The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

Yes, we are a more equal society than most, but not quite as mobile as the Productivity Commission suggests. Here’s why

  • Written by Peter Siminski, Professor of Economics, University of Technology Sydney
Yes, we are a more equal society than most, but not quite as mobile as the Productivity Commission suggests. Here’s why

If you listened to the Productivity Commission, you would think Australia was a pretty equal place in terms of income and wealth, and particularly good in terms of equality of opportunity.

Its major investigation released last week, entitled Fairly Equal?[1], found Australia’s income mobility is second only to Switzerland’s.

It’s a high-quality piece of work, created by linking personal income tax, social security and census records and also linking records across generations. This allows the commission to examine how children fare compared to their parents.

The Australian Financial Review welcomed the findings by declaring they “surprised everyone[2]”, which certainly wasn’t true for researchers in the field.

They were broadly consistent with earlier[3] findings[4].

But the report largely neglects something important that is likely to matter a lot for equality and equality of opportunity.

It’s the role of housing.

Imputed rent matters

There are many ways to define income. The Productivity Commission defines it conventionally but narrowly, excluding so-called imputed rent[5].

Imputed rent can be thought of as the income someone gets from themselves for something they own, usually a home.

Set of keys
Homeowners can be thought of as renting to themselves. Shutterstock[6]

It’s easy to see if you think about landlords. The rent they receive from their tenants is income. If they happen to be their own tenants, paying notional rent to themselves, it remains a benefit and remains income for the purposes of the national accounts[7].

The Bureau of Statistics calculates imputed rent by applying market rents[8] to owner-occupied dwellings.

Imputed rent is often used in studies of inequality.

When it is, Australian incomes look more[9] equal[10] than when it is not. This is because older people tend to have low cash incomes but high imputed rents.

But more importantly, and more so for Australia than for the United States or Germany, including imputed rent lowers estimates of intergenerational mobility.

So far, only one Australian study has examined this. It finds that including imputed rent cuts Australia’s intergenerational mobility by 22%[11].

Although this finding should be interpreted cautiously, on the Productivity Commission’s intergenerational mobility graph it would make Australia more like Canada than Switzerland.

Capital gains matter

The Productivity Commission has also paid scant attention to capital gains.

In recent years property price increases have been so large that some houses have earned more than their owners have[12].

A definition of income that includes changes in net worth may also show Australia was less equal and less generationally mobile than generally thought.

I am working on incorporating changes in the value of housing into measures of inequality and mobility. I don’t yet have results I can share, but they might turn out to matter a lot.

Wealth matters in its own right

If we are really interested in intergenerational mobility (what chance we’ve got of getting a different financial station in life to our parents) it’s worth considering how easy it is to get to a different place in the wealth distribution as well as the income distribution.

Here, the results are mixed, and perhaps concerning.

The commission relies on a study that finds wealth mobility is higher in Australia than in the United States[13].

But those findings are driven by children aged 20-39. In Australia, the correlation between parental wealth and children’s wealth appears to grow stronger when those children reach middle age.

Indeed, from age 40 onwards wealth mobility becomes lower[14] in Australia than in other places including the US.

Again, there are reasons to interpret these findings cautiously. But they are enough – for now – to persuade us to be cautious in celebrating our apparently exceptional economic mobility.

And enough to encourage us to shift our focus from narrow measures of income towards broader measures of wellbeing, especially those that include housing.

Read more: Your parents' income doesn't determine yours – unless you're ultra rich or extremely poor[15]

References

  1. ^ Fairly Equal? (theconversation.com)
  2. ^ surprised everyone (www.afr.com)
  3. ^ earlier (www.sciencedirect.com)
  4. ^ findings (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  5. ^ imputed rent (www.definitions.net)
  6. ^ Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
  7. ^ national accounts (www.rba.gov.au)
  8. ^ applying market rents (www.abs.gov.au)
  9. ^ more (drive.google.com)
  10. ^ equal (static1.squarespace.com)
  11. ^ 22% (www.sciencedirect.com)
  12. ^ more than their owners have (www.smh.com.au)
  13. ^ in the United States (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  14. ^ lower (www.pc.gov.au)
  15. ^ Your parents' income doesn't determine yours – unless you're ultra rich or extremely poor (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/yes-we-are-a-more-equal-society-than-most-but-not-quite-as-mobile-as-the-productivity-commission-suggests-heres-why-234804

The Times Features

Amazon Australia and DoorDash announce two-year DashPass offer only for Prime members

New and existing Prime members in Australia can enjoy a two-year membership to DashPass for free, and gain access to AU$0 delivery fees on eligible DoorDash orders New offer co...

6 things to do if your child’s weight is beyond the ideal range – and 1 thing to avoid

One of the more significant challenges we face as parents is making sure our kids are growing at a healthy rate. To manage this, we take them for regular check-ups with our GP...

Joykids Australia Presents the Joykids Family Rave: A Weekend Adventure Like No Other

Get ready to kick off the first day of summer and the festive season with an unforgettable family adventure! Joykids Australia is excited to announce the Joykids Family Rave—an...

New study suggests weight loss drugs like Ozempic could help with knee pain. Here’s why there may be a link

The drug semaglutide, commonly known by the brand names Ozempic or Wegovy, was originally developed[1] to help people with type 2 diabetes manage their blood sugar levels. How...

Maintaining Your Pool After a Marble Interior Upgrade

After upgrading your pool with a marble interior, it’s crucial to understand that maintenance is key to preserving its elegance and longevity. You’ll want to regularly skim for d...

Labor using explanatory document to hide true powers of Misinformation Bill

The opinions and commentary of individuals could be deemed misinformation under Labor’s proposed legislation changes, according to James McComish of Victorian Bar. Appearing in...

Times Magazine

Lenovo announces comprehensive new hybrid AI portfolio at global Tech World event

Lenovo showcases end-to-end, responsible AI capabilities to fast-track AI adoption and innovation for individuals, enterprises, and entire industries—delivering Smarter AI for All Global technology leader Lenovo has unveiled the next phase of its ...

Cyber Insurance: What It Covers and Why It Matters

In today's digital environment, cyberattacks are becoming more frequent, making cybersecurity essential for businesses of all sizes. Cyber insurance has become a key resource for companies aiming to manage the financial fallout from these threats. T...

Lovely Blooms for Your Sweetheart on Valentine's Day

History of Valentine's Day Flowers Valentine’s Day is a special day of the year for many, as people show their affection for one another with gifts and kind words. One of the most popular items associated with this holiday is flowers, but do you k...

Truck Dealers Sales and Service: Get the Best Deals on Trucks Here

Looking for the best deals on trucks near you? Truck repair shops in Australia offer a range of services and sales options that can help you get the perfect truck for your needs.  Whether you're looking for a new or used one, these professional ...

Google Pixel 9 Pro XL: The Ultimate Flagship for Android Enthusiasts

The Google Pixel 9 Pro XL continues the Pixel tradition of delivering an unparalleled Android experience, blending Google's cutting-edge AI features with premium hardware. With advancements in both camera technology and overall performance, the Pixel...

Transform Your Vehicle with Car Wall Stickers

Welcome! Are you looking to add a unique touch to your home decor or spruce up a room in your house? Look no further than car wall stickers! Car wall stickers are the perfect way to bring a touch of nostalgia and fun to any space. Whether you're a ...