The Times Australia
The Times World News

.

Why the 'drug dealers defence' doesn't work for exporting coal. It's actually Economics 101

  • Written by John Quiggin, Professor, School of Economics, The University of Queensland
Why the 'drug dealers defence' doesn't work for exporting coal. It's actually Economics 101

In defending a Federal Court case brought by opponents of her decisions to approve two export coal mines, Environment Minister Tanya Plibersek[1] is relying in part on what critics call the “drug dealer’s defence[2]”.

It’s reasoning that argues: if we don’t sell this product, someone else will[3].

Prime Minister Albanese has argued the same thing, telling The Australian[4]

policies that would just result in a replacement of Australian resources with resources that are less clean from other countries would lead to an increase in global emissions, not a decrease.

Albanese’s reasoning is that saying no to new Australian coal mines wouldn’t cut global emissions, it would just produce “less economic activity in Australia”.

If it sounds like a familiar argument, it is – past prime ministers[5] and the coal industry[6] have made similar claims for decades.

It’s possible to test this argument using economics, putting to one side the question of whether it is morally justifiable.

The defence works for drug dealers

Let’s look at how this defence works with retail drug dealers, many of whom are drug users themselves.

Street-level drug dealing is a job that doesn’t require much skill and pays above the minimum wage, even after allowing for the risk of arrest.

As a result, as soon as one dealer is arrested, someone will enter the market to replace the dealer. For this reason, drug policy has shifted away from traditional modes of street-level enforcement and towards community partnerships[7].

But coal is different. Global markets are supplied by a range of producers, each with different costs. Some mines can cover their costs even when world prices are low, others require very high world coal prices to break even.

In the case of metallurgical[8] (coking) coal used to make steel, Australia’s mines are mostly at the low-cost end of the spectrum as shown below:

Indicative hard coking coal supply curve by mine, 2019

Notes: ‘Free on Board’ prices, meaning the buyer accepts the title at the shipment point. The cost curves account for variable production costs, overburden removal, royalties, inland transportation and port usage fees. International Energy Agency[9]

Thermal coal, used in electricity generation, is more complex, since much of the variation in price relates to its quality, rather than extraction cost.

Nevertheless, the fact remains that if one producer withdraws from the market or reduces output, it is highly unlikely to be replaced by an identical-cost producer.

It is likely instead to be replaced by a higher-cost supplier who needs a higher price to cover its costs. That’ll make the coal less attractive to the buyer who would have bought from the low-cost producer, making that buyer likely to buy less of it.

This is Economics 101, illustrated in the supply and demand diagrams in just about every economics textbook[10].

Why Australia’s coal matters globally

In most markets, the demand curve is downward sloping, meaning the higher the price, the less the buyer wants.

Fifth Wheel Freight, Supply and Demand in the Transportation Industry[11] And in most markets, the supply curve is upward sloping, meaning the higher the price, the more the seller is prepared to sell. What’s bought, and for how much, depends on where those curves meet. Fifth Wheel Freight, Supply and Demand in the Transportation Industry[12] If the supply curve moves up, because the cost of supply has increased, the price at which the good is bought will move up and the quantity bought will move down. In the figure below, the supply curve S1 is the current global supply. If Australia supplies less coal, the supply curve will shift from S1 to S2, resulting in the higher price P2. The higher price will result in increased supply from competitors, but also a reduction in the total amount consumed, a cut from Q1 to Q2. Fifth Wheel Freight, Supply and Demand in the Transportation Industry[13] This means that, contrary to government claims, our decisions will have an impact on global emissions and ultimately on global heating Moreover, Australian decisions aren’t isolated. All around the world, governments, financial institutions and civil society groups are grappling with the need to transition away from coal. Proposals for new and expanded coal mines and coal-fired power stations face resistance at every step. In particular, the great majority of global banks and insurance companies now refuse to finance and insure new coal. This means that the long-run response to a reduction in Australia’s supply of coal will involve less substitution and more of a drop in use than might be thought. For coal, the drug dealer’s defence is shoddy It makes the drug dealers defence for exporting coal especially shoddy. It would be open to Plibersek to make another argument: that in the government’s political judgement, Australians are not willing to wear the short-run costs of a transition from coal, regardless of the impact on the global climate manifested every day in bushfires, floods and environmental destruction. But instead, we are being told that if Australia cuts supply, other suppliers will rush in, without being told about their costs and what will happen next. In markets like coal, with a fixed number of suppliers facing different costs, demand responds to the withdrawal of supply in the way the economics textbooks say it should. Read more: Yes, Environment Minister Tanya Plibersek approved a coal mine. But save the angst for decisions that matter more[14] References^ Tanya Plibersek (thewest.com.au)^ drug dealer’s defence (www.thesaturdaypaper.com.au)^ if we don’t sell this product, someone else will (johnmenadue.com)^ The Australian (www.theaustralian.com.au)^ prime ministers (www.theguardian.com)^ industry (www.smh.com.au)^ community partnerships (www.campbellcollaboration.org)^ metallurgical (www.bhp.com)^ International Energy Agency (www.iea.org)^ economics textbook (www.core-econ.org)^ Fifth Wheel Freight, Supply and Demand in the Transportation Industry (www.fwf.com)^ Fifth Wheel Freight, Supply and Demand in the Transportation Industry (www.fwf.com)^ Fifth Wheel Freight, Supply and Demand in the Transportation Industry (www.fwf.com)^ Yes, Environment Minister Tanya Plibersek approved a coal mine. But save the angst for decisions that matter more (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/why-the-drug-dealers-defence-doesnt-work-for-exporting-coal-its-actually-economics-101-214588

Times Magazine

Headless CMS in Digital Twins and 3D Product Experiences

Image by freepik As the metaverse becomes more advanced and accessible, it's clear that multiple sectors will use digital twins and 3D product experiences to visualize, connect, and streamline efforts better. A digital twin is a virtual replica of ...

The Decline of Hyper-Casual: How Mid-Core Mobile Games Took Over in 2025

In recent years, the mobile gaming landscape has undergone a significant transformation, with mid-core mobile games emerging as the dominant force in app stores by 2025. This shift is underpinned by changing user habits and evolving monetization tr...

Understanding ITIL 4 and PRINCE2 Project Management Synergy

Key Highlights ITIL 4 focuses on IT service management, emphasising continual improvement and value creation through modern digital transformation approaches. PRINCE2 project management supports systematic planning and execution of projects wit...

What AI Adoption Means for the Future of Workplace Risk Management

Image by freepik As industrial operations become more complex and fast-paced, the risks faced by workers and employers alike continue to grow. Traditional safety models—reliant on manual oversight, reactive investigations, and standardised checklist...

From Beach Bops to Alpine Anthems: Your Sonos Survival Guide for a Long Weekend Escape

Alright, fellow adventurers and relaxation enthusiasts! So, you've packed your bags, charged your devices, and mentally prepared for that glorious King's Birthday long weekend. But hold on, are you really ready? Because a true long weekend warrior kn...

Effective Commercial Pest Control Solutions for a Safer Workplace

Keeping a workplace clean, safe, and free from pests is essential for maintaining productivity, protecting employee health, and upholding a company's reputation. Pests pose health risks, can cause structural damage, and can lead to serious legal an...

The Times Features

The Role of Your GP in Creating a Chronic Disease Management Plan That Works

Living with a long-term condition, whether that is diabetes, asthma, arthritis or heart disease, means making hundreds of small decisions every day. You plan your diet against m...

Troubleshooting Flickering Lights: A Comprehensive Guide for Homeowners

Image by rawpixel.com on Freepik Effectively addressing flickering lights in your home is more than just a matter of convenience; it's a pivotal aspect of both home safety and en...

My shins hurt after running. Could it be shin splints?

If you’ve started running for the first time, started again after a break, or your workout is more intense, you might have felt it. A dull, nagging ache down your shins after...

Metal Roof Replacement Cost Per Square Metre in 2025: A Comprehensive Guide for Australian Homeowners

In recent years, the trend of installing metal roofs has surged across Australia. With their reputation for being both robust and visually appealing, it's easy to understand thei...

Why You’re Always Adjusting Your Bra — and What to Do Instead

Image by freepik It starts with a gentle tug, then a subtle shift, and before you know it, you're adjusting your bra again — in the middle of work, at dinner, even on the couch. I...

How to Tell If Your Eyes Are Working Harder Than They Should Be

Image by freepik Most of us take our vision for granted—until it starts to let us down. Whether it's squinting at your phone, rubbing your eyes at the end of the day, or feeling ...