The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

The NZ aviation industry is making bold climate claims – and risking anti-greenwashing litigation

  • Written by James Higham, Professor of Tourism, Griffith University

On the same day last week that Air New Zealand announced the purchase of its first fully electric aircraft[1], Christchurch Airport announced[2] it had reached “a new standard for decarbonisation”. On the face of it, great news for reducing aviation emissions in Aotearoa.

The reality is a little more complex – and risky. As the climate warms, so too is the temperature in boardrooms and courtrooms. The aviation industry is under increasing scrutiny for its sustainability claims, and climate litigation is on the rise.

At the same time, “net zero” strategies in general are being challenged. The United Nations High-Level Expert Group[3] was established at last year’s COP27 summit, as Secretary General António Guterres explained, because “net zero suffers from a surplus of confusion and a deficit of credibility”.

The expert group has put forward a set of net-zero guidelines to put a “red line through greenwashing”. The guidelines underpin the UN’s approach to net zero, which requires corporate entities to advance ambitious climate mitigation actions based on rigorous and comprehensive science-based targets[4].

Among other things, the targets must include emissions reductions from the entity’s full value chain and activities[5]. These include emissions from sources the entity owns and controls directly (known as scope 1); emissions the entity causes indirectly (scope 2); and emissions not produced by the entity itself, but arising up and down its value chain (scope 3).

The expert group also notes that voluntary carbon credits (offsets) cannot be counted[6] towards interim emissions reductions required on the pathway to Net Zero 2050. This is because carbon offsetting has been shown to be troublesome at best[7], and in many cases a scam[8].

planes at an airport
Flights of fancy: unsupportable claims about sustainability are increasingly under scrutiny. Getty Images

Airlines in the firing line

Key players in the global aviation industry that make unsupportable claims have become targets for climate litigation[9].

A recent greenwashing complaint to the European Commission, for example, was filed by consumer groups in 19 countries against 17 airlines. Virgin Atlantic and British Airways are facing formal complaints[10] filed by a climate charity and law firm over sustainable flight claims.

Read more: Airlines are being hit by anti-greenwashing litigation – here's what makes them perfect targets[11]

Advertisements for Air France, Lufthansa and Etihad have been banned[12] in the UK for greenwashing, following complaints to the UK Advertising Standards Board that phrases such as “protecting the future”, “sustainable avitaion” and “low-emissions airline” are misleading consumers.

Delta faces a class action lawsuit[13] for claiming to be “the first carbon neutral airline on a global basis” in a case brought by a California resident claiming the airline has grossly misrepresented its climate impact.

And KLM is being sued[14] for greenwashing by law firm Client Earth, which successfully argued the Dutch airline’s “Fly Responsibly” campaign consitutes misleading advertising[15] under EU law while KLM is growing its number of flights rather than reducing emissions.

Long-haul growth versus decarbonisation

Cases like these raise questions about Air New Zealand’s “Flight NZ0[16]strategy and marketing[17], which focuses on sustainable aviation fuel and next-generation aircraft (including its recently bought electric Beta Alia[18]), complemented by carbon offsetting and operational efficiency.

The focus on sustainable fuel will have to overcome significant scientific, energy, scalability and cost barriers[19]. Solutions to these complex problems[20] are likely to be decades away at least.

While Air New Zealand promotes the Beta Alia – with its inherent altitude, payload and range limitations – it also aims to significantly increase[21] its long haul network, and is setting its sights[22] on the “ultra long haul experience”.

The contradiction between long-haul growth and decarbonisation strategies is expressed in the airline’s own 2017 sustainability report[23], in which the sustainability advisory panel chair wrote:

And that’s the dilemma for anyone who cares passionately about addressing the multiple threats of climate change: either stop flying altogether (the logical but somewhat unworldly idealist’s position), or fly as little and as discriminatingly and responsibly as possible (the often uncomfortable pragmatist’s position).

As consumers and environmentalists focus more on the validity of climate claims and the viability of carbon reduction strategies, Air New Zealand may find it harder to defend its net zero pathway.

Read more: High Court decision on $125 million fine for Volkswagen is a warning to all greenwashers[24]

Airports on the radar

The environmental claims of other players in the wider aviation system – notably airports – are also likely to attract critical attention.

Airports Council International (ACI) is the global industry body[25] for airports, with over 550 airports taking part in its Airport Carbon Accreditation[26] program, including many in New Zealand (most recently Invercargill Airport[27]).

Christchurch Airport has been in the program for longer, and makes significant climate claims. In April 2022, it announced[28] “another world class sustainability achievement”, going “beyond carbon neutral, to become climate positive”.

But this doesn’t account for scope 3 emissions, mainly associated with flights in and out of the airport, which make up 95.39% of total emissions[29]. Airports can only appear to be climate-neutral by not accounting for the high and growing emissions of the planes that are their core business.

Read more: 'Boys will be boys': why consumers don't punish big polluters for greenwashing lies[30]

Stakeholder reputations on the line

Key stakeholders are also exposed to any potential accusations of greenwashing. Christchurch City Council own 75% of the airport through a holding company, and the government owns 25%. Both have declared climate emergencies[31] and made emissions reduction commitments.

Industry groups are involved, too. Tourism Industry Aotearoa, which represents businesses across the tourism industry, last month announced Christchurch Airport the winner of its Tourism Environment Award[32].

It cited the airport’s “climate positive” status and hailed it as being “at the forefront of airport environmental initiatives globally”. Such claims can be technically true if one accepts the limited parameters used to measure them.

But the Tourism Industry Aotearoa will need to ensure its environmental awards keep pace with developments in this rapidly changing field – including the increasing risk of litigation over unsustainable claims about sustainability.

References

  1. ^ first fully electric aircraft (www.rnz.co.nz)
  2. ^ announced (www.christchurchairport.co.nz)
  3. ^ High-Level Expert Group (www.un.org)
  4. ^ science-based targets (sciencebasedtargets.org)
  5. ^ full value chain and activities (zerotracker.net)
  6. ^ cannot be counted (zerotracker.net)
  7. ^ troublesome at best (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ scam (www.stuff.co.nz)
  9. ^ targets for climate litigation (theconversation.com)
  10. ^ facing formal complaints (www.theguardian.com)
  11. ^ Airlines are being hit by anti-greenwashing litigation – here's what makes them perfect targets (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ have been banned (www.bbc.com)
  13. ^ class action lawsuit (www.bloomberg.com)
  14. ^ being sued (www.reuters.com)
  15. ^ misleading advertising (www.clientearth.org)
  16. ^ Flight NZ0 (www.airnewzealand.co.nz)
  17. ^ strategy and marketing (flightnz0.airnewzealand.co.nz)
  18. ^ Beta Alia (www.beta.team)
  19. ^ barriers (www.sciencedirect.com)
  20. ^ complex problems (royalsociety.org)
  21. ^ significantly increase (www.airnewzealandnewsroom.com)
  22. ^ setting its sights (www.stuff.co.nz)
  23. ^ sustainability report (p-airnz.com)
  24. ^ High Court decision on $125 million fine for Volkswagen is a warning to all greenwashers (theconversation.com)
  25. ^ global industry body (aci.aero)
  26. ^ Airport Carbon Accreditation (www.airportcarbonaccreditation.org)
  27. ^ Invercargill Airport (www.airportcarbonaccreditation.org)
  28. ^ announced (www.christchurchairport.co.nz)
  29. ^ total emissions (www.christchurchairport.co.nz)
  30. ^ 'Boys will be boys': why consumers don't punish big polluters for greenwashing lies (theconversation.com)
  31. ^ declared climate emergencies (newsline.ccc.govt.nz)
  32. ^ winner of its Tourism Environment Award (www.tia.org.nz)

Read more https://theconversation.com/the-nz-aviation-industry-is-making-bold-climate-claims-and-risking-anti-greenwashing-litigation-219591

The Times Features

Sunshine Coast Personal Injury Lawyers: Expert Guidance for Work Accident Claims

When accidents occur in the workplace, they can have profound and lasting effects on a worker's life, both physically and financially. In Queensland's Sunshine Coast, personal in...

iS Clinical's Skincare Secrets for Radiant Party Season Skin

As the festive season approaches, having runway-ready skin is easier than ever with iS Clinical's  top skincare prep tips. Whether you're walking the red carpet or simply stepp...

How to Camp Sustainably in Byron Bay: Eco-Friendly Tips

Camping in Byron Bay is a fantastic way to soak up nature, from beautiful beaches to lush rainforests. It’s no wonder Byron Bay camping is on so many bucket lists! But with more ...

Book a room in Broome as the northwest is best

Looking for a different kind of seaside escape? Done the east coast? Then book a room in Broome to discover why those in the know say the northwest is best, with Broome one of ...

Primary care involves more than GPs. A new review shows how patients can better access care

Australians today are more likely[1] than previous generations to live with complex and chronic diseases, such as diabetes, heart disease and depression. This means they’re mo...

Why Your Credit Score Matters More Than You Think in Australia

Your credit score isn't just a number, it's a reflection of your financial reputation. In Australia, a good credit score can unlock doors to better financial opportunities, while...

Enhance Your Home’s Comfort and Style with Blackout Curtains from 3Hlinen

Creating a comfortable and peaceful home environment often involves choosing the right window treatments. Among the various options available, blackout curtains stand out as a ve...

Is thirst a good predictor of dehydration?

Water is essential for daily functioning and health, and we can only survive a few days[1] without it. Yet we constantly lose water through sweat, urination and even evaporatio...

How doctors use light to diagnose disease

You’re not feeling well. You’ve had a pounding headache all week, dizzy spells and have vomited up your past few meals. You visit your GP to get some answers and sit while they ...

Times Magazine

Segway ZT3 Pro All-Terrain Electric Scooter

Segway-Ninebot, the global leader in the micromobility transportation solutions and robotic service industries is announcing its brand-new ZT series of electric scooters with the ZT3 Pro in Australia. The Segway ZT3 Pro combines cutting-edge smar...

Unveiling The Future: Dive Into The Latest Canon Models Online

Canon has remained at the forefront in the rapidly changing world of photography, continually setting new standards and transforming the sector. Canon constantly introduces innovative camera models that enthrall both professionals and enthusiasts...

The Top 5 Differences Between Wall Stickers And Wallpapers

Your living room wall is the first thing guests see when they visit your home. It should be welcoming, stylish, and above all, reflect your personality.  But with so many choices on the market, it can take time to decide how to achieve the perfect...

Vehicle Emissions Star Rating using public data to inform consumer purchasing decisions

Global open data company Link Digital has used open source technology to develop a new Vehicle Emissions  Star Rating (VESR) website for the New South Wales Government to help drivers consider the efficiency and  environmental impact of their nex...

In-Depth Guides to Mobility Scooters

Electric scooters play a very important role in the daily needs of many people. They are ideal for the elderly, injured, and disabled who want to regain their independence when it comes to going from one place to another. Learn about the history ...

Choosing the Right WordPress Hosting Provider in Australia

Introduction Australia’s thriving technological market has led to an increase in demand for trusted web hosting providers more than ever before, specifically for organizations and users who are utilizing WordPress to increase their online visibili...