The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

The next Pandora Papers exposé is inevitable – unless governments do more on two key reforms

  • Written by Roman Lanis, Associate Professor, Accounting, University of Technology Sydney
The next Pandora Papers exposé is inevitable – unless governments do more on two key reforms

The International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ[1]) is in the process of working through another mountain of documents showing how the rich and powerful use the global financial system to hide their wealth and avoid taxes.

Those 11.9 million records, dubbed the Pandora Papers[2], follows similar leaks in 2017 (the Paradise Papers[3]), in 2016 (the Panama Papers[4]) and in 2014 (the Luxembourg Leaks[5], or LuxLeaks).

Commenting on the 13 million financial and tax documents comprising the Paradise Papers in 2017, we wrote that[6] “governments have not learnt their lesson and taken action”.

Four years later here we are again. Some progress has been made on the critical reforms needed – in particular, eliminating the secrecy that shrouds tax havens – but there’s still more to do.

Systemic issues

In sorting through these new documents, journalists have quite reasonably tended to focus on the “easy connections” and “known individuals”. This work has identified at least 956 companies with more than 336 beneficiaries who are “high-level politicians and public officials”.

This includes Vladimir Putin’s mistress allegedly having assets worth US$100 million, Jordan’s King Abdullah II using offshore companies to buy three Malibu mansions[7] for US$70 million, and the 11-year-old son of Azerbaijani president Ilham Aliyev owning nine waterfront mansions[8] in Dubai worth US$44 million.

Also on the list of 35 current and former national leaders, including Czech prime minister Andrej Babiš, Kenyan president Uhuru Kenyatta, Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky and former British prime minister Tony Blair.

But as juicy as these stories are, we should not be distracted from the systemic issues that lead to the wealthy using offshore legal entities and accounts. It’s not always nefarious or illicit.

Read more: Pandora papers: 'it's time to pursue lawyers and accountants who enable tax evasion' – offshore tax expert Q&A[9]

Protecting assets

In the Pandora Papers are arrangements that, with incomplete information, may appear suspect but may be quite legitimate.

An example might be the 81 trust structures established in the US state of South Dakota and at least 100 more in various other US states where trust disclosures, especially about beneficial ownership, are not mandatory. To properly assess these transactions we really need more information.

Read more: What's in the Pandora Papers? And why does South Dakota feature so heavily?[10]

The use of complex business structures, involving countries with high levels of secrecy, may be done to facilitate tax avoidance. But it might also be “asset protection”.

Weak property rights

In countries with weak property rights and unreliable judicial systems, even those who accrue wealth legitimately can fear losing it.

Consider, for example, the case of China’s billionaire actress and singer Zhao Wei, who in August was “erased from history[11]”, or Jack Ma[12], China’s richest man until he criticised financial regulators[13] last year.

This creates a demand for assets held in other countries (preferably secretly) and a legal system that protects ownership of those assets. It also likely explains why 3.3 million of the 6.9 million documents in this latest leak relate to offices located in Hong Kong.

An analysis of these documents recognising the relative strength of property rights in the countries where individuals, or their businesses, are based would be interesting — and not just as an “academic” exercise.

In many countries, particularly developing countries, weak property rights contribute to lack of capital for economic development by creating incentives for the legitimately wealthy to use offshore accounts and assets.

This suggests a critical need to enhance property rights in these countries.

Weak legal systems also facilitate wealth accumulation through corruption or exploitation.

Unfinished business

Five years ago when discussing the revelations from the Panama Papers, we suggested the first thing the global community needed to do was require the public disclosure of country-by-country reporting of company tax affairs by all tax authorities. This idea (known as CbCR) emerged from OECD and G20 recommendations made about the time of the Luxembourg Leaks in 2014.

Read more: Three strategies to fight the tax avoidance revealed by the Paradise Papers[14]

About 100 countries have adopted the CbCR policy, at least in part. The problem is that in too many cases – such as Australia and the US – the disclosures are only to the tax authority, not to the public.

In 2017 we also recommended all countries have public registers of beneficial ownership of all entities.

There has also been some progress on this. Significant pressure has been applied to tax havens or secrecy jurisdictions such as the Bahamas and Switzerland. But more is needed.

In Australia, for example, the Paradise Papers led to the government floating the idea of a public register of beneficial ownership, but this was shut down soon after. In the US, states such Delaware and South Dakota are still “secrecy jurisdictions”.

Some progress has been made in making tax havens and secrecy jurisdictions more transparent. But many would say the progress has been mainly benefited wealthy countries, helping them increase tax revenue and to be seen to be doing something to fight corruption, while still allowing corruption to flourish in poorer nations.

Until countries such as the US and Australia embrace the reforms that have been on the table since LuxLeaks, expect further document leaks with similar results in the next five years.

Read more https://theconversation.com/the-next-pandora-papers-expose-is-inevitable-unless-governments-do-more-on-two-key-reforms-169357

The Times Features

Air is an overlooked source of nutrients – evidence shows we can inhale some vitamins

You know that feeling you get when you take a breath of fresh air in nature? There may be more to it than a simple lack of pollution. When we think of nutrients, we think of t...

FedEx Australia Announces Christmas Shipping Cut-Off Dates To Help Beat the Holiday Rush

With Christmas just around the corner, FedEx is advising Australian shoppers to get their presents sorted early to ensure they arrive on time for the big day. FedEx has reveale...

Will the Wage Price Index growth ease financial pressure for households?

The Wage Price Index’s quarterly increase of 0.8% has been met with mixed reactions. While Australian wages continue to increase, it was the smallest increase in two and a half...

Back-to-School Worries? 70% of Parents Fear Their Kids Aren’t Ready for Day On

Australian parents find themselves confronting a key decision: should they hold back their child on the age border for another year before starting school? Recent research from...

Democratising Property Investment: How MezFi is Opening Doors for Everyday Retail Investors

The launch of MezFi today [Friday 15th November] marks a watershed moment in Australian investment history – not just because we're introducing something entirely new, but becaus...

Game of Influence: How Cricket is Losing Its Global Credibility

be losing its credibility on the global stage. As other sports continue to capture global audiences and inspire unity, cricket finds itself increasingly embroiled in political ...

Times Magazine

Insider Tips to Improve Your Dota 2 Matches

Dota 2 matches are the ultimate test of skill and strategy. Two teams of five battle it out on a virtual battlefield, with each player controlling a powerful hero with unique abilities. The objective of the game is to defeat the opposing team by de...

The Future of Smartphones: Embracing Sustainability with Refurbished iPhones

Are you ready to revolutionize the way we use smartphones? In a world driven by technology, it's time for us to shift our focus towards sustainability. Say hello to refurbished iPhones - the game-changer that combines cutting-edge features with e...

SEN and MyRacehorse give punters the chance to win a share in exciting Freedman trained Colt

SPORTS Entertainment Network (SEN) has partnered with MyRacehorse to offer its audience the chance to experience the thrills and excitement of racehorse ownership, all by simply using the Same Racer app.With the Spring Racing Carnival around the co...

Business email compromise attacks are on the rise

Expert shares 5 simple steps to combat email threats every business should consider following There’s an astounding 84% increase in business email compromise attacks, according to the latest Email Threat Report, which compares half-yearly statis...

Rental Car Accidents: Key Steps to Take Right After a Crash

Rental Car Accidents: Key Steps to Take Right After a Crash The Immediate Aftermath of a Rental Car Accident When the unexpected happens, and you're involved in a rental car accident, the moments immediately following the crash are crucial. S...

Breaking the Stigma: Fostering Mental Health Awareness in the Workplace

In the evolving landscape of modern workplaces, the conversation around mental health is no longer relegated to the sidelines. As awareness grows, organizations are recognizing the profound impact that mental health has on their employees and, cons...