The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

How hate speech during the Voice campaign can harm personal wellbeing, as well as democracy

  • Written by Paul Komesaroff, Professor of Medicine, Monash University

Last week, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese announced[1] Australia will vote in the Voice referendum on October 14.

When the proposal for a Voice to Parliament was first put forward in the Uluru Statement from the Heart[2], it was mostly welcomed[3] as an invitation to Australians to come together.

The subsequent announcement[4] of a referendum brought hope and history into alignment for a possible process of reconciliation – just as occurred with the 1967 referendum.

It was recognised that opinions would differ, but there was confidence these could be resolved through considered dialogue.

Now, however, we are seeing[5] increases[6] in racism[7] and hardening of entrenched positions instead of respectful dialogue[8].

Where we need trustworthy analysis of and commentary on the proposed Voice, and careful, respectful discussion, there has been a torrent of misinformation, personal criticisms and even abuse[9].

Read more: How we can avoid political misinformation in the lead-up to the Voice referendum[10]

Misinformation has multiplied

There have been claims and “theories” unleashed through the media, campaigning and social media that are often unverifiable and of uncertain origin. The surfacing of Donald Trump-style conspiracies has severed the link between political claims and established standards of truth[11].

We’ve heard claims such as the Voice would somehow lead to reparations[12] for Aboriginal people or a new “Black State[13]”. It has also been argued Australia Day will be abolished[14] and the courts would be overwhelmed[15] with claims from the Voice. Although there is no evidence for such claims, and a lot of them have been disproven, they have the potential to sow confusion and reap distrust of the proposed Voice.

However, the most concerning are the conspiracy claims[16] and personal attacks against First Nations individuals[17] and groups.

There have been calls for blood tests[18] to verify Aboriginal heritage, and even accusations that some people darken their skin[19] to gain some kind of advantage. These inflammatory claims have focused on undermining the validity of First Nations people, securing political advantage regardless of the truth.

It is our argument that many of these attributions qualify as “hate speech”. Hate speech[20] is written or spoken communication that incites discrimination, prejudice or hatred based on race, ethnicity, religion, gender or other characteristics. The damage hate speech can cause is well established[21]. Harms include the normalisation and more frequent occurrence of deliberate derogatory, discriminatory and dishonest speech.

Hate speech can cause physical and psychological harm

Hate speech causes harm at a social level, as it can worsen and even promote intolerance, divisiveness and hostility towards its targets. It hinders[22] public discussion by using polarising and exaggerated claims, disrupting any chance of civil discussion. At its most extreme it can lead to the large-scale collapse of law and order, and catastrophic social division[23], as we have seen in the United States, and even overt political violence, as in the assault on the Washington Capitol[24].

At the individual level, evidence shows hate speech can also cause physical and psychological[25] injury[26], including increased risk[27] of stress-related illnesses. Hate speech can cause fear and anxiety, leading to social exclusion and isolation[28]. It can also lead to discrimination becoming normalised[29] and accepted.

It is true our democracy has become increasingly fragile. Political debates can easily be distorted or compromised. Access to reliable information cannot always be assumed. Particular voices can be excluded systematically from public discussions[30] – traditionally, the voices of women and minority groups.

The undermining of the Voice debate has far-reaching and potentially dangerous consequences. The apparent inability of the nation to conduct a reasoned, respectful debate about an issue central to its collective identity will likely inflict lasting damage[31] on our society. It will undermine confidence in public institutions, the legitimacy of government and social policies.

These are not extreme predictions. We have already seen how the questioning of health policy by some groups during the COVID emergency in some states led to actual violence[32]. Overseas, examples of the breakdown of civil order[33] have become common.

But it’s not too late to change course

It is important the debate be depoliticised, with politicians from all sides stepping back. The voices of ordinary people, including especially ordinary Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, should be brought to the fore, in the spirit of the Uluru Statement. Careful truthfulness should be observed by all participants in the debate. And exaggerated claims calculated only to provoke discord should be named as such by existing fact-checking processes.

The authors of this article have developed a compendium of key resources[34] that avoid ideological distortions and political grandstanding. It is available free of charge to all Australians to help them make up their minds about how to vote. Interested people are invited to visit https://voicetoparliament.info/[35] and download the pdf, read the text, or search it using a ChatGPT-powered search facility.

Australia is facing a test of the resilience of its peaceful social infrastructure and the safety of individual citizens.

Regardless of the referendum outcome, we must return to respectful, ethical, fact-based dialogues and political processes.

References

  1. ^ announced (www.abc.net.au)
  2. ^ Uluru Statement from the Heart (ulurustatement.org)
  3. ^ mostly welcomed (hir.harvard.edu)
  4. ^ announcement (insight.thomsonreuters.com.au)
  5. ^ seeing (www.theage.com.au)
  6. ^ increases (www.theage.com.au)
  7. ^ racism (www.theguardian.com)
  8. ^ respectful dialogue (www.theguardian.com)
  9. ^ personal criticisms and even abuse (www.theage.com.au)
  10. ^ How we can avoid political misinformation in the lead-up to the Voice referendum (theconversation.com)
  11. ^ established standards of truth (www.theguardian.com)
  12. ^ reparations (www.smh.com.au)
  13. ^ Black State (www.aap.com.au)
  14. ^ abolished (www.abc.net.au)
  15. ^ overwhelmed (theconversation.com)
  16. ^ conspiracy claims (www.crikey.com.au)
  17. ^ individuals (www.smh.com.au)
  18. ^ blood tests (www.theguardian.com)
  19. ^ darken their skin (www.dailymail.co.uk)
  20. ^ Hate speech (www.un.org)
  21. ^ well established (www.degruyter.com)
  22. ^ hinders (johnmenadue.com)
  23. ^ catastrophic social division (www.apa.org)
  24. ^ assault on the Washington Capitol (theconversation.com)
  25. ^ psychological (www.healthaffairs.org)
  26. ^ injury (jcn.cognethic.org)
  27. ^ increased risk (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
  28. ^ isolation (www.healthaffairs.org)
  29. ^ discrimination becoming normalised (www.undp.org)
  30. ^ excluded systematically from public discussions (muse.jhu.edu)
  31. ^ lasting damage (johnmenadue.com)
  32. ^ actual violence (www.npr.org)
  33. ^ breakdown of civil order (www.jstor.org)
  34. ^ compendium of key resources (voicetoparliament.info)
  35. ^ https://voicetoparliament.info/ (voicetoparliament.info)

Read more https://theconversation.com/how-hate-speech-during-the-voice-campaign-can-harm-personal-wellbeing-as-well-as-democracy-211730

The Times Features

Designer Wardrobe reports surge in pre-loved wedding gowns

As Australia’s wedding season approaches, and amidst a challenging cost of living backdrop, new insights from Designer Wardrobe reveal that Australia and New Zealand (ANZ) brid...

DIY Bathroom Remodel: Essential Tips for a Fresh Look

As the home improvement craze continues to grow, more folks are diving into the world of DIY projects to transform their living spaces. Among these, bathroom remodels have gain...

STI rates are increasing among midlife and older adults. We need to talk about it

Globally, the rates of common sexually transmissible infections[1] (STIs) are increasing among people aged over 50. In some cases, rates are rising faster than among younger pe...

The Gift That Keeps Growing: Why Tinybeans+ Gift Cards are a game-changer for new parents

As new parents navigate the joys and challenges of raising a child in the digital age, one question looms large: how do you preserve and share your baby's milestones without co...

Group Adventures Made Easy: How to Coordinate Shuttle Services from DCA to IAD

Traveling as a large group can be both exciting and challenging, especially when navigating busy airports like DCA (Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport) and IAD (Washington...

From Anxiety to Assurance: Proven Strategies to Support Your Child's Emotional Health

Navigating the intricate landscape of childhood emotions can be a daunting task for any parent, especially when faced with common fears and anxieties. However, transforming anxie...

Times Magazine

Moving Overseas from Australia Checklist

Living abroad is not for everyone, and there is a lot to think about before planning a move overseas. Most people spend significant time thinking about a move like this while at the same time discussing their plans with family and friends beforeh...

Harnessing Success with Vistaprint: A Strategic Alliance for Australian Businesses

In the vibrant marketplace of today, businesses are consistently on the lookout for innovative methods to amplify their brand presence. A pioneering brand assisting in this endeavour is Vistaprint, an international e-commerce titan offering an im...

The Entrepreneur's Legal Toolkit

Essential Resources and When to Call in the Lawyers When it comes to entrepreneurship, laying a strong legal foundation is just as crucial as the business idea itself, if not more. As you embark on the exhilarating journey of building your enterpr...

When to Say Goodbye: Understanding the Right Time for Kids to Part with Stuffed Animals

teddy bear shop Kids often form a special bond with their stuffed animals, turning to these soft, cuddly friends for comfort during naptime, playtime, or when facing new situations. The journey from clinging to a favorite teddy bear to leaving it on...

Employment support for people with disability

If you’re a job seeker in Australia and you’re currently living with a disability, there will be some hurdles to overcome and added challenges you will have to face in your efforts to find and keep a job. The positive news is that you don’t have ...

Here is a great checklist for organising your wedding flowers

For many, flowers are a big component of a wedding day, and if you are soon to be married and you are considering your flower arrangements, this post is for you. Working out the details for a wedding is a big job, that's why we've compiled this che...