The Times Australia
The Times Australia

.
The Times Real Estate

.

As antisemitic attacks reach ‘disturbing’ levels, is strengthening hate crime laws the answer?

  • Written by Keiran Hardy, Associate Professor, Griffith Criminology Institute, Griffith University



Mike Burgess, head of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation, has issued a stark warning[1] following the discovery of explosives in a caravan in northwest Sydney, alongside a note bearing the address of a Sydney synagogue.

We have seen a disturbing escalation in the targeting of Jewish interests, and a disturbing escalation in the severity and recklessness of the targeting.

In response to the recent spate of antisemitic incidents in Sydney – which include a childcare centre being set alight and graffitied[2] – NSW Premier Chris Minns has also pledged to strengthen the state’s hate laws.

Changes to these laws would bring NSW in line with other states. However, they will have limited impact on a serious social problem. Both nationally and in the states, many existing laws can be used to prosecute people for these crimes, including incitement to violence on the basis of religion, race or ethnicity.

Responding quickly to the growing crisis around antisemitic attacks is understandable, but greater long-term investments must also be made to prevent extreme, hateful beliefs from developing in our communities in the first place.

Fire damage to childcare centre.
Fire damage to the Maroubra Preschool and Early Learning Centre in Sydney. Steve Markham/AAP

What crimes are being committed?

Different laws can be triggered depending on the nature of a particular offence.

The firebombing of a Melbourne synagogue[3] late last year was treated as an act of terrorism, while a joint counter-terrorism team is investigating[4] the caravan explosives.

Other hateful acts can be charged as arson, property damage or serious vilification.

For conduct to be treated as terrorism, it must be done for the purpose of advancing a political, religious or ideological cause.

Extreme right-wing or neo-Nazi beliefs can certainly satisfy this. But whether an individual case will be treated as terrorism depends on whether there is enough evidence of an underlying ideological motive.

Serious vilification offences[5] apply when someone incites others to cause harm on the basis of race, religion, sexuality or gender identity.

Both nationally and in the states, new offences also apply for displaying Nazi symbols. Neo-Nazis who were arrested after a march in Adelaide this month, for example, were charged[6] with various offences, including failing to cease loitering and displaying a Nazi symbol.

Read more: Legal in one state, a crime in another: laws banning hate symbols are a mixed bag[7]

What is NSW considering changing?

The biggest change would be to section 93Z[8] of the NSW Crimes Act.

Section 93Z is a serious vilification offence, but it applies only to the incitement of violence. Equivalent offences[9] in other states are broader because they also include incitement to hatred, serious contempt or severe ridicule.

In Queensland, this requires threats or inciting threats of physical harm. In Victoria, changes likely to pass[10] in parliament soon would remove a similar harm requirement.

In NSW, vilification[11] on broader grounds is still unlawful, but it falls under civil law. Complaints[12] can be made to Anti-Discrimination NSW and this may lead to lawsuits and potential compensation – but not criminal prosecution.

It makes sense for NSW to match section 93Z to equivalent laws in other states. But this would go against the very recent recommendations[13] of the NSW Law Reform Commission.

In its report last November, the commission concluded that strengthening laws is not always the best way to address underlying social issues. It said the low prosecution rate for section 93Z could be explained by police preferring other, more serious offences for these types of crimes.

Still, it appears Minns may go ahead with the reforms, saying[14] an antisemitic attack “begins with hateful, racist language”.

If I can stop it at its source with changes to the law, that’s exactly what we’ll do.

New South Wales Premier Chris Minns says ‘something needs to change’. Steven Saphore/AAP

Would these changes make a difference?

The proposed changes are quite technical and are unlikely to have a significant impact on the growing threat of antisemitism.

Widening section 93Z could generate some additional prosecutions for hate speech that falls below inciting violence. But in most cases, other, more serious offences are already available to prosecutors.

Ultimately, in addition to the ongoing investigations, there needs to be greater investment in efforts to understand extremism in Australian society. This includes developing clearer answers to these questions:

  • why extreme, hateful beliefs are thriving in our communities
  • who is most likely to develop these beliefs and act on them, and
  • how extremist narratives can best be countered, in our communities and online.

Countering violent extremism[15] programs are improving over time. These include interventions for at-risk youth and broader efforts to educate communities. But investments in these approaches have never kept pace with changes to the criminal law.

Antisemitism has no place in Australian society, and changing the law in NSW will send a quick message that the government is taking the problem seriously. But taking it seriously also means doing whatever else we can as a society to ensure no one experiences hate or violence for who they are or what they believe.

References

  1. ^ has issued a stark warning (www.smh.com.au)
  2. ^ childcare centre being set alight and graffitied (www.theguardian.com)
  3. ^ firebombing of a Melbourne synagogue (theconversation.com)
  4. ^ joint counter-terrorism team is investigating (www.sbs.com.au)
  5. ^ Serious vilification offences (www.austlii.edu.au)
  6. ^ charged (www.abc.net.au)
  7. ^ Legal in one state, a crime in another: laws banning hate symbols are a mixed bag (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ section 93Z (www.austlii.edu.au)
  9. ^ Equivalent offences (www.austlii.edu.au)
  10. ^ changes likely to pass (www.theguardian.com)
  11. ^ vilification (classic.austlii.edu.au)
  12. ^ Complaints (antidiscrimination.nsw.gov.au)
  13. ^ recommendations (lawreform.nsw.gov.au)
  14. ^ saying (www.smh.com.au)
  15. ^ Countering violent extremism (www.livingsafetogether.gov.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/as-antisemitic-attacks-reach-disturbing-levels-is-strengthening-hate-crime-laws-the-answer-248549

Independents took cities by storm last election. This time, they’ve got regional Australia in their sights

In 2022, the national vote for independents or minor parties was the highest[1] in almost a century. A third o...

The Times Features

Gastric Balloon Surgery: A Minimally Invasive Solution to Weight Loss

A gastric balloon is a soft silicone device placed in your stomach to reduce its space, helping you feel full with smaller meals. The balloon can be inserted through your mouth ...

How to Find Affordable and Quality Sheet Sets on a Budget

Finding the perfect balance between affordability and quality when shopping for sheet sets can be quite the challenge, especially if you're sticking to a budget. The right sheet se...

What’s the difference between wholemeal and wholegrain bread? Not a whole lot

If you head to the shops to buy bread, you’ll face a variety of different options. But it can be hard to work out the difference between all the types on sale. For instance...

Expert Tips for Planning Home Electrical Upgrades in Australia

Home electrical systems in Australia are quite intricate and require careful handling. Safety and efficiency determine the functionality of these systems, and it's critical to ...

Floor Tiling: Choosing the Right Tiles for Every Room

Choosing floor tiles is more than just grabbing the first design that catches your eye at the showroom. You need to think about how the floor tiling option will fit into your spa...

Exploring Family Caravans: Your Ultimate Guide to Mobile Living and Travel

Australia is the land of vast horizons, spectacular coastlines, and a never-ending adventure. As landscapes and adventures vary across the country, Voyager will route you, carava...

Times Magazine

The Ultimate Guide to Apple Watch Faces & Trending Wallpapers

In today’s digital world, personalization is everything. Your smartwatch isn’t just a timepiece—it’s an extension of your style. Thanks to innovative third-party developers, customizing your Apple Watch has reached new heights with stunning designs...

The Power of Digital Signage in Modern Marketing

In a fast-paced digital world, businesses must find innovative ways to capture consumer attention. Digital signage has emerged as a powerful solution, offering dynamic and engaging content that attracts and retains customers. From retail stores to ...

Why Cloud Computing Is the Future of IT Infrastructure for Enterprises

Globally, cloud computing is changing the way business organizations manage their IT infrastructure. It offers cheap, flexible and scalable solutions. Cloud technologies are applied in organizations to facilitate procedures and optimize operation...

First Nations Writers Festival

The First Nations Writers Festival (FNWF) is back for its highly anticipated 2025 edition, continuing its mission to celebrate the voices, cultures and traditions of First Nations communities through literature, art and storytelling. Set to take ...

Improving Website Performance with a Cloud VPS

Websites represent the new mantra of success. One slow website may make escape for visitors along with income too. Therefore it's an extra offer to businesses seeking better performance with more scalability and, thus represents an added attracti...

Why You Should Choose Digital Printing for Your Next Project

In the rapidly evolving world of print media, digital printing has emerged as a cornerstone technology that revolutionises how businesses and creative professionals produce printed materials. Offering unparalleled flexibility, speed, and quality, d...

LayBy Shopping