The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

Some clinicians are using AI to write health records. What do you need to know?

  • Written by Stacy Carter, Professor and Director, Australian Centre for Health Engagement, Evidence and Values, University of Wollongong

Imagine this. You’ve finally summoned up the courage to see a GP about an embarrassing problem. You sit down. The GP says:

before we start, I’m using my computer to record my appointments. It’s AI – it will write a summary for the notes and a letter to the specialist. Is that OK?

Wait – AI writing our medical records? Why would we want that?

Records are essential for safe and effective health care. Clinicians must make good records to keep their registration[1]. Health services must provide good record systems to be accredited[2]. Records are also legal documents: they can be important in insurance claims or legal actions.

But writing stuff down (or dictating notes or letters) takes time. During appointments, clinicians can have their attention divided between good record-keeping and good communication with the patient. Sometimes clinicians need to work on records after hours, at the end of an already-long day.

So there’s understandable excitement[3], from all kinds of health-care professionals, about “ambient AI” or “digital scribes”.

What are digital scribes?

This is not old-school transcription software: dictate letter, software types it up word for word.

Digital scribes are different. They use AI – large language models with generative capabilities – similar to ChatGPT (or sometimes, GPT4[4] itself).

The application silently records the conversation between a clinician and a patient (via a phone, tablet or computer microphone, or a dedicated sensitive microphone). The AI converts the recording to a word-for-word transcript.

The AI system then uses the transcript, and the instructions it is given, to write a clinical note and/or letters for other doctors, ready for the clinician to check.

Most clinicians know little about these technologies: they are experts in their speciality, not in AI. The marketing materials promise to “let AI take care of your clinical notes so you can spend more time with your patients.”

Put yourself in the clinician’s shoes. You might say “yes please!”

GP talks to a patient
Some clinicians will welcome the chance to cut down their workload. Stephen Barnes/Shutterstock[5]

How are they regulated?

Recently, the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency[6] released a code of practice for using digital scribes. The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners released a fact sheet[7]. Both warn clinicians that they remain responsible for the contents of their medical records.

Some AI applications are regulated as medical devices[8], but many digital scribes are not. So it’s often up to health services or clinicians to work out whether scribes are safe and effective.

What does the research say so far?

There’s very limited data or real world evidence on the performance of digital scribes.

In a big Californian hospital system, researchers followed 9,000 doctors for ten weeks in a pilot test of a digital scribe[9].

Some doctors liked the scribe: their work hours decreased, they communicated better with patients. Others didn’t even start using the scribe.

And the scribe made mistakes – for example, recording the wrong diagnosis, or recording that a test had been done, when it needed to be done.

So what should we do about digital scribes?

The recommendations[10] of the first Australian National Citizens’ Jury on AI in Health Care[11] show what Australians want from health care AI, and provide a great starting point.

Building on those recommendations, here are some things to keep in mind about digital scribes the next time you head to the clinic or emergency department:

1) You should be told if a digital scribe is being used.

2) Only scribes designed for health care should be used in health care. Regular, publicly available generative AI tools (like ChatGPT or Google Gemini) should not be used in clinical care.

3) You should be able to consent, or refuse consent, for use of a digital scribe. You should have any relevant risks explained, and be able to agree or refuse freely.

4) Clinical digital scribes must meet strict privacy standards. You have a right to privacy and confidentiality[12] in your health care. The whole transcript of an appointment may contain a lot more detail than a clinical note usually would. So ask:

  • are the transcripts and summaries of your appointments processed in Australia, or another country?
  • how are they kept secure and private (for example, are they encrypted)?
  • who can access them?
  • how are they used (for example, are they used to train AI systems)?
  • does the scribe access other data from your record to make the summary? If so, is that data ever shared?
Clinician writes paper notes in a clinic corridor
Clinicians need to adhere to privacy standards. PeopleImages.com - Yuri A/Shutterstock[13]

Is human oversight enough?

Generative AI systems can make things up, get things wrong, or misunderstand some patient’s accents. But they will often communicate these errors in a way that sounds very convincing. This means careful human checking is crucial.

Doctors are told by tech and insurance companies that they must check every summary or letter (and they must). But it’s not that simple[14]. Busy clinicians might become over-reliant on the scribe and just accept the summaries. Tired or inexperienced clinicians might think their memory must be wrong, and the AI must be right (known as automation bias).

Some have suggested[15] these scribes should also be able to create summaries for patients. We don’t own our own health records, but we usually have a right to access them. Knowing a digital scribe is in use may increase consumers’ motivation to see what is in their health record.

Clinicians have always written notes about our embarrassing problems, and have always been responsible for these notes. The privacy, security, confidentiality and quality of these records have always been important.

Maybe one day, digital scribes will mean better records and better interactions with our clinicians. But right now, we need good evidence that these tools can deliver in real-world clinics, without compromising quality, safety or ethics.

References

  1. ^ keep their registration (www.ahpra.gov.au)
  2. ^ good record systems to be accredited (www.safetyandquality.gov.au)
  3. ^ understandable excitement (www.goldcoast.health.qld.gov.au)
  4. ^ GPT4 (www.medicalrepublic.com.au)
  5. ^ Stephen Barnes/Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
  6. ^ Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (www.ahpra.gov.au)
  7. ^ released a fact sheet (www.racgp.org.au)
  8. ^ regulated as medical devices (www.tga.gov.au)
  9. ^ in a pilot test of a digital scribe (catalyst.nejm.org)
  10. ^ recommendations (www.mja.com.au)
  11. ^ Australian National Citizens’ Jury on AI in Health Care (www.uow.edu.au)
  12. ^ right to privacy and confidentiality (www.safetyandquality.gov.au)
  13. ^ PeopleImages.com - Yuri A/Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
  14. ^ that simple (www.nature.com)
  15. ^ Some have suggested (www.pulseit.news)

Read more https://theconversation.com/some-clinicians-are-using-ai-to-write-health-records-what-do-you-need-to-know-237762

The Times Features

Exploring Hybrid Heating Systems for Modern Homes

Consequently, energy efficiency as well as sustainability are two major considerations prevalent in the current market for homeowners and businesses alike. Hence, integrated heat...

Are Dental Implants Right for You? Here’s What to Think About

Dental implants are now among the top solutions for those seeking to replace and improve their teeth. But are dental implants suitable for you? Here you will find out more about ...

Sunglasses don’t just look good – they’re good for you too. Here’s how to choose the right pair

Australians are exposed to some of the highest levels[1] of solar ultraviolet (UV) radiation in the world. While we tend to focus on avoiding UV damage to our skin, it’s impor...

How to Style the Pantone Color of the Year 2025 - Mocha Mousse

The Pantone Color of the Year never fails to set the tone for the coming year's design, fashion, and lifestyle trends. For 2025, Pantone has unveiled “Mocha Mousse,” a rich a...

How the Aussie summer has a profound effect on 'Climate Cravings’

Weather whiplash describes the rollercoaster-like shifts in weather we’ve experienced this summer —a blazing hot day one moment, followed by an unexpectedly chilly or rainy tur...

The heart research that could save fit and healthy Australians

Australians are now one step closer to being able to check that their heart is in working condition with a simple blood test. Leading scientists at the Heart Research Institu...

Times Magazine

Waave launches ‘Wallet’ for Pay by Bank with Australian-first biometric security

Payments technology and Open Banking leader Waave today announces the introduction of the Waave Wallet to house its upgraded Pay by Bank product, a real-time account-to-account payment method which now features industry-leading biometric security...

Abstract blues and cute otters – the unlikely art of Aussie love

Online dating site eharmony asked 12 regular Australians to paint what love and compatibility looked like, with a view to understanding if stereotypical symbols of love were still relevant, or if they varied greatly across ages and walks of life. ...

The Joy of Shopping for Fabric at Your Fingertips

Benefits of Online Fabric Shopping In today's world, the internet has changed how we shop for items. Shopping online has become a popular option for many consumers and one area that is gaining traction is online fabric shopping. There are several ...

Techniques Used in Pest Infestations

Pest infestations can be a frustrating reality for those residing in homes or other residential buildings. Residential pest control refers to the elimination or management of pests that can cause harm to individuals, property, or the environment. T...

PawPawUp: Pamper Your Pet

Got a lovely critter that makes you smile? Pets are great, however much like us, they need things to be happy and wholesome. That's in which PawPawUp is available! We offer a wide variety of awesome puppy supplies to hold your bushy (or feathery, o...

AURA BUY INVEST DONATE

Aura Buy Invest Donate, one of Australia’s newest cash back reward programs, is thrilled to announce Shell Coles Express as its Exclusive Fuel Partner, in a new deal that will see Aura Members receive money back into their Aura Investment Account...

LayBy Shopping