The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

Is Salman Rushdie's decision to publish on Substack the death of the novel?

  • Written by Julian Novitz, Lecturer, Writing, School of Media and Communication, Swinburne University of Technology

Email newsletters might be associated with the ghost towns of old personal email addresses for many: relentlessly accumulating unopened updates from organisations, stores and services signed up to and forgotten in the distant past. But over the last few years they have experienced a revival, with an increasing number of writers supplementing their income with paid newsletter subscriptions.

Most recently, Salman Rushdie’s decision[1] to use the newsletter subscription service Substack[2] to circulate his latest book has sparked conversation around this platform and its impact on the world of publishing.

What is Substack?

Launched in 2017[3], Substack allows writers to create newsletters and set up paid subscription tiers for them, offering readers a mixture of free and paywalled content in each edition.

Substack has thus encroached on the traditional territories of newspapers, magazines, the blogosphere – and now trade publishing. Though it is worth noting that until now it has been most enthusiastically adopted by journalists rather than authors.

Rather than monetising the service via advertising, Substack’s profits come from a percentage of paid subscriptions. Substack’s founders see the platform as a way of breaking from the ‘attention economy’[4] promoted by social media, allowing a space for more thoughtful and substantial writing that is funded directly by readers.

Read more: Substack isn't a new model for journalism – it’s a very old one[5]

Not a radical disruption

Rushdie’s decision to publish via Substack signals a surprising inroad into one of the areas associated with trade publishing – literary fiction – and certainly makes for a good news story. He is the first significant literary novelist to publish a substantial work of fiction via the platform and Rushdie himself talks jokingly about helping to kill off the print book with this move.

However, the novella that Rushdie is intending to serialise will almost certainly be available in a more conventional format at some point in the future, given all Substack writers retain full rights to their intellectual property.

Other experiments with digital self-publication by prominent fiction authors, such as Stephen King’s novella Riding the Bullet (first published independently as an eBook), and the fiction first generated on Twitter by writers like David Mitchell and Neil Gaiman, have made their way to traditional publishers.

Is Salman Rushdie's decision to publish on Substack the death of the novel? Neil Gaiman has also experimented with digitally distributed fiction. shutterstock

While this movement provides excellent publicity for Rushdie and the Substack service, it’s perhaps better understood as a limited term platform exclusivity deal than as a radical disruption of the literary publishing ecosystem.

Potentially more interesting is what the “acquisition” of Rushdie by Substack illustrates about their operation as a digital service. Throughout its history, Substack has offered advances to promising writers to support them while they cultivate a subscriber base.

This practice has now been formalised as Substack Pro[6], where selected writers, like Rushdie himself, are paid a substantial upfront fee to produce content, which Substack recoups by taking a higher percentage of their subscription fees for their first year of writing.

The exact sums paid vary between writers, but it is not dissimilar to a traditional advance on royalties. When coupled with some of the other services[7] that are available to writers with paid subscriptions – like a legal fund and financial support for the editing, design, and production of newsletters – Substack can be seen as operating in a grey area between publisher and platform.

They pursue promising and high-profile writers, generate income, and provide services in ways that parallel the operations of trade publishers, but do not claim rights or responsibilities in relation to the content that is produced.

Although Substack do not see themselves as commissioning writers it could be argued they do play an editorial role in curating content on their platform through not terribly transparent[8] Substack Pro deals and incentives.

The evolution of Substack

Recently Jude Doyle, a trans critic and novelist, has abandoned the platform. They note the irony of how profits generated by the often marginalised or subcultural writers who built paid subscriber bases in the early days of Substack are now being used to fund the much more lucrative deals offered to high-profile right-wing writers, who have in some cases exploited Substack’s weak moderation policy to spread anti-trans rhetoric and encourage harassment[9].

It could be argued Substack Pro is evolving into an inversion of the traditional (if somewhat idealised) publishing model, where a small number of profitable authors would subsidise the emergence of new writers. Instead, on Substack, profits generated from the work of large numbers of side-hustling writers are used to draw more established voices to the platform.

The founders of Substack have been unapologetic about their policies[10], considering the “unsubscribe” button to be the ultimate moderation tool for their users. They do, however, acknowledge Substack’s free-market approach may not appeal to all and anticipate competition from alternatives.

Ghost[11] already exists as a non-profit newsletter platform with a more active approach to moderation, and Facebook’s Bulletin[12] provides a carefully curated newsletter service from commissioned writers.

At this stage, the use of newsletters for literary fiction is an experiment, and it remains to be seen if it will be sustainable. As Rushdie puts it[13]: “It will either turn out to be something wonderful and enjoyable, or it won’t.”

References

  1. ^ Salman Rushdie’s decision (www.theguardian.com)
  2. ^ Substack (substack.com)
  3. ^ Launched in 2017 (www.newyorker.com)
  4. ^ breaking from the ‘attention economy’ (on.substack.com)
  5. ^ Substack isn't a new model for journalism – it’s a very old one (theconversation.com)
  6. ^ Substack Pro (on.substack.com)
  7. ^ other services (www.cjr.org)
  8. ^ terribly transparent (thehypothesis.substack.com)
  9. ^ spread anti-trans rhetoric and encourage harassment (doyles.substack.com)
  10. ^ unapologetic about their policies (on.substack.com)
  11. ^ Ghost (ghost.org)
  12. ^ Bulletin (techcrunch.com)
  13. ^ Rushdie puts it (www.theguardian.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/is-salman-rushdies-decision-to-publish-on-substack-the-death-of-the-novel-167530

The Times Features

FedEx Australia Announces Christmas Shipping Cut-Off Dates To Help Beat the Holiday Rush

With Christmas just around the corner, FedEx is advising Australian shoppers to get their presents sorted early to ensure they arrive on time for the big day. FedEx has reveale...

Will the Wage Price Index growth ease financial pressure for households?

The Wage Price Index’s quarterly increase of 0.8% has been met with mixed reactions. While Australian wages continue to increase, it was the smallest increase in two and a half...

Back-to-School Worries? 70% of Parents Fear Their Kids Aren’t Ready for Day On

Australian parents find themselves confronting a key decision: should they hold back their child on the age border for another year before starting school? Recent research from...

Democratising Property Investment: How MezFi is Opening Doors for Everyday Retail Investors

The launch of MezFi today [Friday 15th November] marks a watershed moment in Australian investment history – not just because we're introducing something entirely new, but becaus...

Game of Influence: How Cricket is Losing Its Global Credibility

be losing its credibility on the global stage. As other sports continue to capture global audiences and inspire unity, cricket finds itself increasingly embroiled in political ...

Amazon Australia and DoorDash announce two-year DashPass offer only for Prime members

New and existing Prime members in Australia can enjoy a two-year membership to DashPass for free, and gain access to AU$0 delivery fees on eligible DoorDash orders New offer co...

Times Magazine

How To Customise Your Website with HubSpot CMS: A Step-by-Step Guide

In the fast-paced digital landscape, owning a mere business website is not just enough. Your website is the first impression for your potential customer. It must be user friendly and well-designed, the content on the website needs to be appealing, ...

The nitty gritty: 7 cell phone booster for rural area FAQs answered

Cell phone signal boosters have long been a lifesaver for people living in rural Australia. Think about it: our wide, sunburned land is famous (or infamous) for its isolated stretches, the kind in which you might not see a single soul for days. ...

Life-Saving Hacks for Working Moms

Being a mom is hard work – it’s the most amazing job you’ve ever had, but also the most exhausting. It’s deeply rewarding as well, but there are days when you’re simply running on a very low battery. As a working mom with not much spare time, you c...

Your Own Batmobile in the City: Is it Possible?

What do bats and submarines have in common? The smart answer is that they both use sound to get to where they are going. It is more interesting, however, to note why. Bats and submarines both have to deal with dark surroundings with limited visio...

The Future of Smartphones: Embracing Sustainability with Refurbished iPhones

Are you ready to revolutionize the way we use smartphones? In a world driven by technology, it's time for us to shift our focus towards sustainability. Say hello to refurbished iPhones - the game-changer that combines cutting-edge features with e...

Protecting Stray Cats in Your Community

Stray cats are a common sight in many neighbourhoods in Melbourne and all around Australia. These feline wanderers, often abandoned or born on the streets, struggle to survive in the harsh urban environment. Many of them face dangers such as traf...