The Times Australia
The Times World News

.

Australia’s first civilian jury was entirely female. Here’s how ‘juries of matrons’ shaped our legal history

  • Written by Alice Neikirk, Program Convenor, Criminology, University of Newcastle
Australia’s first civilian jury was entirely female. Here’s how ‘juries of matrons’ shaped our legal history

It’s hard to imagine now, but for almost 1,000 years, pregnant women in England could avoid the death penalty just by virtue of being pregnant. A pregnant woman sentenced to death would receive a stay of execution until the baby was born. It was called “pleading the belly” and often resulted the death sentence being reduced to a less severe penalty once the pregnancy was over.

Of course, anyone could say they’re pregnant without actually being with child. So how did courts determine whether it was true?

It was standard practice to assemble all-female juries, called “juries of matrons”, to determine whether a woman was pregnant and could therefore avoid hanging for capital offences. These were also features of Australia’s colonial legal system, with juries of matrons being used in trials until the early 1900s.

Exploring the history of these juries reveals how the roles of women in our legal systems have changed over time. It also shows a shift in beliefs about who is an expert in the female body, and who gets to make decisions about it.

Highly regarded medical experts

All-female juries existed as early as 1140 in England and persisted until 1931. Their role in the courts was highly regarded. They were medical experts[1]. If they found the woman was “quick with child[2]” (pregnant), their findings were not disputed.

In addition to determining whether a woman was pregnant, they helped evaluate inheritance claims, examined females to determine whether they bore the physical marks of witchcraft[3], and decide whether a woman accused of infanticide had given birth[4]. They provided expert medical testimony for the courts but were not necessarily midwives.

A black and white drawing of twelve women in turn of the century dress with various expressions on their faces.
This cartoon, imagining what women on juries would look like, was published in Life Magazine in the US in 1902. Charles Dana Gibson, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons[5]

These women were respectable, law-abiding women. Similar to their male counterparts, serving on a jury was a high-status privilege. There is evidence that from 1233 until 1435 in Newcastle upon Tyne, an official pool of matrons[6] existed. They held an appointed position in the court.

Australia’s first civilian jury

Historically, we tend think of juries as only being comprised of males, yet these all-female juries also existed in colonial America and in Australia and New Zealand until the early 1900s. In fact, Australia’s first civilian jury was an all-female jury of matrons.

In 1789, Ann Davis was found guilty of stealing items of clothing. This theft was a capital offence. She “pleaded the belly”.

An all-female jury of matrons was convened to assess her claims, marking the first time a civilian jury was used in Australia. More than 200 years ago, the 76-year-old forewoman of that jury found, “Gentlemen! She is as much with child as I am[7]”. Her plea unsuccessful, Davis became the first woman hung in Australia.

Another notable example of pleading the belly was Elizabeth McGree in South Australia. In 1883 she was charged with killing a man. The “powerfully built man” had been drinking with her husband that evening. After the husband passed out drunk, the man left the house, only to return in the early hours of the morning.

A clip put of the telegrams section of an old newspaper An extract of the Border Watch newspaper from Mount Gambier on December 23 1882, discussing McGree’s case. Border Watch/National Library of Australia[8]

The forensic evidence demonstrated[9] he kicked in the door, strangling McGree while also attempting to rape her. McGree’s 12-year-old son hit the man on the head with a hammer in an effort to stop the assault. After the initial blow, McGree started to beat the man with the hammer (who got up after her son’s first blow and wandered outside, promising not to touch her again) and stabbed him with a knife.

McGree was found guilty, despite the forensic evidence, largely because she allowed the man to drink liquor at the house with her husband. She was sentenced to hang.

Once found guilty, she pleaded the belly and a jury of matrons was called. They determined she was “quick with child”, and she dodged the noose[10]. She later gave birth to her child in Gladstone Prison. Her death sentence was commuted to ten years.

Read more: Health care offered to women in prison should match community standards – and their rights[11]

If the pregnancy resulted in birth, a reprieve from the noose was fairly common. This raised the concern among men that women might falsely plead the belly to avoid a capital offence. They worried a jury of matrons, being “naturally” sympathetic, might grant them a reprieve from death.

While there is scant evidence this was the case, to address this concern, the laws around pleading the belly stipulated this plea could only be made once. If a pregnant woman was granted a reprieve from death to have the baby, she could be executed for any future crime – even if pregnant.

Women “too irrational” for courts

By the late 1800s, suspicion that juries of matrons were “soft” and that women were abusing the belly plea merged with concerns[12] that women were “too irrational, too burdened by suckling infants, too sexually ignorant or too easily corrupted by sexual knowledge” to have a role in courts.

These concerns, along with the rise of medical professionals[13] and the invention of the stethoscope[14], shifted the balance of power away from the jury of matrons and towards male medical officers.

Who had expert knowledge of the female body shifted. Until this point, women determined whether the fetus was alive by examining the women and feeling for signs of fetal movement or “quickening”. Quickening[15] was considered the moment the fetus becomes animated with a soul, and thus fully human.

A historical drawing of four female bodies next to each other showing the growth of the womb in a pregnant woman Women were historically the ones deciding the stages of pregnancy, but that responsibility eventually moved to doctors. Jacques Pierre Maygrier/Wellcome Collection, CC BY[16][17]

Now, the stethoscope could detect a fetal heartbeat. This was considered a more reliable method of establishing pregnancy.

The jury of matrons disappeared from the courts in Australia. It was another 50 years before women in Australia would be allowed to serve on juries[18]. Progress, in terms of female representation, is rarely linear.

Juries of matrons were an extraordinary example of women having an official role[19] in a justice system otherwise dominated by men. The examples of women pleading the belly provide a glimpse the role and interactions women had in Australia’s early legal systems.

References

  1. ^ medical experts (first100years.org.uk)
  2. ^ quick with child (amazingwomeninhistory.com)
  3. ^ witchcraft (www.famous-trials.com)
  4. ^ infanticide had given birth (law.jrank.org)
  5. ^ Charles Dana Gibson, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (commons.wikimedia.org)
  6. ^ official pool of matrons (www.cambridge.org)
  7. ^ Gentlemen! She is as much with child as I am (convictrecords.com.au)
  8. ^ Border Watch/National Library of Australia (trove.nla.gov.au)
  9. ^ forensic evidence demonstrated (trove.nla.gov.au)
  10. ^ noose (www.digitalpanopticon.org)
  11. ^ Health care offered to women in prison should match community standards – and their rights (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ with concerns (insidestory.org.au)
  13. ^ rise of medical professionals (womenshistorynetwork.org)
  14. ^ stethoscope (www.lung.org)
  15. ^ Quickening (www.historynewsnetwork.org)
  16. ^ Jacques Pierre Maygrier/Wellcome Collection (wellcomecollection.org)
  17. ^ CC BY (creativecommons.org)
  18. ^ serve on juries (www.themonthly.com.au)
  19. ^ official role (www.taylorfrancis.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/australias-first-civilian-jury-was-entirely-female-heres-how-juries-of-matrons-shaped-our-legal-history-229283

Times Magazine

Exploring The Wonderful World of Moss Sheets

A lovely addition to any house or garden purely is moss sheets. They are very adaptable and available in a wide range of hues and textures. Moss sheets are a fantastic way to bring a little bit of nature within or outside. The simplicity of use of ...

Protect Your Vehicle with a Quality Metal Carport

Advantages of Choosing Metal Carports When you are looking for a way to protect your vehicles from the elements, one of the best options is a metal carport. Metal carport kits in Melbourne offer a variety of advantages over other types of carport...

Prestons ranked Australia’s worst suburb for parcel theft

Shocking new data reveals that parcel theft claims have more than doubled this year, with Prestons in New South Wales named the worst suburb. This year there’s been a 59% increase in claims for parcel loss with a wider range of people lodging ...

Categories of Dragon Sculptures

Dragon sculptures have been a symbol of power, strength, and protection for countless cultures throughout history, ranging from China to Europe. These intricate works of art are often used to infuse a touch of the mystical into homes or gardens and...

JOLT, Australia’s first free electric vehicle charging network

Seedooh charges up with JOLT   JOLT, Australia’s first free electric vehicle charging network, has partnered with purpose-built technology platform Seedooh to verify all advertising campaigns running across its new 100% Digital Out of Home netw...

Alcohol and your brain: study finds even moderate drinking is damaging

It’s a well-known fact that drinking too much alcohol can have a serious impact on your health, including damaging your liver. But how much is too much? For conditions such as liver cirrhosis, that’s usually more than 21 units of alcohol a we...