The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

There are two sides to the 'no' campaign on the Voice. Who are they and why are they opposed to it?

  • Written by Bronwyn Carlson, Professor, Indigenous Studies and Director of The Centre for Global Indigenous Futures, Macquarie University

On October 14, the voting public will be asked to vote “yes” or “no” on a proposed First Nations Voice to Parliament.

While the “yes” campaign has largely coalesced behind a single message, the “no” campaign is not a singular cohort. There are two sides to the “no” camp and they are very different.

Here’s what they are arguing and the different approaches they’ve taken when it comes to style and tone.

Read more: For a lot of First Nations peoples, debates around the Voice to Parliament are not about a simple 'yes' or 'no'[1]

The conservative ‘no’ campaign

One side of the “no” campaign comes from the right of politics, including prominent members[2] of the Coalition. With the catch phrase, “If you don’t know, vote no[3]”, this camp hopes to impel voters who are unsure about what it all means to just vote no instead of finding the information required.

Also in this camp are a number of Australians who believe Indigenous people are beneficiaries of special privileges. Some claim the referendum is about introducing “racial privilege[4]” by establishing a system of government that gives Indigenous people influence over decisions made by the government.

“No” proponents have cited former Prime Minster Bob Hawke[5] to make their case that we should all just be considered Australian and Indigenous people should not have a moral or legal right of recognition or special land rights. Hawke said[6] in 1988:

In Australia, there is no hierarchy of descent […] there must be no privilege of origin. The commitment is all. The commitment to Australia is the one thing needful to be a true Australian.

One of the drivers behind this “no” campaign is Fair Australia, an arm of the lobbying group Advance Australia[7]. Advance counts former Prime Minister Tony Abbott as an advisory member and is backed by wealthy donors[8].

These groups are harnessing social media[9] to push their arguments, which mainly revolve around two themes[10]: “dividing” the nation, and the lack of detail masking a hidden agenda.

This side of the “no” camp has faced many accusations[11] of spreading misinformation[12].

Senior Indigenous politician Senator Jacinta Nampijinpa Price is the Liberal party’s spokesperson against the Voice and the main Indigenous voice in the conservative “no” camp. Liberal Party leader Peter Dutton recently appointed Price[13] as the new shadow minister for Indigenous Australians.

The Blak Sovereign ‘no’ campaign

The other side of the “no” campaign is completely different in that it professes to have the best interests of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people at its core.

This camp is often framed as the progressive side of the “no” campaign, with independent Senator Lidia Thorpe its most prominent voice[14]. Thorpe has referred to the Voice as a “powerless advisory body[15]” that will do little to change the life circumstances of most Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. Instead, Thorpe supports other measures such as truth-telling and treaty[16].

Thorpe has said the Voice is just an easy way to fake any real progress[17] for Indigenous people without any actual change.

She also points to the harm and divisiveness the Voice debate has caused, referring to it as a “destructive distraction[18]”. The Voice debates have resulted in a significant rise of racism and hate speech[19] targeting Indigenous people online.

While both sides are supporting a “no” vote, they are distinct in that one’s aim is for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people to have more rights of self-determination, while one advocates for the status quo.

Where does this leave Indigenous people?

Voice proponents believe it will bring the promise of a new and enlightened Australia. But in reality, the government will be able to disregard the advice it brings to the parliament.

Arrernte writer Celeste Liddle captures[20] how many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are feeling about the referendum:

I feel stuck with a choice between systems I do not trust and the fear of giving in to rabid racists.

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are tired[21] of dealing with the misinformation, lies, hatred and racism[22] the referendum debate is fuelling in society. I was asked by a non-Indigenous person if it is true Aboriginal people will get double Centrelink payments and be “given” land for free.

These falsehoods are repeatedly being spread because they hit at the heart of the racism we see in Australia – that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people will be entitled to something other Australians are not, and we are undeserving.

Many have questioned Australia’s ability[23] to engage in a debate over the Voice without descending into racist stereotypes and contempt for Indigenous people.

My own research has pointed to high levels of ongoing racism online[24] and in workplaces[25].

Australians need to be fully informed[26] and not swayed by misinformation fuelled by racism. We are told there is much at stake, but we do not yet know if the Voice will bring any substantial change for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. This campaign will, however, tell us who we are as a people, and what we value.

References

  1. ^ For a lot of First Nations peoples, debates around the Voice to Parliament are not about a simple 'yes' or 'no' (theconversation.com)
  2. ^ prominent members (www.abc.net.au)
  3. ^ If you don’t know, vote no (www.theguardian.com)
  4. ^ racial privilege (www.ruleoflaw.org.au)
  5. ^ “No” proponents have cited former Prime Minster Bob Hawke (www.dailymail.co.uk)
  6. ^ said (pmtranscripts.pmc.gov.au)
  7. ^ an arm of the lobbying group Advance Australia (www.abc.net.au)
  8. ^ backed by wealthy donors (www.abc.net.au)
  9. ^ harnessing social media (www.theguardian.com)
  10. ^ two themes (theconversation.com)
  11. ^ many accusations (www.abc.net.au)
  12. ^ spreading misinformation (theconversation.com)
  13. ^ appointed Price (www.skynews.com.au)
  14. ^ its most prominent voice (www.smh.com.au)
  15. ^ powerless advisory body (www.afr.com)
  16. ^ treaty (www.aljazeera.com)
  17. ^ easy way to fake any real progress (www.theguardian.com)
  18. ^ destructive distraction (www.sbs.com.au)
  19. ^ rise of racism and hate speech (theconversation.com)
  20. ^ captures (www.theguardian.com)
  21. ^ people are tired (www.theguardian.com)
  22. ^ misinformation, lies, hatred and racism (www.theguardian.com)
  23. ^ Australia’s ability (reporter.anu.edu.au)
  24. ^ racism online (theconversation.com)
  25. ^ workplaces (theconversation.com)
  26. ^ fully informed (humanrights.gov.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/there-are-two-sides-to-the-no-campaign-on-the-voice-who-are-they-and-why-are-they-opposed-to-it-212362

The Times Features

Amazon Australia and DoorDash announce two-year DashPass offer only for Prime members

New and existing Prime members in Australia can enjoy a two-year membership to DashPass for free, and gain access to AU$0 delivery fees on eligible DoorDash orders New offer co...

6 things to do if your child’s weight is beyond the ideal range – and 1 thing to avoid

One of the more significant challenges we face as parents is making sure our kids are growing at a healthy rate. To manage this, we take them for regular check-ups with our GP...

Joykids Australia Presents the Joykids Family Rave: A Weekend Adventure Like No Other

Get ready to kick off the first day of summer and the festive season with an unforgettable family adventure! Joykids Australia is excited to announce the Joykids Family Rave—an...

New study suggests weight loss drugs like Ozempic could help with knee pain. Here’s why there may be a link

The drug semaglutide, commonly known by the brand names Ozempic or Wegovy, was originally developed[1] to help people with type 2 diabetes manage their blood sugar levels. How...

Maintaining Your Pool After a Marble Interior Upgrade

After upgrading your pool with a marble interior, it’s crucial to understand that maintenance is key to preserving its elegance and longevity. You’ll want to regularly skim for d...

Labor using explanatory document to hide true powers of Misinformation Bill

The opinions and commentary of individuals could be deemed misinformation under Labor’s proposed legislation changes, according to James McComish of Victorian Bar. Appearing in...

Times Magazine

The benefits of multilingual data management (2023)

Organizations and businesses that produce a lot of data in different languages need to manage their data effectively for record purposes. Multilingual Data Management refers to the process of creating and storing data in different languages. Bel...

6 Reasons Why Perfume Gift Sets Make an Ideal Present

Perfume gift sets are the perfect way to show someone you care. Whether you're looking for a special treat for a loved one or want to give yourself a luxurious gift, perfume gift sets are a great choice. They come with a variety of different scents...

Your Own Batmobile in the City: Is it Possible?

What do bats and submarines have in common? The smart answer is that they both use sound to get to where they are going. It is more interesting, however, to note why. Bats and submarines both have to deal with dark surroundings with limited visio...

The perfect picture: what makes dream Sydney wedding photography?

The photo album is, without a shadow of a doubt, the most important memento from any loving couple’s special day! It’s the keepsake that keeps on giving, the souvenir to saviour, and the perfect reminder of what was one of the biggest - and most jo...

The Top 5 Differences Between Wall Stickers And Wallpapers

Your living room wall is the first thing guests see when they visit your home. It should be welcoming, stylish, and above all, reflect your personality.  But with so many choices on the market, it can take time to decide how to achieve the perfect...

Best Practices for Creating a High-Performance SaaS Product

Achieving high performance in designing a Software as a Service (SaaS) product must be done strategically by putting user experience, scalability, consistency, and data-driven decision-making at the forefront. In today's competitive world, where us...