The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

why consumers don't punish big polluters for greenwashing lies

  • Written by Adam Austen Kay, Lecturer, School of Business, The University of Queensland
why consumers don't punish big polluters for greenwashing lies

Stigma is an awful burden for business. But what if – for some companies – stigma is an asset?

That’s what I and an international team of researchers set out to investigate in a new paper published in the Journal of Management Studies[1].

We examined how consumers around the world responded to firms in stigmatised industries like oil and gas that are found “greenwashing[2]”, meaning they claim to do more for the environment than they really do.

We anticipated that the market would punish greenwashers, but we thought it would treat firms seen to be “dirty” rather differently.

Specifically, we thought the market would either

  • punish dirty firms more, as might the judge of a repeat offender in court; or

  • punish dirty firms less, as might parents who overlook poor behaviour by their child with outdated excuses like “boys will be boys”.

What we discovered has important implications for greenwashing and important implications more broadly.

What we found

In a study tracking 7,365 companies in 47 countries over 15 years, we found that consumers financially penalised firms for greenwashing – but not if those firms were stigmatised[3] as dirty.

In other words, the market imposed a kind of tax on companies for greenwashing, unless they were already regarded as big polluters.

In order to find out why stigmatised greenwashers were exempt from this market tax, we conducted a follow-up experiment.

Read more: 'Toxic cover-up': 6 lessons Australia can draw from the UN's scathing report on greenwashing[4]

After a pre-study to determine which industries are most regarded as “dirty”, “clean” or “neutral” (the answers were oil and gas, solar and wind power, and stationery and office supplies), we presented 458 consumers with a statement from the corporate citizenship report of a firm in one of these three industries.

In the statement, the firm professed its core values of honesty, integrity, and environmental sustainability. The only difference between the three versions of the statement was the industry the firm was in.

Next, we presented consumers the results of an independent environmental audit that either found the firm to be acting in line with its professed values or not (i.e., greenwashing). Results showed that greenwashing took much less of a toll on the perceived trustworthiness of the oil and gas company. As a result, consumers said they were significantly more likely to purchase its products and services. Taken together, these two studies suggest that consumers have a “boys will be boys” attitude to greenwashing by dirty firms. They even expect it. Why this matters for greenwashing Our findings have important implications for how to regulate greenwashing. First, it’s often assumed that consumers punish greenwashers, but data supporting this assumption is hard to come by. We demonstrate empirically that this assumption is true. For many firms, greenwashing results in real financial costs. Second, we find the market penalty for greenwashing is much weaker for firms that are regarded as dirty. Those who expect the market to punish greenwashing by firms in the oil and gas industry and other heavy polluters should reconsider. Third, our findings suggest governments and international organisations that have a “zero tolerance[5]” approach to greenwashing should focus their limited resources on dirty industries and let the market take care of the rest. Why this matters more broadly The “boys will be boys” attitude that we uncovered in this research is likely to play out in other fields in which people respond to the misdeeds of “bad boys”, including politics. An example might be former US President Donald Trump. Having survived scandal after scandal, Trump once famously declared that he could shoot someone[6] on Fifth Avenue and not lose votes. Read more: Out of bounds: how much does greenwashing cost fossil-fuel sponsors of Australian sport?[7] The more deplorable the media has made him out to be – the greater the stigma attached to the Trump name – the less his misdeeds seem to have hurt him. Our research offers new clues as to why. As consumers and voters, we need to recognise that our “boys will be boys” attitude enables bad behaviour. Unless we do, and until we regulate with this psychological bias in mind, we will continue to be part of the problem. References^ Journal of Management Studies (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)^ greenwashing (www.investopedia.com)^ stigmatised (managementstudiesinsights.com)^ 'Toxic cover-up': 6 lessons Australia can draw from the UN's scathing report on greenwashing (theconversation.com)^ zero tolerance (www.un.org)^ shoot someone (www.cbsnews.com)^ Out of bounds: how much does greenwashing cost fossil-fuel sponsors of Australian sport? (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/boys-will-be-boys-why-consumers-dont-punish-big-polluters-for-greenwashing-lies-194902

The Times Features

Amazon Australia and DoorDash announce two-year DashPass offer only for Prime members

New and existing Prime members in Australia can enjoy a two-year membership to DashPass for free, and gain access to AU$0 delivery fees on eligible DoorDash orders New offer co...

6 things to do if your child’s weight is beyond the ideal range – and 1 thing to avoid

One of the more significant challenges we face as parents is making sure our kids are growing at a healthy rate. To manage this, we take them for regular check-ups with our GP...

Joykids Australia Presents the Joykids Family Rave: A Weekend Adventure Like No Other

Get ready to kick off the first day of summer and the festive season with an unforgettable family adventure! Joykids Australia is excited to announce the Joykids Family Rave—an...

New study suggests weight loss drugs like Ozempic could help with knee pain. Here’s why there may be a link

The drug semaglutide, commonly known by the brand names Ozempic or Wegovy, was originally developed[1] to help people with type 2 diabetes manage their blood sugar levels. How...

Maintaining Your Pool After a Marble Interior Upgrade

After upgrading your pool with a marble interior, it’s crucial to understand that maintenance is key to preserving its elegance and longevity. You’ll want to regularly skim for d...

Labor using explanatory document to hide true powers of Misinformation Bill

The opinions and commentary of individuals could be deemed misinformation under Labor’s proposed legislation changes, according to James McComish of Victorian Bar. Appearing in...

Times Magazine

The Guide Dogs Australia and Black Hawk pet food ultimate Dog Care Guide

GUIDE DOGS AUSTRALIA & BLACK HAWK JOIN FORCES TO RELEASE THE ULTIMATE DOG CARE GUIDE WITH TIPS YOU CAN TRUST Guide Dogs Australia is proud to announce Black Hawk as its new dog food partner. Joining forces to ensure that Australia's most tru...

The Best Deals for Venue Rentals on a Budget

Are you looking for a cheap venue for your next event? Look no further! In this introduction, we will discuss the benefits of renting a venue near you at an affordable price. Renting a local venue can save you time and money on transportation, as w...

How To Do Automated Web Testing?

Web testing is a must for modern online software. It is crucial to test your web applications throughout the developing process and especially before launch to ensure the best quality and user experience. However, automated testing is in most cas...

Understanding Hair Loss in Men: Causes, Prevention, and Effective Care Routines

Most men suffer from hair loss, which is a common problem affecting millions of users worldwide and starts at various stages — Some may even have their hair thinning in the early 20s While others cannot observe any signs later on. No matter how it ...

Racer Holly Espray hits the track with Uniden for V8 SuperUte Series in Bathurst

Leading SuperUte racer Holly Espray is geared up for her next big challenge at Bathurst, and she's relying on support from her new sponsor Uniden, known for its cutting-edge technology, to keep her connected and secure, both on and off the track. ...

Cadbury CHOCBUSTER store opens in Sydney

Following the exciting launch of Cadbury Choc Tops in Australia, Peters Ice Cream and Cadbury are teaming up again to bring you the ultimate blast from the past, along with 8,000 FREE Choc Tops and freshly made popcorn for the perfect movie night...