacific region or elsewhere.

And it should certainly not be regarded as a quick fix for under-investment in the country’s defence sector by governments over many years.

References

  1. ^ held discussions (www.beehive.govt.nz)
  2. ^ statement (www.beehive.govt.nz)
  3. ^ The defence dilemma facing NZ's next government: stay independent or join 'pillar 2' of AUKUS? (theconversation.com)
  4. ^ trilateral security pact (www.whitehouse.gov)
  5. ^ NZ’s first national security strategy signals a 'turning point' and the end of old certainties (theconversation.com)
  6. ^ According to Collins (www.rnz.co.nz)
  7. ^ national security strategy (www.dpmc.govt.nz)
  8. ^ calling for a ceasefire (www.reuters.com)
  9. ^ From the Middle East to the South China Sea: NZ's new government inherits a defence dilemma (theconversation.com)
  10. ^ send a Defence Force team (www.beehive.govt.nz)
  11. ^ some members of the Republican party (www.theguardian.com)
  12. ^ The 'number 8 wire' days for NZ's defence force are over – new priorities will demand bigger budgets (theconversation.com)
  13. ^ Pacific Island (www.stuff.co.nz)
  14. ^ ASEAN (foreignpolicy.com)
  15. ^ Ukraine war: what the US public thinks about giving military and other aid (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/moving-closer-to-australia-is-in-new-zealands-strategic-interest-joining-aukus-is-not-223843

The Times Features

The Gift That Keeps Growing: Why Tinybeans+ Gift Cards are a game-changer for new parents

As new parents navigate the joys and challenges of raising a child in the digital age, one question looms large: how do you preserve and share your baby's milestones without co...

Group Adventures Made Easy: How to Coordinate Shuttle Services from DCA to IAD

Traveling as a large group can be both exciting and challenging, especially when navigating busy airports like DCA (Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport) and IAD (Washington...

From Anxiety to Assurance: Proven Strategies to Support Your Child's Emotional Health

Navigating the intricate landscape of childhood emotions can be a daunting task for any parent, especially when faced with common fears and anxieties. However, transforming anxie...

The Rise of Meal Replacement Shakes in Australia: Why The Lady Shake Is Leading the Pack

Source Meal replacement shakes are having a moment in Australia, and it’s not hard to see why. They’re quick, convenient, and packed with nutrition, making them the perfect solu...

HCF’s Healthy Hearts Roadshow Wraps Up 2024 with a Final Regional Sprint

Next week marks the final leg of the HCF Healthy Hearts Roadshow for 2024, bringing free heart health checks to some of NSW’s most vibrant regional communities. As Australia’s ...

The Budget-Friendly Traveler: How Off-Airport Car Hire Can Save You Money

When planning a trip, transportation is one of the most crucial considerations. For many, the go-to option is renting a car at the airport for convenience. But what if we told ...

Times Magazine

The Evolution of Digital Marketing: Trends and Innovations.

In the dynamic realm of digital marketing, staying ahead of the curve is imperative for businesses aiming to thrive in an increasingly competitive landscape. As we navigate through the ever-evolving digital ecosystem, it's crucial to understand the...

Harnessing Modern Technology for Sustainable Solutions: A Blueprint for the Future

In an era where sustainability is not just a buzzword but a critical imperative, the convergence of digital, cloud, data, and intelligence offers unprecedented opportunities to create a more sustainable world. Organizations across the globe are lev...

Introduction to the Traces of Friable Asbestos Removal in Western Australia

In the domain of safety and health, the ultimate removal and handling of friable asbestos is important. In western Australia this aspect is ultimately important. Friable asbestos is categorised as very easily crumbly airborne, which poses a serio...

Best Practices for Creating a High-Performance SaaS Product

Achieving high performance in designing a Software as a Service (SaaS) product must be done strategically by putting user experience, scalability, consistency, and data-driven decision-making at the forefront. In today's competitive world, where us...

Protect Your Vehicle with a Quality Metal Carport

Advantages of Choosing Metal Carports When you are looking for a way to protect your vehicles from the elements, one of the best options is a metal carport. Metal carport kits in Melbourne offer a variety of advantages over other types of carport...

If You Want To Purchase a Property In Melbourne – Engage With An Owner’s Corporation

Many Australians are looking to get on the property ladder this year because they know and understand that property continues to go up in price year-on-year and so do rental opportunities. If this describes you then it’s likely that you still wan...