The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

From UFOs to COVID conspiracy theories, we all struggle with the 'truth out there'

  • Written by Meg Elkins, Senior Lecturer with School of Economics, Finance and Marketing and Behavioural Business Lab Member, RMIT University

For ufologists the US government’s eagerly anticipated report[1] of “unidentified aerial phenomena” may be a major disappointment. It goes further than any previous report in admitting unknowns[2]. But conspiracy theorists will likely dismiss it as a cover-up.

But they aren’t alone in tending to dismiss anything that jars with their accepted narrative.

Take the “lab leak theory”. In January, for example, the Washington Post not only called the idea that COVID-19 was man-made a “debunked fringe theory[3]”. It also called the theory it originated from the Wuhan Institute of Virology a “disputed fringe theory[4]”.

Facebook banned claims the virus was made in a lab for being false and debunked[5] in February. It has now reversed that ruling, with US president Joe Biden ordering his intelligence experts[6] to “bring us closer to a definitive conclusion” by the end of August.

Read more: Conspiracy theories on the right, cancel culture on the left: how political legitimacy came under threat in 2020[7]

The issue has been complicated by hyper-partisan media conflating Facebook’s ban with censorship of the lab-leak theory. But many also dismissed the lab-leak theory[8] too easily by conflating it with other conspiracy theories.

Read more: The COVID-19 lab-leak hypothesis is plausible because accidents happen. I should know[9]

We’re all prone to accepting one narrative and sticking to it, no matter the evidence. This problem isn’t just “out there”. Behavioural research offers some lessons for all us to keep front and centre.

Seeing what we want to see

Even if we pride ourselves on being independently minded we can still fall prey to cognitive biases.

Part of this is due to overconfidence in our own decision-making skills[10].

This isn’t just the result of the phenomenon known as the Dunning-Kruger effect[11] – in which we tend to overestimate our competence in areas in which we are incompetent. Highly intelligent people are also susceptible to believing highly irrational ideas, as demonstrated by the list of Nobel prize-winning scientists who have embraced scientifically questionable beliefs[12].

Part of it also has to do with believing what we want to be true[13].

We settle on most of our opinions through nothing better than snap judgement[14] or instincts. Our internal “press secretary” – a mental module that convinces us of our own infallibility – then justifies our reasons for holding those opinions after the fact.

Behavioural scientists call this motivated reasoning[15] – when your personal preferences cloud your grasp on reality.

As Malcolm Gladwell writes in his book Blink: The Power of Thinking Without Thinking (Little, Brown, 2005): “Our selection decisions are a good deal less rational than we think.”

Protesters who believe COVID-19 is a hoax. Most of us are overconfident about our own decision-making skills. lyas Tayfun Salci/Shutterstock

How long is a piece of string? You tell me

One cognitive bias that is especially amplified by social media is good old-fashioned conformism.

The potency of conformist thinking was graphically demonstrated by psychologist Solomon Asch in his classic 1956 study[16] showing we can even disregard the evidence of our own eyes when it contradicts the majority view.

Asch assembled groups of participants and had them judge which of three numbered lines had the same length as a target line.

Solomon Asch's conformity experiment line comparison. Solomon Asch’s conformity experiment line comparison. Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA[17][18]

Which numbered line is the same length as the one on the left? The answer should be easy. But in Asch’s group only one person was a real participant. The six others were “stooges”, instructed to sometimes give the same, patently wrong answer before the subject of the experiment answered.

The result: about a third of the time subjects went along with the majority view, though it was clearly wrong. The painful lesson: we are social creatures, swayed by the group, even willing to sacrifice the truth just to fit in.

Locked in the echo chamber

Facebook, Twitter and other social media sites can reinforce all the above instincts through creating “echo chambers” that validate what we chose to believe.

Exposure to different ideas does not fit well with the economics of online media – in which platforms, and content creators on those platforms, fight for limited attention by appealing to preferences and prejudices.

We enjoy echo chambers.

According to psychologist Jonathan Haidt, we appear to be born with a “self-righteousness gene[19]” – an inherent need to be right. We are more prone to defend our opinions by criticising others. We find comfort in validation.

Once we have made our opinion known to others, we are doggedly reluctant to change course. Seeming consistent can become more important than seeming right[20], so we will go to great lengths to shore up opinions that come under scrutiny.

These foibles might be endearing if they didn’t have such serious implications. Believing in misinformation is an undeniable problem.

Read more: Coronavirus misinformation is a global issue, but which myth you fall for likely depends on where you live[21]

But we are going to need a different way to deal with conspiracy theories than simply trying to ban them. Seeking to enforce a single accepted narrative is not the solution.

If Facebook or mainstream media are the arbiters of who gets heard and who does not, then we will be pushed more towards our own filter bubbles, and conspiracy theorists towards theirs.

References

  1. ^ report (www.dni.gov)
  2. ^ in admitting unknowns (theconversation.com)
  3. ^ debunked fringe theory (www.washingtonpost.com)
  4. ^ disputed fringe theory (www.washingtonpost.com)
  5. ^ false and debunked (www.theguardian.com)
  6. ^ ordering his intelligence experts (www.whitehouse.gov)
  7. ^ Conspiracy theories on the right, cancel culture on the left: how political legitimacy came under threat in 2020 (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ dismissed the lab-leak theory (www.thelancet.com)
  9. ^ The COVID-19 lab-leak hypothesis is plausible because accidents happen. I should know (theconversation.com)
  10. ^ own decision-making skills (hbr.org)
  11. ^ Dunning-Kruger effect (www.psychologytoday.com)
  12. ^ scientifically questionable beliefs (skepticalinquirer.org)
  13. ^ want to be true (medium.com)
  14. ^ snap judgement (www.nytimes.com)
  15. ^ motivated reasoning (www.sciencedirect.com)
  16. ^ 1956 study (cynlibsoc.com)
  17. ^ Wikimedia Commons (commons.wikimedia.org)
  18. ^ CC BY-SA (creativecommons.org)
  19. ^ self-righteousness gene (onbeing.org)
  20. ^ more important than seeming right (hbr.org)
  21. ^ Coronavirus misinformation is a global issue, but which myth you fall for likely depends on where you live (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/from-ufos-to-covid-conspiracy-theories-we-all-struggle-with-the-truth-out-there-163483

The Times Features

Fast, Fun, And Fantastic Looking Gel Polish For Your Nails!

Today's women spend a lot of time and money on their beauty and fashion regime because they love looking their very best! Looking good makes you feel good, and let's face it, it...

Energy-Efficient Roof Restoration Trends to Watch in Sydney

As climate consciousness rises and energy costs soar, energy-efficient roof restoration has become a significant focus in Sydney. Whether you're renovating an old roof or enhan...

Brisbane Water Bill Savings: Practical Tips to Reduce Costs

Brisbane residents have been feeling the pinch as water costs continue to climb. With increasing prices, it's no wonder many households are searching for ways to ease the burde...

Exploring Hybrid Heating Systems for Modern Homes

Consequently, energy efficiency as well as sustainability are two major considerations prevalent in the current market for homeowners and businesses alike. Hence, integrated heat...

Are Dental Implants Right for You? Here’s What to Think About

Dental implants are now among the top solutions for those seeking to replace and improve their teeth. But are dental implants suitable for you? Here you will find out more about ...

Sunglasses don’t just look good – they’re good for you too. Here’s how to choose the right pair

Australians are exposed to some of the highest levels[1] of solar ultraviolet (UV) radiation in the world. While we tend to focus on avoiding UV damage to our skin, it’s impor...

Times Magazine

BLUETTI EB3A Portable Power Station review

At work and on assignment The crew at TheTimes.com.au were offered the opportunity to carry out a long term test of a BLUETTI power station. When the EB3A power station arrived by courier, we unpacked it with enthusiasm and some curiosity as none o...

Sydney's Finest: How to Identify a Top-Tier SEO Company

In the dynamic realm of digital marketing, the success of your online presence relies heavily on effective search engine optimisation (SEO). A pivotal force in this journey is the SEO company you choose. In Sydney's competitive business landscape...

The Benefits of School Excursions to Underwater Worlds

Exploring the mystical depths of underwater worlds holds an unparalleled charm, especially for young minds eager to learn and discover. School excursions to places like aquariums offer more than just a day away from the classroom; they present a un...

Technical Surveillance Counter Measures: Safeguarding Corporate Intelligence

The rapid advancement of surveillance technology has created unprecedented challenges for businesses seeking to protect their sensitive information and intellectual property. In this landscape of evolving security threats, technical surveillance ...

Make the Most of Your Printing with the Right Printer Price in Singapore

Printers Available in Singapore Singapore is home to a wide variety of printers available at various price points. Whether you need a printer for home or office use, there's something for everyone. With the latest technology and features on offer...

4 Types of SEO every Business Must Embrace

There is no getting around it, if you are involved in any type of business or service then getting your online presence watertight is key to any hopes of success. Yet with 1.8 billion pages on the internet competition is fierce. So how can you sta...

LayBy Shopping