The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Beatbot

.

The government agrees Australia’s secrecy laws need to change. Now comes the hard part – taking action

  • Written by Peter Greste, Professor of Journalism and Communications, Macquarie University



Earlier this year, the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM), Jake Blight, compared[1] the sheer volume of Australia’s secrecy laws to works of literature.

“You’d be looking at about 3,000-plus pages. That’s about the same as the complete works of William Shakespeare, War and Peace, and the three volumes of the Lord of the Rings – added together,” he told the ABC.

Of course, secrecy laws are necessary in an increasingly dangerous world. And since the September 11 2001 attacks, Australia has passed more than any other country on Earth – more than 90[2] by a 2021 count (though the number is now closer to 100).

But as Blight went on to point out, when these laws also smother the transparency that legitimate whistleblowing and investigative journalism bring to a democracy, they can wind up damaging the very system they are designed to protect.

That is why Attorney General Mark Dreyfus’ announcement this week that he has accepted[3] six of the INSLM’s 15 recommendations to reform Australia’s secrecy laws in full, and six others in part, is an important break from the direction of travel.

When classified information causes harm

In Blight’s review of the secrecy offences in the Criminal Code, some of those making submissions (including my own organisation, the Alliance for Journalists’ Freedom[4]) argued that many of the laws are inconsistent with the rule of law and human rights principles.

Critics also argue the laws unnecessarily penalise legitimate whistleblowing and criminalise the very journalists, lawyers and activist groups that are essential to the effective functioning of our democracy.

As it stands, the law makes it an offence to “deal with” classified information – a phrase so broad that a journalist or lawyer cannot open an envelope containing a classified document without risking prison. The government has agreed that merely receiving information should not be an offence alone.

The law also assumes that if a document is stamped “classified”, it would be harmful if it were released. It is what the law describes as “deemed” harm.

Instead, the government has agreed that what matters is the actual harm that might be caused if a document is released, rather than the stamp at the top of it.

In his review, Blight agreed the current system of classifying documents depended on secret policies and anonymous public servants rather than the courts. He said, however, that should not form the basis for criminal prosecutions that could send people to prison for years.

He told journalists[5] on Wednesday:

My concern is in taking a policy document and trying to enshrine it in the criminal law. Criminal laws need much more precision than a policy like that can provide.

Independent National Security Legislation Monitor Jake Blight
Independent National Security Legislation Monitor Jake Blight at a press conference at Parliament House in Canberra. Mick Tsikas/AAP

‘The most extreme secrets’

Dreyfus also agreed to invite the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions to revise the policy to consider press freedom when the office is dealing with journalists or publishers in cases involving classified documents.

But the government did not go as far as Blight had asked, particularly with regard to narrowing the scope of what is considered harmful information about intelligence agencies.

Currently, it is an offence to publish any information from an intelligence agency. Blight had recommended it be restricted to information about the data they handle, their operations, capabilities, technologies, methods and sources.

While Dreyfus agreed the scope of protected information is broad, he said Blight’s recommendation would “remove protections from categories of information which would cause harm if disclosed”.

Blight called that decision “unfortunate”.

Many of our intelligence agencies now do important work, but actually isn’t intelligence work, and I think our laws need to be tailored to that. Extreme secrecy should be focused only on the most extreme secrets.

Government lacking action

Broadly, though, Blight and other groups, including the Human Rights Law Centre[6] and the Alliance for Journalists’ Freedom, have welcomed the government’s response as an important step towards improving transparency and press freedom.

But accepting the recommendations is not the same as implementing them. The government has a record of promising improvements in transparency, but falling short in terms of passing legislation.

In 2020, the parliament’s intelligence and security committee published a report[7] into the impact of the law enforcement and intelligence agencies on the freedom of the press.

The report included 16 recommendations, and both the government and the opposition accepted 15 of them. Dreyfus, who was the shadow attorney general at the time, went even further. He described the recommendations as “the bare minimum”.

So far, five years on, only one has been implemented.

References

  1. ^ compared (www.abc.net.au)
  2. ^ more than 90 (cdn.getup.org.au)
  3. ^ he has accepted (www.ag.gov.au)
  4. ^ Alliance for Journalists’ Freedom (www.journalistsfreedom.com)
  5. ^ told journalists (www.theguardian.com)
  6. ^ Human Rights Law Centre (www.hrlc.org.au)
  7. ^ published a report (www.aph.gov.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/the-government-agrees-australias-secrecy-laws-need-to-change-now-comes-the-hard-part-taking-action-244823

The Times Features

LaManna at Essendon Fields is transforming into a festive wonderland

This festive season, LaManna is decking its halls with an incredible range of goodies to meet all your Christmas needs and ensure your next holiday feast is one to remember.  Wit...

'Big school ready’ before 2025

Rebecca Suseno, a mother from Croydon, NSW, shares her excitement and preparation for her daughter Chiara’s big leap into kindergarten in 2025. As a mother, there’s nothing...

ADHD medications affect children’s appetites. Here’s how to manage this

Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) impacts the ability to maintain attention to tasks. Often, it also involves impulsive behaviour – saying or doing things without...

For the foodie or home chef, look no further than premium pizza oven brand, Gozney

Founder and designer, Tom Gozney, wanted to bring a different way of cooking to as many people as possible and has led a movement of unforgettable cooking experiences inspired ...

Beyond bricks and mortar: Building socially connected communities is Australia’s next big challenge

As state governments rush to deliver thousands of homes across the major capitals,1 one of the nation’s leading urban planners warns we must build transit based, mixed-use, w...

New research shows how long, hard and often you need to stretch to improve your flexibility

Can you reach down and touch your toes without bending your knees? Can you reach both arms overhead? If these sound like a struggle, you may be lacking flexibility. Flexibilit...

Times Magazine

CSIRO and Space Machines partner to test Australian flexible solar cells in space

Space Machines and CSIRO partner to test Australian flexible solar cells in space  SYDNEY, Australia - Thursday 5th August 2021 - Australian in-space transportation provider Space Machines Company (SMC) and CSIRO, Australia's national scie...

A Fantastic Look Into The Top Fitness Trackers And Swimming Apps For 2022

People want swimming pools for several reasons and the best fibreglass pools today offer myriad advantages in your backyard. Anyone who gets a pool these days wants to swim in it for fun and fitness. Once you get a pool installed, you will likely u...

Upgrade Your Gaming Setup this Black Friday from TEMU

This year, Black Friday is set to be a record-breaker in Australia, with a staggering $6.7 billion expected to be spent over the four-day shopping period. As Aussies get ready to snap up deals, 1 in 10 are looking to TEMU, the online marketplace ...

Car Servicing Tips for Prolonged Vehicle Life

Car servicing is an indispensable aspect of automobile ownership. By adhering to a routine maintenance schedule, vehicle owners can not only keep their cars running smoothly and efficiently, but also enhance their performance, reduce the likelihood...

Utilize Rip Rap Seawall for Shoreline Protection

A Rip Rap seawall is a type of coastal engineering structure that protects shorelines from wave erosion, which is composed of large stones or boulders placed in an interlocking pattern along the shoreline. The design of the seawall is to absorb and d...

Choosing the Right Supplements for Your Pet: A Comprehensive Guide

In the pursuit of ensuring the best health and vitality for our furry companions, pet parents often find themselves navigating the complex world of dietary supplements. With a myriad of options available, it's imperative to choose wisely to support...

LayBy Shopping