The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Beatbot

.

NZ biggest firms will soon have to disclose their climate risk – but will it really curb climate change?

  • Written by Ilan Noy, Chair in the Economics of Disasters and Climate Change, Te Herenga Waka — Victoria University of Wellington
NZ biggest firms will soon have to disclose their climate risk – but will it really curb climate change?

Climate change has many catastrophic consequences[1], including droughts, floods[2], wildfires, heat waves, rising sea levels[3] and biodiversity loss[4]. These all have adverse implications for social cohesion, economic development and financial stability.

Regrettably, the goals of advancing a better environment and a flourishing economy don’t always line up. Driving greater awareness of climate-related risks among large firms and powerful financial institutions is therefore of paramount importance and urgency.

Read more: Green investing: the global system for rating companies' ethical credentials is meaningless[5]

Responding to this challenge, economists, environmentalists, activists and politicians have sought ways to ensure financial decisions factor in climate change[6]. To that end, policymakers are now considering the introduction of mandatory climate-related disclosures for firms and financial institutions.

In essence, the idea is to employ disclosures to force large financial actors to consider their impact on climate change, and the impact of climate change on them.

For example, consider the potential exposure of a bank to climate risks. Home loans may not be recoverable if houses become uninhabitable because of rising seas. Other homes may become uninsurable because of increasing flood risks.

Likewise, agricultural loans may become riskier because of the increasing intensity of droughts. All of these risks are important not only to the bank’s profitability but also to the homeowners, farmers and manufacturers who borrowed money from that bank.

Who should disclosures target?

New Zealand’s recently published draft General Requirements for Climate-related Disclosures[7] defines climate-related disclosures as:

disclosures about climate-related risks and opportunities that are useful to primary users when they assess, and make decisions about, an entity’s enterprise value, including information about its governance, strategy and risk management, and metrics and targets.

Read more: Business can no longer ignore extreme heat events – it’s becoming a danger to the bottom line[8]

The rationale behind the proposed framework is that consistent, comparable and understandable disclosures will encourage better climate-related decision-making and risk management. In turn, this will encourage firms to adopt more climate-resilient strategies, smoothing the transition to a net-zero economy.

The disclosures themselves seek to inform “primary users” – defined as “existing and potential investors, lenders and other creditors” – how companies respond to and consider[9] the impacts of climate change. Armed with this knowledge, primary users are then presumed to be able “to assess the merits of how entities are considering climate-related risks and opportunities”.

But the proposed framework regards only investors, lenders and other creditors as primary users. The definition does not include employees, customers or the public. This narrow definition represents a missed opportunity.

Stakeholders versus shareholders

Focusing on a relatively narrow range of primary users undermines the potential for disclosures to bring about change. Including employees, customers and the public would make the disclosures more powerful. By increasing their impact and relevance, the disclosures would better serve their goals.

This touches on the modern concept of stakeholders and “stakeholder capitalism” rather than only shareholders. Shareholders will mostly (or only) care about one limited dimension of the firm’s impact: profits. If they own only a small share of the entity through the stock market or their superannuation or pension fund, shareholders may not even pay much attention to what the firm does.

Stakeholders, however, include the firm’s employees, customers and everyone directly affected by its activities. Unlike shareholders, stakeholders often have a long-term perspective and a more immediate and direct interest in what the entity does.

The public interest

Stakeholders will therefore typically look beyond the firm’s profits to consider the broader social and community interests at stake. Stakeholders will desire, or indeed demand, more sustainable strategies that benefit a larger set of groups (rather than just the shareholders).

Interestingly, the European Union adopted a similarly broad perspective in its “guidelines on reporting climate-related information[10]” in 2019. These require firms to adopt a “double materiality” standard: looking at what is material for both shareholders (the financial audience) and stakeholders (the environmental and social audiences).

Read more: SEC proposes far-reaching climate disclosure rules for companies – here’s where the rules may be vulnerable to legal challenges[11]

Considering the public’s interest in financial disclosures about climate change also aligns with other recent regulatory efforts, such as the Plain Language Bill[12] currently before parliament. This signals that citizens have a democratic right to receive comprehensible information from government organisations.

While the bill focuses on public service and Crown agencies, it illustrates the need to put citizens at the centre of laws and communicate with them effectively.

Read more: The end of jargon: will New Zealand's plain language law finally make bureaucrats talk like normal people?[13]

Disclosure for all

The New Zealand External Reporting Board, which is responsible for the proposed disclosure framework, has invited responses and is now considering the submissions.

This final review and consultation[14] stage provides a valuable opportunity to reconsider the definition of primary users.

While New Zealand is a world leader in advancing these measures, just how effective and useful they will be remains to be seen. A revised definition that will encompass all stakeholders – including customers, employees and the public at large – will increase the disclosures’ efficacy.

In New Zealand and elsewhere, governments should adopt as wide a target audience as is feasible for climate-related disclosures. Otherwise, we risk undermining the promise of disclosures to mitigate climate change and contribute to a more climate-resilient future economy.

References

  1. ^ many catastrophic consequences (www.ipcc.ch)
  2. ^ floods (www.nytimes.com)
  3. ^ rising sea levels (www.climate.gov)
  4. ^ biodiversity loss (www.gov.uk)
  5. ^ Green investing: the global system for rating companies' ethical credentials is meaningless (theconversation.com)
  6. ^ factor in climate change (www.ft.com)
  7. ^ General Requirements for Climate-related Disclosures (www.xrb.govt.nz)
  8. ^ Business can no longer ignore extreme heat events – it’s becoming a danger to the bottom line (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ respond to and consider (www.fsb-tcfd.org)
  10. ^ guidelines on reporting climate-related information (ec.europa.eu)
  11. ^ SEC proposes far-reaching climate disclosure rules for companies – here’s where the rules may be vulnerable to legal challenges (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ Plain Language Bill (www.parliament.nz)
  13. ^ The end of jargon: will New Zealand's plain language law finally make bureaucrats talk like normal people? (theconversation.com)
  14. ^ final review and consultation (www.xrb.govt.nz)

Read more https://theconversation.com/nz-biggest-firms-will-soon-have-to-disclose-their-climate-risk-but-will-it-really-curb-climate-change-191490

The Times Features

How can brands recognise the very important role that visual content plays in the real world?

For nearly three decades, Getty Images and iStock have developed unparalleled expertise in understanding the impact of visual content on our world. During this time, one truth ...

Long COVID appears to be driven by ‘long infection’. Here’s what the science says

Around 5–10%[1] of people with COVID infections go on to experience long COVID, with symptoms lasting three months or more. Researchers have proposed several biological mechan...

Evaluating Costs and Benefits of DIY Plumbing vs. Professional Services in Newcastle

Plumbing is an essential service for homes and businesses in Newcastle, ensuring the smooth flow of water and sanitation facilities. As residents and businesses strive to maintai...

Tasting Australia welcomes Journey Beyond as new presenting partner

One of the country’s longest running food and beverage festivals, Tasting Australia has announced Journey Beyond as the festival’s new presenting partner for 2025 and beyond. Th...

There are 2 main ways to stretch – the one you should choose depends on what you want your body to do

Picture this: you’ve just woken up and rolled out of bed. Your feet hit the floor, and your legs buckle. They are in absolute agony – that run yesterday has really come back to...

Chef Tom Walton shares three top tips to create budget-friendly meals without compromising on flavour

Feeding the family on a budget doesn’t need to mean sacrificing flavour. Chef Tom Walton shares his top three tips for creating delicious and cost-effective meals. Here’s how y...

Times Magazine

Online Shopping Experience at Ryft Australia

Welcome to Ryft Australia's online shop! Ryft is a leading Australian retailer offering unbeatable value on the highest quality products. We specialize in providing customers with an extensive range of products for their home and lifestyle needs. O...

Employment support for people with disability

If you’re a job seeker in Australia and you’re currently living with a disability, there will be some hurdles to overcome and added challenges you will have to face in your efforts to find and keep a job. The positive news is that you don’t have ...

"From Concrete to Carpets: Surfaces that Ride-On Sweepers Can Clean"

In the drive towards clean and hygienic environments, ride-on sweepers form part of the critical roles. From solid concrete floors to sophisticated carpets, these versatile machines navigate a variety of surfaces with precision. This article delves...

Latidreams Review: Where Dreams of Love Become Reality

In a digital age where love is but a swipe away, Latidreams.com emerges as a beacon for those yearning for a deeper connection. It's not just another dating site; it's a romantic odyssey waiting to unfold. With a suite of innovative features like L...

Dog Breeder Charged with Inhumane Puppy Farming

Breeders of all kinds of puppies are very common nowadays with more people looking to care for their new little furry pals at home. But if you’re looking to get your first dog or are just looking to add another pup to the pack, you’ll want to make su...

Russia Banned from the Olympics: What Can We Expect?

With Russia being already forced to compete under the name ROC, it is now questionable if there’ll be further sanctions for Russian athletes? Russian Athletes to Face Bans and Championship Disqualifications Is Russia technically banned from com...