The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

Why NZ’s new housing rules risk cheap builds and shoebox apartments

  • Written by Christine McCarthy, Senior Lecturer in Interior Architecture, Te Herenga Waka — Victoria University of Wellington

There is a lot of good in Housing Minister Chris Bishop’s new housing policy[1] – especially in relation to mixed-use developments[2] and intensification along transit corridors[3]. But he has also proposed the abolition of minimum floor area and balcony requirements.

Will removing minimum dwelling sizes result in poor quality housing? The short answer is yes.

The minister has justified the minimum requirements by arguing any apartment, regardless of the size, will be bigger than a car or an emergency motel room[4].

Of course, he’s right about this. For those vulnerable to homelessness[5] and poor housing[6] – the poor, immigrants, pensioners, students and ex-prisoners, for example – a warm, dry shelter is vital. Anything is better than nothing for those without.

But there are risks to removing size regulations, even when it is meant to help solve New Zealand’s long-running housing crisis[7].

Small can work

Small does not necessarily mean bad. As the United Nations has noted[8], smaller units are often more sustainable. Other factors also determine the quality of living spaces. Overcrowded conditions, for example, can make a perfectly liveable space unviable.

There are numerous examples of high-quality small and micro-apartments – usually defined as being 14–32 square metres (sqm).

Take, for example, PKMN Architecture’s La Casa de Yolanda[9] (Madrid, 50 sqm), Graham Hill’s Life Edited Apartment[10] (SoHo, New York City, 39 sqm), Tsai Design’s Type Street Apartment[11] (Richmond, Australia, 33 sqm), Proctor and Shaw’s Shoji Apartment[12] (North London, 29 sqm), Brad Swartz’s Darlinghurst Apartment[13] (Sydney, 27 sqm), Takeshi Hosaka’s Love2 House[14] (Tokyo, 18 sqm), and A Little Design’s Taiwanese studio[15] (Taipei, 17.6 sqm).

But these are all architect-designed and expensive. They often use generous room heights to create a sense of spaciousness. On top of that, many require owners to have sufficient strength to move walls or unfold furniture to transform a room from, say, a bedroom into a living room.

That could be ideal for the proverbial young professional, living much of their lives outside their flat, or for the short-term rental market. But it doesn’t work as well for families or older people.

Small apartment with murphy bed
Small apartments can suit young professionals. But this may not be the best solution for many New Zealanders. John Carl D'Annibale /Getty Images[16]

The fear of shoebox apartments

A lack of minimum regulations can also cause unintended consequences.

In Melbourne, loose regulations[17] resulted in “saddleback bedrooms” – where long thin light corridors (or “snorkels”) were built to access the required external windows. Bedrooms became reliant on borrowed light from other rooms.

Using borrowed light is now banned[18] there, and snorkels have restrictions.

Auckland’s late 20th century shoebox apartments[19] were built as small as 12 sqm[20] – smaller than many of the motel rooms Bishop uses to justify abandoning minimum dwelling sizes.

These apartments led to the introduction of New Zealand’s minimum size requirements in the early 2000s.

Existing protections

New Zealand’s building code[21] requires “adequate” openings for natural light, with illuminance of no less than 30 lux at floor level (for 75% of the time) – 30 lux being the equivalent of the light from 30 candles.

Openings must be transparent, suitably located and provide awareness of the outside.

Councils have different, but often similar, requirements for interior spaces. For example, Wellington’s District Plan’s Residential Design Guide[22] requires dwellings get at least four hours sun in the main living room during the winter.

All habitable rooms must have natural light, rooms must be large enough for furniture, and circulation and windows must be placed for privacy.

The guide also requires that sleeping areas are shielded from external noises. These safeguards will mean there is a minimum quality for new apartments even if they are small. But it will also require political will from local government to ensure these safeguards are mantained.

Building for future risks

The real question, though, is whether the new policy will protect New Zealand long term – when the full wrath of climate change hits, or during any lockdown when the inevitable next pandemic[23] emerges.

New Zealand needs homes offering longevity and resilience, as well as compassion for when we are most vulnerable. Cramped spaces are not great for mental well-being[24].

Housing rules need to be cognisant of infrastructure needs for a changing climate and decades of network neglect. This will be a challenge. Under the proposed policy, councils will not be able to refuse a development on the grounds that infrastructure costs are too high[25].

So yes, these changes will undoubtedly increase housing supply – but we need to ask if these builds are fit for purpose. There needs to be a balance between the very real need for more houses on one hand, and the need to preserve adequate dwelling standards on the other.

References

  1. ^ new housing policy (wellington.scoop.co.nz)
  2. ^ mixed-use developments (www.voanews.com)
  3. ^ intensification along transit corridors (www.rnz.co.nz)
  4. ^ car or an emergency motel room (www.beehive.govt.nz)
  5. ^ homelessness (www.thepeoplesproject.org.nz)
  6. ^ poor housing (www.parliament.nz)
  7. ^ long-running housing crisis (www.rnz.co.nz)
  8. ^ United Nations has noted (sustainableconsumption.usdn.org)
  9. ^ La Casa de Yolanda (www.archdaily.com)
  10. ^ Life Edited Apartment (www.idesignarch.com)
  11. ^ Type Street Apartment (assemblepapers.com.au)
  12. ^ Shoji Apartment (www.nevertoosmall.com)
  13. ^ Darlinghurst Apartment (www.archdaily.com)
  14. ^ Love2 House (www.archdaily.com)
  15. ^ Taiwanese studio (arqa.com)
  16. ^ John Carl D'Annibale /Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com.au)
  17. ^ loose regulations (www.smh.com.au)
  18. ^ now banned (www.planning.vic.gov.au)
  19. ^ shoebox apartments (www.1news.co.nz)
  20. ^ 12 sqm (mangeredevelopment.co.nz)
  21. ^ building code (www.legislation.govt.nz)
  22. ^ Residential Design Guide (wellington.govt.nz)
  23. ^ inevitable next pandemic (theconversation.com)
  24. ^ mental well-being (www.verywellmind.com)
  25. ^ infrastructure costs are too high (www.beehive.govt.nz)

Read more https://theconversation.com/size-matters-why-nzs-new-housing-rules-risk-cheap-builds-and-shoebox-apartments-234162

The Times Features

What are physician assistants? Can they fix the doctor shortage?

If you’ve tried to get an appointment to see a GP or specialist recently, you will likely have felt the impact of Australia’s doctor shortages[1]. To alleviate workforce sho...

Do men and women agree on how easy it is for each other to find a job or a date?

Typically, you don’t have to write a cover letter before attending a candlelit dinner. But there are some eerie emotional parallels between finding a job and finding a date. ...

Australia’s clinical guidelines shape our health care. Why do so many still ignore sex and gender?

You’ve heard of the gender pay gap. What about the gap in medical care? Cardiovascular diseases – which can lead to heart attack and stroke – are one of the leading causes[1...

Don't Get Burned—Smart Insurance for Your Investment Property

Real estate investment offers lucrative opportunities even though it brings operational risks. Real estate investment protection fundamentally depends on obtaining the correct insu...

Why it’s important to actively choose the music for your mood

Many of us take pleasure in listening to music[1]. Music accompanies important life events and lubricates social encounters. It represents aspects of our existing identity, a...

The Link Between Heart Health and Ageing Well

Millions of Australians are at risk of heart disease, but fewer realise that keeping their heart healthy can also help protect their brain, memory, and cognitive function, redu...

Times Magazine

Improving Website Performance with a Cloud VPS

Websites represent the new mantra of success. One slow website may make escape for visitors along with income too. Therefore it's an extra offer to businesses seeking better performance with more scalability and, thus represents an added attracti...

Why You Should Choose Digital Printing for Your Next Project

In the rapidly evolving world of print media, digital printing has emerged as a cornerstone technology that revolutionises how businesses and creative professionals produce printed materials. Offering unparalleled flexibility, speed, and quality, d...

What to Look for When Booking an Event Space in Melbourne

Define your event needs early to streamline venue selection and ensure a good fit. Choose a well-located, accessible venue with good transport links and parking. Check for key amenities such as catering, AV equipment, and flexible seating. Pla...

How BIM Software is Transforming Architecture and Engineering

Building Information Modeling (BIM) software has become a cornerstone of modern architecture and engineering practices, revolutionizing how professionals design, collaborate, and execute projects. By enabling more efficient workflows and fostering ...

How 32-Inch Computer Monitors Can Increase Your Workflow

With the near-constant usage of technology around the world today, ergonomics have become crucial in business. Moving to 32 inch computer monitors is perhaps one of the best and most valuable improvements you can possibly implement. This-sized moni...

Top Tips for Finding a Great Florist for Your Sydney Wedding

While the choice of wedding venue does much of the heavy lifting when it comes to wowing guests, decorations are certainly not far behind. They can add a bit of personality and flair to the traditional proceedings, as well as enhancing the venue’s ...

LayBy Shopping