The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

The Labor Party has long struggled over a position on Israel and Palestine. Here's why

  • Written by Dennis Altman, Professorial Fellow in Human Security, La Trobe University

After the brutal conflict in Gaza flared yet again in the past month, and the end of Benyamin Netanyahu’s 12 years as prime minister of Israel, attention is again focused on the apparently intractable conflict between Israel and Palestine.

Australia has been one of Israel’s staunchest supporters, but this is increasingly being questioned, particularly within the Labor Party. The Queensland branch recently passed a resolution[1] condemning Israel for the “ethnic cleansing” and “oppression and dehumanisation of Palestinian people”. The party’s federal leadership immediately disavowed the resolution.

The Labor Party has long struggled over a position on Israel and Palestine. Here's why H.V. ‘Doc’ Evatt was instrumental in the establishment of Israel. National Archives of Australia

This is not a new debate within Labor, nor is it likely to disappear. While there is less obvious dissent within Coalition ranks, there is growing public scepticism about Australia’s consistent support of Israeli governments. What data we have suggests less enthusiasm[2] for Israel’s position than is reflected in mainstream media, with younger Australians less supportive of Israel’s current position.

Australia played a significant role in the formation of Israel after the second world war. As president of the United Nations General Assembly, Herbert “Doc” Evatt, then Labor’s foreign minister, shepherded through[3] the resolutions that led to the partition of the British mandate of Palestine and the recognition of the state of Israel.

Support for Israel continued under successive governments. In the Suez Crisis[4] of 1956, the Menzies government stood with Britain and France in backing Israel’s attack on Egypt. In the United Nations, Australia is one of a dwindling number of American allies that have supported Israel in a series of votes condemning Israel.

Disputes over Palestine split the National Union of Australian Students in the mid-1970s. In her memoir[5], Julia Gillard writes that these debates contributed to her strong sympathies for Israel. Her sympathies were tested when Bob Carr, then foreign minister, pushed for Australia to modify its automatic support for Israel in United Nations votes. Carr mobilised considerable support within caucus, and Australia abstained[6] on a General Assembly vote on Palestinian recognition.

Read more: Netanyahu's visit in perspective: Australia has more important relationships than Israel[7]

By 2012, attitudes within Labor had begun to shift. When he was foreign minister in the Hawke and Keating governments, Gareth Evans had written[8] of the dilemmas facing Israel if it refused to acknowledge the claims of the Palestinians.

In his memoir[9] he argues Israel “could not be simultaneously a Jewish state, a democratic state, and a state occupying the whole of biblical Judea and Samaria”.

Labor’s shift is due to both ideological and pragmatic reasons. Carr is very explicit about the growing importance of Lebanese and other Arab-Australian voters to the Labor cause, as against the already influential, though smaller, Jewish community.

The Labor Party has long struggled over a position on Israel and Palestine. Here's why As foreign minister, Bob Carr pushed for Labor to modify its automatic support of Israel. AAP/Alan Porritt

But he also saw a shift[10] in Australia’s position as a necessary recognition of the Palestinian case against continuing Israeli occupation of the West Bank.

Traditionally, Australians have felt a sense of identity with Israel. It represented for several generations a chance to atone for the horrors of the Holocaust, and Australia has been largely free of the sort of unreflective anti-Semitism that colours much debate about Israel.

The first Australian-born governor-general, Sir Isaac Isaacs[11], was Jewish. Stories of settling the land had particular resonance for many Australians; reflecting on whose land was being dispossessed was too uncomfortable for most of us to consider.

It’s not surprising the strong government and media support for Israel finds a reaction in pro-Palestinian sympathies among many Australians, predominantly on the left. Supporters of Israel claim this is selective indignation and complain there is far less condemnation of equally or more repressive regimes closer to home. But as both Evans and Carr point out, Israel claims to be a democratic state and must be held to account by the norms of Western liberal democracies.

Australian debate on Israel/Palestine too often becomes ritualistic. It is either totally supportive of one side or the other, or resorts to vague talk of a “two-state solution”, which has long ceased to be meaningful[12] given the scope of Israeli settlements on the West Bank. The current government has quietly shelved Scott Morrison’s suggestion of moving the Australian embassy to Jerusalem, a thought bubble aimed at pleasing both Donald Trump and the electors of Wentworth.

Read more: Morrison's decision to recognise West Jerusalem the latest bad move in a mess of his own making[13]

Foreign Minister Marise Payne’s statement on the recent conflicts[14] suggested a more critical stance towards Israel, calling for

a halt to actions that increase tensions, including land appropriations, forced evictions, demolitions and settlement activity.

It is doubtful the new government in Israel will change the dynamics of the conflict. While the coalition government straddles the political spectrum, new Prime Minister Naftali Bennett opposes any concessions to the Palestinians.

One might expect both domestic and international pressure on Australian governments to adopt a more critical position of Israel.

Read more: Netanyahu leaves behind a complex legacy in Israel. His successor will need to deliver change — and fast[15]

References

  1. ^ recently passed a resolution (www.theage.com.au)
  2. ^ suggests less enthusiasm (plus61j.net.au)
  3. ^ shepherded through (catalogue.nla.gov.au)
  4. ^ Suez Crisis (www.theguardian.com)
  5. ^ In her memoir (www.penguin.com.au)
  6. ^ Australia abstained (www.aph.gov.au)
  7. ^ Netanyahu's visit in perspective: Australia has more important relationships than Israel (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ had written (www.mup.com.au)
  9. ^ In his memoir (www.mup.com.au)
  10. ^ saw a shift (www.newsouthbooks.com.au)
  11. ^ Sir Isaac Isaacs (adb.anu.edu.au)
  12. ^ long ceased to be meaningful (mondoweiss.net)
  13. ^ Morrison's decision to recognise West Jerusalem the latest bad move in a mess of his own making (theconversation.com)
  14. ^ statement on the recent conflicts (www.foreignminister.gov.au)
  15. ^ Netanyahu leaves behind a complex legacy in Israel. His successor will need to deliver change — and fast (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/the-labor-party-has-long-struggled-over-a-position-on-israel-and-palestine-heres-why-162611

The Times Features

Fast, Fun, And Fantastic Looking Gel Polish For Your Nails!

Today's women spend a lot of time and money on their beauty and fashion regime because they love looking their very best! Looking good makes you feel good, and let's face it, it...

Energy-Efficient Roof Restoration Trends to Watch in Sydney

As climate consciousness rises and energy costs soar, energy-efficient roof restoration has become a significant focus in Sydney. Whether you're renovating an old roof or enhan...

Brisbane Water Bill Savings: Practical Tips to Reduce Costs

Brisbane residents have been feeling the pinch as water costs continue to climb. With increasing prices, it's no wonder many households are searching for ways to ease the burde...

Exploring Hybrid Heating Systems for Modern Homes

Consequently, energy efficiency as well as sustainability are two major considerations prevalent in the current market for homeowners and businesses alike. Hence, integrated heat...

Are Dental Implants Right for You? Here’s What to Think About

Dental implants are now among the top solutions for those seeking to replace and improve their teeth. But are dental implants suitable for you? Here you will find out more about ...

Sunglasses don’t just look good – they’re good for you too. Here’s how to choose the right pair

Australians are exposed to some of the highest levels[1] of solar ultraviolet (UV) radiation in the world. While we tend to focus on avoiding UV damage to our skin, it’s impor...

Times Magazine

4 Elements of Continuum of Care Services You Need To Know

Aging is a new stage of life. You feel wonderful most days, but you may notice some aches and pains before bed or that keeping up with all of your tasks and activities isn't as easy as it used to be. Getting older doesn't have to mean that you gi...

The Hidden Gems of the Sim Plans Market: Finding the Best Deals

Sim plans are the perfect way to stay connected to the people that matter most. Whether you're trying to stay in touch with friends and family or stay up-to-date on the latest news, Sim plans to make it easy and affordable. With the Top Sim plans, yo...

Tesselaar Tulip Festival

THE BULBS ARE BACK FOR A DAZZLING DISPLAY THIS SPRING AT THE 2022 TESSELAAR TULIP FESTIVAL  The much-loved and visually spectacular Tesselaar Tulip Festival, in Melbourne’s magical Dandenong Ranges, returns this spring to once again surprise, de...

The ultimate guide to test driving a new car

There’s something uniquely exciting about being in the market for a new car and getting to go out on test drives. The new gadgets you’ve never had before, that feeling of getting to grips with the handling of a new machine and, of course, the new...

An Introductory Guide to Electrical Sub Boards

Advantages of Installing an Electrical SubBoard Installing an electrical subboard is a great way to keep your home or business safe and properly wired. By adding a subboard to your existing wiring system, you can increase the safety and efficien...

Some Tips For Buying The Right Pair Of Sneakers

The old saying goes "Never judge a book by its cover". This august wisdom applies to a lot more things in life than just books, including today's topic, sneakers. It's easy to be charmed by clever designs, bright colours, and blingy glitz, but it's...

LayBy Shopping