The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

Strip searches in prison are traumatising breaches of human rights. So, why are governments still allowing them?

  • Written by Andreea Lachsz, PhD Candidate, University of Technology Sydney

Content warning: This article contains details readers may find distressing including discussion of excessive or gratuitous violence, abuse and mental illness.

In December, the Victorian Court of Appeal found[1] certain routine strip searches in prison breach human rights[2] to privacy and dignity in detention. The decision highlights how traumatising, unnecessary and degrading the routine practice of strip searching people can be.

In Victoria’s prisons, strip searches involve[3] forcing a person to remove their clothing, stand with their legs apart and bend over in full view of prison guards. There is some variation in strip-searching processes in other states and territories[4].

Throughout Australia, police and prison officials conduct strip searches as a matter of routine. They are commonly conducted upon entry into custody, after legal and family visits and hearings, when moving between secure locations[5] or before drug testing.

For Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, who are more likely to be policed, imprisoned[6], subjected to abuses of power and violence within prisons, and strip searched[7], the court’s decision is important. Victoria’s criminal and legal systems are built on Australia’s violent colonial history, and routine strip searches are a modern form of this violence.

The Victorian Court of Appeal case[8] is an opportunity for real systemic reform. The Victorian government must now decide whether it will maintain this violent practice.

Read more: Excessive strip-searching shines light on discrimination of Aboriginal women in the criminal justice system[9]

The case of Thompson v Minogue

In 2020, Dr Craig Minogue successfully challenged a prison order that he submit to a urine test and routine strip search before that test. In the Supreme Court[10], Minogue successfully[11] argued this direction was in breach of his rights to privacy and dignity in detention. The state of Victoria appealed.

The Victorian Aboriginal Legal Service (VALS) was granted leave to intervene[12] in the appeal as a “friend of the court[13]” to make written and oral submissions.[14]. Although Minogue is not Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander, VALS believed it was critical to provide the court information on the harmful impact of strip searching and urine testing on First Nations people.

The Victorian Court of Appeal upheld the Supreme Court’s ruling that routine strip searches prior to urine testing breached Minogue’s human rights and the government did not properly consider human rights[15] when making strip-searching policies.

The Court found these routine strip searches were “extremely invasive and demeaning” procedures which can constitute “a severe limitation upon […] privacy and dignity rights”.

Both the Supreme Court and Court of Appeal found the government did not back up its claims that routine strip searches prior to urine tests were necessary or effective. The government did not sufficiently explain why pre-existing and less harmful alternatives, such as x-ray body scanners, were not used.

However, the Court of Appeal reversed the Supreme Court’s decision on urine testing and found this procedure did not breach Minogue’s human rights. Minogue has sought to appeal this aspect of the decision to the High Court.

Now, it is up to the Victorian government to decide whether it will implement changes to strip-search policies and laws to end this practice across all police stations and prisons.

Read more: Dragging its feet on torture prevention: Australia’s international shame[16]

The human rights of people in prison

Evidence and data[17] in Australia show strip searches are often over-used, ineffective[18] in uncovering contraband and unnecessary[19]. Strip searches are also prone to being a tool for abuses of power and misconduct.

A 2021 IBAC report[20] exposed serious misconduct in the management and conducting of strip searches in Victoria. Staff were unfamiliar with human rights standards and prisons did not properly investigate complaints about inappropriate searches.

The general manager of Port Phillip Prison was reported to have said strip searches were “one of the options available to assert control” over people in prison. Reports from other states[21] tell the same story of unlawful[22] searches being used to degrade and humiliate[23] prisoners.

Under both the Victorian human rights charter[24] and international law, people in prison are entitled to the same human rights as those outside of prison. This includes a right to privacy, including bodily and psychological autonomy, and to be treated with humanity and respect.

International law[25] dictates that, given the harmful impact of strip searches, alternatives such as x-ray scanners should instead be used in prisons.

Independent scrutiny of human rights in prisons is also vital, including preventive oversight under the UN Optional Protocol to the Convention against Torture (OPCAT)[26]. Australia has ratified this protocol, but has missed the January 20, 2022, deadline to meet its obligations to set up an independent oversight system of places of detention.

Strip searches are inherently harmful

There is evidence Aboriginal people are subjected to disproportionate rates of strip searching[27]. Many Aboriginal people who are incarcerated have disabilities[28] and histories of trauma[29]. Strip searches can compound this trauma[30] and impede a person’s ability to recover and heal.

In a 2016 Four Corners episode, entitled Australia’s Shame[31], footage was shown of a young Aboriginal child in the Northern Territory being stripped naked. This horrified Australians and led to a royal commission.

Years later, however, it is still lawful in Victoria[32] and other states and territories to subject Aboriginal children to traumatic strip searches.

A prisoner pinned down by four corrections officers and hit in the head during a strip search.
A prisoner pinned down by four Melbourne corrections officers and hit in the head during a strip search in 2007. Ombudsman Victoria/AAP image[33]

The evidence is indisputable – strip searches do not work, are inherently harmful, and disproportionately impact Aboriginal people.

Rather than persist with this archaic practice, all Australian governments must end the use of strip searches.

References

  1. ^ Victorian Court of Appeal found (www.austlii.edu.au)
  2. ^ breach human rights (www.vals.org.au)
  3. ^ strip searches involve (www.corrections.vic.gov.au)
  4. ^ other states and territories (www.oics.wa.gov.au)
  5. ^ moving between secure locations (www.oics.wa.gov.au)
  6. ^ imprisoned (www.abs.gov.au)
  7. ^ strip searched (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ Victorian Court of Appeal case (www.vals.org.au)
  9. ^ Excessive strip-searching shines light on discrimination of Aboriginal women in the criminal justice system (theconversation.com)
  10. ^ Supreme Court (www.austlii.edu.au)
  11. ^ successfully (www.hrlc.org.au)
  12. ^ leave to intervene (www.vals.org.au)
  13. ^ friend of the court (www.vals.org.au)
  14. ^ written and oral submissions. (www.vals.org.au)
  15. ^ consider human rights (www.vals.org.au)
  16. ^ Dragging its feet on torture prevention: Australia’s international shame (theconversation.com)
  17. ^ data (www.oics.wa.gov.au)
  18. ^ ineffective (www.abc.net.au)
  19. ^ unnecessary (theconversation.com)
  20. ^ 2021 IBAC report (www.ibac.vic.gov.au)
  21. ^ other states (obriensolicitors.com.au)
  22. ^ unlawful (obriensolicitors.com.au)
  23. ^ degrade and humiliate (www.abc.net.au)
  24. ^ Victorian human rights charter (www.humanrights.vic.gov.au)
  25. ^ International law (www.ohchr.org)
  26. ^ Optional Protocol to the Convention against Torture (OPCAT) (theconversation.com)
  27. ^ disproportionate rates of strip searching (theconversation.com)
  28. ^ disabilities (www.aic.gov.au)
  29. ^ histories of trauma (journals.sagepub.com)
  30. ^ compound this trauma (d3n8a8pro7vhmx.cloudfront.net)
  31. ^ Australia’s Shame (www.abc.net.au)
  32. ^ still lawful in Victoria (content.legislation.vic.gov.au)
  33. ^ Ombudsman Victoria/AAP image (photos.aap.com.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/strip-searches-in-prison-are-traumatising-breaches-of-human-rights-so-why-are-governments-still-allowing-them-174463

The Times Features

The Benefits of Animal-Assisted Speech Therapy For Children

Speech therapy has long been a standard for supporting children’s communication and emotional development. But what happens when you introduce a furry friend into the process? Th...

The Hidden Dangers of Blocked Drains and the Ultimate Solution for a Hassle-Free Home

Drain blockages are a big hassle to every homeowner and business owner alike. Whether it is a sink in the kitchen or bathroom, a clogged toilet, or a foul smell circulating aroun...

Understanding the Dangers of Ignoring a Gas Leak

Gas leaks are silent threats lurking within both homes and workplaces. A gas leak occurs when natural gas or any other gaseous substance escapes from a pipeline or containment. T...

Can You Sell Your House Privately in Queensland? Here’s How

Selling a house privately in Queensland is entirely possible and can be a cost-effective alternative to using a real estate agent. While agents provide valuable expertise, their co...

Itinerary to Maximize Your Two-Week Adventure in Vietnam and Cambodia

Two weeks may not seem like much, but it’s just the right time for travelers to explore the best of Vietnam and Cambodia. From the bustling streets of Hanoi to the magnificent te...

How to Protect Your Garden Trees from Wind Damage in Australia

In Australia's expansive landscape, garden trees hold noteworthy significance. They not only enhance the aesthetic appeal of our homes but also play an integral role in the local...

Times Magazine

CWU Assistive Tech Hub is Changing Lives: Win a Free Rollator Walker This Easter!

🌟 Mobility. Independence. Community. All in One. This Easter, the CWU Assistive Tech Hub is pleased to support the Banyule community by giving away a rollator walker. The giveaway will take place during the Macleod Village Easter Egg Hunt & Ma...

"Eternal Nurture" by Cara Barilla: A Timeless Collection of Wisdom and Healing

Renowned Sydney-born author and educator Cara Barilla has released her latest book, Eternal Nurture, a profound collection of inspirational quotes designed to support mindfulness, emotional healing, and personal growth. With a deep commitment to ...

How AI-Driven SEO Enhancements Can Improve Headless CMS Content Visibility

Whereas SEO (search engine optimization) is critical in the digital landscape for making connections to content, much of it is still done manually keyword research, metatags, final tweaks at publication requiring a human element that takes extensiv...

Crypto Expert John Fenga Reveals How Blockchain is Revolutionising Charity

One of the most persistent challenges in the charity sector is trust. Donors often wonder whether their contributions are being used effectively or if overhead costs consume a significant portion. Traditional fundraising methods can be opaque, with...

Navigating Parenting Arrangements in Australia: A Legal Guide for Parents

Understanding Parenting Arrangements in Australia. Child custody disputes are often one of the most emotionally charged aspects of separation or divorce. Parents naturally want what is best for their children, but the legal process of determining ...

Blocky Adventures: A Minecraft Movie Celebration for Your Wrist

The Minecraft movie is almost here—and it’s time to get excited! With the film set to hit theaters on April 4, 2025, fans have a brand-new reason to celebrate. To honor the upcoming blockbuster, watchfaces.co has released a special Minecraft-inspir...

LayBy Shopping