The Times Australia
The Times News

.

The true cost of the government's changes to JobSeeker is incalculable. It's as if it didn't learn from Robodebt

  • Written by Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University

Poor people are different to rich people, and not only in the amount of money they’ve got. They are also different in something that flows from it.

It’s (lack of) ease. And the consequences can be severe.

Economist Sendhil Mullainathan and psychologist Eldar Shafir outline these in their book Scarcity: Why Having So Little Means So Much[1].

They asked shoppers at a New Jersey mall to take part in a so-called fluid intelligence[2] test. Fluid intelligence is problem-solving ability unrelated to language or knowledge.

The test is usually presented as a series of eight images, each different from the one before, followed by an invitation to guess the ninth.

What’s in the missing box?

The true cost of the government's changes to JobSeeker is incalculable. It's as if it didn't learn from Robodebt Raven’s Progressive Matrices test. LifeofRiley/Wikipedia. CC BY-SA 3.0[3]

It’s usually pretty easy. And it was indeed easy for the first half of the shoppers they tested. Comparing the scores against self-reported income, the researchers found no significant differences – “the rich and poor looked equally smart[4]”.

Just before they presented the first half of shoppers with the test, they also presented a hypothetical scenario:

Imagine that your car has some trouble, which requires a $300 service. Your auto insurance will cover half the cost. You need to decide whether to go ahead and get the car fixed, or take a chance and hope that it lasts for a while longer. How would you go about making such a decision?

For the second half of shoppers they presented the same scenario with just one change. Instead of the car service costing $300, it cost $3,000[5].

The one simple change had a remarkable effect on the test results of just one group of shoppers – those on low incomes. Although completely fictional, the scenario got them thinking about how they couldn’t afford a $3,000 bill from out of the blue. They mightn’t know where to find the money.

Read more: What happens when you free unemployed Australians from 'mutual obligations' and boost their benefits? We just found out[6]

Instead of performing as well as the high earners (which low earners had done without the $3,000 prompt) they did dramatically worse. Their mental impairment was as bad as if they had lost an entire night’s sleep[7].

Stress is costly when ends can’t meet

The researchers have replicated the results time and time again. Even when they pay for correct answers (which might be expected to incentivise low earners more than high earners) low earners can’t concentrate enough to do well.

The authors’ conclusion is that it is incumbent on authorities not to send such people over the edge – not to make them fill in multi-page forms or reapply for assistance or attend recurring pointless meetings, and not to send them unexplained unpayable bills out of the blue – not to do anything that will remind them of how their finances don’t really allow them to cope.

Read more: The bad bits of ParentsNext just came back[8]

When that happens, when what Mullainathan and Shafir call mental bandwidth[9] is flooded, it is hard to think properly about things such as caring for children and getting work.

Australia’s treasury gets it. Its well-being framework[10] sets out five points it believes should be considered in designing programs and policies. Point five is the cost to individuals of “dealing with unwanted complexity[11]”.

Not so treasury’s political masters. When on Thursday the government boosts JobSeeker by a meagre $25[12] a week, it will cut the amount job seekers actually receive by a net $50 per week because of the end of the coronavirus supplement[13].

Mutual obligations impose stress

To offset that generosity – the first real increase in the base rate in 30 years – from April 1 it will ramp up its “mutual obligation” requirements. Job seekers will have to show they have applied for 15 jobs a month, climbing to 20 jobs[14] a month on July 1 – that’s a fresh application every working day.

Failures will attract demerit points[15]. Too many demerits and payments will be stopped.

There will be increased auditing[16] of job applications to ensure they are “genuine”, a return to the compulsory face-to-face meetings suspended during the pandemic, and a dob-in line[17] for employers to report job seekers they think aren’t genuine.

The true cost of the government's changes to JobSeeker is incalculable. It's as if it didn't learn from Robodebt The Productivity Commission drew attention to the link between mutual obligation requirements and mental health in its unresponded-to report.[18] That this will dangerously ramp up stress on the people most susceptible to it, and make it hard for them to do things such as care for their children, ought not to surprise the government. It has been considering the three-volume report of its Productivity Commission inquiry into mental health for nine months[19]. The report says stringent mutual obligation requirements might do more than stress those who take part — they might precipitate “clinically defined mental illness in previously well[20] participants”. For people with preexisting problems, “sound reasons and plausible evidence suggest this could aggravate their illness”. The government ought to have learnt from repeated mistakes. A Senate inquiry found the compliance measures associated with its ParentsNext[21] program caused “anxiety, distress and harm”. Post-pandemic, it reinstated[22] those compliance measures. Robodebt should have been a wakeup call Its unsolicited “robodebt[23]” demands for repayments of thousands of dollars[24] per recipient the Federal Court found was not owed[25] caused what another Senate inquiry[26] found to be “breakdown, anxiety, depression requiring medication, sleeplessness, stress causing physical illness, and fear”. The ministers who announced the program in 2016 were Scott Morrison (then treasurer) and Christian Porter (then social services minister). Read more: Robodebt was a fiasco with a cost we have yet to fully appreciate[27] They promised that smarter use of technology[28] would “better manage our social welfare system to ensure that every dollar goes to those who need it most” and predicted it would save the budget $2 billion. The kindest thing that can be said about what happened is that they didn’t follow through with the details, at considerable human cost[29]. It would be great to see something – anything – that made it look as if, five years on, they have learned from what happened.

References

  1. ^ Scarcity: Why Having So Little Means So Much (www.penguin.co.uk)
  2. ^ fluid intelligence (www.verywellmind.com)
  3. ^ LifeofRiley/Wikipedia. CC BY-SA 3.0 (en.wikipedia.org)
  4. ^ the rich and poor looked equally smart (archive.org)
  5. ^ $3,000 (archive.org)
  6. ^ What happens when you free unemployed Australians from 'mutual obligations' and boost their benefits? We just found out (theconversation.com)
  7. ^ entire night’s sleep (archive.org)
  8. ^ The bad bits of ParentsNext just came back (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ mental bandwidth (richmedia.lse.ac.uk)
  10. ^ well-being framework (treasury.gov.au)
  11. ^ dealing with unwanted complexity (treasury.gov.au)
  12. ^ $25 (theconversation.com)
  13. ^ coronavirus supplement (www.servicesaustralia.gov.au)
  14. ^ 20 jobs (www.pm.gov.au)
  15. ^ demerit points (www.servicesaustralia.gov.au)
  16. ^ increased auditing (ministers.dese.gov.au)
  17. ^ dob-in line (ministers.dese.gov.au)
  18. ^ The Productivity Commission drew attention to the link between mutual obligation requirements and mental health in its unresponded-to report. (www.pc.gov.au)
  19. ^ nine months (www.pc.gov.au)
  20. ^ previously well (www.pc.gov.au)
  21. ^ ParentsNext (www.aph.gov.au)
  22. ^ reinstated (theconversation.com)
  23. ^ robodebt (theconversation.com)
  24. ^ thousands of dollars (www.notmydebt.com.au)
  25. ^ was not owed (www.comcourts.gov.au)
  26. ^ inquiry (www.aph.gov.au)
  27. ^ Robodebt was a fiasco with a cost we have yet to fully appreciate (theconversation.com)
  28. ^ smarter use of technology (webarchive.nla.gov.au)
  29. ^ considerable human cost (www.aph.gov.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/the-true-cost-of-the-governments-changes-to-jobseeker-is-incalculable-its-as-if-it-didnt-learn-from-robodebt-158059

Times Magazine

Understanding ITIL 4 and PRINCE2 Project Management Synergy

Key Highlights ITIL 4 focuses on IT service management, emphasising continual improvement and value creation through modern digital transformation approaches. PRINCE2 project management supports systematic planning and execution of projects wit...

What AI Adoption Means for the Future of Workplace Risk Management

Image by freepik As industrial operations become more complex and fast-paced, the risks faced by workers and employers alike continue to grow. Traditional safety models—reliant on manual oversight, reactive investigations, and standardised checklist...

From Beach Bops to Alpine Anthems: Your Sonos Survival Guide for a Long Weekend Escape

Alright, fellow adventurers and relaxation enthusiasts! So, you've packed your bags, charged your devices, and mentally prepared for that glorious King's Birthday long weekend. But hold on, are you really ready? Because a true long weekend warrior kn...

Effective Commercial Pest Control Solutions for a Safer Workplace

Keeping a workplace clean, safe, and free from pests is essential for maintaining productivity, protecting employee health, and upholding a company's reputation. Pests pose health risks, can cause structural damage, and can lead to serious legal an...

The Science Behind Reverse Osmosis and Why It Matters

What is reverse osmosis? Reverse osmosis (RO) is a water purification process that removes contaminants by forcing water through a semi-permeable membrane. This membrane allows only water molecules to pass through while blocking impurities such as...

Foodbank Queensland celebrates local hero for National Volunteer Week

Stephen Carey is a bit bananas.   He splits his time between his insurance broker business, caring for his young family, and volunteering for Foodbank Queensland one day a week. He’s even run the Bridge to Brisbane in a banana suit to raise mon...

The Times Features

Metal Roof Replacement Cost Per Square Metre in 2025: A Comprehensive Guide for Australian Homeowners

In recent years, the trend of installing metal roofs has surged across Australia. With their reputation for being both robust and visually appealing, it's easy to understand thei...

Why You’re Always Adjusting Your Bra — and What to Do Instead

Image by freepik It starts with a gentle tug, then a subtle shift, and before you know it, you're adjusting your bra again — in the middle of work, at dinner, even on the couch. I...

How to Tell If Your Eyes Are Working Harder Than They Should Be

Image by freepik Most of us take our vision for granted—until it starts to let us down. Whether it's squinting at your phone, rubbing your eyes at the end of the day, or feeling ...

Ways to Attract Tenants in a Competitive Rental Market

In the kind of rental market we’ve got now, standing out is half the battle. The other half? Actually getting someone to sign that lease. With interest rates doing backflips and ...

Top Tips for Finding the Ideal Block to Build Your Home

There’s something deeply personal and exciting about building your own home. You’re not just choosing paint colours or furniture, you’re creating a space that reflects your lifes...

The Home Buying Process Explained Step by Step

Buying a home is a thrilling milestone, but it can also feel like navigating a maze without a map. With paperwork, finances, and decisions at every turn, understanding the home-b...