The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

Lie detection tests have worked the same way for 3,000 years – and they're still hopelessly inaccurate

  • Written by Rebecca Wilcoxson, Lecturer in Forensic Psychology, CQUniversity Australia
Lie detection tests have worked the same way for 3,000 years – and they're still hopelessly inaccurate

Popular culture is fascinated with the ability to detect liars. Lie detector tests are a staple of police dramas, and TV shows such as Poker Face feature “human polygraphs” who detect deception by picking up tell-tale signs in people’s behaviour.

Records of attempts to detect lies, whether by technical means or by skilled observers, go back at least 3,000 years. Forensic science lie detection techniques have become increasingly popular[1] since the invention of the polygraph early in the 20th century, with the latest methods involving advanced brain imaging.

Proponents of lie detection technology sometimes make grandiose claims[2], such as a recent paper[3] that said “with the help of forensic science and its new techniques, crimes can be easily solved”.

Despite these claims, an infallible lie detection method has yet to be found. In fact, most lie detection methods don’t detect lies at all – instead, they register the physiological or behaviour signs of stress or fear.

From dry rice to red-hot irons

The earliest recorded lie detection method[4] was used in China, around 1000 BC. It involved suspects placing rice in their mouths then spitting it out: wet rice indicated innocence, while dry rice meant guilty.

In ancient China, chewing dry rice was used a way to determine whether a person was speaking the truth or telling lies. Shutterstock

In India, around 900 BC, one method[5] used to detect poisoners was observations of shaking. In ancient Greece a rapid pulse rate was taken to indicate deceit.

The Middle Ages saw barbaric forms of lie detection used in Europe, such as the red-hot iron method which involved suspected criminals placing their tongue, often multiple times, on a red-hot iron. Here, a burnt tongue indicated guilt.

What the polygraph measures

Historical lie detection methods were based in superstition or religion. However, in the early 20th century a purportedly scientific, objective, lie detection machine was invented: the polygraph.

The polygraph measures[6] a person’s respiration, heart rate, blood pressure, and skin conductance (sweating) during questioning.

Usually a “control question” about a crime is asked, such as “Did you do it?” The person’s response to the control question is then compared to responses to neutral or less provocative questions. Heightened reactions to direct crime questions are taken to indicate guilt on the test.

The overconfidence of law enforcers

Some law enforcement experts claim they don’t even need a polygraph. They can detect lies simply by observing the behaviour of a suspect during questioning.

Worldwide research shows that law enforcers are often confident they can detect lying[7]. Many assume a suspect’s nonverbal behaviour reveals deceit.

Unlike Poker Face’s ‘human polygraph’, the lie-detection efforts of real-life law enforcers are often fallible. Peacock

A 2011 study with Queensland police[8] revealed many officers were confident they could detect lying. Most favoured a focus on nonverbal behaviour even over available evidence.

However, research shows[9] that law enforcers, despite their confidence, are often not very good at detecting lying.

Law enforcement officers are not alone in thinking they can spot a liar. Global studies[10] have found that people around the world believe lying is accompanied by specific nonverbal behaviours such as gaze aversion and nervousness.

What’s really being tested

Many historical and current lie detection methods seem underpinned by the plausible idea that liars will be nervous and display observable physical reactions.

These might be shaking (such as in the ancient Indian test for poisoners, and the nonverbal behaviour method used by some investigators), a dry mouth (the rice-chewing test and the hot-iron method), increased pulse rate (the ancient Greek method and the modern polygraph), or overall heightened physiological reactions (the polygraph).

Read more: How's your poker face? Why it's so hard to sniff out a liar[11]

However, there are two major problems with using behaviour based on fear or stress to detect lying.

The first problem: how does one distinguish fearful innocents from fearful guilty people? It is likely that an innocent person accused of a crime will be fearful or anxious, while a guilty suspect may not be.

This is borne out with the polygraph’s high false-positive rate[12], meaning innocent people are deemed guilty. Similarly, some police have assumed that innocent, nervous suspects were guilty[13] based on inaccurate interpretations of behavioural observations.

The second major problem with lie detection methods based on nervous behaviour is there is no evidence[14] that specific nonverbal behaviours reliably accompany deception.

Miscarriages of justice

Despite what we know about the inaccuracy of polygraph tests, they haven’t gone away.

In the US, they are still used in some police interrogations and high-security job interviews[15]. In the UK, lie detector tests are used for some sex offenders on probation[16]. And in China, the use of polygraphs in law enforcement may even be increasing[17].

Australia has been less enthusiastic in adopting lie-detection machines. In New South Wales, the use of lie-detector findings was barred from court in 1983, and an attempt to present polygraph evidence to a court in Western Australia in 2003 also failed[18].

Many historical and current lie detection methods emulate each other and are based on the same assumptions. Often the only difference[19] is the which part of the body or physical reacion they focus on.

Using fallible lie detection methods contributes to wrongful convictions[20] and miscarriages of justice.

Therefore, it is important that criminal-justice practitioners are educated about fallacious lie detection methods, and any new technique grounded in fear or stress-based reactions should be rejected.

Despite outward appearances of technological advancement, over many millennia little has changed. Fearful innocents remain vulnerable to wrongful assumptions of guilt, which is good news for the fearless guilty.

References

  1. ^ increasingly popular (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  2. ^ make grandiose claims (www.press.umich.edu)
  3. ^ recent paper (doi.org)
  4. ^ earliest recorded lie detection method (journals.sagepub.com)
  5. ^ one method (scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu)
  6. ^ polygraph measures (www.ojp.gov)
  7. ^ confident they can detect lying (doi.org)
  8. ^ 2011 study with Queensland police (www.emerald.com)
  9. ^ research shows (link.springer.com)
  10. ^ Global studies (journals.sagepub.com)
  11. ^ How's your poker face? Why it's so hard to sniff out a liar (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ high false-positive rate (nap.nationalacademies.org)
  13. ^ innocent, nervous suspects were guilty (cqu-primo.hosted.exlibrisgroup.com)
  14. ^ no evidence (journals.copmadrid.org)
  15. ^ high-security job interviews (www.wired.com)
  16. ^ some sex offenders on probation (www.gov.uk)
  17. ^ even be increasing (www.sciencedirect.com)
  18. ^ also failed (www.tandfonline.com)
  19. ^ only difference (muse.jhu.edu)
  20. ^ contributes to wrongful convictions (journals.copmadrid.org)

Read more https://theconversation.com/lie-detection-tests-have-worked-the-same-way-for-3-000-years-and-theyre-still-hopelessly-inaccurate-200741

The Times Features

Itinerary to Maximize Your Two-Week Adventure in Vietnam and Cambodia

Two weeks may not seem like much, but it’s just the right time for travelers to explore the best of Vietnam and Cambodia. From the bustling streets of Hanoi to the magnificent te...

How to Protect Your Garden Trees from Wind Damage in Australia

In Australia's expansive landscape, garden trees hold noteworthy significance. They not only enhance the aesthetic appeal of our homes but also play an integral role in the local...

Brisbane Homeowners Warned: Non-Compliant Flexible Hoses Pose High Flood Risk

As a homeowner in Brisbane, when you think of the potential for flood damage to your home, you probably think of weather events. But you should know that there may be a tickin...

Argan Oil-Infused Moroccanoil Shampoo: Nourish and Revitalize Your Hair

Are you ready to transform your hair from dull and lifeless to vibrant and full of life? Look no further than the luxurious embrace of Argan Oil-Infused Moroccanoil Shampoo! In a...

Building A Strong Foundation For Any Structure

Building a home or commercial building can be very exciting. The possibilities are endless and the future is interesting. You can always change aspects of the building to meet the ...

The Role of a Family Dentist: Why Every Household Needs One

source A family dentist isn’t like your regular dentist who may specialise in a particular age group and whom you visit only when something goes wrong. A family dentist takes proa...

Times Magazine

"Eternal Nurture" by Cara Barilla: A Timeless Collection of Wisdom and Healing

Renowned Sydney-born author and educator Cara Barilla has released her latest book, Eternal Nurture, a profound collection of inspirational quotes designed to support mindfulness, emotional healing, and personal growth. With a deep commitment to ...

How AI-Driven SEO Enhancements Can Improve Headless CMS Content Visibility

Whereas SEO (search engine optimization) is critical in the digital landscape for making connections to content, much of it is still done manually keyword research, metatags, final tweaks at publication requiring a human element that takes extensiv...

Crypto Expert John Fenga Reveals How Blockchain is Revolutionising Charity

One of the most persistent challenges in the charity sector is trust. Donors often wonder whether their contributions are being used effectively or if overhead costs consume a significant portion. Traditional fundraising methods can be opaque, with...

Navigating Parenting Arrangements in Australia: A Legal Guide for Parents

Understanding Parenting Arrangements in Australia. Child custody disputes are often one of the most emotionally charged aspects of separation or divorce. Parents naturally want what is best for their children, but the legal process of determining ...

Blocky Adventures: A Minecraft Movie Celebration for Your Wrist

The Minecraft movie is almost here—and it’s time to get excited! With the film set to hit theaters on April 4, 2025, fans have a brand-new reason to celebrate. To honor the upcoming blockbuster, watchfaces.co has released a special Minecraft-inspir...

The Ultimate Guide to Apple Watch Faces & Trending Wallpapers

In today’s digital world, personalization is everything. Your smartwatch isn’t just a timepiece—it’s an extension of your style. Thanks to innovative third-party developers, customizing your Apple Watch has reached new heights with stunning designs...

LayBy Shopping