Auckland is the world's 'most liveable city'? Many Māori might disagree

While I am always happy to celebrate any accolades my country and city might garner on the international stage, seeing Auckland/Tāmaki Makaurau awarded the top ranking in a recent “most liveable cities^[1]” survey left me somewhat flummoxed.

In particular, I would argue that many Māori whānau^[2] in Auckland do not enjoy the benefits of this supposed “liveability”.

This is important, given Māori comprised 11.5%^[3] of the Auckland population in the 2018 Census. Roughly one in four Māori in Aotearoa New Zealand are living in the greater Auckland region.

The survey was conducted by the Economist Intelligence Unit, sister company of The Economist, and looked at 140 world cities. Auckland was ranked 12th in 2019, but took top spot this year for one obvious reason:

Auckland, in New Zealand, is at the top of The Economist Intelligence Unit’s Liveability rankings, owing to the city’s ability to contain the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic faster and thus lift restrictions earlier, unlike others around the world.

Alternative liveability criteria

Each city in the survey was rated on “relative comfort for over 30 qualitative and quantitative factors across five broad categories: stability, healthcare, culture and environment, education and infrastructure”.

Overall rankings depended on how those factors were rated on a sliding scale: acceptable, tolerable, uncomfortable, undesirable, intolerable. Quantitative measurements relied on “external data points”, but the qualitative ratings were “based on the judgment of our team of expert analysts and in-city contributors”.

Read more: Recession hits Māori and Pasifika harder. They must be part of planning New Zealand's COVID-19 recovery^[4]

The methodology, particularly around culture and environment, seems somewhat subjective. It’s predicated on the judgement of unnamed experts and contributors, and based on similarly undefined “cultural indicators”.

To better understand the living conditions of Māori in Auckland, therefore, we might use more robust “liveability” criteria. The New Zealand Treasury’s Living Standards Framework^[5] offers a useful model.

This sets out 12 domains of well-being: civic engagement and governance, cultural identity, environment, health, housing, income and consumption, jobs and earnings, knowledge and skills, time use, safety and security, social connections and subjective well-being.

The Māori experience

Applying a small handful of these measures to Māori, we find the following.

Housing: According to recent reports^[6], Auckland house prices increased by about NZ$140,00 on average in the past year. That contributed to Auckland being the fourth-least-affordable housing market, across New Zealand, Singapore, Australia, the US, UK, Ireland, Canada and Hong Kong.

Next to that sobering fact, we can point to estimates^[7] that Māori made up more than 40% of the homeless in Auckland in 2019. We can only assume this rapid increase in house prices has made homelessness worse.

Poverty: Alongside housing affordability is the growing concern about poverty in New Zealand, and particularly child poverty. While there has been an overall decline in child poverty, Māori and Pacific poverty rates remain “profoundly disturbing^[8]”.

Read more: Wage restraint aims to lift the lowest-earning public servants, but it won't fix stubborn gender and ethnic pay gaps^[9]

Employment: As of March 2021, the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment recorded a Māori unemployment rate^[10] of 10.8%, well above the national rate (4.9%). This is particularly high for Māori youth (20.4%) and women (12.0%).

Health: Māori life expectancy is considerably lower than for non-Māori, and mortality rates are higher for Māori than non-Māori across nearly all age groups. Māori are also over-represented^[11] across a wide range of chronic and infectious diseases, injuries and suicide^[12].

The digital divide: The Digital Government^[13] initiative has found Māori and Pasifika are among those less likely to have internet access^[14], thus creating a level of digital poverty that may affect jobs and earnings, knowledge and skills, safety and security, and social connections.

Read more: If New Zealand can radically reform its health system, why not do the same for welfare?^[15]

Making Auckland liveable for all

Taken together, these factors show a different and darker picture for far too many Māori than “liveable city” headlines might suggest.

I say this as someone who has lived in Auckland for the majority of the past 60 years. It is a city I love, and I acknowledge the grace and generosity of the mana whenua^[16] of Tāmaki Makaurau, with whom I share this beautiful whenua and moana^[17].

I am also part of a privileged group of Māori who enjoy job security, a decent income, a secure whānau and strong social networks.

But, until we address and ameliorate the inequities and disadvantages some of our whānau face, we cannot truly celebrate being the “most liveable city in the world”.

References

1. ^{^} most liveable cities (www.economist.com)
2. ^{^} whānau (maoridictionary.co.nz)
3. ^{^} comprised 11.5% (statsnz.maps.arcgis.com)
4. ^{^} Recession hits Māori and Pasifika harder. They must be part of planning New Zealand's COVID-19 recovery (theconversation.com)
5. ^{^} Living Standards Framework (www.treasury.govt.nz)
6. ^{^} recent reports (www.newshub.co.nz)
7. ^{^} estimates (www.rnz.co.nz)
8. ^{^} profoundly disturbing (www.stuff.co.nz)
9. ^{^} Wage restraint aims to lift the lowest-earning public servants, but it won't fix stubborn gender and ethnic pay gaps (theconversation.com)
10. ^{^} unemployment rate (www.mbie.govt.nz)
11. ^{^} over-represented (www.healthnavigator.org.nz)
12. ^{^} suicide (www.health.govt.nz)
13. ^{^} Digital Government (www.digital.govt.nz)
14. ^{^} less likely to have internet access (www.digital.govt.nz)
15. ^{^} If New Zealand can radically reform its health system, why not do the same for welfare? (theconversation.com)
16. ^{^} mana whenua (maoridictionary.co.nz)
17. ^{^} moana (maoridictionary.co.nz)