The Times Australia
The Times World News

.

justices will consider if the fundamental right to keep a gun at home applies to carrying weapons in public

  • Written by Morgan Marietta, Associate Professor of Political Science, University of Massachusetts Lowell
justices will consider if the fundamental right to keep a gun at home applies to carrying weapons in public

The Supreme Court is set to hear arguments Nov. 3[1], 2021, on a clear question: Does the constitutional right to possess a gun extend outside the home? The answer may alter gun regulations in many states.

The crux of the issue before the court[2] is captured by a debate that Thomas Jefferson had with himself at the time of the founding.

When Jefferson was drafting a proposed constitution for his home state of Virginia in June 1776, he suggested a clause[3] that read “No freeman shall ever be debarred the use of arms.”

In the second draft, he added in brackets, “[within his own lands or tenements].”

Jefferson’s debate with himself captures the question posed to the court: Is the purpose of the right to “keep and bear arms” the protection of a citizen’s “own lands,” or is it self-protection in general? Does the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution recognize a right to keep and bear arms in the home, or a right to “keep” firearms in the home and also “bear” them outside of the home for protection in society?

The plaintiffs in the upcoming case New York Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen[4] want the court to strike down the state’s restrictions and allow citizens who meet basic requirements, such as having no criminal convictions, to carry concealed weapons.

A man with a tattoo that reads 'We the People' carrying a gun in a leather holster
Will an upcoming Supreme Court ruling loosen gun laws across the country? AP Photo/Eric Gay[5]

Gun in the house

There are surprisingly few Supreme Court rulings[6] on the meaning of the Second Amendment.

The question of whether the amendment recognizes a fundamental right – on par with free speech or free exercise of religion – was not decided until 2008 in the landmark ruling in District of Columbia v. Heller[7]. For the first time, the court recognized a clear individual right to bear arms for the purpose of self-defense. This deeply disputed 5-4 ruling[8] was expanded two years later to cover state laws[9].

The Heller ruling stated that the Second Amendment’s right is like the others in the Bill of Rights[10], which cannot be violated without the most compelling reasons. The amendment, the ruling says, “surely elevates above all other interests[11] the right of law-abiding, responsible citizens to use arms in defense of hearth and home.” The Washington, D.C., law intended to reduce crime cannot ban firearms in “the home[12], where the need for defense of self, family, and property is most acute.”

That ruling – written by Justice Antonin Scalia, who died in 2016 and was replaced by Justice Neil Gorsuch[13] – also recognized that “like most rights, the right secured by the Second Amendment is not unlimited[14].” Scalia cited regulations like “longstanding prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill” or “prohibitions on carrying concealed weapons” as “presumptively lawful.”

The principal dissent was written by Justice Stephen Breyer, the only dissenter in Heller still serving on the court. He emphasized the balance between core rights and the needs for public safety.

“If a resident has a handgun in the home[15] that he can use for self-defense,” wrote Breyer, “then he has a handgun in the home that he can use to commit suicide or engage in acts of domestic violence.”

Concealed carry laws

State governments follow very different procedures for determining who will be allowed to carry a concealed firearm outside of the home.

Open carry[16],” or just having a handgun in plain sight on a belt holster or carrying a long gun (rifle or shotgun), is actually legal in many places. The general idea is that carrying openly would be done only by an honest actor, so less regulation is needed. “Concealed carry,” having a hidden weapon in a pocket or under a jacket, is far more restricted.

At one end of the continuum are near-bans on what are called “concealed carry licenses,” while at the other end are states in which no license is needed. These laws are referred to as “constitutional carry[17],” meaning the U.S. Constitution itself is a citizen’s license to carry[18] a firearm.

In between these two positions are rules known as “shall issue,” whereby the government issues a license if the applicant meets the requirements such as having no felony convictions, or “may issue,” which gives the government discretion to deny a license based on perceptions of fitness.

New York state has “may issue” laws with stringent requirements[19], which in practice allow almost no licenses to be issued. Applicants must demonstrate a “proper cause[20]” – such as being in imminent danger from a known source – which effectively eliminates ordinary applicants.

A head-and-shoulders photo of the late Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia.
The 2008 Heller ruling, written by Justice Antonin Scalia, pictured here, stated that the Second Amendment is a right like the others in the Bill of Rights. Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images[21]

Regulation or eradication

The strongest argument in the gun owners’ brief[22] to the Supreme Court relates to New York’s insistence that citizens show an exceptional or extraordinary need to exercise a right that the court has recognized as fundamental.

No other fundamental right, such as freedom of speech or religion, is limited to people who can demonstrate special circumstances. Instead, fundamental rights are understood to be held by ordinary people in ordinary circumstances.

The strongest argument in the opposing brief[23] from the New York State Police is federalism – the longstanding conservative argument that state lawmakers hold wide latitude to determine their own regulations to serve as “laboratories of experimentation[24],” as Justice Louis Brandeis phrased it[25] in 1932. The federalist principle suggests that the court should defer to the judgment of state legislatures representing the needs of local citizens.

As a close observer of the Supreme Court[26], I can imagine an outcome to the case in which the justices rule that, under the Second Amendment, a state can limit but not eliminate the core purposes of the protected right.

The Heller decision identifies at least one purpose as self-defense. The question is whether a specific concealed carry law creates a burden so strong that it becomes equivalent to eradication of the right to self-protection, or whether it imposes a legitimate public safety regulation that still maintains the core right for citizens who assert it.

Individual rights vs. fellow citizens

The most permissive laws that allow unrestricted concealed carry are almost certainly not mandated by the Constitution.

“Shall issue” laws, which allow states to screen applicants for flaws but compel local governments to provide a concealed carry license to qualified citizens, are likely to be seen even by the conservative justices as legitimate regulations that do not create unconstitutional burdens.

However, the current court might be likely to see a “may issue” law like New York’s, which allows the government to deny a license to nearly every applicant, as creating a burden that blocks the core of the right to self-protection where ordinary citizens are exposed to greater threats – outside the home.

The dissenters will likely focus on Scalia’s invocation of the home as the height of the defensive right, allowing for restrictions outside one’s “own lands,” where individual rights are balanced against the interests of fellow citizens.

[You’re smart and curious about the world. So are The Conversation’s authors and editors. You can read us daily by subscribing to our newsletter[27].]

References

  1. ^ Supreme Court is set to hear arguments Nov. 3 (www.thetrace.org)
  2. ^ issue before the court (theconversation.com)
  3. ^ suggested a clause (www.monticello.org)
  4. ^ New York Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (www.scotusblog.com)
  5. ^ AP Photo/Eric Gay (newsroom.ap.org)
  6. ^ Supreme Court rulings (theconversation.com)
  7. ^ District of Columbia v. Heller (www.supremecourt.gov)
  8. ^ deeply disputed 5-4 ruling (content.time.com)
  9. ^ two years later to cover state laws (www.supremecourt.gov)
  10. ^ Bill of Rights (www.archives.gov)
  11. ^ elevates above all other interests (www.supremecourt.gov)
  12. ^ the home (www.supremecourt.gov)
  13. ^ replaced by Justice Neil Gorsuch (www.npr.org)
  14. ^ not unlimited (www.supremecourt.gov)
  15. ^ handgun in the home (www.supremecourt.gov)
  16. ^ Open carry (worldpopulationreview.com)
  17. ^ constitutional carry (www.cnn.com)
  18. ^ license to carry (concealedguns.procon.org)
  19. ^ stringent requirements (codes.findlaw.com)
  20. ^ proper cause (sheriff.ongov.net)
  21. ^ Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
  22. ^ gun owners’ brief (www.supremecourt.gov)
  23. ^ opposing brief (www.supremecourt.gov)
  24. ^ laboratories of experimentation (www.supremecourt.gov)
  25. ^ phrased it (tile.loc.gov)
  26. ^ close observer of the Supreme Court (doi.org)
  27. ^ You can read us daily by subscribing to our newsletter (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/gun-rights-at-the-supreme-court-justices-will-consider-if-the-fundamental-right-to-keep-a-gun-at-home-applies-to-carrying-weapons-in-public-169235

Times Magazine

Headless CMS in Digital Twins and 3D Product Experiences

Image by freepik As the metaverse becomes more advanced and accessible, it's clear that multiple sectors will use digital twins and 3D product experiences to visualize, connect, and streamline efforts better. A digital twin is a virtual replica of ...

The Decline of Hyper-Casual: How Mid-Core Mobile Games Took Over in 2025

In recent years, the mobile gaming landscape has undergone a significant transformation, with mid-core mobile games emerging as the dominant force in app stores by 2025. This shift is underpinned by changing user habits and evolving monetization tr...

Understanding ITIL 4 and PRINCE2 Project Management Synergy

Key Highlights ITIL 4 focuses on IT service management, emphasising continual improvement and value creation through modern digital transformation approaches. PRINCE2 project management supports systematic planning and execution of projects wit...

What AI Adoption Means for the Future of Workplace Risk Management

Image by freepik As industrial operations become more complex and fast-paced, the risks faced by workers and employers alike continue to grow. Traditional safety models—reliant on manual oversight, reactive investigations, and standardised checklist...

From Beach Bops to Alpine Anthems: Your Sonos Survival Guide for a Long Weekend Escape

Alright, fellow adventurers and relaxation enthusiasts! So, you've packed your bags, charged your devices, and mentally prepared for that glorious King's Birthday long weekend. But hold on, are you really ready? Because a true long weekend warrior kn...

Effective Commercial Pest Control Solutions for a Safer Workplace

Keeping a workplace clean, safe, and free from pests is essential for maintaining productivity, protecting employee health, and upholding a company's reputation. Pests pose health risks, can cause structural damage, and can lead to serious legal an...

The Times Features

Distressed by all the bad news? Here’s how to stay informed but still look after yourself

If you’re feeling like the news is particularly bad at the moment, you’re not alone. But many of us can’t look away – and don’t want to. Engaging with news can help us make ...

The Role of Your GP in Creating a Chronic Disease Management Plan That Works

Living with a long-term condition, whether that is diabetes, asthma, arthritis or heart disease, means making hundreds of small decisions every day. You plan your diet against m...

Troubleshooting Flickering Lights: A Comprehensive Guide for Homeowners

Image by rawpixel.com on Freepik Effectively addressing flickering lights in your home is more than just a matter of convenience; it's a pivotal aspect of both home safety and en...

My shins hurt after running. Could it be shin splints?

If you’ve started running for the first time, started again after a break, or your workout is more intense, you might have felt it. A dull, nagging ache down your shins after...

Metal Roof Replacement Cost Per Square Metre in 2025: A Comprehensive Guide for Australian Homeowners

In recent years, the trend of installing metal roofs has surged across Australia. With their reputation for being both robust and visually appealing, it's easy to understand thei...

Why You’re Always Adjusting Your Bra — and What to Do Instead

Image by freepik It starts with a gentle tug, then a subtle shift, and before you know it, you're adjusting your bra again — in the middle of work, at dinner, even on the couch. I...