The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

How Australia's gig workers may remain contractors under Labor's reforms

  • Written by David Peetz, Professor Emeritus, Griffith Business School, Griffith University
How Australia's gig workers may remain contractors under Labor's reforms

Uber Australia’s historic agreement[1] with the Transport Workers’ Union, on the need to regulate the gig economy, is the first step in fundamental reform of gig work. It suggests the direction the Albanese government will to take to deliver better conditions for gig workers.

The “statement of principles” agreed to between Uber and the union supports “regulatory certainty for platforms” and “minimum benefits and standards for platform workers who aren’t engaged as employees”. It does not agree that gig workers should be classified as employees instead of independent contractors.

Read more: What's driving Uber's historic agreement with the TWU on gig work[2]

The response of federal workplace relations minister Tony Burke to the agreement[3] suggests the government will take the same route – not changing the classification of gig workers but giving the federal industrial relations umpire, the Fair Work Commission, the power to set minimum standards for gig workers in “employee-like work”.

A precedent for this approach comes from New South Wales provisions[4] enabling regulation of payments to owner-drivers of trucks. Those provisions have been in place for more than 40 years, and have inspired the proposal before the Queensland parliament[5] to regulate the work of independent courier drivers.

Read more: A new definition of 'worker' could protect many from exploitation[6]

Leaving gig workers as contractors

There are good reasons to aim to regulate gig economy workers as contractors, rather than attempting to bring them under the umbrella of being employees.

Yes, their relationship with platforms can look an awful lot like an employment relationship – hence the reason for court cases[7] supported by the Transport Workers’ Union seeking to have gig workers deemed employees.

Read more: An employee, not a contractor: unfair dismissal ruling against Deliveroo is a big deal for Australia's gig workers[8]

As the saying goes[9], if it looks, swims and quacks like a duck, it probably is a duck.

But the outcome of trying to define gig workers as employees has been mixed. Around the world these attempts have sometimes succeeded[10], sometimes not[11].

Roadblocks to becoming employees

Platform companies have worked against these attempts, leveraging the fact quite a number of gig workers like to imagine themselves as independent[12], self-employed people, as well as customers’ preference for cheap services.

The best (but not only) example is their success against California’s AB5[13] law, passed in 2019, that tightened the rules for companies to hire workers as independent contractors.

Uber and rival Lyft first threatened to suspend operations[14] in California rather than comply with the law. They then teamed up with other platform companies such as DoorDash and spent a reported US$200 million[15] in 2020 to secure and a win a “ballot proposal” (known as Proposition 22) exempting[16] app-based transportation and delivery companies from the new law.

Workers rally in August 2019 in support of California's proposed AB5 law to stop companies categorise workers as independent contractors. The law was passed, but Uber and other platform companies bankrolled a successful attempt in 2020 to be exempt from t
Workers rally in August 2019 in support of California’s proposed AB5 law to stop companies categorise workers as independent contractors. The law was passed, but Uber and other platform companies bankrolled a successful attempt in 2020 to be exempt from the law. Rich Pedroncelli/AP

A Californian court has since found Proposition 22 unconstitutional[17], but it remains in place pending an appeal.

Even when a rule is devised to interpret the contracts that gig workers sign as employment contracts, gig companies could amend their contracts[18] to get around that.

Read more: Redefining workers in the platform economy: lessons from the Foodora bunfight[19]

But in the end, a company such as Uber will adhere, grudgingly, to most standards that are imposed on it — other than defining its workers as employees. Thus it has accepted training requirements in Quebec[20] (after first threatening to quit[21] the Canadian province), fare regulation in Massachusetts[22] and driver accreditation requirements in several[23] jurisdictions[24].

Regulating contractors as contractors

Regulating gig work without redefining gig workers as employees is not just politically easier, and hence more sustainable. It is can also more effective policy.

It enables regulation to be tailored to circumstances[25]. For example it may mean applying an hourly wage rate in one sector, and a piece rate of some sort in another.

For example, a New York state inquiry into how to regulate passenger transport came up with an amount expressed like taxi charges – that is, dollars per kilometre travelled – drivers needed to be paid to earn the equivalent of the state’s minimum wage[26] (taking into account waiting times, average speeds and so on).

Different panels of the Fair Work Commission could determine different forms of gig economy regulation for different industries.

Legislation does not need to specify how regulation should be expressed. It just needs to make sure that the Commission has all the power it needs, to regulate in whatever way it sees fit.

Levelling the playing field

The Transport Workers’ Union – which has a number of former officials in the Albanese government – has a long history of successfully promoting regulation of safety conditions for independent contractors (such as truck owner-drivers) without rebadging workers as employees.

In the 1970s, for example, it persuaded the Wran government in NSW to introduce amendments to the NSW Industrial Relations Act that have made roads safer.

The Albanese government does not need to legislate specific regulation. It just needs give the Fair Work Commission the power it needs to regulate in whatever way it sees fit, setting a minimum hourly rate or something else.

The law must also direct the commission to set minimum standards in a way that ensures gig workers are paid as much as comparable award-covered employees, taking account of expenses. (Contractors often pay for costs that, if they were employees, would be covered by their employer.) This sort of direction is important to ensure neutrality between the costs of using employees or contractors.

References

  1. ^ agreement (www.twu.com.au)
  2. ^ What's driving Uber's historic agreement with the TWU on gig work (theconversation.com)
  3. ^ the agreement (ministers.dese.gov.au)
  4. ^ New South Wales provisions (www.ntc.gov.au)
  5. ^ before the Queensland parliament (statements.qld.gov.au)
  6. ^ A new definition of 'worker' could protect many from exploitation (theconversation.com)
  7. ^ court cases (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ An employee, not a contractor: unfair dismissal ruling against Deliveroo is a big deal for Australia's gig workers (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ saying goes (en.wikipedia.org)
  10. ^ succeeded (www.theguardian.com)
  11. ^ sometimes not (btlaw.com)
  12. ^ independent (www.cipd.co.uk)
  13. ^ AB5 (www.acslaw.org)
  14. ^ threatened to suspend operations (calmatters.org)
  15. ^ US$200 million (www.theguardian.com)
  16. ^ exempting (www.nytimes.com)
  17. ^ Proposition 22 unconstitutional (www.nelp.org)
  18. ^ amend their contracts (www.hcamag.com)
  19. ^ Redefining workers in the platform economy: lessons from the Foodora bunfight (theconversation.com)
  20. ^ training requirements in Quebec (www.uber.com)
  21. ^ threatening to quit (www.thedrive.com)
  22. ^ fare regulation in Massachusetts (www.masslive.com)
  23. ^ several (www.transport.nsw.gov.au)
  24. ^ jurisdictions (www.intellinews.com)
  25. ^ tailored to circumstances (research-repository.griffith.edu.au)
  26. ^ equivalent of the state’s minimum wage (news.yahoo.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/how-australias-gig-workers-may-remain-contractors-under-labors-reforms-186197

The Times Features

Group Adventures Made Easy: How to Coordinate Shuttle Services from DCA to IAD

Traveling as a large group can be both exciting and challenging, especially when navigating busy airports like DCA (Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport) and IAD (Washington...

From Anxiety to Assurance: Proven Strategies to Support Your Child's Emotional Health

Navigating the intricate landscape of childhood emotions can be a daunting task for any parent, especially when faced with common fears and anxieties. However, transforming anxie...

The Rise of Meal Replacement Shakes in Australia: Why The Lady Shake Is Leading the Pack

Source Meal replacement shakes are having a moment in Australia, and it’s not hard to see why. They’re quick, convenient, and packed with nutrition, making them the perfect solu...

HCF’s Healthy Hearts Roadshow Wraps Up 2024 with a Final Regional Sprint

Next week marks the final leg of the HCF Healthy Hearts Roadshow for 2024, bringing free heart health checks to some of NSW’s most vibrant regional communities. As Australia’s ...

The Budget-Friendly Traveler: How Off-Airport Car Hire Can Save You Money

When planning a trip, transportation is one of the most crucial considerations. For many, the go-to option is renting a car at the airport for convenience. But what if we told ...

Air is an overlooked source of nutrients – evidence shows we can inhale some vitamins

You know that feeling you get when you take a breath of fresh air in nature? There may be more to it than a simple lack of pollution. When we think of nutrients, we think of t...

Times Magazine

Why Is a Website the Most Important Part of Digital Marketing?

Your website is the most important digital marketing tool you have, even more so than social media, content marketing, email marketing, traditional outbound advertising, and printed materials. All of your marketing activities will likely lead users...

Choosing Between an SEO Consultant and Agency: What You Need to Know in Australia

In the bustling world of digital marketing in Australia, Search Engine Optimisation (SEO) plays a vital role. Whether you're a small business owner or part of a larger organisation, ensuring your online presence is optimised can't be overstated. Wi...

Mastering the art of food photography by Kirsty Owen, WOW Pictures

Food photography is the ultimate in visual storytelling.  From the crispy, delicate croissant to be indulged at daybreak,  the glistening cocktail set against the sunset, to the appetising cheese on offer at a regional food festival, food photograp...

Paramedic pointers to stay safe at the tennis

As thousands flock to Melbourne Olympic Park over the next two weeks to watch tennis stars compete in the Australian Open, Ambulance Victoria (AV) is reminding spectators to stay safe on long, hot days at the major event. Ambulance Victoria (AV) p...

Photovoltaic in a condominium: what you need to know

In recent years, photovoltaics in Australia has experienced strong growth. The increase in the number of installations is mainly due to the fact that solar energy allows you to save on bills thanks to self-consumption, which can reach 90% with a ...

Satisfy the Sweet Tooth with Chocolate Covered Strawberry Near Me

Chocolate-covered strawberries are a classic treat that can be enjoyed any time of year. Whether you’re looking for something sweet to satisfy your sweet tooth or a unique gift for a special someone, this delicious treat is sure to bring a smile to...