The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

If we do it right, we can replant trees and shrubs to store carbon – and restore biodiversity

  • Written by Rachel Standish, Associate Professor, Murdoch University
If we do it right, we can replant trees and shrubs to store carbon – and restore biodiversity

This is how carbon farming works. Farmers plant trees on abandoned farmland. The trees take in carbon from the atmosphere as they grow, acting as a natural sink to offset some emissions. For farmers, these carbon-storing plants pay off with carbon credits.

It sounds simple. But in recent years, the technique has come under fire[1] over claims the approach is not delivering the carbon credits required to offset Australia’s carbon emissions.

This comes amid a broader crisis of confidence[2] in carbon offsets and credits.

As a restoration scientist, I believe it’s good the industry gets more scrutiny. But we should not write off carbon farming. If done properly, carbon farming can also restore lost habitat and help tackle the global biodiversity crisis. As Earth loses more and more species, large-scale restoration is now essential.

We know keeping existing habitat and restoring degraded land to habitat will benefit 86%[3] of the over 1,300 threatened species in Australia. At one well-run carbon farming initiative in southwestern Australia, for instance, we saw a rare malleefowl – a bird that is exceptionally fussy about where it lives.

two scientists looking at their revegetation project
Restoration scientists Suzanne Prober and Tina Parkhurst contemplate a biodiverse carbon project 10 years after planting in south-western Australia. Rachel Standish, CC BY-ND[4]

Carbon farming can be a win-win – if done right

There are good and bad ways to do carbon farming. It’s wrong to claim credits for the growth of native remnant vegetation caused by rainfall, for instance, rather than regrowth after ending livestock grazing or other deliberate human intervention. It’s also wrong to claim credits for “avoided deforestation” – leaving vegetation intact when it was never intended to be cleared. We should also avoid planting trees in grasslands, which have their own set of species and should not be replaced.

Some carbon farming efforts have been run like plantations, where you plant a single fast-growing species such as blue mallee. The assumption here[5] is monocultures like this store more carbon than a mix of species.

But we and other researchers have found this isn’t the case. Planting a diverse range of trees – like in a real forest – can store just as much carbon[6] as monocultures.

Shrubs store less carbon than trees but play an important role in restoration. Their tangle of branches and leaves can offer safe harbour for smaller birds, for instance. Shrubs also boost projects’ resilience[7] to drought and fire as they respond differently, which helps in recovery.

There would be no penalty to farmers for planting shrubs if the government’s planned nature repair market[8] comes into force. Biodiverse projects could earn both carbon and biodiversity credits.

This would open the door to a win-win. Carbon-farming efforts could double as nature restoration projects, if we avoid tree monocultures and focus on restoring biodiversity while storing carbon. Australia has 13 million hectares of degraded land[9], meaning there’s plenty of room for restoration without taking farmland or compromising agricultural production.

Australia could benefit

As critics of carbon farming have pointed out, carbon credits from tree planting can be rubbery. But we shouldn’t tar all projects with the same brush.

In Australia, a number of companies are offering high-integrity carbon credits from biodiverse native tree planting projects, such as Carbon Positive Australia[10] and Greening Australia[11].

Nature restoration[12] is likely to become more attractive to investors because of the potential for growth in natural capital and employment.

As much as restoration is needed, so too is ongoing care such as feral animal control and leaving remnant vegetation intact[13].

Read more: Australia’s central climate policy pays people to grow trees that already existed. Taxpayers – and the environment – deserve better[14]

Climate change is, unfortunately, threatening the environmental restoration which can help reduce its effects. In dryland Australia, drought makes it harder for seedlings to survive[15] and for trees or shrubs to grow well even once established[16].

While many of Australia’s native plants are tough enough to weather fires, more frequent fires make it harder to bounce back. Plants need time between fires to grow rootstock and develop seed banks.

vista of tree revegetation and blue sky We have been researching how mixed-species revegetation efforts store carbon at the University of Western Australia’s research farm Ridgefield. Rachel Standish, CC BY-ND[17]

Biodiversity matters

When we talk about biodiversity, we’re talking about the richness of life.

To date, Australia’s carbon farming efforts vary a great deal in how they protect biodiversity. Think of the difference in walking through a blue mallee or sugar gum plantation – where there are few birds or other species – compared to walking through a patch of native forest. Some carbon farms can be diverse[18].

Restoration efforts which attract more species will come to function[19] more like a true native ecosystem typical of their region.

This is not to say restoration work is easy. Turning a weed-filled paddock worn down by decades of agricultural use is tough[20]. Even native species such as kangaroos and emus can become challenges by eating seedlings.

Treating experimentation as part of practice and publicly reporting successes and failures can help the industry progress. For instance, our restoration research has found native shrubs return[21] if given the chance – but not understorey species.

In defence of carbon farming

Carbon farming is new. While some efforts may well be aimed at gaming the system, there are many others genuinely seeking ways of using nature to store the carbon we’ve released into the atmosphere. As this new approach progresses, there will be failures. But a failure is not necessarily greenwashing.

And as Australia, like many other nations[22], sets ambitious restoration targets to protect 30% of land and sea[23] by 2030, we will need to experiment, innovate, work alongside Traditional Owners and plan to be there for the long term.

We are already seeing hopeful signs restoration work does yield benefits for at least some species, such as ants[24] and woodland birds[25].

Restoration can work: for us, for climate and for our species. Let’s make sure it does work.

Read more: Here's how to fix Australia's approach to soil carbon credits so they really count towards our climate goals[26]

References

  1. ^ come under fire (theconversation.com)
  2. ^ broader crisis of confidence (www.wsj.com)
  3. ^ will benefit 86% (www.sciencedirect.com)
  4. ^ CC BY-ND (creativecommons.org)
  5. ^ assumption here (www.csiro.au)
  6. ^ can store just as much carbon (www.sciencedirect.com)
  7. ^ boost projects’ resilience (besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  8. ^ nature repair market (www.dcceew.gov.au)
  9. ^ 13 million hectares of degraded land (besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  10. ^ Carbon Positive Australia (carbonpositiveaustralia.org.au)
  11. ^ Greening Australia (www.greeningaustralia.org.au)
  12. ^ Nature restoration (www.bkconnection.com)
  13. ^ remnant vegetation intact (grist.org)
  14. ^ Australia’s central climate policy pays people to grow trees that already existed. Taxpayers – and the environment – deserve better (theconversation.com)
  15. ^ seedlings to survive (link.springer.com)
  16. ^ grow well even once established (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  17. ^ CC BY-ND (creativecommons.org)
  18. ^ can be diverse (nph.onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  19. ^ will come to function (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  20. ^ is tough (esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  21. ^ native shrubs return (besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  22. ^ many other nations (www.decadeonrestoration.org)
  23. ^ protect 30% of land and sea (theconversation.com)
  24. ^ ants (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  25. ^ woodland birds (besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  26. ^ Here's how to fix Australia's approach to soil carbon credits so they really count towards our climate goals (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/if-we-do-it-right-we-can-replant-trees-and-shrubs-to-store-carbon-and-restore-biodiversity-216734

The Times Features

Spousal Maintenance in Australia: What Divorcing Couples Must Know

Divorce rates in Australia have seen fluctuations over the years, highlighting the importance of a comprehensive understanding of financial obligations post-separation. Spousal...

Australians increasingly turn to AI chatbots for holiday shopping

Chatbots are changing how we shop, from the way we select a gift, virtually try on clothes, scan the best deals and visually search for items through Google lens. Amazon is now...

Reforms fast tracking overseas medical specialists risk lives and fail to solve shortage of surgeons in the bush

The Urological Society of Australia and New Zealand (USANZ) is warning moves to fast track overseas trained medical specialists coming to work in Australia will do little to im...

What Is IVF And When Should We Consider It?

Starting a family is a big dream for many people, but for some, it can be difficult. When natural pregnancy is not possible, medical treatments can help. One such treatment that ...

BBC Studios Executes Global Deal to Bring Bluey to Worldwide Cinemas in 2027

BBC Studios and The Walt Disney Company today announced the first-ever animated feature film for ’Bluey’, the beloved Emmy® and BAFTA Award-winning animated series that is 2024...

2025 bookings for the Paintrock Canyon Ranch open

Ranchlands is excited to announce that 2025 bookings for the Paintrock Canyon Ranch, nestled at the western base of the Bighorn Mountains in Wyoming, are now open. The Paintroc...

Times Magazine

Dog Yog Launches Delicious New Range of Snoopy Products

Melbourne-based company Dog Yog is making doggy dreams come true everywhere with their new, delicious collaboration with Peanuts™ featuring the world’s most famous beagle, Snoopy. The new, tasty range includes a dog-friendly ice cream, available...

Abstract blues and cute otters – the unlikely art of Aussie love

Online dating site eharmony asked 12 regular Australians to paint what love and compatibility looked like, with a view to understanding if stereotypical symbols of love were still relevant, or if they varied greatly across ages and walks of life. ...

Everything You Need to Know About Solar Panel Savings

Last year, the U.S. recorded its highest amount of renewable energy usage. It comes at a time where climate change has become an increasing factor in society. To help the Earth, more people have switched to renewable energy sources because they ...

The Seamless Transition from Blogs to AI-Enhanced Videos

The stuff we see and do online keeps changing because new technologies and websites pop up. We use different things like words, pictures, sounds, and videos. Blogs are one of the oldest and coolest ways people share their thoughts online. They us...

Understanding Different Types of Child Care

In New South Wales, Australia, parents are faced with a myriad of choices when it comes to child care. From long daycare centres to family daycares, preschools, and occasional care services, each option offers its own set of benefits and considerat...

Rental Car Accidents: Key Steps to Take Right After a Crash

Rental Car Accidents: Key Steps to Take Right After a Crash The Immediate Aftermath of a Rental Car Accident When the unexpected happens, and you're involved in a rental car accident, the moments immediately following the crash are crucial. S...

LayBy Shopping