The Times Australia
The Times News

.

Why is the government trying to make the cashless debit card permanent? Research shows it does not work

  • Written by The Conversation

Dystopic policy in Australia is often hidden in plain sight.

As Curtin University Professor Suvendrini Perera has written[1], systematic failures are not necessarily “spectacular acts” but the “decisions and indecisions of bureaucratic oversights and misplaced assumptions”. And these amount to a “slow violence” over time.

Read more: Australia has been stigmatising unemployed people for almost 100 years. COVID-19 is our big chance to change this[2]

One such failure is the Cashless Debit Card[3], which has been trialled in Australia since 2016.

Yet, among all the measures in last month’s budget was the news the Morrison government will make the trial scheme “ongoing[4]”.

What is the Cashless Debit Card?

The Cashless Debit Card scheme quarantines 80% of social security payments to a cashless card, which prevents spending on alcohol, illegal drugs and gambling products.

Empty shopping trolley in supermarket aisle. The card is supposed to quarantine welfare payment for essentials such as food and groceries. www.shutterstock.com

It is currently being trialled in Ceduna in South Australia, the East Kimberley in Western Australia, the Goldfields in WA and Hervey Bay region in Queensland, with about 12,000 people[5] involved.

The card compulsorily includes a broad range of people[6] receiving support for many reasons, including payments for disability, parenting, caring, unemployment and youth allowance. The Australian Human Rights Commission[7] is among those who have pointed out the the card disproportionately impacts First Nations people.

Research shows it does not work

Peer-reviewed research has consistently shown the card, and income management[8] more broadly, do not meet policy objectives. A 2020 academic study[9] of multiple locations found compulsory income management “can do as much harm as good”.

Survey respondents reported not having enough cash for essential items, while the research found the card “can also stigmatise and infantilise users”.

My research examining the card in the East Kimberley shows it makes life more difficult[10] for people subjected to it, including making it harder to manage money. People also reported the card made it more difficult to buy basic goods[11] such as medicine and groceries.

Read more: 'I don't want anybody to see me using it': cashless welfare cards do more harm than good[12]

Other research from the Life Course Centre suggests compulsory income management has been linked to a reduction of birth weight[13] and school attendance[14]. The majority of these children are First Nations kids.

Bill before parliament

A bill[15] to make the card permanent was introduced to parliament just a day after the budget was handed down.

If passed, it will also transfer about 25,000 people in the Northern Territory and Cape York[16] who are on the Basics Card (an earlier version of income management) onto the Cashless Debit Card.

Introducing the bill to the House, Morrison government minister Trevor Evans said[17] the card was delivering “significant benefits” in the trial communities.

The program has the objective of reducing immediate hardship and deprivation, helping welfare recipients with their budgeting strategies and reducing the likelihood that they will remain on welfare and out of the workforce for extended periods.

The government also says[18] the card is used “just like an everyday bank card” and is seeing a reduction in drug and alcohol use and gambling.

Senate inquiry

But as highlighted above, the value of the scheme is heavily disputed by policy experts. People put on the card, community groups, lawyers and doctors also oppose[19] any expansion of the card.

The card’s expansion has been the subject of a brief Senate inquiry[20], which is due to report on November 17.

This is the sixth Senate inquiry into the Cashless Debit Card. Each one has seen submissions from across the community which overwhelmingly reject the card[21].

First Nations groups have led the charge[22], stating income management is not in the spirit of self-determination and the current bill would “directly contradict the recent National Agreement on Closing the Gap”.

Smoke and mirrors

Trials of public policy programs require, by definition, research to examine their performance and to justify any continuation. Yet, the government continues to rely on anecdotes[23] and the widely criticised 2017 evaluation by ORIMA Research[24] as “proof” for the roll out of the Cashless Debit Card.

In 2018, the Australian National Audit Office[25] found the ORIMA evaluation was methodologically flawed and unable to provide any credible conclusions regarding the real impact of the trial.

Aerial view of Hervey Bay, Queensland. The card has been trialled in the Hervey Bay and Bundaberg region since 2019. www.shutterstock.com

In the latest bill, the government also misrepresents the findings from a 2014 evaluation of compulsory income management into the Northern Territory, claiming the findings were supportive of income management[26]. Yet this evaluation[27],

[did] not find any consistent evidence of income management having a significant systematic positive impact.

Compelled by the Senate[28], the government has since commissioned the University of Adelaide[29] to evaluate the scheme. This research was due to be released by the end of 2019 but is yet to be made public.

When asked about the report in Senate estimates last month[30], Social Services Minister Anne Ruston said it was not about deciding whether the card would continue, but to give advice on “what what was working particularly well”.

Perversely, the current bill also removes any need to further evaluate the Cashless Debit Card, instead opting to rely on the department to undertake its own desk-based research[31].

Why is evidence being ignored?

The protracted life of the Cashless Debit Card in Australian public policy shows the ongoing disregard for evidence-based policy making.

It also shows the continued slow violence against thousands of Australians who deserve much better from elected officials and the structures set up to support them.

Whilst it is easy not to pay attention to the mundane details of policy, the Cashless Debit Card shows we must.

Read more: 'An insult' – politicians sing the praises of the cashless welfare card, but those forced to use it disagree[32]

References

  1. ^ has written (www.smh.com.au)
  2. ^ Australia has been stigmatising unemployed people for almost 100 years. COVID-19 is our big chance to change this (theconversation.com)
  3. ^ Cashless Debit Card (www.theguardian.com)
  4. ^ ongoing (www.abc.net.au)
  5. ^ 12,000 people (www.theguardian.com)
  6. ^ broad range of people (www.dss.gov.au)
  7. ^ Australian Human Rights Commission (humanrights.gov.au)
  8. ^ income management (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  9. ^ academic study (theconversation.com)
  10. ^ life more difficult (openresearch-repository.anu.edu.au)
  11. ^ buy basic goods (128f2a8c-7e2b-db29-c5ed-c863dde6f97c.filesusr.com)
  12. ^ 'I don't want anybody to see me using it': cashless welfare cards do more harm than good (theconversation.com)
  13. ^ birth weight (www.lifecoursecentre.org.au)
  14. ^ school attendance (www.lifecoursecentre.org.au)
  15. ^ bill (www.aph.gov.au)
  16. ^ Northern Territory and Cape York (www.dss.gov.au)
  17. ^ Trevor Evans said (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)
  18. ^ also says (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)
  19. ^ also oppose (www.aph.gov.au)
  20. ^ Senate inquiry (www.aph.gov.au)
  21. ^ overwhelmingly reject the card (www.theguardian.com)
  22. ^ led the charge (www.amsant.org.au)
  23. ^ anecdotes (www.anneruston.com.au)
  24. ^ evaluation by ORIMA Research (www.dss.gov.au)
  25. ^ Australian National Audit Office (www.anao.gov.au)
  26. ^ were supportive of income management (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)
  27. ^ this evaluation (caepr.cass.anu.edu.au)
  28. ^ by the Senate (www.theguardian.com)
  29. ^ University of Adelaide (www.abc.net.au)
  30. ^ Senate estimates last month (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)
  31. ^ desk-based research (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)
  32. ^ 'An insult' – politicians sing the praises of the cashless welfare card, but those forced to use it disagree (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/why-is-the-government-trying-to-make-the-cashless-debit-card-permanent-research-shows-it-does-not-work-149444

Times Magazine

Headless CMS in Digital Twins and 3D Product Experiences

Image by freepik As the metaverse becomes more advanced and accessible, it's clear that multiple sectors will use digital twins and 3D product experiences to visualize, connect, and streamline efforts better. A digital twin is a virtual replica of ...

The Decline of Hyper-Casual: How Mid-Core Mobile Games Took Over in 2025

In recent years, the mobile gaming landscape has undergone a significant transformation, with mid-core mobile games emerging as the dominant force in app stores by 2025. This shift is underpinned by changing user habits and evolving monetization tr...

Understanding ITIL 4 and PRINCE2 Project Management Synergy

Key Highlights ITIL 4 focuses on IT service management, emphasising continual improvement and value creation through modern digital transformation approaches. PRINCE2 project management supports systematic planning and execution of projects wit...

What AI Adoption Means for the Future of Workplace Risk Management

Image by freepik As industrial operations become more complex and fast-paced, the risks faced by workers and employers alike continue to grow. Traditional safety models—reliant on manual oversight, reactive investigations, and standardised checklist...

From Beach Bops to Alpine Anthems: Your Sonos Survival Guide for a Long Weekend Escape

Alright, fellow adventurers and relaxation enthusiasts! So, you've packed your bags, charged your devices, and mentally prepared for that glorious King's Birthday long weekend. But hold on, are you really ready? Because a true long weekend warrior kn...

Effective Commercial Pest Control Solutions for a Safer Workplace

Keeping a workplace clean, safe, and free from pests is essential for maintaining productivity, protecting employee health, and upholding a company's reputation. Pests pose health risks, can cause structural damage, and can lead to serious legal an...

The Times Features

Exploring the Curriculum at a Modern Junior School in Melbourne

Key Highlights The curriculum at junior schools emphasises whole-person development, catering to children’s physical, emotional, and intellectual needs. It ensures early year...

Distressed by all the bad news? Here’s how to stay informed but still look after yourself

If you’re feeling like the news is particularly bad at the moment, you’re not alone. But many of us can’t look away – and don’t want to. Engaging with news can help us make ...

The Role of Your GP in Creating a Chronic Disease Management Plan That Works

Living with a long-term condition, whether that is diabetes, asthma, arthritis or heart disease, means making hundreds of small decisions every day. You plan your diet against m...

Troubleshooting Flickering Lights: A Comprehensive Guide for Homeowners

Image by rawpixel.com on Freepik Effectively addressing flickering lights in your home is more than just a matter of convenience; it's a pivotal aspect of both home safety and en...

My shins hurt after running. Could it be shin splints?

If you’ve started running for the first time, started again after a break, or your workout is more intense, you might have felt it. A dull, nagging ache down your shins after...

Metal Roof Replacement Cost Per Square Metre in 2025: A Comprehensive Guide for Australian Homeowners

In recent years, the trend of installing metal roofs has surged across Australia. With their reputation for being both robust and visually appealing, it's easy to understand thei...